4 ms·
There already is a request in congress which was never visited, from the 1800s. From my understanding those never die—but also very unlikely to be brought to t
by mc32 8y ago
There already is a request in congress which was never visited, from the 1800s. From my understanding those never die—but also very unlikely to be brought to the floor.
This new effort has like a 1% chance. I’d give Jefferson State a 2% chance.
- dfee 8y agoI can only assume you’re referring to the Russian propaganda campaign. https://www.kqed.org/news/11217187/from-his-home-in-russia-calexit-leader-plots-california-secession https://www.kqed.org/news/11217187/from-his-home-in-russia-c...
- mc32 8y agoNo, that’s some nut who lives in the urals. The proposed state of Jefferson has been ongoing since a while. The last serious effort was before wwii, so it got derailed by a national emergency. The current three way split is funded by some billionaire guy. It’s actually not a bad idea. The rural interior has way different needs than the coastal areas. Kind of like the downstate upstate dichotomy NY suffers.
- akkartik 8y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jefferson_(proposed_Pacific_state) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jefferson_(proposed_Pacific_st...
- lev99 8y ago> It’s actually not a bad idea. The rural interior has way different needs than the coastal areas. The biggest impact of a new state isn't on the local area that gains a new governor but on the national legislative branch. It creates two new senators and changes the house of representatives adjusting the political balance of the entire nation.
- rectang 8y agoThe three-way split produces 4 new Senators, 2 which would likely be Democrats and 2 which would likely be Republican. That's a wash. California is not currently gerrymandered as far as house seats. That could change for any the three new states. The biggest change would actually be the electoral college. Currently California is winner-take-all and reliably blue. If they split it without splitting another large state like Texas, that compounds the current Republican advantage and makes it even easier for a Republican president to be elected while losing the popular vote. In other words, Draper's ballot initiative is a gerrymander which benefits Republicans. And that's one reason it's going nowhere.
- seanmcdirmid 8y agoIf all those new states go blue, however, republicans lose out on the two extra electoral votes per state. I don’t think republicans really like this either, even SoCal is in the process of going blue in the near term.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> The current three way split is funded by some billionaire guy. True. > It’s actually not a bad idea. It's a phenomenally bad idea. > The rural interior has way different needs than the coastal areas. To the extent that's true, it just proves that the proposed three-way split is a bad idea, since it includes: (1) a south-to-central coastal state (“California”; basically LA plus less populated coastal regions), and (2) a Bay Area and further north coastal + northern half of the inland regions state (“Northern California”, loosely Bay Area + Sacramento + rural regions), and (3) a far southern coast and southern half of the inland regions state (“Southern California”; San Diego + inland rural regions).
- bdowling 8y agoBills that aren't passed in a single Congress (2 year period) are dead and would need to be reintroduced to be considered.