4 ms·
The US is still Democratic, you may not like Trump but enough people did.
by tonyedgecombe 8y ago
The US is still Democratic, you may not like Trump but enough people did.
- na85 8y agoThe US is an oligarchy.
- adventured 8y agoIf the US were an oligarchy, Trump would have never been elected. The most powerful people in the US were nearly universally against his election, including the most powerful billionaires, politicians, media and political families - on both sides of the aisle.
- Retric 8y agoUSA holds elections, but the system has been gamed enough to convince most people that their votes don't matter. That's dangerous over the long term. Democracy is more about the will of the population than highly technical rules.
- tonyedgecombe 8y agohighly technical rules Like the number of voters? I can't help feeling these complaints wouldn't have been made if the result was different. I don't like Trump but it seems he did win.
- extra88 8y ago> Like the number of voters? 3 million more voters voted for Clinton but Trump won because of the Electoral College.
- titanix2 8y agoThe electoral rules are the rules. If you contest the result of an election that hadn’t irregularities, you put yourself in the anti-democratic camp. I’m not an US citizen but I start feeling worried about the democracy in general as more and more one side seems to entitle itself to impose its point of view despite loosing elections or referendum.
- extra88 8y agoI was replying to a comment about the number of voters determining the outcome, pointing out that it did not and that it's not that simple. I know what the Electoral College is and what it's for.
- Retric 8y agoRules are half of the equation the population must feel the rules are reasonable. Gerrymandering is perhaps the most blatant example, but it's mostly a question of feeling the next election will be fair. If things are down to a coin toss of votes then you can feel it might flip next election. But many US elections don't even have someone running for the opposite party.
- cuckcuckspruce 8y agoWhich has been in place since the Constitution was ratified. This sour grapes whining by Clinton supporters is like a baseball team complaining that they lost a baseball game because while they scored fewer runs they had more hits and fewer errors. Except that's not how baseball games are scored, and that's known from the beginning of the game. (Just to get it out of my way: I did not vote for Trump, and I've never supported the man. I'm just sick of people complaining about losing by the rules of the system they knew was in place when they started.)
- extra88 8y agoI was replying to a comment that implied that Trump's win was based on having the greatest number of votes when he did not.
- tonyedgecombe 8y agoI could have been clearer but I certainly didn't mean to imply it was based on the overall vote rather refute the idea that the democrats lost on a technicality.
- davrosthedalek 8y agoAnd the existence of the EC surprised the DNC how? The US is a republic for good reasons. Better plan your campaign accordingly.
- Retric 8y agoThe EC disenfranchises both Republicans and Democrats. A Texas Republican feels just as useless as a California Republican in the presidential election. But it's the far from the only issue. Gerrymandering, hanging chad, electronic voting machines / hacking, voter rolls, death of the filibuster, etc are all on various groups minds. Individually they don't mean much but the narrative is just as important as the reality.
- fiblye 8y ago>USA holds elections, but the system has been gamed enough to convince most people that their votes don't matter. This has been a concern for Americans since the dawn of the country. Things in the early 20th century were worse than they are now.
- Retric 8y agoThe US got surprisingly close to a second civil war during that time period. The issue is large numbers of both Republicans and Democrats feel their votes don't matter. Further, the last civil war is outside of living memory. It's a black swan event which can easily catch people off guard. Rules put in place by people in power have ~zero impact on how much people trust the system.
- davrosthedalek 8y agoWhat makes me worried is the rise of populist politicians, not only in the US, but also across Europe. It's certainly partly motivated by exactly what you describe. For many people, democracy seems like a theater play performed by the political cast, and not even a good one at that.
- knorker 8y ago> heir votes don't matter. If you live in California or Texas then you pretty much can't vote for President. Your vote doesn't matter.