4 ms·
Not with current technology because all ad blocking does is blocking hosts. So a site can tell if parts of the code have loaded/executed or not. In order to go
by elorant 8y ago
Not with current technology because all ad blocking does is blocking hosts. So a site can tell if parts of the code have loaded/executed or not. In order to go completely stealth you'd have to let the page load everything and then just don't show it. But that's way more complicated and besides a bit pointless because part of the reason for ad blocking is to make sites load faster by removing all that bloatware. That, or we move ad blocking out of the browser and into the OS where sites have absolutely no access whatsoever.
- akerro 8y ago>Not with current technology because all ad blocking does is blocking hosts That's funny as first adblockers on Firefox used to just hide divs. Browser was still downloading flash object and images, but was not displaying them
- navbaker 8y ago>That, or we move ad blocking out of the browser and into the OS where sites have absolutely no access whatsoever. Interesting concept. Asking as a layman: is this possible? Is the browser sandboxed enough away from the OS that this is a difficult problem? Is that why we haven’t seen solutions that implement this approach?
- elorant 8y agoPossible yes, probable not so much. Building extensions is simpler than building desktop apps. For one you need only JavaScript. While if you move in the OS you'd have to support different versions of systems (you have Windows, OSX, Android, IOS, Linux) and it is much more cumbersome than in the browser.
- gruez 8y ago>That, or we move ad blocking out of the browser and into the OS where sites have absolutely no access whatsoever. that's probably overkill. all you need to do is move the adblocking part further back into the rendering pipeline (ie. outside of the DOM) so that javascript can't detect it.
- stefan_ 8y agoWhat does "move ad blocking out of the browser and into the OS" even mean? As long as you have websites built by JavaScript, trying to do perfect adblocking is solving the halting problem. Can't do that, but we should start fixing the most obvious, glaring abuses (JS need not be able to tell if something actually loaded, no 3rd party host resource, certainly no 3rd party scripts. If I'm putting foo.com in as the address, my browser should only be talking with foo.com)
- elorant 8y agoYou can't turn off third party JS. What if I have an Intranet that's loading an external API. It could be anything from a chat session to analytics. You do that and you break the web.
- perl4ever 8y agoWell, it's feasible if you fork the web instead. If a significant number of people want draconian measures to be taken, and they converge on a search engine that can exclude the non-compliant, then the new standards have a chance of catching on. Suppose I say I just want to eliminate javascript entirely - that's not feasible to enforce, but if I could just search the non-javascript pages out there, then a new way of doing things can be bootstrapped.
- stefan_ 8y agoUhm, external analytics is exactly what we're trying to break here. And if you need an external API, have whoever is serving the Intranet page load that - that's how it's been forever. Websites loading data through JS from 20+ endpoints on a single page is very much a recent disease.
- krageon 8y agoI run all of my browsers (including mobile) with all 3rd party scripts blocked by default. Most sites that you care to casually consume will work without issue. Anything that uses a payment provider or google to login needs 2 greylist rules (which are mind-numbingly simple to click on once). I can set it up for people that don't understand what they are doing (and I have) and they will not notice anything in almost every case. As such, I conclude that this generalisation is grossly overstated and you probably haven't tried it to see if what you are saying is correct.
- contravariant 8y agoI don't see how moving to an even higher level of abstraction would help. At the OS level you can basically only block hosts (unless you're inspecting packages but that seems excessive). Doing what uBlock origin does by loading dummy versions of common tracking scripts is a lot more effective.
- scarface74 8y agoThe reason I use an ad blocker is not to see intrusive ads. I've whitelisted a site and told Safari to immediate go in reader view mode for the site. It's a decent compromise.