3 ms·
So, what happened? And why are we seeing this again now? Especially, when internal combustion is about obsolete?
by ncmncm 8y ago
So, what happened? And why are we seeing this again now? Especially, when internal combustion is about obsolete?
- owenversteeg 8y agoBecause there are a lot of applications where you've just got to have an internal combustion engine, and that will remain the case for many years. Everything from aerospace to long-distance to simply low-cost applications usually require ICEs and the high fuel density that comes along with them.
- zrobotics 8y agoAnother point is easily refuelable. Chainsaws are by and large 2 stroke due to weight, and while electric saws do exist they have a short runtime. Hauling enough batteries into the woods for a day of firewood cutting isn't an option when 1.5gal of fuel will more than suffice.
- dsfyu404ed 8y ago>while electric saws do exist they have a short runtime. It doesn't help that they're all flimsy consumer models that break if you even think about doing real work with them.
- AmVess 8y agoThis article is almost 30 years old. No one pursued it because there's not a cheap and simple way of getting 2-stroke engine emissions down to an acceptable level. ICE are far from obsolete, and will be in demand until the day we wring the last drop of petrol from this Earth.
- joecool1029 8y agoPretty much sums it up. Anyways there's better directions for research now like HCCI that should bring petrol engines efficiencies up: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homogeneous_charge_compression_ignition https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homogeneous_charge_compression...
- phillc73 8y ago> No one pursued it because there's not a cheap and simple way of getting 2-stroke engine emissions down to an acceptable level. I don't think it's fair to say no one pursued a more efficient and emissions friendly two-stroke engine. In the boating world, there are examples of modern two-stroke outboard engines which do meet current emission standards. For example, the Evinrude E-TEC range.[1][2] [1] https://www.evinrude.com/en-US/e-tec.html https://www.evinrude.com/en-US/e-tec.html [2] http://www.evinrude.com.au/BuyAnEngine/News/NewEmissionLawsareComing-We.aspx http://www.evinrude.com.au/BuyAnEngine/News/NewEmissionLawsa...
- maxerickson 8y agoThere's some crossover point where synthetic fuels are cheaper than drilling. If energy prices decline with solar, ICE may be in demand forever. I guess probably not for personal vehicles.
- sitkack 8y agoWe will start synthesizing petrol. Organic fuels will be with us for whatever the human race decides is _forever_.
- zaarn 8y agoThe simple reason ICE's will remain in use is energy density, no matter how much you wish it wasn't true. Diesel packs 48 Megajoules per Kilogram of Mass, Jet Fuel 43 and plain old wood does 16. Accumulators/Batteries manage betweed 0.25 and 0.9 MJ per Kilogram, exception being LiPo which can do 1.8 MJ per KG. ICE's usually can do a 30% efficiency, even in crude designs, so even accounting for that you get like 16 MJ per KG of fuel out of a diesel engine while LiPo even at 90% efficienty manages a 1/10th of that. If you're weight constrained like when you want to fly an aircraft, there isn't much choice but to have a combustion engine of sorts. If you wanted to replace an aircraft gas turbine (usually a turbojet or turbofan) with an electric one, you'd have to make the engine and battery combo that weighs no more than a jet fuel engine while having the same power output. For raw numbers A Boeing 737 MAX has an engine that weighs 2'780 kg. Two of them. It has a TSFC of 0.012kg/kN*s which works out to 70 MW on continous thrust. The fuel weighs 19 tons at full load. So the electric replacement for this engine now needs to output twice 70MW of power for up to 7'000 kilometers of range. At normal cruising speed that's 10 hours. 140MW over 10 Hours is 1400MWh / 2.5 Gigajoules. The best battery tech we have will result in a 2777.8 ton battery. If the electric motor can do 100% efficiency. 2777.8 tons vs 19 tons. (If my numbers are correct, which should be the case)
- chrisseaton 8y agoThe batteries need to weigh less than the fuel because fuel weight disappears as it’s used.
- zaarn 8y agoYup, I didn't account for fuel weight going down overtime, in part because I forgot and in part because it complicates the equations. Even not accounting for that, the fuel tank wins over batteries, which would be like stapling a third engine on the aircraft that doesn't work, yet wanting the same distance and speed performance from the aircraft. I also tried to figure out how much energy you could pull from solar panels to cover energy usage and reduce the battery use but A) doesn't work for overnight flights and B) the energy output is abysmal for various and dozens of reasons even if you magically doubled the surface area that the sunlight reaches. By over-the-fist estimations, the weight you save on the battery would be lost on the solar panels.