4 ms·
That's ok with me? I wish it were like life insurance where they can ask you anything and then you get that rate locked down for the term. I also actually like
by exabrial 8y ago
That's ok with me? I wish it were like life insurance where they can ask you anything and then you get that rate locked down for the term.
I also actually liked the proposal in Congress that got rejected: allow people to make their own groups. So if you are a person who likes to work out and get your fat levels tested once a year, you could join a group of like minded individuals and insurance companies would bid to insure your group.
- ceejayoz 8y ago> That's ok with me? I wish it were like life insurance where they can ask you anything and then you get that rate locked down for the term. That's an understandable attitude for a healthy person. What is the person born with a disability or a gene making cancer, Alzheimers, heart disease, etc. likely supposed to do? "Your insurance premium is $25k/month. We take checks!"
- sDlEzAtyoNAz 8y agoIf they can't afford to pay anyone enough to insure them, they should ask for charity, because that's what they need.
- 5874-4b22-a4e0 8y agoThey should go to the emergency room, iirc its free if they can't extract the money.
- ceejayoz 8y agoYou can't get stuff like chemo or a transplant at an ER. They are only required to (attempt) to (temporarily) stabilize you. "Just go to the ER" also is pretty much the most inefficiently stupid way of handling healthcare for the needy you can come up with.
- ceejayoz 8y agoShockingly, it turns out that most charities don't have the financial resources to dedicate a hundred thousand dollars for a single heat transplant.
- sDlEzAtyoNAz 8y agoAlso shockingly, if you already know you need a heart transplant, you're well beyond the point where any market-based risk pool is going to offer to pay for your transplant in exchange for a premium that's below the cost of your transplant. You need charity, not a market.
- ceejayoz 8y ago> Also shockingly, if you already know you need a heart transplant, you're well beyond the point where any market-based risk pool is going to offer to pay for your transplant in exchange for a premium that's below the cost of your transplant. Everyone is at potential risk for needing something like a transplant eventually. Making the pool large enough allows reasonable premiums, just as I can pay a couple hundred bucks a year to replace my entire house if it burns down. The rest of the developed world defines the risk pool as "everyone", and the end result is healthcare costs half of ours (including the tax component) and similar outcomes. > You need charity, not a market. You need government, not a charity.
- sDlEzAtyoNAz 8y ago>Everyone is at potential risk for needing something like a transplant eventually. Not everyone is at equal risk, and many choices people make can have an impact on that risk. That's the point of this thread. >Making the pool large enough allows reasonable premiums, just as I can pay a couple hundred bucks a year to replace my entire house if it burns down. What is 'large enough'? The populations of many entire European countries are dwarfed by the number of subscribers to several health insurance companies in the US. Of course we don't know how large health insurance companies would get in a market without heavy government interference, but do you have some reason to believe the size of pools in a market with less interference would result in unreasonable premiums? >The rest of the developed world defines the risk pool as "everyone", and the end result is healthcare costs half of ours (including the tax component) and similar outcomes. And our health care system requires subscribers to insurance companies to pay those insurance companies to A) provide charity to people who wouldn't be able to afford to buy insurance in real market and B) pay for routine care (i.e. care where there is no risk to insure against - you know you're going to need it). And of course the health insurance company is going to collect its cut of the money that the government has forced subscribers to funnel through those companies. Is it really any surprise that system gets expensive? >You need government, not a charity. You need charity, whether it's administered by a public organization or a private organization or funded by private individuals or taxpayers.
- frgtpsswrdlame 8y agoYou're okay with a society where people die on the street because they didn't have enough wealth? How much money you have isn't a determinant of the moral worth of your life, it's not even a proxy. So why do consider it as a relevant detail in the allocation of healthcare? Why should the obese, smoking trust-fund kid get the heart bypass but the obese smoking poor guy not? Liberalism (classical or otherwise) requires some base level at which we treat people as equals, it seems the ability to continue living would be about as base as we can get.
- sDlEzAtyoNAz 8y ago>You're okay with a society where people die on the street because they didn't have enough wealth? I didn't take a position on whether or not I'm okay with a society where people die in the street if they don't have enough wealth. All I said was that people who can't afford to buy health insurance need charity, whether that charity is public or private. The market is not going to help them. Attempting to fit that round peg into a square hole is going to cause a lot of issues that are very obvious to predict, in addition to all of the issues that are less easy to predict. >How much money you have isn't a determinant of the moral worth of your life Neither is anything else. The 'moral worth of your life' is fundamentally an opinion, not a fact. >So why do consider it as a relevant detail in the allocation of healthcare? Because that's how we allocate most goods and services, and it does a fairly good job at it. >Why should the obese, smoking trust-fund kid get the heart bypass but the obese smoking poor guy not? That's a pretty complicated question that comes down to an individual's own priorities and that individual's assessment of the potential effects of various alternative policies on the attainment of various goals.
- rland 8y ago>people who can't afford to buy health insurance need charity, whether that charity is public or private. The market is not going to help them. Attempting to fit that round peg into a square hole is going to cause a lot of issues that are very obvious to predict, in addition to all of the issues that are less easy to predict. So, a free market is ineffective at allocating resources in healthcare. Unless we redefine healthcare to mean "care for people who are not sick," which does not really make it healthcare at all, does it?
- exabrial 8y agoFor the vast majority of people, this is all the healthcare they need, and an efficient system should/could run that way! I think you misunderstood something I said, however. A "risk pool"'s rates can only be decided by non-preventable risk factors of that pool. The examples you give don't reflect that well: some cancers are preventable, Alzheimer's cause and treatments are not well understood, and most heart disease is preventable. For someone with a childhood disease, for instance, they could possibly fit into a certain risk pool, but they likely won't. Any "risk pool" based insurer will not have the funds to cover them anyway, and forcing them to cover the extreme cases has shown to leave more people without healthcare. [Take the case in Iowa, where a single person caused 30,000 individuals to lose their insurance. That is not an acceptable outcome!]. Right now, the best answer on how you handle these extreme cases will have to be a combination of Medicare and Charity, as they are the only organizations with a pool of money big enough to help them.
- frockington 8y agoThat does souns appealing. I'm all in for a mandatory annual weigh in and fitness test
- wild_preference 8y agoI’d go a step further and give people discounts if they even try to eat healthy. Amazing how long I can go shopping cart peeking without spotting a single vegetable or fruit.
- frockington 8y agoAgreed. It'd be pretty easy to create a proxy for that via blood pressure or cholesterol or some type of improvement metric combining the two
- amorphid 8y agoIncentives are different. Life insurance companies have an incentive for you to not die. Health insurance companies have an incentive for you to not live (e.g. you don't that organ $$$$$$ transplant you need to live). Health insurance is cheaper when more people are in it, not fewer. If you start offering discounts to the healthiest people, it gets more expensive for unhealthy people. So let's say the sickest people no longer have insurance. Now there's a new group of unhealthy people in the insurance pool. So you raise prices for them, and they get kicked out, too. Eventually you get to the point where insurance is not useful, because nobody needs it at all, as the insured people don't get sick. Until they do get sick, at which point they get kicked off the insurance plan. Health insurance that doesn't insure is basically fraud. If you want to drive down the health related costs of healthcare, reduce the things that make people sick.
- sDlEzAtyoNAz 8y ago>So you raise prices for them, and they get kicked out, too. They only get kicked out if no one will offer them prices that they can afford and that they want to pay for. Why do you expect that would happen? >Until they do get sick, at which point they get kicked off the insurance plan. It seems like that would be solved by treating health insurance like term life insurance as the person you're replying to suggested.
- amorphid 8y agoWhen you get older & sicker, I'm guessing you'll feel differently. It's all fun & games until you can't afford a basic prescription.
- sDlEzAtyoNAz 8y agoWhat do you think I said that I will feel differently about when I'm older and sicker? You made a bunch of claims about the nature of the health insurance market, and I pointed out that your claims were bogus. What feelings are involved there?
- chicob 8y agoI do not think that this is a good idea, for various reasons. 1) Letting peer pressure and self censorship to police our habits is the end of individuality and freedom. This is exactly what China is trying to achieve with that horrible social credit system. It also inverts the logic behind healthy practices: today you run because it makes you feel good; tomorrow you run because you can't afford to be left behind and lose insurance. This kind of thing really lowers the bar on the respect of privacy and dignity because it is basically large scale surveillance in exchange for cheaper insurance. Take car insurance: are you willing to give insurance companies full access to your GPS and tachometer data just so you can prove you're a good driver (in their own terms) and pay a little less? 2) What is healthy today might not be healthy tomorrow. Imagine some food is considered healthy in 2020, and you happen to eat lots of it, but in 2050 it turns out it's the other way around. And 3) this all boils down to the reason why, in general, associating people in groups and then judging individuals accordingly is unconstitutional in so many countries. That group may be gay people, black people, people that voted Left or some other group that you cannot leave or join because of some arbitrary definition. And is also worth considering that the group to which you belong can vote a change on its definition that leaves you out with no appeal, the worse case being some AI deciding that you're done.