10 ms·
This is pretty neat, but Windows feels like it's in a weird place right now. For gaming, Windows is awesome. But this machine would be terrible for anything ot
by criddell 8y ago
This is pretty neat, but Windows feels like it's in a weird place right now.
For gaming, Windows is awesome. But this machine would be terrible for anything other than casual games.
For other software, everything interesting and exciting is coming out on iOS, macOS, or Android. Outside of gaming, there doesn't seem to be any excitement or energy behind Windows anymore. When was the last time Twitter was buzzing with talk about some Windows program?
Of course, the big market for this is running Office and a browser and that's probably enough to justify the machine. That might be a big niche, it just isn't very interesting.
- whywhywhywhy 8y ago> When was the last time Twitter was buzzing with talk about some Windows program? To be fair when was the last time it was buzzing about some iOS or MacOS app that wasn't just an Electron app that was also available on Windows. I remember the times when a Mac/iOS app like Clear or Coda would come out and everyone would be so hyped about it but it seems as far as I can tell those days are long gone. Which is sad as a Mac user but since the app store raced to the bottom it just doesn't seem to be worth the effort for developers to ship 3 highly tuned versions of their software for 3 Apple platforms. I mean you can look yourself, look at the top ten free/paid on the Mac and iOS app stores, it's grim.
- creyes 8y agoSketch
- andrewl-hn 8y agoSketch is almost 8 years old, and was released before the AppStore Mania died out and before Electron/CEF became a de-facto app platform for desktops. Windows has other market leading software that isn't on a Mac. 3ds Max comes to mind.
- criddell 8y agoIf you are going to say an 8 year old program is tired, then why mention 3ds Max? It has to be 20 years old by now.
- andrewl-hn 8y agoGrandparent comment pointed out that there are no recent big Mac-specific AppKit/Cocoa-based blockbuster apps in a post-Electron world. Parent mentions Sketch and a counter-example. I pointed out it wasn't really valid. Mentioning 3dsMax was indeed inconsiderate of me, because it didn't add up to a discussion and subverted it instead. My bad.
- pjmlp 8y ago> Electron/CEF became a de-facto app platform for desktops. Nah, like every fad it will join HTA in a couple of years. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HTML_Application https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HTML_Application
- PStamatiou 8y agoThough lots of designers are migrating to Figma, which is web-based and works just fine on Windows. (I'm a designer and just moved to Figma after 4 years on Sketch and am definitely seeing lots of peers do the same)
- swebs 8y agoPokemon Go?
- cbhl 8y agoAre you really playing Pokemon Go on your Macbook Air, Pixel Chromebook, or iPad?
- swebs 8y agoThe question was: >when was the last time it was buzzing about some iOS or MacOS app that wasn't just an Electron app that was also available on Windows.
- cbhl 8y agoIn the context of the release of a new Surface Tablet! Surely one would typically buy a Surface Go and also buy an iPhone to play Pokemon Go.
- NamTaf 8y agoYou'd be surprised how many people play it on an iPad. You'd also be surprised at how many middle-aged to elderly play it. These two things may be correlated.
- coryfklein 8y agoPixelmator
- mrpippy 8y agoTransmit 5. Tweetbot 3. OmniFocus 3. If it has to be something new, Retrobatch.
- jordache 8y agoprocreate - a painting app, exclusive to iOS is tremendous. There is simply no equivalent on any other platform.
- freehunter 8y agoOn the other hand, where's the excitement around the iPad? Several notable companies don't even make iPad apps, and some just have a scaled up iPhone app. The big draw for the iPad is Kindle, Office (or Office-ish products) and a browser.
- lucasverra 8y agoThe PRICE ! Ipad is damn cheap nowadays. I just bought an ipad 2018 (with pen support) for 329€ [0] new in Paris. VAT included. I wanted something to show my decks on the go and not having to put "geek mode on" with my laptop. Im all for diversity, but not at any price. I would consider that surface for 3/7 - 4/7 of the price of the ipad. More is Microsoft not wanting my business. I just saw 399 on MS side. Not. [0]: https://www.apple.com/shop/buy-ipad/ipad-9-7 https://www.apple.com/shop/buy-ipad/ipad-9-7
- supernovae 8y agoWhat is your "mission"? $329 is a lot of money if all you do is use mobile apps and you already have a phone whereas for this new surface 399 gets you a computer where you have tablet functionality as well as full OS. Surface is wonderful at showing and creating presentations :)
- EarthMephit 8y ago399 USD is 340 Euros, so that's only a 10 Euro price difference I'd easily pay 10 Euros extra over an iPad for a fully functional computer - Seems like an easy choice
- rorykoehler 8y agoiPad is the best computer ever made. Microsoft will never make anything remotely as good.
- izacus 8y agoThat's because it built something better: a computer that actually allows you to run any software you want.
- beauzero 8y agoThe day that I can just set my phone down in front of some monitors will be the day I am happy. I need Windows to do this and be able to run Visual Code at a minimum, preferably an instance of VC and 2 instances of Visual Studio. Also needs the bandwidth of 5G. 4G is almost there but just not quite enough. We live in rural West Georgia and DSL is the only game in town. Both parents work remotely at least 50% of the time and kids are going through GCA/K12.com because of accelerated school. I need my only "hands on" compute platform to be a phone.
- solarkraft 8y agoThat was the great opportunity for windows phone. It's still there - the other players still haven't caught up with the powerful windows ecosystem yet.
- beauzero 8y agoYeah the last I saw Continuum seemed dead. It made sense when Jobs took the iPod to the iPhone. It makes sense to scale back the OS and make the Phone the only desktop you will ever carry. Unfortunately I have to pay the bills and MS does that here right now.
- ThrowawayR2 8y ago> That was the great opportunity for windows phone. It's still there - the other players still haven't caught up with the powerful windows ecosystem yet. Can't be done because there's no x86 smartphone chip. Intel, in their infinite brilliance, killed off their smartphone chip project in April of 2016. https://www.extremetech.com/computing/227523-intel-kills-upcoming-smartphone-and-tablet-hardware https://www.extremetech.com/computing/227523-intel-kills-upc...
- Retric 8y agoWindows 10 runs on ARM, which should aromatically include most if not all Windows .net CLI application. However, if MS got serious about this I suspect Intel would quickly slap an x86 chip together.
- supernovae 8y agoI use my surface pro 4 still as a daily driver (its outdated compared to these specs). Book annotation is awesome, the ebook store is nice if you like to use the pen to take notes. I use the Linux subsystem all the time (Ubuntu) and i have vscode installed and write node/go/python and lots of arduino/esp8266 code on my surface. the utility/portability is amazing.. BTW, what do people find interesting/exciting from Apple these days?
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 8y ago> For gaming, Windows is awesome. Eh... kinda. It certainly has the best hardware available for the task, and is still open enough that developers need not get approval to distribute software for it, or create software for it, but one wonders how long that will last. See: https://youtu.be/rWrHfGfzoOE?t=6757 https://youtu.be/rWrHfGfzoOE?t=6757 for additional ranting. (from that time to the end, there are some unrelated Q&A).
- freehunter 8y agoI would challenge anyone to find a better computing platform for gaming than Windows. It's not about the hardware, it's the compatibility. People have been worrying about MS locking the platform down since Windows 8 was released nearly 6 years ago, and we're no closer to that now than we were back then. I'm an Apple user, but I'd be surprised if Apple didn't turn macOS into iOS before Microsoft turns Windows into iOS. That's just not how Microsoft operates.
- pjmlp 8y agoWell, they are bringing iOS APIs into macOS.
- izacus 8y agoAnd killing off compatibility with a significant portion of games that were released (via removal of 32-bit support and just general AppStore churn due to yearly subscriptions). Meanwhile even old Win95 targeted games run on Win10.
- PeanutNore 8y agoThis will probably actually run more games than you'd expect. Intel does a pretty decent job with the iGPUs in their low power embedded processors. I'd expect anything from before 2010 or so to run fine, along with more modern e-sports type stuff. I bet it will run Fortnite just fine. I have a Windows 10 tablet from 2015 with an Atom x5 Z8500, and it will run pretty much any game Valve has made - DOTA 2, anything running on the HL2 engine, etc - at 40+ fps in 720p. The iGPU in that thing has 12 EUs and will hit 600mhz, while the Pentium 4415Y in the Surface Go has 24 EUs and will hit 850mhz.
- some_account 8y agoWindows is definitely the worst part of anything Microsoft puts out. I really hope there is a new, light and fast operating system being worked on in Microsoft Labs. Something with a Linux core for developers with a brand new desktop environment could compete with MacBooks.
- ToFab123 8y agoI don't think they are. For many years Microsoft Research worked on an entirely new OS, codename Midori (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Midori_(operating_system) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Midori_(operating_system)), and it actually went into the incubation phase (which is Microsoft speak for "This is no longer a research project. We are turning it into a product") Then it got cancel around 2 or 3 years ago … just before it otherwise would have become a beta. Today, they are not working on a new OS AFAIK. They are working on something called Andromeda. They have been working on that for, I don't know, 4-5 years or something like that. It is not a new OS. It is windows 10, but they have turned it very very very modular. It has a new adaptive shell named cshell as its party trick. Andromeda is really about that shell. Not so much about the modularity. The new shell, they are working on, can adapt to any screen size or form factor on the fly and enable Microsoft's wet dream: Turning a phone size device into a tablet sized device. You know from sci-fi movies "stretchable screens". you have a small phone size device, you stretch it and suddenly you have a book/newspaper/something-with-a-bigger-screen devices. Then you squeeze it back into phone size and put it into the pocket. Windows need a new shell for when those types of monitors become available and it is the redmonds wet dream to be the ones that comes with those devices. You might have stumbled across articles lately that Microsoft is about to launch (or have cancelled launching) a new device with 2 screens that you can turn in to 1 screen and there by turning a phone size device into a tablet). That is andromeda and apparently is has been delayed (or maybe cancelled. Who knows) because the software is not ready. The "not ready part" is this adaptable shell. (https://www.windowscentral.com/microsoft-andromeda-everything-we-know-so-far https://www.windowscentral.com/microsoft-andromeda-everythin...)
- pnloyd 8y agoIt's hard to believe that such a stretchable device is feasible. Just can't imagine how that might work.
- izacus 8y ago> For other software, everything interesting and exciting is coming out on iOS, macOS, or Android. Outside of gaming, there doesn't seem to be any excitement or energy behind Windows anymore. When was the last time Twitter was buzzing with talk about some Windows program? If you live in a Sillicon Valley / Apple tech bubble, then it might seem so. But that's just your filtered bubble and bias - because you're invested into other ecosystems, you of course follow people who gush over and praise those products. There's plenty of software still constantly being released on the most popular operating sytem in the world. You just decided to ignore it all.
- criddell 8y agoThe iPad is my only Apple device. Most of the time I'm writing Windows desktop software in Visual Studio using C++. I never decided to ignore Windows software at all but maybe you're right and I've inadvertently shielded myself from it. Somehow though, I still am seeing exciting projects in Linux (software defined radio has piqued my interest this week). I also see a lot of news around iOS and macOS stuff but maybe that's just because those platforms have so many high profile fans. Aside from gamers, Windows feels mature and conservative. I run into a Windows fan about as often as I run into an Oracle fan. So what's cool and new in the Windows ecosystem? Who are the fun startups focused on Windows?
- massysett 8y ago"Aside from gamers" is an odd qualification. That's like saying "aside from SUVs and trucks, Ford is not doing well, so they stopped making sedans" or "aside from beer commercials, NFL games don't get many advertisers." I've used Mac, Linux, and iOS for years and had long abandoned Windows, but when I built a game PC this winter, I bought a retail copy of Windows. Mac hardware is not upgradeable enough, and Linux takes too much time. At this point it's not like Mac is some innovation hub either.
- criddell 8y agoI'm guessing, the Surface Go wasn't designed with gamers in mind. If Ford made a small, efficient engine I might ask what they are going to use it in. Aside from SUVs and trucks, what is it that people are buying from Ford that makes the small engine interesting? Nobody is talking about cool new Windows software and so the Windows ecosystem feels stagnant. With the number of Windows machines out there, you know that can't be true.
- mc32 8y agoAs I mentioned on another thread, this would make for a great consumption device ala iPad which can in a pinch actually allow you to do work, albeit in a compromised form factor. So you’d take it with you when you normally would not take anything or take the plunge and take your full laptop with you. It’s like an accessory to your main laptop. There’s probably some use case for that situation, and this is their answer.
- Tloewald 8y agoFor years I used windows and Mac side by side and my impressions was always that windows was less refined but perfectly solid and slightly faster at first with a tendency to slow down over time and much better for games and 3d. For the last four years I’ve been Mac only but recently got two new windows laptops for testing. I don’t know what’s going on with windows. It’s far worse than it used to be. The UI is horribly inconsistent. Performance is randomly sluggish. The built in browser is unbearable. And even games don’t seem to run well. The single worst thing is the way windows trackpads work. It feels like time traveling to 1997.