5 ms·
I will reiterate my prior statements: if you take a job that pays you (in part) in stock, with no path to sell it pre-IPO, you should never accept anything othe
by olliej 8y ago
I will reiterate my prior statements: if you take a job that pays you (in part) in stock, with no path to sell it pre-IPO, you should never accept anything other than the highest class of preferred stock. If the company is unwilling to give you that, then you should assume that their, or their VC, long term plan is to screw you.
At this point there have been enough cases where startups have clawed back the shares the issues, never gone public even when they’ve “made it” so you can’t sell your stock, or in this case outright stolen from their employees by changing the company charter to retroactively devalue all the stock that they used to pay their employees.
[edit: charter is not spelled “charta”. I’d swear I used to be able to spell...]
- JumpCrisscross 8y ago> you should never accept anything other than the highest class of preferred stock. If the company is unwilling to give you that, then you should assume that their, or their VC, long term plan is to screw you If this is your mentality, don't work for a start-up. Employees don't get preferred stock. Founders don't get preferred stock. Your downside protection is your cash salary. Asking for preference as a non-capital contributing stakeholder conveys a fundamental mis-understanding of start-up financing's tradeoffs. (I would be highly suspect of a company throwing preferred stock at employees. It smells like something between incompetence and a scam.)
- olliej 8y agoBased on this article alone anything other than preferred stock isn’t viable. Unless executive have skin in the game - say no executive can make money off a sale of the company or a funding round unless all the employees who have been paid in stock have been given first rights to convert their stock before any member of the executive or founder team. This seems reasonable, as it prevents the founders or executive board from doing what happened here: theft.
- JumpCrisscross 8y ago> Based on this article alone anything other than preferred stock isn’t viable Common stock pays when companies do well. It diverges from non-participating preferred when companies sell for less than their most-recent valuation. Investors get preferences, employees get cash salaries. > say no executive can make money off a sale of the company or a funding round unless all the employees who have been paid in stock have been given first rights to convert their stock Everyone could convert their stock. But the stock was worthless. Preferences are obligations, like debt. If a company with $400 million in debt due on acquisition sells for $300 million, should the owners get a pay-out? > what happened here: theft If KKR et al hadn't invested when they did, FanDuel would have closed down. This wasn't a tradeoff between employees making money and not. It was a tradeoff between employees (a) losing their jobs years ago and (b) keeping their salaries and having the chance, if the company did well, of making more off their options. They kept their jobs. But the company didn't do terrifically well. The lotto didn't pay out, but HR did.
- olliej 8y agoAgain as I have said repeatedly - the ceo got 11 million. It seems that they could have taken less and employees could have taken more. As far as the employees losing there jobs years ago: if that had happened they would have got jobs elsewhere, maybe jobs that paid them what they were worth. Other things that make it theft: people who got the biggest pay outs were the ones he rewrote the charter to ensure that the employees got nothing. This is theft. If you change the value of something you have already used to pay someone, it is theft. And yeah “it’s a lottery”, but what they did was basically the same as you buy a lottery ticket that says there a 10% chance of winning $1000 if you wait 6 months before scratching it off, and then 5 months later they say “we’ve change the reward amounts, now it’s $100. Except instead of being a lottery ticket it was the employees time, money, and cost from losing out on other opportunities. In very simple probability terms. The value of stock as payment for employment at a startup is ExpectedValue = amount * P(non preferred stock gets money) * ExpectedStoxkPrive The exact amount you would accept for working at a startup obviously varies from person to person. You estimate the probability that you’ll be able to sell your stock, based on the details of the company, and offer to work in exchange for what you consider a fair amount. After that the company deliberately changes the probability of you receiving a pay out on the stock you have already been granted. That is they retroactively changed what they paid you. Also employees don’t get cash salaries, they get a mix of cash and stock. The statement is: we know your time is worth more than we can afford to pay you in cash. So we will accept that you are reinvesting part of your earnings as a capital investment in the company. The company depends of capital being invested until it is profitable. The stock being granted to employees is because the employees are directly investing their own money into the company. The difference between employees and VC is the VC have enough ownership of the company to steal from the other owners.
- ChuckMcM 8y agoActually, if a company exits at some multiple of the money raised, the common stock will have some value. But it is true that once a company has raised more than 50 million or so things become less likely. That is why I advise people to value their options at zero in terms of financial plans.
- sk5t 8y agoPossibly--factors such as liquidation preferences > 1x, dividends due on change in control, and ordinary debt can still leave nothing for common.
- bradleyjg 8y agoYour premises aren’t totally wrong, but your conclusion is off. Value post-founder to pre-IPO equity at zero and if the offer—-all things considered—-is better than any other you have available, take it.
- jasonlotito 8y ago> Your downside protection is your cash salary. This salary is pretty much always lower than what you could make elsewhere. The benefit to working at a startup can be simulated by taking a well paying job at a non-startup and playing the lottery.
- olliej 8y agoAll employees who are getting paid below market rates are providing a direct and ongoing capital investment of their own money. At minimum they are investing the difference between their market rate salary and the amount you are paying them. That is a direct investment in the company that is no different from investments from VCs. In fact I would argue the cash investment of employees must be greater than that of any VC, because if it weren’t you would simply pay them entirely in cash. The only way paying in stock makes sense is if you recognize that they are investing more from each paycheck than your VCs are willing to pay. Otherwise your VC “partners” would insist you pay market rate and don’t issue stock.
- hn_throwaway_99 8y agoBut your advice is still basically "Don't work for a startup", because I still do not know of any startup that would incentivize employees with preferred shares. I think much better advice is to (a) be sure you have a good understanding of the cap table, and what the liquidation preferences are for the preferred investors, and (b) have a general sense of how likely it is for your shares to be diluted over time.
- olliej 8y agoNo, my advice is to balance the expected return on your stock against your personal margin of safety - startup companies have younger employees almost entirely due to the reduced cost of the risk. My personal risk level is maybe lower than “I quit my job and started a company”, but I consider my work to have value, and I consider an employer structuring employment agreements such that my return is is given a lower precedence than another investor to be either sign that they do not value my work at at least market rate, and given the risk entailed my expected income should be much greater than market rate. Your claim is basically: startups have been able to screw employees because that’s what startups do. The funding your describing for example is /not/ funding, it’s an extremely high interest loan, and in that case should not be considered a share in the company. I also realized I had not said earlier: the theft in this case did not happen when the company was sold, it happened when one group of shareholders rewrote the company charter for the express purpose of devaluing the shares belong to all employees. This gets to the heart of my problem with the “pro let yourself get screwed” argument: because VC funding is miscategorized as ownership rather than a loan, it is in their interest to screw the people who actually invest in the company. Maybe it makes me unemployable for believing that my work has value and my not believing that “taking on risk” should mean “others should be able to treat my investment in the company as being not real investment” is unrealistic. But I find it hard to feel sorry for anyone stupid enough to sign a contract that has any room to legally discard your investments. Is it bullshit that this company did that? Yes. Is it the employee’s fault that they had their investment stolen: yes. Would I ever sign a contract that allowed someone to dilute my investment in anything without compensation? Of course not, because that’s stupid.
- adventured 8y ago> If this is your mentality, don't work for a start-up. Not all start-ups are the same. My last start-up took VC from a top tier entity and exclusively used common shares for all owners, no exceptions under any circumstances. No special arrangements, every share was the same. My current start-up will follow the same pattern. No investors will be allowed in without accepting their position as common shares. If they don't like it, they can fuck off. It's important to tell all interested investors how things are going to be up front and to stick rigidly to it. There's enough capital sloshing around right now that the tilt is aggressively in the entrepreneur's favor, use that to your advantage while you have it (it'll last until the next recession). Build things that don't absolutely require venture capital (but can be accelerated by it if it makes sense). And or build in a very lean manner, to boost your chances. Maximize your leverage by getting as far as you can without venture capital. Under no circumstances allow venture capitalists to have anything other than common shares, with no special arrangements (their money does not get out first). But it limits the prospective VCs? See the first item.
- sk5t 8y agoOkay, however, bear in mind that selling to investors a riskier class of equity than is their custom, will likely meet with lower valuations. In business, lower risk = more money, and vice versa.
- jkaplowitz 8y agoLower valuations also mean less extreme growth expectations in order for the founders and employees to get a successful exit. This may be a good tradeoff for a business with a long enough pre-investment runway, where the VC money is merely an optional accelerant, as the post you're replying to advocates.
- sk5t 8y agoAgreed, lower valuations during a raise ought to reduce the risk of a crushing down-round and double-or-nothing gambling. If the deal could really be structured for straight common stock, no ratchet, no option pool shuffle, etc., this could quite dramatically shift the landscape. OTOH, it would be very interesting to see how everything comes out in the wash. Suppose one needed to raise a hard floor of $5mm: a VC that might take 10% ownership for 1x preferred and a board seat, well, what will they demand when it's strictly common on offer for that $5mm--20%, 30%? Playing along with the idea of making it big, wouldn't it make more sense not to give up so much equity?
- everdev 8y agoIsn't there a way to earn shares in a company that convert to cash in the event of an acquisition?
- pdpi 8y agoNot really, not in a way that would solve this sort of problem. Who would pay that cash? Where would the money come from? How does the buyer valuate that money coming out of somewhere when figuring out their offer? How does it interact with the preferences on the investors’ stock?
- everdev 8y agoI guess similar to how stocks work, but instead of having to wait for an IPO, the acquisition price would be distributed proportionally to all of these "acqui-stock" holders.
- bradleyjg 8y agoA company could give employees debt of some or other seniority, but I’ve never heard of a start-up doing so.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- kinkora 8y agoThat might be true but you also have this bit in the article: > “Mr King is expected to receive a payment of up to $11.3m as a result of the Paddy Power Betfair deal. The firm’s current chief technology officer Robin Spira is due to make up to $3.5m, its legal officer Christian Genetski stands to make up to $6.2m, and it chief financial officer Andy Giancamilli is due to receive up to $5m” (Those add up to $26 m)" All these guys can be classified as "late stage" employees and I can't believe that these guys were given a way much more bigger payout than to the founders or to the original team of founding employees. I am not saying they don't deserve the payout however some comments below stated that these guys are possibly the reason why the company could even have an exit thus rewarded accordingly but wouldn't one argue that if the founders did not start the company, there wouldn't be anything to sell with? I am just completely confounded how unfair compensation is regardless of what the terms of the VC were. My honest question to YC members - What is the general advice shared between the YC community to prevent this happening to founders and/or founding employee(s)?
- icedchai 8y agoDon't want this stuff to happen? Bootstrap and self-fund. If you take other people's money, you're subject to their rules.
- greglindahl 8y agoIt's usual to pay ~ 10% to the people who are needed to make the deal close. The founders, who have common shares and/or options, knew the terms when they started. If you think any of this is unfair, don't take external funding.
- clips 8y agoThis is in no way typical (and 10% seems very high but it obviously depends on deal size). There will be certain cases where management carveouts are part of a deal, but it's far from the norm. Executives who join at a later stage also receive the same type of common stock / options that the founders have, and they typically don't receive much of an equity payout in comparison.
- sonnyblarney 8y agoNo, you'll never get preferred shares working for a startup, so don't even ask for them; it would also highlight a misunderstanding of what those shares are. Preferred shares are for investors, and they have 'preference' during liquidity, i.e. if the company is sold, they get their $X back first, then the rest is split among all shareholders etc.. 'Clawback' terms are almost always applied to investors, not employees, in which case, by virtue of type distinction, you'll never get those. Though it's reasonable to ask about certain aspects of share rights, there's no way on earth a regular startup is going to give you all the details and fine-print on their stocks that'll give you all then information you'd be after. Unfortunately, basically nobody gets this information when joining a startup. Even later stage investors don't necessarily get to see all the terms of earlier investors, depending on the situation.
- chrisbennet 8y agoEmployees that get part of their payment in stock are also investors. It’s just that they have less leverage so it is understood that, unlike the other investors that have preference, employees won’t get their investment back.
- sonnyblarney 8y agoEven though one could rhetorically try to make the case that 'employees are investors' ... really, in any common sense of the term, they are not. Employees are compensated with equity, they are not investors. Not even founders would be referred to as investors, unless they've put a meaningful amount of cash up for equity.
- olliej 8y agoLet’s try to rearrange this to demonstrate that your reasoning that employees are not investors is wrong: Instead of paying employees below market rate, the startup pays employees an actual fair market rate. Note that because of the short term failure risk of a startup a fair market rate is /still/ higher than market rate and an established company. Now each time they receive a paycheck the employees give you back a chunk of the money in exchange for common shares. The end result is the employees have the same amount of cash and shares, and the company has the same amount of cash. Employees working below market rate are investing in the company. Getting paid isn’t “security” it is the part of their income the employee is choosing not to invest in the company.