4 ms·
Commercial website operators, no? One thing that "would be funny" would be having the contact information show up only for IPs from Germany
by raverbashing 8y ago
Commercial website operators, no?
One thing that "would be funny" would be having the contact information show up only for IPs from Germany
- tpetry 8y agoBadicly any website which is not strictly private: which courts ruled as something like a family photo album, a (personsl) blog is by their definition targeted at a wider audience.
- ferongr 8y ago"Commercial" has a different definition in Germany and really, in much of Europe.
- phicoh 8y agoAt least in the Netherlands, I'm not aware of any requirements for 'commercial' web sites. If they exist, they are not enforced. Typically it is mostly the tax office that cares about your commercial activities: if you sell stuff, they may want you to collect VAT. If you have regular income from those activities, you have to pay income tax, etc.
- pbhjpbhj 8y agoThey'll be bound by the EU "E-commerce" and "Distance Selling Regulations" directives assuming they've been ratified, they're quite old (well over a decade) so I doubt they're not nationally implemented.
- phicoh 8y agoI'm not an expert, but it seems that this is about actually selling something. In addition, if the item is sold by a private person who is not acting in any professional capacity selling then it doesn't apply. So my naive reading is that having ads is fine, because you are not actually selling something. Having professional information and getting paid is also fine. Having a hobby and occasionally selling something as part of your hobby is fine.
- majewsky 8y agoI thought about this. I write about my own tech adventures on my blog, and I'm also working in tech, so I figured a lawyer could construe this as being a commercial website, even though I have not (as of this date) written about my paid work on my blog.
- Tomte 8y ago„Commercial“ in German would be „geschäftlich“ or „beruflich“, but the word used in legislation here is „geschäftsmäßig“ which probably also translates to „commercial“, but maybe better as „in the style of a business“. The word has been chosen specifically and distinctly in this field of law so it can mean something specific, not the run-of-the-mill meaning of „commercial“. You show ads (or Wordpress does for you in the free offering)? Geschäftsmäßig. For certain. You have a web site with information that is interesting to many people (maybe how to repair bikes)? Geschäftsmäßig. Very probably. You have a photo gallery of aunt Mary‘s 80th birthday. It‘s password protected, and you share the password only with family. Everyone else only sees the link text „Aunt Mary‘s birthday“ and noth8ng more? Not geschäftsmäßig. For certain. Everything between examples two and three? Uncertain. Assuming „geschäftsmäßig“ is a good idea.
- raverbashing 8y agoAh I see, thanks for the explanation. Privacy in Germany seems to be complicated, in one way some things are much more private, but you can't have a website without a mailing address.
- wsy 8y agoYes, you can, for personal purposes, as explained above.
- pasabagi 8y agoOne thing I don't understand about this, is what practical means does the state have of enforcing this? Why don't people just ignore this law?
- Tomte 8y agoMany private people ignore it. Theoretically there is an office that can fine them, but why should they? It gets interesting when you‘re in any way, shape or form having a business (even a non-profit or a club — anything that is not personal). Suddenly there are other organizations that can be seen as competitors (another freelance designer, another sports club in town etc.). And now you‘re not being fined by the state, you‘re being sued by other private parties. Because that‘s unfair business practices. You‘re not following the law, so you have an illicit advantage.