6 ms·
> "...we had to ask ourselves what people want and need from a 10” Surface..." Answer: Maybe not a 10" Surface. What I dream of is single computing unit (read
by chiefalchemist 8y ago
> "...we had to ask ourselves what people want and need from a 10” Surface..."
Answer: Maybe not a 10" Surface.
What I dream of is single computing unit (read: cpu + ram + storage + etc.) with the ability to attach to different UIs.
Maybe that's a 5" screen. Maybe that's a 10" screen. Maybe it's voice (and no screen at all).
I know Motorola tried (is still trying?) this to some extent, but as strong as they are, they are not MS.
- golergka 8y agoSo, you're dreaming about a cloud solution then?
- k__ 8y agoBut for them to carry around. Effectively they want an universal docking-station for smartphones, I guess.
- pjc50 8y agoMicrosoft sort of had this with Continuum. It was great and hardly anyone used it. Previously Motorola had the "lapdock", too.
- digi_owl 8y agoHardly anyone used it because it was barely available on a single brick of a "phone" from HP, with a price only a corporation would consider. As for the motorola attempt, it needed two plugs (hdmi and USB), and they could never commit to having a single spacing and overall phone shape across generations. End result, each phone needed its own docks until Motorola went "fuck this" and released a lapdock with some massive cables instead of the dock plugs. And the Samsung attempt seems poised to develop the same problem...
- k__ 8y agoI think smartphones are the right form-factor for this. You can carry them arround, even do most stuff on the small touch screen. The only problem is their interface. You would need something better than USB or lightning. Something more like PCIe, to get a low latency connection to your other devices (ereader, laptop, desktop, tv, etc.) and the external devices could also offer your the resources that make them unique. I mean a bigger screen or different UI is cool, but the USP of a desktop is also its CPU/GPU that is much faster.
- bryanlarsen 8y ago"low latency" USB2 has low enough latency for gaming mice and keyboards, and the various embedded display port interfaces (USB-C alternate mode, thunderbolt) have no more latency than desktop DP.
- tgb 8y agoThunderbolt 3 is certainly enough - see its use in eGPU setups. (My understanding is that this actually runs PCIe lines over it.)
- k__ 8y agoNice, but are 4PCIe lanes enough (I read TB3 emulates 4)? Don't GPUs use more lanes?
- detaro 8y agoThey do, but you can go quite far without having them, so it's likely not much of an issue It seems unlikely you'd do very GPU-bandwidth intense applications which such a hybrid device.
- Postremus 8y agoAt least for graphic cards, 4 lines are enough. Linus tech tips did some videos on external gpu enclosures (e.g. [1]). Conclusion was, if I recall correctly, that the performance declined around 10% when using such an enclosure. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2D79GsrEqe4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2D79GsrEqe4
- zyberzero 8y agoSo, the thing that Microsoft called Continuum? If you had their Windows Phone-device, you could just hook it up to a big screen either via a docking solution or Miracast and Bluetooth keyboard and mouse. It worked quite good for some of the applications (mostly used Outlook and PowerPoint this way, also RDP to my "real" computer to use Visual Studio).
- chiefalchemist 8y agoYes. I remember that. But that was a "phone". Close. But not the "universal computing device" I'm dreaming of. Currently, nearly every device I have is massively underutilized because I'm chained to a fix UI (screen size) for a given moment / need. p.s. Do you know if this new Surface (via some W10 feature?) will be able to serve as an extended monitor for my laptop. At home I'm used to an extra screen but on the road that's no possible. 10" would be better than nothing.
- arcbyte 8y agoShould be possible with the Connect app thats been out since the Anniversary update
- beauzero 8y agoYes but still needs to have 5G for it to be viable for everyday for me.
- glhaynes 8y agoThe problem is you'd end up with almost the same underutilization in a scenario where the "core" was provided by one device -- for the big desktop setup, for example, you'd still need a large display, power supply, input devices, etc... yeah, you'd be able to lose the powerful CPU (which is sitting idle when not being used anyway), but you'd replace it with (admittedly less complex) support chips that handle the remote-desktop-from-the-smartphone features. How would that be handled? With a low-power SoC. So in almost any situation, it ends up being worth it just to spend a tiny bit more on a good SoC — then you'd have more power, both devices able to be used simultaneously and/or by different people without compromise, etc.
- digi_owl 8y agoI think i have seen multiple attempts over the years (earliest i can recall was some IBM brick you could dock to various desktop setups). Damn it, MS was even demoing something of that fashion right before the pulled the plug on Windows Phone completely.
- mciancia 8y agoSo something like intel compute card?
- digi_owl 8y agoSpeaking of compute cards: http://rhombus-tech.net/ http://rhombus-tech.net/
- rbanffy 8y agoThat's a seriously bad idea. Why put the computing inside the smallest, more constrained part when all you care about is carrying the state of your computer. One nice feature of the NeXT cubes with the drives was that you could carry your environment on a disk and insert it on any NeXT machine to work from there. It failed because NeXT machines were never that mainstream and MO disks were slow as hell, but the core idea is that you saved your "world" to that disk, ejected it, went home, inserted it and continued to work. I can do that with a USB stick and generic x86 computers.
- boterock 8y agoI think that would be interesting but speaking of single compute unit and attachment to UIs is imposing artificial limitations. What I would like best is a seamless compute device integration, with whatever hardware it connects, so for example, I connect my mobile device to a workstation, and not only I get the dual screen or whatever setup the workstation has, but all the compute capabilities, so my mobile device becomes just a storage that keeps all my data... I could even connect the phone to a render farm and let it do its work. Also in a small form factor, the actual usage is very different than workstation usage (at least for myself, it would be messaging+email+browser+youtube vs visual studio/blender/UE4 in the workstation) and having a powerful cpu/ram would be pointless... The storage doesn't need to be that big either, I think that just storing the equivalent of %appdata% in the phone would work as it keeps your setup and preferences in your device, work software/data can be kept in the workstation attachment devices.
- abrowne 8y agoThat seems to be (one of) Purism's ultimate goal(s) with the Librem 5, their upcoming phone that runs Linux with a GNOME desktop.
- lmm 8y ago> What I dream of is single computing unit (read: cpu + ram + storage + etc.) with the ability to attach to different UIs. The Surface range is the best progress I've seen in that direction to date. A compute unit that one can use as a tablet, a laptop, or (via the Surface Dock) a desktop - my Surface Book has replaced what used to be three separate devices, which is pretty good going. Yes it would be ideal if it could also shrink down to phone, watch, or ring size, but let's walk before we try to run.
- some_account 8y agoI don't know. I never felt I wanted one device for everything. It would be average at every task. In my pocket, android phone without Google Services. No way I want this to be Windows. In living room, an iPad for Netflix, light games and light web surfing while in sofa. I don't want Windows for this purpose either. Kids room - gaming computer. Windows. Version 7. It's good at this. Best device for powerful gaming. My work room. Linux laptop and a MacBook air. The macbook is great for banking and other tasks where Linux can't do it. Otherwise I enjoy Linux as my daily work horse. Multiple devices are great!
- chiefalchemist 8y agoUm. 1) I'm not suggesting on device for everything. I'm suggesting that having 3-ish devices where the only major difference is the interface is: stupid, wasteful, reeks of FW consumption, etc. 2) Put another way. You seem to have A LOT excess capacity just collecting dust and becoming obsolute while most of the time it's doing nothing. Given the state of the world I find that mindset rooted in the 20th Century, and bordering on offensive. At some point anticipating tomorrow will have to become more important than the convenience of today. Apparently that understanding is currently unevenly distributed.
- some_account 8y agoI understand your point of view, but the state of the world has nothing to do with buying a couple of devices or not. It has to do with wars for profit and control, powerless or corrupted media and journalism, science as religion, culture of passive consumerism, and a future tech of AI, genetics, implants, robots which seem cool but will be used as weapons.
- gehsty 8y agoWhy do you think this is a better? Modularity comes at a cost. Size & weight will all be compromised in order to make this device. Having devices for specific use cases - phones and laptops for example, allow the device to be optimised for their specific use case. A phone made up of a modular compute unit + screen will always be bigger / heavier (for the same performance) as a phone with an integrated screen. I see this dream quite a lot on HN and I've never understood why anyone wants their phone to be their computer at their desk. How do you answer your phone if it is powering your desktop? It just seems impractical.
- bryanlarsen 8y ago"How do you answer your phone if it is powering your desktop?" You'll have a camera & speakers or headset either integrated into your monitor, or plugged into it, just like almost every workplace computer does. So you just click the green "answer phone" button.
- gehsty 8y agoBut then your assuming that the person will have a headset, or worse have the call come through the speakers connected to the computer. I imagine that currently 99% of phone calls are answered by the person picking up their phone, breaking this pattern would be difficult. If it was a purely enterprise device then maybe it could work, as you could make assumptions about headsets etc, but I still don't see it being better than what we currently have. Also if I have a desk, I have enough space and power for a high end computer, a mobile computer unit that could convert into a phone would never compete in terms of power with a desktop (or even laptop). Why restrict yourself to your most limiting use case? If you need a mobile computer/phone with a tiny processor that sips at the battery use that, then if you need a huge multi CPU multi GPU system that knows it will never be unplugged from its 1600W power supply use that. The mobile compute unit will be compromised in both these use cases.
- WorldMaker 8y ago> Also if I have a desk, I have enough space and power for a high end computer, a mobile computer unit that could convert into a phone would never compete in terms of power with a desktop (or even laptop). It doesn't have to be an either/or. You can think of it as an "expansion bus" situation. You can have a bunch of compute power on the desk, but still a relatively "dumb" terminal. It can augment the mobile device from your pocket rather than being an entirely separate device. An example would be how the Surface Book dGPU option has an extra GPU in the detachable keyboard. Attach the keyboard and you play some games you couldn't otherwise when detached. Sometimes you just use the power the mobile device itself carries; sometimes you increase its access to CPU/GPU cores as you have access to fixed resources such as work desks or home desks or cool hotel screens or what have you.
- rbanffy 8y ago> What I dream of is single computing unit (read: cpu + ram + storage + etc.) with the ability to attach to different UIs. It's called "The Cloud". On my lap I have a Linux laptop, a couple Google Sheets open, an open Word document (in a browser window) which I was reading a moment ago from my Android tablet. The spreadsheet is also open on the big screen machine upstairs, from where I was videoconferencing before that, and on my wife's laptop (she's working from the kitchen). A couple terminal windows are connected to different servers, one upstairs (actually, a VM running on it), one a beefy GCE instance with lots of number crunching power and the Mac upstairs (the big screen machine), updating ports. If I want to leave the house without a backpack, I can take the tiny Acer "Cloudbook" and summon pretty much all that's on this laptop from there through a VPN and a bastion host. I can get to my e-mail from anywhere. Same for my documents (Google and Office 365). I can edit code with the tablet (can, but really, no) or any laptop. Where the computing takes place is largely irrelevant - it's taking place in multiple machines, on multiple networks. My phone is just one point where I can get to my stuff.
- TeMPOraL 8y ago> It's called "The Cloud". And it's shit. A Google Sheets is not Microsoft Excel. Data stored in some proprietary databases are not files. A browser is (still) not an ergonomic platform for work. > I can edit code with the tablet (can, but really, no) or any laptop. Exactly. Yes, but really, no. Same for editing images, or doing actual work with documents and spreadsheets. The problem of the cloud is that data is held captive by SaaS companies, while all we've got are shiny toys working over web browser. We can't exchange data beyond what SaaS vendors allow. We can't edit data in non-vendor-sanctioned tools. We can't work off-line. We need something that lets you retain ownership and control of your data, supports powerful software running locally, and generally doesn't treat Internet access as if it was electricity (i.e. assumes it's always available).
- cube2222 8y agoMicrosoft office syncs over OneDrive which just doesn't sync when there's no internet.
- seanmcdirmid 8y agoMicrosoft actually tried this with their last Windows Phobe effort. Most people were scratching their head because they didn’t really want this.
- SSLy 8y agoBest shot right now would be Samsung Dex or equivalent solutions from MS (Continuity) or other vendors (Canonical dropped one).
- at-fates-hands 8y agoInterestingly enough, Micorsoft had been working on Continuum where you could have some of this functionality. Considering most flagship phones are packing as much RAM and processors that are as fast as some laptops, this seemed like a good solution. The only caveat is the Windows Mobile platform is dead. Too bad really, I thought Continuum had some real promise. https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/Continuum https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/Continuum
- bryanlarsen 8y agoThis is such an obvious problem with such an obvious solution it's surprising that so many efforts to solve it have fallen on their face: Motorola Atrix, Microsoft Continuum, Ubuntu Mobile, Samsung Dex, et cetera. A mid-range phone has more than enough CPU, RAM, storage, GPU to do everything 99.9% of consumers need to do: browser, email, word, excel, Candy Crush, even Fortnite etc. Just plug it into a USB-C monitor, plug a keyboard & mouse into the monitor & voila all your issues with sharing a computer and syncing your documents have disappeared. Along with time & money cost of maintaining multiple computers. So why has it failed? It's a chicken & egg problem. The available solutions aren't polished enough to be suitable for the mass market, and the market isn't big enough for all of the app providers to polish their app to seamlessly adapt between such disparate UI paradigms. Normally, tech goes through the bleeding edge. Early adopters put up with the lack of polish and provide the early market for development of that polish. But the phone as a single unit of computing isn't suitable for the bleeding edge. The bleeding edge is pretty much the only place that needs specialized devices. Chromebooks had a similar issue, but found their path to market through schools. What is the phone as computer breakthrough market going to be? I see two possibilities, there are probably others. 1: Apple. I'm confident that Apple has prototyped this out and then deemed it "not ready yet". If/when they do it, it will be polished from day 1 and would drag app makers along with them, solving that chicken & egg problem. 2: Businesses. I could easily imagine several large businesses targeting their in house apps at a phone or phone-like device that can plug into monitor stations.
- anderspitman 8y agoI think the reason this hasn't caught on is because there isn't a big enough market period. Seems like most people only need a smartphone and a smart TV for personal uses. Anything work related is probably done on a computer provided at/by their. Makes me sad because I really want it to be a thing. I really like your idea of this getting going as a business-oriented product.
- mark_l_watson 8y agoI think you have it exactly correct: either an iPhone or Android with a USB-C to quickly plug into a base station. With an eventual huge market, there would be good competition for inexpensive base station peripherals. That would provide a good web browser, keyboard, access to web IDEs, Office 365, etc.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- coredog64 8y agoI think it was Verizon that killed Motorola's first effort. They wanted users to pay for some outrageous plan if you were using the phone with a Lapdock. I have (and still use) a Windows Phone (Lumia 950), and the Continuum is brilliant. We've got USB-C inputs on all videoconference TVs in the office, and my phone "just works" with it. Meanwhile, the Mac users find it to be very fiddly. For one user, when he plugs in, his mouse stops working.