4 ms·
> Including purchase prices in the CPI would be just as silly as including 401(k) contributions. If 401k contributions were deemed by 60% of Americans to be a
by mistermann 8y ago
> Including purchase prices in the CPI would be just as silly as including 401(k) contributions.
If 401k contributions were deemed by 60% of Americans to be a ~necessary part of their life.
And whether or not you're going to get it back....you may, yes, but then again, you may not, in a very big way. For example, perhaps there's a gigantic bubble going on.
It's a bit of a philosophical question really - is the government's role to inform people of reality, or to shape their perception of reality.
At least a partial role of the CPI is to measure inflation, and reflect the real world costs to real world citizens. If not, then why fund this department?
Would you be philosophically opposed to publishing two CPI numbers: one as is (that uses estimates), and one that uses actuals that are consistent with the actual economic environment citizens experience according to the way they have chosen to arrange their lives?
- nradov 8y agoYes I would be philosophically opposed to the government publishing CPI numbers that include durable investments of any kind. CPI should only be consumption. People can always choose to rent instead of buy.
- mistermann 8y ago60% of people choose to buy for reasons that are their own business. The question is whether two numbers should be printed, so taxpayers know what is actually happening in their economy. So, you are supporting deceit. Which is your choice, of course.