5 ms·
Large businesses are more efficient because they can hire 1 manager per thousand employees. If laws were introduced to artificially stop this sort of efficienc
by chii 8y ago
Large businesses are more efficient because they can hire 1 manager per thousand employees.
If laws were introduced to artificially stop this sort of efficiency, the country's productivity drops. Thus will actually cause more harm than good.
A much more sound way of redistribution is to close tax loop holes and aggressive hunting down of those who evade (piercing the veil and all). Recover lost tax revenue, and use it to improve social welfare or infrastructure.
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> Large businesses are more efficient because they can hire 1 manager per thousand employees. > If laws were introduced to artificially stop this sort of efficiency, the country's productivity drops. Thus will actually cause more harm than good. These are basically the talking points of big corporate lobbyists, but they don't bear out. Efficiency doesn't help real people unless it results in better products or lower prices. If the surplus is going to executive salaries, Wall St and foreign investors then it has no value -- or negative value, if those people then use that money to e.g. bid up real estate prices so that real people have to spend more of their income on housing. And having less of something isn't always more efficient to begin with. The thing may be producing more value than it costs. For example, people love to go to a store and talk to a knowledgeable person about what they need. A few minutes can save hours of research or years of using the wrong product. But what if one store has that and consequently has higher prices, and another store doesn't have it but has lower prices? Customers go to the store that can answer their questions, determine what they need to buy and then compare prices and buy it from Amazon or Walmart. That isn't more efficient, it's just free riding. And when the smaller stores go out of business, "the country's productivity drops." > A much more sound way of redistribution is to close tax loop holes and aggressive hunting down of those who evade (piercing the veil and all). Recover lost tax revenue, and use it to improve social welfare or infrastructure. But that's just an example of what I'm talking about. The tax code is highly complex federal regulation that benefits large companies at the expense of small. Replace the complicated income tax with simple no-exceptions VAT and they can't do that anymore. If you sell something in the US, VAT is collected and it doesn't matter where the rest of your operations are. It's basically corporate income tax where the jurisdiction of "profit" is the location of final sale rather than a bunch of complex rules that international corporations can game to pay less tax than local businesses. But you also have to make sure they don't absorb that revenue on the spending side. As soon as the feds have money to spend, large corporations devise corruption schemes like the one where government-funded research is patented and transferred for pennies on the dollar to big business, so the public is paying for it twice. Which is why spending should be local -- a billion dollars of corruption sticks out much more in a city budget than the federal budget.