9 ms·
City street orientations around the world
- smcl 8y agoAnyone know why Philadelphia has a kinda NSEW orientation like the other cities but rotated ever so slightly? Manhattan is similar and it makes sense (they are aligned with the island itself), but Philadelphia is so close to the actual compass points and not aligned with anything really else.
- blatherard 8y agoAs I understand it, the grid plan originated in Philadelphia in a stretch of land between the Delaware and Schyulkhill rivers. This portion, which is now generally called Center City, has a grid that aligns itself with the Delaware which runs at that point a little East of North. The rest of the city grew up extending that grid.
- madcaptenor 8y agoAlso, that particular point was picked, I believe, because it was the shortest distance between the Delaware and the Schuylkill. (Well, except for a few miles downriver where the Schuylkill flows into the Delaware, but South Philly was basically swamps back then.) See for example https://hiddencityphila.org/2015/08/courtyard-compass-reveals-a-city-off-axis/ https://hiddencityphila.org/2015/08/courtyard-compass-reveal...
- Piskvorrr 8y agoRiver. The almost-north-south orientation runs parallel to a stretch of the Delaware; same way that Manhattan's uptown/downtown/crosstown are rectangular, but not aligned with the compass points.
- mirimir 8y agoThe ~same offset appears in Penn's original plan.[0] Maybe it was based on geomagnetic north? The magnetic declination in Philadelphia is now about -13 degrees, but it was maybe -8 degrees in 1682.[1] 0) http://www.ushistory.org/philadelphia/images/philadelphia1.gif http://www.ushistory.org/philadelphia/images/philadelphia1.g... 1) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magnetic_declination https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magnetic_declination
- 0x45696e6172 8y agoHow come there appears to be symmetry in Rio de Janeiro?
- systoll 8y ago180 degree rotational symmetry happens because almost all roads are bidirectional -- if there's a road pointing north, it's also a road pointing south. 90 degree symmetry seems like a consequence of the road system consisting more of straightness and 90 degree turns, with no other specific angle being common. https://www.google.com/maps/@-22.9111837,-43.2566471,14z https://www.google.com/maps/@-22.9111837,-43.2566471,14z Rio fits the bill. There's no overarching grid, but if you zoom into any small area, you'll usually find a pattern of rectangular blocks with 90 degree intersections. As far as I can see, the only viable way out rotational symmetry would be to use concentric 'ring-blocks' either for local areas or for the city as a whole. The rings would cancel themselves out, and the 'spokes' could be places relatively freely. So... Canberra might have an interesting distribution? https://www.google.com/maps/place/Canberra+ACT+2601/@-35.2883807,149.1116899,14z/data=!4m5!3m4!1s0x6b164d69b05c9021:0x500ea6ea7695660!8m2!3d-35.2809368!4d149.1300092 https://www.google.com/maps/place/Canberra+ACT+2601/@-35.288...
- noelwelsh 8y agoFunnily enough I find organic street layouts easier to navigate as a tourist than grid systems. In an organic layout there are central roads that go to places of interest and the smaller streets flow to the central roads. In a grids all the roads look the same (they have the same size for example) so I often can't work out how I'm oriented and wandering around doesn't necessarily lead to anywhere interesting. I also find grids less satisfying to walk. I feel they favour cars over pedestrians. I'm always stopping for traffic lights in New York while I feel I can walk mostly without interruption in London. London roads are also more interesting because you don't know what's around the corner. Conclusion: these are pretty graphs but I think the claims in the first post are overstated. Experiments are required.
- molf 8y agoAs a European, I agree. US cities are confusing to me because streets all look the same. I find it impossible to locate interesting areas without prior knowledge. Maybe what seems easiest to navigate depends on what you’re used to?
- noelwelsh 8y agoI think so. My US colleagues seem to find it very easy to get around unfamiliar US cities but seem to struggle in European cities. I expect we have very different unconscious navigation algorithms.
- bfirsh 8y agoI am from London and lived in the US for a bit. I struggled to navigate. I think it is because I navigate by modelling the shape of the streets. When all the streets are the same shape, that subconscious system stops working. I also tend to find I underestimate distances in grid systems. I think it’s because in European cities I estimate distance by the number of distinct shapes I can remember on the way there. In a grid, I think my brain smushes all those identical block shapes into one. In a similar way to how time flies when doing a repetitive task.
- TomK32 8y agoBecause cities do grow it would be interesting to color parts of the ray depending on the age of the streets/districts with that direction.
- retrac98 8y agoI grew up in the UK where most towns and cities have roads going in all directions. I've always found the grid layout of US cities difficult to navigate, which is strange because it's objectively a much simpler system. The sameness of each block and straightness of the roads makes it really hard for me to position myself with sight alone, whereas in the UK there seems to be more uniqueness to each road that makes it easier for me to find my way around. Interestingly, my US friends who've visited the UK have had the exact opposite experience!
- jaclaz 8y ago>I grew up in the UK where most towns and cities have roads going in all directions. ...and - as an observation from an alien - have much more interesting names and shapes : https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/How_to_be_an_Alien https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/How_to_be_an_Alien http://f2.org/humour/howalien.html http://f2.org/humour/howalien.html How to plan a town: http://f2.org/humour/howalien.html#Plan http://f2.org/humour/howalien.html#Plan
- fredley 8y agoUS grid cities are really easy to navigate by car, but at the expense of pedestrians. Old cities like London are easy to navigate on foot, but hard to navigate by car.
- onion2k 8y agoReally interesting. I suspect there's something about the political climate more than the age of the city that dictates the orientation of the roads. Where societies where strongly controlled by small group of leaders (religious leaders, monarchs, city planners, etc) the streets ended up much more coherent. Where cities grew organically as needed the layouts are less coherent. Also, what happened in Charlotte?!
- icebraining 8y agoWhen a city is 1000 years old or more, the societies that control it will inevitably shift between more and less strongly controlled over the years, so unless it suffered a massive razing that required full reconstruction not long ago, there's only so much a central planner can do. You can see that in Lisbon, for example; the downtown area is quite grid-like since it was rebuilt by a single leader after the earthquake and subsequent tsunami of 1755, but the rest either stood or was built later, under a variety of different regimes - the Roman Empire, Visigoths, Caliphates, Christian monarchies, etc.
- pitt1980 8y agoI was curious about Charlotte as well, best I could find: ----- The streets of most newer American cities follow very clear East-West and North-South grid patterns, but not here. The streets of Charlotte have some of the most unusual patterns in the world. Our city may seem like a new city, but it actually has a very rich history of Native Americans, famous battles, and gold. We were founded in 1768 (and officially declared independence from England in 1775) at the crossroads of two Native-American trading paths which ran northeast-southwest and northwest-southeast. That intersection is now the center of our city – Trade and Tryon. Trade and Tryon Streets became the framework for Uptown, which now has blocks that look more like diamonds than squares. The crazy shape of our highways primarily evolved from the shape of the two major creeks, Irwin Creek (77 and top part of 277), and Little Sugar Creek (bottom part of 277). I still haven’t figured out why i85 runs west to east at times, and south to north other times, but it most likely also has it’s roots in the Carolina Peidmond geography as well. The reason for some of the other crazy anomalies in our city (Queens/Providence intersection, Queens loop, all the Sharon rds., etc) stem from the old farmers routes. The city of Charlotte was never really designed to be a major city, so many of the small winding trails simply grew over time. http://www.charlottestories.com/heres-why-the-streets-in-charlotte-dont-run-north-and-south-or-east-and-west/ http://www.charlottestories.com/heres-why-the-streets-in-cha... quick glance at google maps confirms that most of the major roads don't seem to be straight lines, and what grids there are, don't appear to follow any consistent directional orientation https://www.google.com/maps/@35.2120603,-80.8169718,11z?hl=en https://www.google.com/maps/@35.2120603,-80.8169718,11z?hl=e...
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- detaro 8y agosome discussion already in the submission of the american cities only article: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17507676 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17507676
- ericdykstra 8y agoThis is a fun, short video on the different types of city plans (gridiron, organic, radial, loose grid), some examples of each, and some observations on each of them. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zSnt0MTMcbw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zSnt0MTMcbw And from that video I found these cool visualizations of cities and their street orientations: http://www.datapointed.net/2014/10/maps-of-street-grids-by-orientation/ http://www.datapointed.net/2014/10/maps-of-street-grids-by-o...
- mislankanova 8y agoIf anyone is interested in how the layout of a city affects the way in which people perceive the city mentally, you may find the book The Image of the City by Kevin Lynch a nice read. The book talks about how people create mental models of the cities in which they live, using certain abstract elements (paths, landmarks et cetra) that are present in their cities.
- sfifs 8y agoThis is very interesting! I wonder what the chart would look like if the lengths in each direction represented total lengths of streets in that orientation. Hypothesis for some of the oldest European cities which look like big circles currently - the older parts of the cities which would likely have streets going in all directions are small - so the fat circles would get smaller and we'd start seeing spokes for the newer parts of the cities.
- quickthrower2 8y agoSydney would be interesting to add, being a harbour city. With weird stuff like it can take a 10km trip by land to get somewhere just 1km away "as the crow flies"
- bostonpete 8y agoSydney is there though....
- quickthrower2 8y agoOops. Need to get my retinas checked.
- madeofpalk 8y agoHuh - Sydney's arrangement is a lot 'neater' than I would have expected. I would love to know what area it actually counted. The small CBD is rather grid-like, but once you extend past that it gets a bit higgledy-piggledy.
- InsIStERm 8y agoThis looks mindblowing. I see most popular (world-wide and region-wise) and most unique orientations
- nicheasta 8y agoWhat a great idea! Wouldn't have ever thought of that myself. I would love to see more of these and more comparisons. Let's say what are more popular layout for some regions or world-wide or what are most unique. Also, would be interesting to see comparison of same city oldtown to the rest of the city.
- n4r9 8y agoI wonder how roundabouts in European cities would affect these plots, since in OSM they are often represented as a single way. The original post about this says: "OSMnx automatically calculates all of the streets’ bearings. Specifically it calculates the compass bearing from each directed edge’s origin node u to its destination node v." I suppose it depends what they mean by "directed edge". I'd expect it's what most modern routers use i.e. the portion of a way which goes between two junction nodes. Although it might mean literally every section of a way, which in some sense would be more accurate. Either way, you would expect roundabouts to bloat out the plot.
- bartkappenburg 8y agoI followed his jupyter notebook [0] and recreated it for all big dutch cities: https://imgur.com/a/EdvDrZY https://imgur.com/a/EdvDrZY Lelystad is very symmetric! [0]: https://github.com/gboeing/osmnx-examples/blob/master/notebooks/17-street-network-orientations.ipynb https://github.com/gboeing/osmnx-examples/blob/master/notebo...
- mfringel 8y agoVery nice! I didn't see it on the image, but maybe it got cropped out. Did you give credit to the original author for the code/idea?
- nautilus12 8y agoCould someone explain some actionable insights that could possibly come from these visualization?
- 24gttghh 8y agoOne I pondered is how some cities have a primary axis offset a few degrees from N/S, either more to the East or more to the West and how that might be related to their location in a given time zone with respect to where the sun rises/sets to shine directly down a majority of streets. I think of this in terms of perhaps not placing most streets in a grid where you would have to drive directly into the sun around dawn/dusk for most of the year, but it probably has more to do with the local topography; bodies of water or hills in the way, that kinda thing.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- Stratoscope 8y agoRedwood City, California has a strange mix of street grids. There's a roughly NSEW grid downtown, with separate grids to the northwest and southeast angled about 45 degrees. The grids meet in confusing jumbles of triangles: https://www.google.com/maps/@37.4861576,-122.2356476,15z https://www.google.com/maps/@37.4861576,-122.2356476,15z It's easy to see where the 45 degree grids came from: one parallels El Camino and the railroad tracks, the other parallels Middlefield Road. But why the abrupt change to a NSEW grid in between? Downtown Redwood City was once a shipping harbor and a center of the redwood logging trade (thus the name). Redwood Creek ran N-S through this area, and downtown was built up around it. If you're familiar with the area, the multistory parking garage between Broadway/Marshall/Main/Jefferson is located where the "turning basin" was: a wide part of the creek where ships could turn around, with businesses along the banks. Broadway was originally named Bridge Street, for its drawbridge that connected the two sides of the creek. There's an interesting historical marker on Broadway across from the driveway into the garage, and here are a few pages with maps and photos: https://1084.myt.li/tours/45512040/stops/1980869008/index.html https://1084.myt.li/tours/45512040/stops/1980869008/index.ht... http://www.redwoodcityport.com/p7iq/Assets/port_history_for_web.pdf http://www.redwoodcityport.com/p7iq/Assets/port_history_for_... http://www.redwoodcity.org/Home/ShowDocument?id=1038 http://www.redwoodcity.org/Home/ShowDocument?id=1038 [PDF]
- underwater 8y agoThe quirky layout is not at all obvious when you’re on the ground, either I had a few “how did I end up here” moments when driving through the city.
- llimllib 8y agoHere's the road orientation graphic for Redwood City: https://i.imgur.com/iueLofq.png https://i.imgur.com/iueLofq.png
- JorgeGT 8y agoIt would be interesting to add a color dimension with the average age of buildings registered to each street, I'm thinking about cities that Madrid where a combination of "omnidirectional" and "4-direction grid" patterns is clearly visible.
- ansgri 8y agoVery distinctive pattern for Moscow — basically it's a very centralized city with ~15 major radial roads, which segment circular roads into separate streets. It's interesting that the most similar histogram is for Rome, which has also been a center for hypercentralization of power.
- wodenokoto 8y agoI'd love to see comparisons between Manhatten and New York, or central Kyoto and Kyoto proper, as well as other old Asian capitals that were often based on a grid system, but might not have kept it outside "the old city"
- iambateman 8y agoThe most remarkable city I’ve ever visited is Seville, Spain. It has a labyrinth of tiny streets and apparently no grid. As a pedestrian, I felt like I could get “lost” while never really being truly lost. In fact, I think I could still get around in Seville without a map if you dropped me into a random spot. On the other hand, I live 90 minutes from Charlotte and have been there a dozen times and have absolutely no clue how to navigate that city. It’s a mess.
- totally 8y agoCan this visualization ever be non-symmetrical? Like, a street that goes north tends to go south if you're headed in the other direction. Is it one-way streets that make Charlotte's visualization non-symmetrical?
- heartbreak 8y agoHouston's graph is oriented like +, but the downtown grid in Houston should be represented like x.
- bonyt 8y agoCool. Out of curiosity, I ran the Jupyter notebook[1] on the five boroughs of NYC + Nassau County on Long Island, and got the following graphic: https://i.imgur.com/LyxP6yQ.png https://i.imgur.com/LyxP6yQ.png I'm a bit surprised by the results, since Nassau in particular doesn't have anything resembling a county-wide grid system that I know of. I like the diagram for Queens, since it technically has a grid[2], although it shifts in places to be at a different angle, like Long Island City / Hunters Point, which were originally their own cities with their own design plans. The diagram for Brooklyn is really interesting as well. [1]: https://github.com/gboeing/osmnx-examples/blob/master/notebooks/17-street-network-orientations.ipynb https://github.com/gboeing/osmnx-examples/blob/master/notebo... [2]: https://stevemorse.org/census/changes/QueensFormat.htm https://stevemorse.org/census/changes/QueensFormat.htm EDIT: Perhaps scale is a bit deceiving here. The original had every graph on a different scale, so I modified it to have a fixed scale instead, which shows how disproportionately organized Manhattan is compared to the other boroughs / LI: https://i.imgur.com/l3yV1sY.png https://i.imgur.com/l3yV1sY.png
- danesparza 8y agoThis is incredibly misleading. Atlanta proper only accounts for a small percentage of the roads in the Atlanta metro area -- but it's the only place that actually has roads on a grid. The rest of Atlanta has roads that go in every damn direction (and would probably look a lot more like Charlotte if plotted)
- Zaskoda 8y agoI live in Seattle. There's a famous story about how we ended up with half of our streets running along one grid that was N,S,E,W and another grid that was aligned with the water front. As they built the city, these two patterns merged to create a total fuster cluck. I am extremely confident that the graph for Seattle is incorrect.
- imaoreo 8y agoWashington too, a good chunk of our streets are diagonal.