5 ms·
Personally I think this adds no value to the social goodput of trading: its not market informing of real movement, its profit (rent?) seeking in dis-equal acces
by ggm 8y ago
Personally I think this adds no value to the social goodput of trading: its not market informing of real movement, its profit (rent?) seeking in dis-equal access to service.
I understand the profit motive. I just don't think that for trades, informing community of value (prices, derivitives, futures) that moving to femto-seconds is adding value.
"I made a lot of money because I have faster komputer than u"
- rb808 8y agoThe bots are much more efficient and replacing highly paid traders though. eg https://www.technologyreview.com/s/603431/as-goldman-embraces-automation-even-the-masters-of-the-universe-are-threatened/ https://www.technologyreview.com/s/603431/as-goldman-embrace...
- sincerely 8y agoI guess I don't see what that response has to do with the comment you're responding to
- joshu 8y agoYou know what would be more efficient than that? Regular crosses instead of continuous trading.
- throwawaymath 8y agoIn what ways would that proposal be more efficient than continuous trading?
- joshu 8y agoIt requires a great deal less work. No realtime, etc. And the interest on both sides is aggregated for the entire period, leading to fairer prices with less volatility.
- hermitdev 8y agoTheory is the faster the market is, less the room for arbitrage, and better for the day trader. HFT has certainly narrowed the spread. Big problem currently is moving large block (institutional) trades without affecting the market. Thats why a good chunk has moved to dark pools. (I work for a dark pool ATS).
- bjelkeman-again 8y agoAny good reading tips about dark pools?
- srtjstjsj 8y agoDay traders are a different form of arbitrage.
- perl4ever 8y agoIsn't it fundamentally impossible to order everything to an arbitrary precision? If the time between two events is less than the distance between them divided by the speed of light, then which one came first depends on the frame of reference. When you're talking about nanoseconds or less, you're inherently never going to be able to reconcile things that are miles apart, is my understanding.
- toast0 8y agoThe frame of reference is at the exchange. Having incredibly precise time synchronization among computers at the exchange would allow distribution of order acceptance for a given symbol without losing ordering. You could give each HFT a cabinet with your order acceptance port at the back and a processing computer exactly the same distance away from the port. Order processing could run asynchronously from order acceptance, and resort according to accpetance time in batches. This would eliminate complaints about such and such company being three fempto meters closer than me, so they get better execution.
- Dylan16807 8y ago> If the time between two events is less than the distance between them divided by the speed of light, then which one came first depends on the frame of reference. It's not hard to pick a location and use its reference frame. > When you're talking about nanoseconds or less, you're inherently never going to be able to reconcile things that are miles apart Let's say four miles, for 20 light-microseconds. To be even .2 nanoseconds off, you'd need a time dilation of at least ten parts per million. That's a huge amount. Even GPS satellites, with their very high speed and distance, measure time dilation in fractions of a part per billion. For things that are "miles" apart, you can completely ignore relativity at the nanosecond level. Or even between any two locations on the planet.
- perl4ever 8y ago"A natural and very old question in relativity is: can such a global and meaningful time coordinate be constructed for the observers sitting on a disk that rotates at, say, constant angular velocity? It turns out that it cannot. The observers sitting on such a disk cannot agree with each other on the simultaneity of events. In a real sense, this means that no matter how perfect the clocks might be that we use on our rotating Earth, they will still disagree on the simultaneity of events. In fact, this disagreement amounts to tens of nanoseconds, globally." http://math.ucr.edu/home/baez/physics/Relativity/SR/rotatingCoordinates.html http://math.ucr.edu/home/baez/physics/Relativity/SR/rotating...
- hakfoo 8y agoIt's the intersection of two different models of the financial universe. The long-term investor has an interest in liquidity and a reasonable response time to market moving news. He's making decisions about a company based on expectations of the future. Typically, if his trade clears in 1 minute-- or even 1 day-- instead of 1 millisecond, there isn't that much in it except in some corner case situations. The short-term investor is mostly interested in reacting to the noise in the signal-- getting a few nanoseconds ahead of other sellers and positioning accordingly. If you have enough of a "we got the info first" edge, you don't have to have any real opinion of the companies you're investing in, or even a preference of long or short, you can systematically ride the signals. The justifications for ever-faster trading tend to break down as "more liquidity" and "less arbitrage", but we're not asking if the marginal increases in performance there are worth the costs-- both in the arms-race for faster market and informaion access, and in the impacts on market behaviour caused by large numbers of super-short-term investors throwing their inertia around tiny swings in the market.
- deltateam 8y agoit is right at the intersection of things you are more familiar with in tech: aggregating user data and selling it. people with dis-equal access to service and collecting everyone else's orders midstream and selling it: the machine two racks away from the matching engine is selling information to the machine one rack away from the matching engine and this goes all the way out to your broker, your etrade or robinhood who is selling all of your profile and trade data to the machine two racks away from the matching engine it adds a lot of value for a lot of people. the actual femtosecond trade isn't what anybody cares about. regarding the equality, it wasn't that long ago where you had dis-equal access if you couldn't physically be at the stock exchange, in fact thats where you were supposed to be if you wanted to trade. so I can't buy that argument, in isolation. I do think it is a form of front-running, which is regulated in some capacity but very specifically worded such that your broker can't place a trade before you just because they found out you wanted to. what we have here is front-running but from different unrelated companies in the chain and all automated by machine.
- ggm 8y agoYes, good analysis. Whats the goodput (the net social benefit) and whats the badput? Do I (for instance) pay more? I suspect I do. I suspect the intermediary sniping in, forces prices up to their advantage. The dis-equality is being abused, to extract rent from me because I am slow. HURRY UP! Bidness waiting. Which means, overall, we all pay more. This is cost shifting to make money, by snatching goods in flight, and charging a minim to pass them on. The intermediary has no intention of doing anything except profiting. they aren't holding, they aren't helping. I'm not a free market person btw. So, I'd probably say that about a lot of behaviour in 'the market'
- vostok 8y agoI suspect that I (as an individual investor in my retirement account and personal investments, not as an HFT) pay less. My mental model is that pre-HFT, banks and other market makers made a lot more money per share traded. HFT outcompeted them and the HFTs make less money per share. I, as an individual investor, get to keep more of my money and less of it goes to various intermediaries.
- cup-of-tea 8y ago> Personally I think this adds no value to the social goodput of trading: We are long past trading adding any actual value to society.
- throwaway37585 8y ago> Personally I think... I recommend you first familiarize yourself with the subject. People are generally misinformed about this subject but feel obligated to opine on it before doing due dilligence, for some reason.
- ggm 8y agoSo what do you think about the subject?