2 ms·
Well, one interesting thing about the article is the way it describes GOFAI as based on false ideas, which is harsh but fair. But in a lot of ways, GOFAI was "a
by joe_the_user 8y ago
Well, one interesting thing about the article is the way it describes GOFAI as based on false ideas, which is harsh but fair. But in a lot of ways, GOFAI was "applied philosophy", at least something of a direct map of one form of rationalist philosophy to computation.
GOFAI was abandoned but the various perspectives remain and current AI goes forward without necessarily having any larger perspective at all, just "make it work". One might guess we're waiting for a different coherent philosophy to organize the process.
- throwawayjava 8y ago> GOFAI was abandoned GOFAI, as a 10ish year era of easy money for CS research agendas, was a relatively cheap investment and ultimately a tremendous financial, economic, and scientific success. If you're using functional languages, sql databases, or networked computers then you're benefitting from GOFAI. ATM you're using all three.
- arethuza 8y agoGOFAI was around for a lot longer than 10 years - it arguably started at the Dartmouth workshop and was still going strong in the '90s - so at least 40 years.
- throwawayjava 8y agobut the easy money didn't persist that entire time. Maybe 20 in total, max. more like 10 most places. point is, most people funded by gofai money weren't doing agi. they were building pls, dbs, networks, etc.
- arethuza 8y agoThat wasn't my experience - few people were really doing AGI (though some were, even up to the early 90s) but most effort in any area that was explicitly identified as AI was generally in applications (e.g. fault diagnosis and qualitative modelling - the areas I worked in).