8 ms·
The Role of Personality, Authoritarianism and Cognition in Brexit
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- sonnyblarney 8y agoThis really does need to be broken down by demographic because given the tilts in age, immigration status, social status, urban/rural among voters, all of this just might be a measure of one group vs another. 'Londoners more neurotic, Villagers more conscientious and authoritarian' Also - I don't like the term 'authoritarian' in this context as it's ill defined.
- pjc50 8y ago"RWA authoritarian" is pretty well defined as "someone who scores highly on this test": http://www.panojohnson.com/automatons/rwa-scale.xhtml http://www.panojohnson.com/automatons/rwa-scale.xhtml If you scroll down a bit in the original article there's a breakdown of subject RWA scores by age and gender. It even has error bars.
- fortythirteen 8y agoFor reference, I got a 59, which is securely within the supposed "non-authoritarian" side. That being said, the questions in that test are quite binary and, The RW in RWA being for "Right Wing", heavily biased towards "authoritarianism" being a solely right wing, religiously conservative thing, which it is most certainly not. There were no questions on the test that would capture a pure Stalinist/Maoist as the obvious authoritarian he/she is. This throws the entire study into question on its claims. Also, with regards to the original study, the high degree of neuroticism in remainers could easily be characterized as them being susceptible to fear based propaganda.
- epx 8y agoThanks for the mention of this test. I scored 51, but for some reason I am known as the 'right wing conservative AWM' in some circles. I just suppose that even liberal people judge by looks (I do look like the prototypical AWM) and by small disagreements about some liberal thesis (e.g. I don't agree with 100% with current feminism mantras, yet in absolute terms I agree 90% with feminists in general and disagree 99.9% with barefoot&pregnant types). There is a lot of cargo cult among liberals.
- fortythirteen 8y agoLike most situations, you learn more about someone from the questions they ask than the answers they give. The creator(s) of that survey have some extremely binary world views.
- misnome 8y agoI'd be very hesitant to make that conclusion. Much more likely is that more nuanced middle-ground questions are a lot more open to individual interpretation than the "extreme" statements, and thus give you a lot less "signal" in what you are trying to measure - even some of these could be seen as widely open to interpretation. I'm guessing the scale (rather than agree/disagree) is attempting to compensate for this somewhat. (Caveat: I'm a scientist but not with a background in anything close to Psychology; I've seen but not written these sorts of tests).
- shubb 8y agoIt sounds like you have views that are controversial in your social environment. That's not authritarian - that's anti-authoritarian. If you had those views because everyone around you had them, and didn't like people disagreeing because it was outside social norms, then you would be authoritarian. In Germany, people with high RWA are probably very anti-rascist for instance. It's an interesting metric.
- rayiner 8y ago> It is always better to trust the judgment of the proper authorities in government and religion than to listen to the noisy rabble-rousers in our society who are trying to create doubt in people’s minds. I have no idea what this is supposed to measure, but it sounds like garbage to me. It’s literally a test of how people identify themselves (either as establishment or as a “rabble rouser”). Then arbitrarily labeling the earablishment supporters as “autboritarian.” To see why thia question is ridiculous: Imagine asking this question to people in Tehran during the Shah. In that case, the “proper authorities” were the western-aligned Shah government, while the “rabble rousers” would be the Islamists. But it was the rabble rousers’ view that was authoritarian.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- sparkie 8y ago> You have to admire those who challenged the law and the majority’s view by protesting for women’s abortion rights, for animal rights ... This one is completely nuts. Mistreating animals: Not good. Mistreating unborn babies: Totally fine! Disclaimer: I am not anti-abortion, but I'm certainly not pro-abortion in the way I am pro-animal rights.
- astura 8y ago>Important: You may find that you sometimes have different reactions to different parts of a statement. For example, you might very strongly disagree (“-4”) with one idea in a statement, but slightly agree (“+1”) with another idea in the same item. When this happens, please combine your reactions, and [record] how you feel on balance (a “-3” in this case).
- pjc50 8y ago> To see why thia question is ridiculous: Imagine asking this question to people in Tehran during the Shah. In that case, the “proper authorities” were the western-aligned Shah government, while the “rabble rousers” would be the Islamists. But it was the rabble rousers’ view that was authoritarian. This illustrates both a problem with trying to retroactively jam events into ideological frameworks, and a tragedy of revolutionary parties. At the time, the Shah's government was percieved as authoritarian - that's why there was a revolution in the first place. But it turns out that the violent overthrow of a government (internally or externally) tends to result in the new government exerting extreme force to maintain its position against ""counter-revolutionaries"". Perhaps the unique thing about the American revolution is that it wasn't followed by a Terror, and the civil war was deferred for another century by interpreting "all men are created equal" to mean "not all men".
- pattrn 8y agoThe amount of bias in the wording of these questions makes me skeptical of the survey's usefulness. It feels more like a questionnaire about support of various social issues, where if you disagree with the social issue then you get categorized as authoritarian. For instance, it's very possible to believe that protesters are frequently wrong and that authorities are frequently correct without being an authoritarian. You can believe those things without believing it's the government's duty or responsibility to enforce your personal beliefs. Many of the questions exhibit this problem. One of the questions in particular categorizes you as less authoritarian if you support abolishing prayer in schools. By definition, using government to reduce personal freedom is an authoritarian policy, which makes banning prayer an authoritarian policy. This type of bias shows up in many of the questions. Scores from this test seem to represent how closely the person who answered matches the social views of the survey's author. I'm not sure how useful that is to anyone other than the author.
- shubb 8y agoIt is also possible that they were looking for 'questions that indicate cluster membership'. RWA could be defined as "tendency to trust in authority, value obeying rules, and dislike people who break rules". It's a bad name, as someone in a left wing country with high RWA would tend to disapprove of right wing protesters for instance. So in designing the test you put together a huge list of questions that vagually relate to RWA, collect answers, and then look for ones that tend to cluster together. 'People who answer yes to this tend to answer yes to these others'. You then remove the ones that show poor correlation, and you have a test.
- danek 8y agoI think you have it backwards. Abolishing prayer in school is not authoritarianism and doesn’t reduce personal freedom. You’re still free to pray on your own at school. Having an official religion is authoritarian (unless it’s a religious school), and pressuring people to participate in a prayer is pressuring them to have less personal freedom (from your religion). I guess authoritarians tend to view a policy which gives equal preference to everyone as an attack on their “special status” and a reduction of their freedoms.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- reefoctopus 8y agoThe book mentioned at the bottom of the page with the broken link should point here: http://theauthoritarians.org/Downloads/TheAuthoritarians.pdf http://theauthoritarians.org/Downloads/TheAuthoritarians.pdf
- belorn 8y agoLet me rewrite a few of those questions. I wonder how those would change the outcome. The established authorities generally turn out to be wrong as right, while the extremist on all ends of the political scale are usually just “loud mouths” that ignore facts in favor of political positioning. In marriage men should have to promise to serve and protect their wife, and women should have to promise to obey their husbands. Nudist are an recognized minority group and should have their rights protected in the same way as groups that identify based on religion or sexual orientation. You have to admire those who challenged the law and the majority’s view by protesting for women’s abortion rights, Mens rights to consented parenthood, for animal rights, or to abolish school prayer. Abolishment of gender roles is good. The days when women and men are identified based on their gender belong strictly in the past.
- maldusiecle 8y agoI like it, you took all the clearly written statements and added non sequiturs and grammatical errors to them.
- fallingfrog 8y agoI scored 20 (zero percent authoritarian), but I mean those were some pretty extreme and silly questions. I can't see anyone really scoring too high on a test like this who isn't completely crazy!
- sonnyblarney 8y agoI really don't like this survey, and I'm not really sure that it measures anything other than a specific kind of cultural conservatism. There are those who have very authoritative views over how one ought to act that wouldn't be defined as culturally conservative, for example, within the intersectional movement, there are those who believe that one cannot say 'America is a meritocracy and those who work hard can get ahead' because it doesn't fully respect someone's life experience given their race and gender. To the extent that this is an 'infraction' in certain public institutions. Agree or not - it's 'authoritative', just not in the traditional terms. Even if the survey measured this kind of authoritarianism more broadly, I'm not sure it would be measuring something fully.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- pjc50 8y agoSee previous work by the late Chris Lightfoot (2005): http://www.ex-parrot.com/~chris/wwwitter/20050415-my_country_right_or_left.html http://www.ex-parrot.com/~chris/wwwitter/20050415-my_country... Main finding of principal components analysis: "Slightly facetiously we refer to this as the `Axis of UKIP': the extremal positive views are those of people who are Eurosceptic, believe in capital punishment and harsh prison régimes, and oppose immigration. At the other end of the axis people believe in further European integration, the primacy of international law, the benefits of immigration, and so forth. This axis is identifiably left/right -- people at large positive positions are definitely `right wing' -- but it is not the traditional left/right axis of economics and class division."
- Kenji 8y agoIn a situation where “In general, political campaign material in the UK is not regulated, and it is a matter for voters to decide on the basis of such material whether they consider it accurate or not” (The Electoral Commission, 2018) the research also raises the question of whether existing regulatory controls need to be amended. Not only do many voters lack the skills to critically evaluate the information which is being presented, their inherent beliefs and biases clearly influence the way in which they process this information. Yeah, how about outlawing voting against those who are currently in power? We little people cannot judge the issues anyways. Why not abolish democracy completely since we're all so stupid?
- xamuel 8y agoNot sure why people are down-voting you. That's a very important and dangerous quotation from the article. This whole situation sheds a dim light on UK politics: is voting in the UK nothing more than a ritual to legitimize decisions already blessed by the powers that be?
- commandlinefan 8y agoI see more and more stirrings of similar sentiments here in America every day, too.
- Kenji 8y agoIt's because of the snark. People don't like sarcasm because it's negative.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- fortythirteen 8y agoTheir authoritarian scale is the RWA, or Right Wing Authoritarianism. They did no test for general authoritarianism, meaning that their summary is suspect. It's no surprise to anyone that the mostly left-wing remain voters scored low in right wing authoritarianism. Edit: thanks for the brigaded downvotes with no rebuttal, proving that you just don't like your cognitive biases challenged with facts.
- maldusiecle 8y agoYes, a pity that the researchers didn't correlate Brexit positions with Stalinism and Maoism, political stances that are definitely widespread common enough that they could find meaningful connections.
- fortythirteen 8y agoI'm assuming sarcasm, so forgive me if I'm wrong. I'm a pretty centrist, non-politically active guy, and I personally have one acquaintance that identifies as a marxist, another as a communist, and a third, literally as a "radical feminist marxist" who has participated in protests/riots. I know nobody that identifies as a fascist. Anecdotally, left-wing authoritarianism is much more prevalent in my milktoast town. Edit, because HN won't let me reply to the claim of "misunderstanding" Marxism (and the clear gaslighting of the words "communist" and "radical" that were used): Clearly, my "radical marxist" acquaintance destroying public and private property, while actually flying the Soviet flag, is wholly misunderstood for the non-authoritarian, peaceful, theoretical marxism it actually is. Edit 2: Are you perceiving the whole comment or is your cognitive bias actually blocking out the words "communist" and "soviet"? You're picking a minute fraction of my sentences that suit your disposition and acting like they're the whole.
- maldusiecle 8y agoMarxism is not the same as Stalinism or Maoism, and is not necessarily an authoritarian belief system. Fascism is by definition authoritarian. I don't know how you define "left-wing authoritarianism," but the fact that you treat participating in a protest as some extreme point of it suggests to me that you don't know much at all. Edit: If you think destroying property is necessarily authoritarian, once again, you don't know what that word means. Edit 2 (seriously, this is the way you want to have a discussion?): going on and on about "gaslighting" and "cognitive biases" isn't make you look any better. I've known a number of people who toy with soviet chic without actually condoning the actions of the USSR; it's not a surprising in a country where the mildest trade unionism is equated with Full Communism by a large part of the population. I don't like it, but I know enough to know that most of the people flying it aren't Stalinists (or Maoists) by any stretch of the imagination.
- User23 8y agoI believe the real distinction is susceptibility to different types of persuasion. It’s easily observable that the vast majority of people don’t have their own opinion on any subject that receives significant media attention, because their opinion is exactly that espoused by said media (this includes entertainment as well as news). Since the remain faction had almost complete media support, we must conclude that brexit voters were persuaded by other factors. I believe this approach of looking at biddability rather than whatever the arbitry set of opinions being pushed at present will lead to better models.
- pjc50 8y ago> susceptibility to different types of persuasion It's interesting to read Dominic Cummings on this. He talks about how Leave thoroughly tested all their slogans, and came up with "£350m for the NHS" as the most effective. The fact that, after you net out all the downsides of Brexit, that's an entirely fictional number that could never be delivered, never entered into it. This immunity to caring about deliverability is ultimately why the cabinet Brexiteers achieved nothing and eventually have had to resign.
- yayana 8y ago> is ultimately why the cabinet Brexiteers achieved nothing and eventually have had to resign. Are you sure? I thought their original plan was to lose the vote and run on "I told you so" for the rest of their careers. Having won, they had to accept positions offered to them out of spite, but they want to be as far away from the result as possible to say the fallout of renegotiating everything as a country with an unknown relationship to every other country is not "their" Brexit. I for one look forward to seeing what the EU thinks of Britain's difficult to reach internal agreement to steal everything that isn't tied down.. But whether the EU goes hard or soft on them, it leaves a lot of incentives for either a land or individual politicians to try an exit campaign for selfish reasons.
- pjc50 8y ago> Since the remain faction had almost complete media support Leave was (still is!) supported by the Sun, Mail, Express, Telegraph, some of the Times columnists, and arguably whoever in the BBC was responsible for UKIP being on BBCQT far beyond their electoral success would merit.
- ithilglin909 8y agoConsidering that this is a politically charged topic and psychological studies in general seem to have low reproducibility rates, this is the kind of research that, without any disrespect to scientific research in general, is worth taking with a large grain of salt.
- dan-robertson 8y agoAs I read it, this article (or rather, its abstract) seems to work as: 1. The population is divided into leave voters and remain voters (and undecided) 2. Some statistics will be different between these sets 3. Looking at the election campaign and these characteristics can tell us about how to target an election campaign according to these statistics [of the people who will eventually/currently plan on voting for your side] An alternative way to look at this is: 1. There are several qualities of people that change slowly with time; some people are inclined to vote leave and some remain and some in between 2. Some electoral material was produced trying to change how much leave/remain people are inclined to vote 3. Here is some statistics about the qualities of the people who were inclined a certain way. I think the article seems to have confused these two offerings slightly. For example suppose you see that leave voters are more RWA. Do you interpret this as: (a) leave voters are RWA so to encourage leave voters one should produce material targeted at RWA people or encouraging RWA ideas (b) the appeal of election materials for vote leave correlated to how RWA people were so RWA people voted leave so the style of material for vote leave is a lesson in appealing to vote leave personalities.