3 ms·

I can't see any obvious place to download this dirt protocol so I can check (the website seems to be 100% marketing, 0% documentation), but based on a combinati

I can't see any obvious place to download this dirt protocol so I can check (the website seems to be 100% marketing, 0% documentation), but based on a combination of pattern recognition and the evasiveness of the above answer, I would wager the answer is "there is no process, we didn't think about data deletion".

NegativeLatency 8y ago
Yeah sounded to me like: "It's a feature!"
Semirhage 8y ago
You’re being generous... this reeks more of scam than carelessness. Either way, it’s going to never actually be delivered, not be GDPR complient, and based on the answers to questions raised here, full of obvious holes. If it isn’t just a scam, it smells like someone went from “here’s a neat idea I’ve spent a whole ten minutes on,” to fundraising without a beat in between. No resistance to censorship. No resistance to conflicting information. More money = more “truth” with no recourse, because removing info costs. Incorrect info loses you money, but there is no functional systemic way to determine correct/incorrect. Waaaaay too much marketing and nothing else extant.
- paulie_a 8y ago
  For most of the planet GDPR is irrelevant. I personally will never give it any thought when building something.
  - Semirhage 8y ago
    Failing to give thought to something doesn’t make it go away, but of course it’s your right not to think. As long as you understand that ideology and opinion aside, it can greatly impact your ability to do business in Europe, then you go be you. Most companies don't do business in Europe. As defined under GDPR? I’d love citations for that claim.
    - paulie_a 8y ago
      Most companies don't do business in Europe.
      - Aeolun 8y ago
        That's an interesting argument. But unfortunately, it was beaten out by 2%. https://www.inc.com/anne-gherini/fifty-two-percent-of-us-businesses-are-affected-by-this-new-regulation.html https://www.inc.com/anne-gherini/fifty-two-percent-of-us-bus...
yinyinwu 8y ago
Hi there - We are auditing our smart contracts prior to launch and plan to open source them. If you are interested in trying out the protocol on launch, send us a note. Per GDPR specifically, I am learning about the regulations and my understanding is that the right to be forgotten focuses on personal information. Personal information is not a great fit for DIRT registries because it is not publicly verifiable. The concept of voting to determine correctness works best if that data is public and observable.

NegativeLatency 8y ago

Yeah sounded to me like: "It's a feature!"

Semirhage 8y ago

You’re being generous... this reeks more of scam than carelessness. Either way, it’s going to never actually be delivered, not be GDPR complient, and based on the answers to questions raised here, full of obvious holes. If it isn’t just a scam, it smells like someone went from “here’s a neat idea I’ve spent a whole ten minutes on,” to fundraising without a beat in between. No resistance to censorship. No resistance to conflicting information. More money = more “truth” with no recourse, because removing info costs. Incorrect info loses you money, but there is no functional systemic way to determine correct/incorrect. Waaaaay too much marketing and nothing else extant.

paulie_a 8y ago
For most of the planet GDPR is irrelevant. I personally will never give it any thought when building something.
- Semirhage 8y ago
  Failing to give thought to something doesn’t make it go away, but of course it’s your right not to think. As long as you understand that ideology and opinion aside, it can greatly impact your ability to do business in Europe, then you go be you. Most companies don't do business in Europe. As defined under GDPR? I’d love citations for that claim.
  - paulie_a 8y ago
    Most companies don't do business in Europe.
    - Aeolun 8y ago
      That's an interesting argument. But unfortunately, it was beaten out by 2%. https://www.inc.com/anne-gherini/fifty-two-percent-of-us-businesses-are-affected-by-this-new-regulation.html https://www.inc.com/anne-gherini/fifty-two-percent-of-us-bus...

yinyinwu 8y ago

Hi there - We are auditing our smart contracts prior to launch and plan to open source them. If you are interested in trying out the protocol on launch, send us a note. Per GDPR specifically, I am learning about the regulations and my understanding is that the right to be forgotten focuses on personal information. Personal information is not a great fit for DIRT registries because it is not publicly verifiable. The concept of voting to determine correctness works best if that data is public and observable.