4 ms·
People have been predicting the obsolescence of the manned fighter aircraft since the '50s, when guided missiles went mainstream. It even sort of happened in th
by twic 8y ago
People have been predicting the obsolescence of the manned fighter aircraft since the '50s, when guided missiles went mainstream. It even sort of happened in the Soviet navy, which had no fleet carriers, but instead cruisers which bristled with enormous, sophisticated anti-aircraft and anti-ship missiles.
But it still hasn't happened for real. Maybe this time will be different. But maybe not.
What happened with missiles is that, on the one hand, they turned out not to be the universal weapon that some thought they would be, and on the other hand, they were co-opted by manned aircraft, which are now platforms for launching and controlling them. Perhaps something similar will happen with drones?
There's already an emerging air power strategy where your stealthy fifth-generation fighters infiltrate enemy airspace, while your fourth-generation fighters, with their large radars and impressive arsenals, hang about beyond the reach of enemy missiles, supplying information and lobbing in shots to be guided to their destination by the vanguard. Drones could replace manned aircraft in the rear echelon, and perhaps augment the front line; being more disposable, they can risk turning their radars on.
- bitL 8y agoJust curious - what's the point of stealth aircraft infiltrating enemy airspace when they can't use radars or they would be shot within 30s? Seems to me like just bombers make sense - fly in, enable radar/weapon bay for a few seconds, drop the load, make yourself undetectable again, move out; once the air defense is down, send in 4th gen fighters.
- gmueckl 8y agoAttacking enemy ground anti air positions can be a job for stealth fighters. It is a high risk assignment. But there are few alternatives given the range of mopst AA defenses. These missions often requires the attackers to make their presence known in a controlled way to get enemy targetting radars turned on so that these stations can be tracked and targetted. Once the targetting radar is down, the rest of the AA battery typically becomes pretty useless.
- nradov 8y agoLow observable aircraft can use passive sensors for some purposes, and can also accept data links from other offboard radar platforms. The latest radars are also difficult to detect and can be turned on for a few seconds at a time. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Low-probability-of-intercept_radar https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Low-probability-of-intercept_r... Future radars will probably be designed to emit signals that look like random wide spectrum noise, and then rely on advanced signal processing to assemble the reflected "noise" into a useful picture. It will be challenging for adversaries to detect those emissions in a useful way.
- tomohawk 8y agoYou could do a sort of reverse wild weasel attack, where instead of sending in an aircraft ahead of the attacker to light up air defenses, your attacking aircraft could already be there and seeing more of what's going on based on the air defenses interest in the 4th gen aircraft. http://mistyvietnam.com/ http://mistyvietnam.com/ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wild_Weasel https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wild_Weasel
- Gravityloss 8y agoIn the sixties, the gunless fighters had problems and there was a return to more maneuverable fighters with guns. But missiles today have quite different capabilities compared to those in the sixties and seventies. Even in 1991 basically it was all missiles. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Air_engagements_of_the_Gulf_War https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Air_engagements_of_the_Gulf_Wa...