8 ms·
Big Tech’s View of Universal Basic Income Is Deeply Flawed
- woliveirajr 8y ago> Universal Income yields some results in two types of countries: ultra-poor nations when it lifts entire families from the street, or in affluent ones like Finland who already have a generous social safety net, free healthcare, a good education system and a low unemployment rate. So, the author says that it works when the country has almost nothing (and then any money will make a huge difference) and in countries where the population already has a good return for their taxes, and then receiving that money can provide some incentive to do other things.
- yobrobroprogr4m 8y agoQuick, shut down the wrongthink! Anybody who agrees with this should be doxxed, fired, de-platformed, harassed at restaurants and whatever else we can do!
- cortesoft 8y agoI am really having trouble sussing out the author's thesis. What are they arguing, exactly?
- throwawayjava 8y agoIMO the central thesis is that society should have a negative view of tech companies and tech workers. That's the only thesis that each argument made in the post actually justifies. So if that's not the true thesis, then I guess the article is just a sequence of incoherent and poorly constructed arguments about UBI, education, corporate taxation, etc. A counter-argument to the "you should hate tech people" thesis might be the pronounced support among tech workers for fixing the problems their industry helps create. The author argues that this is actually yet another reason why we should have a negative view of tech companies and tech workers, because UBI won't work and because we could fix college affordability by forcing Harvard to fund a few more full rides.
- JamesBarney 8y agoYeah, I had the same feeling, seemed like a long stream of consciousness. UBI is bad! because the U.S. doesn't have free healthcare?
- repolfx 8y agoThat UBI is bad and the tech people who support it are naive and cloistered.
- pitaj 8y agoI'm a libertarian, and don't support a welfare state in general. I view UBI as a great replacement for current welfare programs including food stamps. It largely eliminate the "welfare gap", where when people earn more money, their benefits start dropping off, resulting in a reversed incentive structure leading to trapping people in poverty. UBI implemented as a negative income tax would result in much less waste and more freedom to the beneficiaries. It's also politically viable as it could be seen as more "fair" since technically everyone receives it. Edit: I think the "automation displacing human jobs" argument is easily the weakest in favor of implementing a UBI, especially since it's not necessarily economically realistic.
- andrew_ 8y agoInteresting perspective, and something I had not considered previously.
- thorell 8y agoMy preferred argument in favor is that depression can render government form-filled disability bureaucracy into an unnavigable hellscape and since it's one of the most common disabilities, a lot of human misery could be spared by making a living income automatically accessible.
- commandlinefan 8y ago> a lot of human misery could be spared by making a living income automatically accessible You don't honestly think that those of us who have doubts about UBI are actually cackling and rubbing our hands together gleefully over all the human misery we're causing by denying living income to the miserable, do you? Of course that would be nice - and I do believe that humanity will eventually get to that point, but we're not there yet. We'll have flying, self-driving cars long before we have the level of automation we need to let everybody kick back and pursue whatever intellectual interests they find.
- thorell 8y agoOf course I don't think that. I'm not even certain I support UBI in general. That's just an argument I found compelling compared to others.
- throwawayjava 8y ago> Education is ripe for disruption. There’s a commonly believed fallacy right now that technology companies, specifically VC-backed technology education companies, are going to disrupt education. That’s bullshit. Instead, Harvard, Yale, MIT, and Stanford are the favorites to disrupt education when they fall under heavy and sustained government pressure over the irrational and immoral hoarding of their mammoth endowments. Harvard claims it could have doubled the size of its freshman class last year with no sacrifice to its educational quality. Good. Do it. More students, paying no tuition, at the best schools will disrupt the system. Harvard matriculates a teeny, tiny fraction of all university students. Doubling that number is not a solution. Even doubling that number at all ivies and elite universities is not even remotely close to a solution. UBI may not be the correct solution, but even UBI isn't this out of touch.
- commandlinefan 8y agoMaybe I'm just cynical, but I have a tough time believing that the preference for graduates from "top" colleges is entirely because they produce the best results rather than just a way to (necessarily) artificially limit access to a scarce resource. Just for the sake of round numbers, let's say there are enough quarter-million-dollar-a-year jobs for 1% of the population, but 10% of the population, with a bit of training, could step in and do those jobs. What do you do? You set up some semi-artificial, but still realistic, hurdles to limit the applicant pool. Doubling the applicant pool isn't going to solve the "problem" (if you even see it as a problem); it'll just necessitate an extra hurdle.
- throwawayjava 8y ago> Maybe I'm just cynical, but I have a tough time believing that the preference for graduates from "top" colleges is entirely because they produce the best results rather than just a way to (necessarily) artificially limit access to a scarce resource. This is not really relevant. The author of this piece suggests that the path to affordable higher ed in the US is elite institutions doubling their full-rides. But that's a drop in the bucket; "everyone go to an ivy on a full ride" is not a sustainable or realistic way of decreasing the cost of college. > Just for the sake of round numbers, let's say there are enough quarter-million-dollar-a-year jobs for 1% of the population, but 10% of the population, with a bit of training, could step in and do those jobs. This is also not a problem. Most people who go to college would be perfectly happy with a stable 80k. Or even 60k. The problem is not that folks can't get 250k. The problem is the massive amount of money they have to spend to get certain jobs that pay those wages, even at lower-tier universities. And more Harvard scholarships aren't going to solve that problem.
- jtmcmc 8y agoThis seems like a strawman screed. It seems like this guy literally created an argument out of what he thinks the general "big tech" consensus on UBI is and then attacks it. His argument seems to be the amount suggested (which he suggests) isn't enough and that tech companies need to pour lots of money into helping people.
- bandrami 8y agoThis will be unpopular, but: what if an uncomfortably large part of the population just really doesn't have anything economically worthwhile to offer in the modern context? Nobody wants to say that, but if it's true, then something like a UBI or dole (even granting the author's problems with it) is all we can do short of mounting a massive Plato's Cave-like conspiracy to convince people they are doing something useful.
- RodericDay 8y ago"This will be unpopular..." the opening salvo of fascists everywhere
- zqfm 8y ago> mounting a massive Plato's Cave-like conspiracy to convince people they are doing something useful Maybe I'm missing something but I feel like that's what most of us are doing now anyway.
- theothermkn 8y agoThere's another way to frame that: What if it's a coincidence that the rent of labor has afforded a tolerable lifestyle for the masses and lavish lifestyles for capital owners for nearly 200 years? And, what if this coincidence that has supported a social order (explicit or de facto capitalism) is coming to an end? I'm fond of Zizek's remark that it is easier to imagine the end of the world than the end of capitalism. It seems apposite, here.
- TomMckenny 8y agoPerhaps UBI does require thinks like universal health coverage but that would not make it "deeply flawed" that would mean tweaking is needed. And that UBI requires low unemployment is directly contradicted by the head of the article where UBI is described as a potential solution for loss of jobs due to automation. But either way theorizing beforehand why it will or won't fail is comparatively unproductive; we can actually experiment and see if it works. And interestingly two conditions of the article; a sort of universal heath care and low unemployment, currently apply in the US. So the article should be predicting success there.
- tatersolid 8y ago> we can actually experiment and see if it works. Actually, we can’t test UBI without enormous risk. If the number of people involved isn’t close to 100%, it isn’t universal. Any societal effects for good or ill cannot be reasonably extrapolated to the full population. What might “work” for 5% of the population getting UBI might cause the next Great Depression at 100%.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> Actually, we can’t test UBI without enormous risk. Yes we can. > If the number of people involved isn’t close to 100%, it isn’t universal. Right, so your test has 100% coverage but not at a level that completely displaces all other means tested benefit programs. Maybe it initially just displaces, say, General Assistance type programs. Then you can gradually scale it up and continuously evaluate.
- AnimalMuppet 8y agoI'm not sure that's a valid test. UBI at $10/month is absolutely worthless. UBI at $500/month is probably worthless. UBI at $1000/month is barely adequate. If you start the test at small amounts, you're going to experimentally decide that it doesn't work. But that only means that it doesn't work at those amounts. It could still work at larger amounts. Of course, it could bankrupt the country at larger amounts, too...
- sharemywin 8y ago"That’s why I remain fascinated by smart people in the United States being so misguided about the implications of the UBI in a country that has no decent healthcare system, a poor primary education complemented by a horrendously expensive higher education system. A state in which having more than two children is a mark of social status and in which any life crisis can lead to a social precipice." from the article
- pretendscholar 8y ago>A state in which having more than two children is a mark of social status? Really? I never knew that was a thing.
- bryanlarsen 8y agohttps://www.nytimes.com/2014/04/10/fashion/The-Growing-Three-Child-Household-in-Manhattan.html https://www.nytimes.com/2014/04/10/fashion/The-Growing-Three...
- shafte 8y agoIt's not. I honestly can't even imagine where the author would get this idea. If anything, having fewer/no children is a mark of status, both globally (higher income countries tend to have lower birth rates) and in the US (vaguely implies both parents are working and have access to contraceptives, etc). To be clear, I don't think that there's much of a status signal either way.
- bryanlarsen 8y agoIt is very much a thing in the US. The middle class almost exclusively has 0, 1 or 2 children; only the poor and the rich have more. 21 percent of families earning > $200K had at least 3 kids in 2011, an increase from 15% in 2000. Every other demographic saw their numbers go down. https://www.nytimes.com/2014/04/10/fashion/The-Growing-Three-Child-Household-in-Manhattan.html https://www.nytimes.com/2014/04/10/fashion/The-Growing-Three... Anecdotally I see that too. Almost all of my children's classmates come from 2 child families with the occasional single; almost all of my wife's surgeon friends have 0 or >2 children.
- olefoo 8y agoAny UBI program that doesn't take basic living expenses ( housing, healthcare, bandwidth, food ) into account is just a fancy detour for the money to go back into the pockets of the ownership class rather than creating lasting wealth for society at large. At best UBI is one element of a comprehensive restructuring of society towards one that actually tries to be a knowledge economy where unique individual talents are cultivated and useful knowledge is discovered and disseminated as widely as possible for the maximum benefit of society as a whole.
- paulsutter 8y agoThe author seems to believe that UBI proponents are opposed to single payer healthcare, and this could be his central beef. He never criticizes UBI itself, he's yammering on about big tech's "view". But it's hard to tell, I had to dig for a while to find an identifiable point. > Yep, but not with five hundred bucks a month, Marc. At least not in your country, where 44% of the population can’t afford a $400 medical emergency.
- shafte 8y agoThe author makes a false equivalence between the RSA in France and the typical UBI proposal. An individual's RSA benefit decreases as their work income increases. This has the effect of making an individual weakly indifferent to working, since it will provide no marginal increase in income. Most UBI proposals involve a benefit that doesn't phase out with income (or phases out at an income level so high that it doesn't matter). The RSA, in both design and implementation, is a lot like the already-existing EITC in the US. The whole point of guaranteeing income is to try to avoid the distortion of incentives that comes from means-testing benefits. When the author claims that a UBI (like the RSA) would create a permanent class of non-workers, he is basing his argument on an elementary misunderstanding of policies involved.
- repolfx 8y agoNo, I think it's a reasonable comparison. Yes, phasing out benefits creates an incentive not to work. But even many UBI proposals have some phase out, if only because the taxpayer paying money to a millionaire feels fundamentally wrong on so many levels. And the bigger problem is more basic. The idea of UBI is that freed from the need to work, people will form utopian societies full of volunteering and self improvement and art projects etc. But France and realistically most welfare systems show that isn't true. People don't engage in self-improvement en-masse. They sit around watching TV or scrolling through Instagram all day, feeling useless and depressed.
- mrfredward 8y agoOur culture ties self-worth to work. From CEOs to social workers, people get fulfillment and create their sense of self by seeing the impact they have while at their jobs, and we judge others based by the same metrics. UBI can help people pay their bills, but poverty is a lot more than a financial problem. The communities where work is drying up are the communities most heavily affected by opioid addiction at the moment. Drugs are expensive--people don't get addicted because they lack money, they get addicted because they feel hopeless or lack a sense of purpose. Maybe government assistance can help hopelessness, but it sure as hell won't give people a sense of purpose. It going to take a big shift in culture before UBI can really work out.
- aeleos 8y agoWhat I don’t get about articles like this is how they just go on and on about how bad of an idea UBI is but don’t propose any kind of a solution. It’s not like UBI was created just to have fun, there are legitimate problems facing our society and our current trajectory is that the problems are getting worse. Maybe I am just missing some part of the article but what’s the point of saying something is bad without even talk about ways it could be implemented better or alternatives.
- lewis500 8y agoYeah all I see here is incoherent posturing. "Most of them [the people living on RSA] indeed live out of poverty, but they are no incentivized whatsoever to get any extra training or even to find a job." This is a plain lie and, besides, has nothing to do with UBI. Regarding, the RSA, it diminishes more slowly than labor earnings (as you can see simply by reading the chart on its short Wikipedia page), so the more money you earn, the more money you get to spend. So there is an incentive to get training and a job. But in any case it has nothing to do with UBI proposals: the UBI idea is that your benefit wouldn't diminish at all as you earn more money, so the incentive to get a job and earn more is even stronger under UBI than under RSA. I think the reason this guy is surrounded by unemployed people living off RSA is that he lives next to defunct villages with high unemployment; these people can't get jobs because they aren't available. Thank god for the benefits then. "I doubt they ever drove a couple of days in the backcountry." Blah blah some ad hominem about tech people being elite nerds that doesn't relate to the efficacy of UBI. I love the implicit claim that this dude gets it because he spends time at his summer home in the rough and tumble "backcountry" of the Loire Valley. "To do so, it must take the long view and start to care about its stakeholders and not only about its shareholders. " Blah blah some word salad that doesn't mean anything specific about policy.
- bena 8y ago> What I don’t get about articles like this is how they just go on and on about how bad of an idea UBI is but don’t propose any kind of a solution. You're falling for the politician's fallacy. You see a problem, you see a proposed solution, and not hearing any other solutions, you've determined that this solution will fix the problem. Recognizing that a solution is bad is worthwhile in and of itself. If he's right and we accept that UBI is the wrong solution to the problem then we can stop funneling time and effort into trying to implement that solution and instead look for a solution that may work. Just because he doesn't have that solution doesn't mean we shouldn't listen to his reasons why UBI won't work. It's like if two non-mechanics were trying to fix an engine and one proposes to slap the engine with his dick until it works again. Just because the other guy doesn't know how to fix the problem doesn't mean he's wrong when he says that slapping the engine with a dick isn't going to fix the problem.
- bumholio 8y agoFor the working class, tech is disrupting faster than it's creating value, the results are more distributional then they are enriching. The self driving car removes the human behind the wheel but does nothing to reduce the cost of the average car. Transportation does not become too cheap to meter - it costs about the same, minus the human salaries, and also minus the cab city tax that was typically redistributed into infrastructure for all. There is almost no venture investment into say nuclear, too cheap to meter electricity. There is no investment into radically new and automated ways to build cheap, quality housing from locally available materials, or refine more, cheaper ore with less impact on the environment, or manufacture more durable, upgradable goods. The supply of stuff is not disrupted by massive abundance, just the social rules about who gets what. It used to be the guys building the stuff in every community who were rewarded; now, all their paychecks go to a single dude in San Francisco that wrote a marginally better algorithm for doing stuff and the next day it spread around the world over the Internet. It turns out, there's nothing unique or special about a human body, just a soon-to-be-outdated type of 3D printer - with a software update latency measured in years and limited write cycles. A basic income capable of lifting people from survival and into knowledge building is on the order of $5000 at current purchasing parity - impossible to finance by any tax or industry unless we radically alter the actual supply of goods.
- Analemma_ 8y agoThere's a fellow I follow on Tumblr who got tired of all the talk about UBI without any concrete specifics, and so took it upon himself to look at actual, real UBI proposals with serious analysis. There are fewer than you'd think, considering how much talk there has been about it: https://squareallworthy.tumblr.com/tagged/ubi https://squareallworthy.tumblr.com/tagged/ubi To be honest, the results are sobering. There are depressingly few proposals to begin with, and they all seem to be fundamentally flawed: they either have a lot of fuzzy math to handwave away problems, or they are politically impossible. Each of his posts ends with "If this is the most serious UBI proposal, there are no serious UBI proposals" and it's a hard point to argue with. I was a strong UBI supporter even six months ago, but between this analysis and questions like "With a $2,000/month UBI payment, won't landlords just simultaneously raise rent by $2,000/month?" with no obvious answers, I'm really pulling back.
- DoofusOfDeath 8y agoI have a working theory that the fundamental differences between conservatives and liberals include the following: (1) While both groups would like an accurate understanding of human nature, conservatives tend to be pessimistic and liberals tend to be optimistic. (2) While both groups would like to be compassionate and charitable, they're riled by different problems: Conservatives especially hate the idea of freeloading / abuse of charity, but liberals especially hate the idea of anyone not receiving the charity. It sounds like Filloux would consider himself a conservative, and the VCs liberals, according to my theory.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- bcoates 8y agoSneering about $500-$1000/month and talking about being able to afford a medical emergency[1] tips the author's hand: He's not worried about the actual poor, he's worried about the losers, mid-income aspirational types that will never be able to afford the lifestyle they're intensely integrated into and aware of. UBI would make their misery even worse, asserting their status over people who "flip burgers for a living" is all they've got. [1] If you're in the US and poor enough that UBI would be life-changing, you're almost certainly either on Medicaid or in a place where the first-line medical treatment is going to an emergency room and skipping out on the bill.
- torstenvl 8y agoEverything about this post is based on supposition, speculation, and a fundamental misunderstanding of UBI. No, Mr. Filloux, nobody is advocating for a $500/mo dole in which recipients have to pay out of pocket for emergency room visits. Nor, dear Sir, is the Revenue de Solidarité Active anything even remotely close to Universal Basic Income, because it is not universal. The straw men are piled so high it constitutes a fire hazard.