8 ms·
> Insurers contend they use the information to spot health issues in their clients — and flag them so they get services they need. Horse shit. And I say that a
by FireBeyond 8y ago
> Insurers contend they use the information to spot health issues in their clients — and flag them so they get services they need.
Horse shit. And I say that as someone who writes claims management software for the healthcare industry.
I challenge ANY health insurer to provide examples of this. Of course, they won't, because they'll cite "patient confidentiality", but that just doesn't happen.
They've wanted to do this for years, though, and try to. Requests to be able mine claim data for familial predispositions to diseases was one that we fended off multiple times.
- sidlls 8y agoYou may have fended it off but I assure you there is a whole industry devoted to using claims and other health data to manage care and costs. Insurers are primary partners of these companies and act as both providers and consumers of the data. Not just insurers, but big hospitals and provider networks, too.
- pishpash 8y agoWe're going down some kind of bizarre path. Insurance is ultimately about risk sharing. If every risk is modeled then there is no insurance, just expensive prepayment.
- tlb 8y agoIf I have a 1% chance of a car accident, I’d be happy to pay 1.5% the cost of hospital bills for insurance. Someone else with a 2% chance of an accident should be happy to pay 3%. That’s still insurance. Only if you deny free will and assume perfect information and deterministic laws of physics, can every risk resolve to either 0% or 100%.
- zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC 8y agoWhat is the practically relevant difference between 100% prediction capability and 99.999% prediction capability?
- chimeracoder 8y ago> What is the practically relevant difference between 100% prediction capability and 99.999% prediction capability? If there were 100% prediction capability, there would be no risk to smooth, and there would be no reason to buy insurance, because the insurance would be more expensive than paying the costs of the would-be insured risk directly.
- zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC 8y agoBut with 99.999%, there is a risk to smooth in practice? How about 99.99999999999999999999999999999999%?
- chimeracoder 8y ago> But with 99.999%, there is a risk to smooth in practice? How about 99.99999999999999999999999999999999%? Uh, I guess this question might be interesting from an academic perspective, but not a practical one. There's no risk out there which can be predicted with 35 nines of precision, let alone one that people are interested in insuring. And certainly not one in which the overhead of providing services wouldn't inherently dwarf any benefits to both parties.
- zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC 8y agoIn other words: There is no practically relevant difference between a prediction ability of 100% and 99.99999999999999999999999999999999%, which is exactly the point I was making: There is is nothing magical about the 100% mark--free will or assuming perfect information is irrelevant to the problem at hand, insurance becomes asymptotically less useful the better risks are modeled and used to set premiums where the premiums cannot work as an incentive to avoid the risks in the first place.
- FireBeyond 8y agoAs it in the US, that's already the case. It's amortized and expensive payments, and not "true" insurance. Or rather, insurers like to take all of the pros of being an insurer, and none of the cons. Risk pool didn't change by your entry into it? So what, if there's something deniable, we will. Etc, etc.
- mr_overalls 8y agoYou're right. In the US at least, health insurance is mostly a payment management scheme. Casualty insurance (for accidents, disasters, etc.) more closely resembles a true insurance product.
- lftl 8y agoThis is the core problem of health insurance as currently structured in the US -- everyone will make a claim eventually so it's effectively a whole life insurance policy except the payout is sporadic and involves tons of bureaucratic crap. I personally would be fine with either universal healthcare or regulating the marketing to outlaw non-catastrophic health "insurance" thereby forcing routine care to be a direct payment relationship with your doctor.
- freehunter 8y agoThat's a good point and one I've never linked in my mind. My insurance company takes monthly payments from me in exchange for a certain amount of coverage, then they either mandate or strongly recommend that I go to the doctor regularly, which they will cover for a nominal cost to me... basically I'm paying for "insurance" for something that the insurance company has me do on a regular and recurring schedule (visit my doctor). Whatever your politics on healthcare, it does seem insane that something as routine as visiting the doctor for a yearly physical could be so expensive that you need insurance to pay for it. Like you said, insurance should be to cover unpredictable catastrophic events. My homeowners insurance doesn't pay for roof maintenance until the old one fails. My car insurance doesn't pay for car maintenance until I've had a collision. Why is my health insurance covering routine maintenance?
- roel_v 8y ago"Why is my health insurance covering routine maintenance?" Because the preventative care reduces the costs down the line, and there is no way for an insurer to check if people are actually doing their routine maintenance if they don't do it. So it's better to include it in the premium. It's different from your roof in that your HO insurance only covers freak accidents (not failure because of old age), whereas health insurance covers many old age related problems.
- chimeracoder 8y ago> Because the preventative care reduces the costs down the line This is a common myth. Preventive care actually doesn't reduce costs, on net. It improves the overall quality of care, yes, but it doesn't (in aggregate) save more money than it requires. For some conditions, early intervention is cheaper (and more effective) than delayed intervention, but that's not always the case - and either way, it's not considered preventive care.
- cryoshon 8y ago>just expensive prepayment. you have discovered their business model.
- lotsofpulp 8y agoPPACA legislation caps net income for health insurance companies at 15% of revenue.
- erik_seaberg 8y ago… and now I have no incentive to press for lower health care costs, because if I succeed I get the same percentage of a smaller number.
- lotsofpulp 8y agoUnless everyone had to sign up for insurance allowing enough population so that multiple health insurance companies can co-exist and compete on price.
- chimeracoder 8y ago> We're going down some kind of bizarre path. Insurance is ultimately about risk sharing. If every risk is modeled then there is no insurance, just expensive prepayment. This is completely backwards. Insurance is about risk smoothing, across states of the world. Insurance should not have a positive expected value - that is, there should be no person for whom the total lifetime expected payouts exceed the total lifetime expected costs. For a number of reasons, health insurance isn't actually insurance, and this is one of them. You can identify individuals who are dramatically likely to receive more money in payouts and benefits than they are to pay in their regular premiums, which means you're talking about a redistribution system, not an insurance system.
- wool_gather 8y agoI think the point parent is making is that there's (nominally/supposed to be) smoothing across people too. The uncharitable description is that "healthy people are subsidizing sick people". Part of the reason we accept this is that each individual doesn't know whether she will get sick. She pays the premium, not because she knows she'll need it, but because she knows not having it is worse, if she gets sick. But the insurance also has price proportionate to the chance she will need it. The more finely the chance it'll be needeed is known, the more closely individual prices will match the probability, and thus less smoothing will take place.
- chimeracoder 8y ago> I think the point parent is making is that there's (nominally/supposed to be) smoothing across people too. The uncharitable description is that "healthy people are subsidizing sick people" That's a common refrain, but it's wrong and misleading. It's why people talk about young and healthy people being "necessary" to balance out the costs of the older and sick under the ACA. That's describing a redistribution scheme, not insurance. > But the insurance also has price proportionate to the chance she will need it. No, they don't. They price based on age, sex, zipcode, income, and smoking status. That's only very loosely related to the chance that she will need it. It's nowhere near enough to provide precise pricing. > The more finely the chance it'll be needeed is known, the more closely individual prices will match the probability, and thus less smoothing will take place. No, that's another common misconception. The price is not determined by the ability of the insurer to predict the probability of the risk; that's what determines the insurer's profit margins. Under a free insurance market, the price is determined by the relative demand and supply of patients and insurers.
- rhizome 8y agoThere is a concept in insurance called "shirking," which is the principle of externalizing as much risk as possible.
- supertrope 8y agoAll businesses are constantly externalizing costs.
- rhizome 8y agoI didn't mention costs.
- supertrope 8y agoRisk can be considered a cost. Expected value = sum of individual payoffs * their individual probabilities.
- FireBeyond 8y agoVery true. We're not perfect, but I am at least happy we made an ethical and moral (and in some cases legal) choice that I'm much more comfortable with than some others.
- s73v3r_ 8y ago"You may have fended it off but I assure you there is a whole industry devoted to using claims and other health data to manage care and costs. " If by "manage care and costs", you mean kick people off insurance and deny claims, then sure.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> If by "manage care and costs", you mean kick people off insurance and deny claims, then sure. The prohibition of pre-existing condition exclusion and the associated practice of rescission in the ACA largely ended the “kick people off insurance” practice (and the limitation of profits to a percentage of actual paid bills eliminates some of the incentive on the other), though the current Administration’s drive to reverse those policies combined with the way the industry is vacuuming up personal data could make them return with a vengeance.
- s73v3r_ 8y agoRight. Given the aims of the current administration, unless something happens, I don't believe that those protections will survive. There is currently a court case in Texas which is stating that the protections around pre-existing conditions are not legal. The makeup of the courts, especially if Trump gets to nominate another justice, makes me believe they will kill it, and then we'll be even worse off than we were before.
- tunap 8y agoAt what cost? Specifically, at what price point are the insurance co's limited to charge for PECs? Mandating w/o cost-controls is an invitation to charge as much as necessary to rid themselves of the liability, no? So my question is, where does it mandate what PEC costs are allowable to avoid abuse by providers?
- dragonwriter 8y ago> So my question is, where does it mandate what PEC costs are allowable to avoid abuse by providers? The ACA prohibits denying coverage or charging additional premiums based on, or limiting in any way coverage for services because they are related to, pre-existing conditions. (Now, within the existing state and federal rules on minimal coverage, insurers may limit coverage for particular conditions, but can't differentiate based on whether they were present before the person sought coverage.) The real big deal, though, is the linked prohibition on rescission: before the ACA, insurance companies would frequently do focused investigations to find evidence of non-disclosure pre-existing conditions, however minor and unrelated to the current condition, when an insured person incurred high covered expenses, then use any discovered pre-existing condition as an excuse to retroactively cancel their insurance avoiding the high pending bills and dumping them on the patient.
- pishpash 8y agoAnd people voluntarily spend money to send their DNA to some random websites. Sure, they don't use it in this way now, but for how long can they hold off on the temptation?
- duxup 8y agoI have read a few stories about some small insurers who were using health data to address ongoing issues and help people get more consistent care. The catch was for it to work it was a very labor intensive task to have someone work with the customer. Granted it was more of a story about how things should work than how they do.
- FireBeyond 8y agoSure. That's arguably more the job of the PCP, to manage ongoing issues, just as in my other role as a paramedic, we are running 'community medic' programs to handle non-emergent calls and patients who are 'frequent fliers'. Using this data to spot "chronic conditions being treated acutely or not at all", I admit I can see. But beyond that, not so much.
- duxup 8y agoYup, cronic conditions and patterns like poorly managing that care. If they saw a lot of stuff related to problems with diabetes, they might schedule / send someone to the home to help establish better care and etc.
- cowkingdeluxe 8y agoI am curious if they will be able to use this data to raise rates if the pre-existing coverage is removed ( https://www.npr.org/2018/06/08/618263772/trump-administration-move-imperils-pre-existing-condition-protections https://www.npr.org/2018/06/08/618263772/trump-administratio... )? I presume that it would be smart now for people to use certifications of creditable coverage?
- lvspiff 8y agoYou'd be surprised - your not seeing the informatics side I'm guessing - they take all the data from the claims system and use it to check if a patient is over 55 and has had a colonoscopy, or female and over 45 and hasn't had her annual breast exam. Things like that are common practice for major insurance carriers (see unitedhealth, blue cross, humana, etc) to notify their customers of opportunities.
- kolpa 8y agoInsurers are paid in premiums, not health outcomes. An insurance company is incentivized to help avoid costly claims, but if you are likely to make costly claims, and they can't drop you, they are incentivized toward healthcare choices that kill you before you need long-expensive term care.
- chimeracoder 8y ago> An insurance company is incentivized to help avoid costly claims, but if you are likely to make costly claims, and they can't drop you, they are incentivized toward healthcare choices that kill you before you need long-expensive term care. Insurance companies don't make the choices - providers do. In the US, insurers have very little control over providers' decisions in most care settings. Ironically, under capitated care, the provider acts as the insurer, and is expected to balance both the medical outcomes for the patient and the overall cost to the system directly in their decision-making. For some reason, that's the model that people seem to advocate in this (and other) HN threads about healthcare, which boggles my mind: I can't understand why patients would want their medical provider to have an inherent conflict of interest from the start.
- supertrope 8y agoBecause the choice for many is not mostly loyal physician vs. HMO or corporate employee doc. It’s HMO doc vs. no doctor visit.
- chimeracoder 8y ago
- Spooky23 8y agoThey do it in two ways that I have seen. If you have a prescription for an off-label use of a drug that is commonly used for other diseases with high maintenance costs (say diabetes or asthma), you'll start getting newsletters about early management/intervention. They also do subrogation. If you have something that is a high likelihood to be somebody else's (Worker's Comp, auto insurance) problem like a back injury, you'll have an investigator call to try to link an earlier incident, ER admission, etc to your current issue. Most of the other stuff (familial predispositions, etc) are fraught with ethical problems. You can't send a random letter to a random person and suggest that they are predisposed to cancer or something.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]