4 ms·
Android does not have a monopoly either. You can buy an iPhone.
by ekianjo 8y ago
Android does not have a monopoly either. You can buy an iPhone.
- rjvbk 8y agoI used the wrong term, I meant "dominant position". Google has one with Android and they abuse it. That's why they are being fined.
- littlecranky67 8y agoA monopoly is not defined by the possiblity that there are other products available for purchase on the market, but rather how many products have been purchased and are in use. Using your reasoning, Microsoft could never have had a monopoly on Windows because you always could have bought a Mac.
- repolfx 8y agoThat latter definition is in fact a reasonable counter-argument to Windows being a monopoly (people did buy Macs), and that's why Microsoft got in trouble for the deals they cut to try and crush Netscape, not for making a more popular OS than Apple did. You can't define a monopoly as "your competitors aren't popular" because otherwise it'd be illegal to invent new product categories, as at the start you'd be the only player in the new space. You can't define it that way for another reason: it punishes success.
- SparklingCotton 8y agoMonopolies are not illegal, so your argument is irrelevant.
- pbhjpbhj 8y agoFWIW the definition of a patent is a "time-limited monopoly on working an invention", so all new products that are patented are monopolies by definition. As the sibling comment rightly says, monopolies are acceptable. But, as the EU clearly point out, a greater onus is put on monopolies to avoid abusing their monopoly power.
- ekianjo 8y agoA monopoly is exactly that. Mono means one. Thats the root of the word. What you are describing is a dominant position, which is completely different since its a relative definition.
- onion2k 8y agoYou're mistaking the dictionary definition for the legal definition.
- realusername 8y agoThat's not what a monopoly means, yeah you can buy an iPhone but Android has 75% market share in Europe, that's why it's a monopoly.
- tomaha 8y agoThe problem with this definition is that it also assumes that if you have 75%+ market share you're likely having a similar share of the profits which is not the case here. If you take profit into account it's really at best a 50-50 market for Google.
- icebraining 8y agoThere's no implied assumption about profits.
- tomaha 8y agoI agree that assumption is the wrong word. But do you have examples of monopolies that didn't take the profits and control the pricing of the markets they control?
- devdas 8y agoGoogle is controlling profits from advertising and playstore sales by using Android to route traffic to those endpoints. The profit isn't from the direct sale of an Android device, it's from the system the device is a gateway to.
- realusername 8y agoMonopolies are not based on the profit but market share. Yes Apple has a very profitable niche but that does not mean Android does not have a near-monopoly on smartphones.
- ericdykstra 8y agoNo, a monopoly is controlling a market to the point where competition is restricted via controlling supply or other means. A company can have 100% market share and not be a monopoly (which is always what happens when a new market emerges).
- dalore 8y agoThis is talking about from the perspective of phone manufacturer. As a phone manufacturer you can't license iOS so that's out. You can really only license Android and if you do you have to also install Google Apps, Chrome, and make Google the default search engine on your phone.
- dlp211 8y agoYou are not required to license Android to use Android. AOSP and other versions forked from AOSP do exist. There are.other mobile OSes available as well. I'm sure Microsoft will gladly let you use their OS for the right price, KaiOS, Ubuntu phone OS could be resurrected, you could role your own, I'm sure Symbian is for sale somewhere, how about Meego.
- dalore 8y ago>In particular, Google has prevented manufacturers wishing to pre-install Google apps from selling even a single smart mobile device running on alternative versions of Android that were not approved by Google (so-called "Android forks"). If you want to have Google apps on your phone you can't sell any forked android version.
- ulfw 8y agoMicrosoft never had a monopoly in operating systems ever in it's history either. You could install CP/M on IBM XTs and you could run OS/2 or Linux or a plethora of other UNIXes on later IBMs and clones instead of Windows. Doesn't mean they hadn't had market control due to it's market share.
- vixen99 8y agoits history
- BlackFly 8y agoThere is an excellent quote from the actual link: > Nevertheless, the Commission investigated to what extent competition for end users (downstream), in particular between Apple and Android devices, could indirectly constrain Google's market power for the licensing of Android to device manufacturers (upstream). The Commission found that this competition does not sufficiently constrain Google upstream for a number of reasons, including: They are not punished for their behavior in the downstream market (in which they barely participate). They are punished for their behavior in the upstream market. We consumers do not participate in the upstream market. Nevertheless, the EU commission considered whether the lack of a monopoly in the downstream market ameliorated the monopoly effects in the upstream market and found it did not.
- IanCal 8y agoThey have a dominant market position. The EU does not use the term "monopoly" so complaints that it is not a monopoly are irrelevant. http://europa.eu/rapid/press-release_IP-18-4581_en.htm http://europa.eu/rapid/press-release_IP-18-4581_en.htm