4 ms·
Have today's engineers somehow stopped believing that the simpler thing is the most useful? Or is it that writing some code to glue together off-the-shelf parts
by StavrosK 8y ago
Have today's engineers somehow stopped believing that the simpler thing is the most useful? Or is it that writing some code to glue together off-the-shelf parts is cheaper and easier than designing and manufacturing a giant machine?
- raverbashing 8y ago> Have today's engineers somehow stopped believing that the simpler thing is the most useful? See how much crap do you have to install before using some modern js framework For some others, you need to use an Arduino to make a led blink Or maybe the true engineers are solving other problems.
- lghh 8y ago> Or maybe the true engineers are solving other problems Nice gatekeeping. Nice gatekeeping.
- raverbashing 8y agoI think a clarification is merited even if I think your comment is a bit low effort Engineering involved, for most of its history, balancing cost (design and production and TCO) x effort x reliability What people see today as an "planned obsolescence" (which does happen in some cases) is one facet of that balance. Yes you can make an incandescent bulb that lasts 1Mi hours. But it will cost more and probably consume 200W instead of 50W for the same luminosity. Using React is not an engineering mistake. Using React for a page that has only a "Coming Soon" text and a picture probably is. And the mess of dependencies and tools that you need to use React/npm is probably not justifiable, especially compared to other systems.
- eeZah7Ux 8y agoSpot on. Most traditional engineering (electrical/electronics, chemical, civil) consider bloat and overcomplexity a big design failure. This is mainly due to the cost of maintaining something during its lifetime.
- bo1024 8y agoOne point is that pushing software into products gives companies more control and power. * The software can collect data about the user. * The software can prevent repairability by the user. * The software can enforce obsolenscence (see the absurdity of smart TVs: an expensive display that can last for 20 years bundled with a super cheap computer that is obsolete in 2). * The software can limit the user's options, in the manufacturer's favor.
- lmm 8y ago> Have today's engineers somehow stopped believing that the simpler thing is the most useful? Simplicity is a means to an end. There's no point in a "simpler" solution if it's more expensive and harder to maintain. > Or is it that writing some code to glue together off-the-shelf parts is cheaper and easier than designing and manufacturing a giant machine? Exactly. Good engineering is about meeting the client's needs, not about showing off your own virtuosity. Too many on HN seem to forget that.
- henriquemaia 8y agoI would argue that if a solution is more expensive or harder to maintain, it is not simpler. Teleologically speaking, being simpler is a bigger umbrella which covers many facets of the intended solution.
- Dylan16807 8y agoI don't think "more expensive" is a valid criterion. When you replace a big chunk of metal with 20 carefully-designed parts that come out to be a third of the price, you have not made things simpler. Even if it comes out as equally difficult to maintain.
- dredmorbius 8y agoSimplicity includesthe dimension of risks imposed by technologically complex solutions.
- skygazer 8y agoMy brain just did something weird. Instead of instantly recognizing two concatenated words, it spent a while trying to work out the pronunciation of an apparently old English word, before Occam’s razor finally kicked in, hopefully before my vocabulary absorbed an errant entry.
- dredmorbius 8y agoApologies (and too late to edit). Really crappy tablet soft-keyboard, and miss-, non-, and duplicate- keyregistrations. That along with lack of preview or spellcheck, scroll-away-from-post mechanics, and tiny edit boxes, are my kryptonite. Occasionally an amusing typo emerges, though not sufficient to compensate for the pain.
- ghaff 8y agoI don't think so. It's just easy to over-optimize things because you can. Personal case in point. I've been hacking together some automated plant watering systems around my house. My initial thought was to have moisture detectors, Raspberry Pi, etc. I ended up just empirically figuring out how many seconds per day I needed to turn on the pump and that was good enough and a lot simpler/more reliable.