4 ms·
I've heard claims that caloric restriction only works in the lab because the average lab animal is fed plenty and sits doing nothing. Under those circumstances,
by joe_the_user 16y ago
I've heard claims that caloric restriction only works in the lab because the average lab animal is fed plenty and sits doing nothing. Under those circumstances, yes, most animals live longer when fed less ... die(still chasing the link down...).
Anyway, articles I've read describe caloric restrictionists as going from average build to barely underweight. I am currently barely underweight with my unrestricted diet. It seems pretty clear that any further reductions would be unhealthy in my case. But I think that pretty well shows that the generalizations about caloric restriction are over-broad.
Looking at it with that lense, the original article is one experiment concerning markers for markers for something that's arguable, the very common product of biological science: an experiment that settles nothing except if its taken with a thousand others (and maybe then not).
I wonder why the thing is in the economist with some crazily optimistic headline...