5 ms·
A problem (at least in the UK) is the promoting breast feeding has actually turned into some really nasty state-sponsored bullying of often vulnerable women who
by chrisseaton 8y ago
A problem (at least in the UK) is the promoting breast feeding has actually turned into some really nasty state-sponsored bullying of often vulnerable women who for whatever reason don’t manage to breast feed.
The push the breast feeding seriously needs to be calmed down. The stress and shame it causes can’t be good for mothers or babies.
‘Breast feeding is great if you can do it’ is fine but the state line is only just short of being ‘if you don’t breast feed you’re a terrible mother.’
- joeblow9999 8y ago"promoting breast feeding has actually turned into some really nasty state-sponsored bullying of often vulnerable women" I think I see the problem here and it's not in promoting breast feeding.
- Vendan 8y agoThis happens in the US as well.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- ams6110 8y agoAgreed. I 100% think breast feeding is great if you can do it but it's no shame if you can't or need to supplement with formula. Additionally I think it should be a matter between a mother and her pediatrician/lactation specialist and not the government.
- mirceal 8y agoHmm. I think the government can step in and properly inform people, subsidize lactation consultants so that everyone can afford them, subsidize breast pumps (how are you gonna feed your baby when you’re at work?) and subsidize breast milk banks. You make the final call, but it should not be a struggle to feed your baby breast milk.
- usaar333 8y agoI definitely agree with you on information providing, but I think these actions all need careful cost/benefit analysis. > subsidize breast pumps Especially given that they can be rented, this is probably a clear positive to do. > subsidize breast milk banks Donor Milk is extremely expensive ($3-$5 an once). While infant consumers do see reduced rates of gastrointestinal tract infection and eczema, other benefits are less clear. Some more research would be needed to see if this is the best use of health dollars; perhaps a minimal amount of donor milk (several onces), combined with formula may be optimal. > subsidize lactation consultants so that everyone can afford them I'm down with this, as long as lactation consultants are more regulated. The ones we used were far overzealous in over-pushing breast feeding (e.g. overstating benefits)
- mirceal 8y agoSure. Not gonna chance the world overnight, but we need to know where North is. Right now I feel like people are questioning the compass and if it really works :(
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- cxseven 8y agoNot that you intend to support this, but many mothers fear that they're not providing enough milk to their babies, even though there are natural ramp-up periods where a baby will be left temporarily wanting more. Lack of faith (or awareness) in this stressful process, and the beckon of relief lures those mothers to supplementation. That can interrupt the feedback loop that encourages more milk production and begin a slide towards dependence on formula, reassured by its pervasiveness and positive marketing. Of course, even more significantly, most mothers are forced back to work prematurely and then don't have the time, energy, or even a private space to pump their milk. I bet formula companies know all of this. They shipped a pallet of "free" formula to our address as soon as our daughter was born, unrequested.
- ekianjo 8y ago> ‘Breast feeding is great if you can do it’ is fine but the state line is only just short of being ‘if you don’t breast feed you’re a terrible mother.’ To me this is something you decide on a private level. I don't see what the government or the society has to decide about what you do at home, as long as you don't actively, purposely aim at making your children suffer.
- mikeash 8y agoImplying it’s ok to make your children suffer as long as you didn’t mean to do it? I don’t think we should just let ignorant parents hurt or kill their children because of some idea that it’s a private matter. Obviously you can take it too far, but if you refuse to feed your baby what it needs, or seek treatment for serious medical problems, or put the baby in a dangerous environment, that should be stopped even if the parent thinks it’s just dandy.
- sanderjd 8y agoThese sorts of resolutions at the government / society play a more indirect role. It may affect educational materials, pediatrician recommendations, research funding, etc. But it isn't a direct affect on what you decide in private; there's no new law or anything like that.
- throwaway5752 8y agoYou are arguing against a straw man.
- mirceal 8y agoYes. It’s a private decision that the family makes when the mom has to return to work 2 weeks after giving birth (oh hello unpaid vacation). Fuck this. You, as the government, need to help the people and need to ensure that where matters are clear cut (like breastfeeding) you make it stupid easy for people to be informed and to follow the right path. Ultimately it should be your choice, but you should not struggle to make the choice.
- usaar333 8y ago
- tzahola 8y agoAmongst mothers, the same bullying/shaming goes with vaginal birth vs C-section.
- mirceal 8y agoBullying is not okay obviously. But people do need to be informed. If breast milk is an option you should take that option. I have actually gone as far as seeing people buy breast milk (legit sources - some sort of breast milk bank) to ensure their kid has the best. Why would someone do this if formula was just as good?
- dpark 8y ago> I have actually gone as far as seeing people buy breast milk (legit sources - some sort of breast milk bank) to ensure their kid has the best. Why would someone do this if formula was just as good? Because they don’t know any better. There are women who feed their babies juice or even soda. That doesn’t mean it’s a good choice. There is some evidence that breast fed children have some minor immune benefits. There is to my knowledge no evidence that children fed from breast milk banks have any benefit over formula fed children. The health benefits are not well understood but one reasonable theory is that the feedback loop from breastfeeding (bacteria/viruses migrate from the child’s mouth through the mother’s nipple) is what allows the milk to provide useful antibodies. If the milk is from a bank or the mother exclusively pumps, that feedback loop does not exist. The bonding/nurturing that is sometimes hypothesized to help the child is also missing with bottled milk, no matter the source.
- mirceal 8y agohttp://www.nichd.nih.gov/health/topics/breastfeeding/conditioninfo/benefits http://www.nichd.nih.gov/health/topics/breastfeeding/conditi... Yeah. Right! Fuck all these “scientists” and “doctors”. And let’s also forget millions of years of evolution and the refining of breast milk, through natural selection to be just what a baby needs. That’s fake news.
- dpark 8y agoWhere on that page do you see any claims that milk from a bank provides any health benefits over formula? You are presenting an idealogical belief here, not one based on science.
- sanderjd 8y agoI see a lot of truth in this, but is that what the US diplomats were worried about with this resolution? From reading the article, it isn't clear to me what their real problem with the language is. The article strongly claims that it is about protecting formula companies rather than about supporting women who can't breastfeed. I don't see a huge amount of actual evidence for that in the article, but absent a statement from the State department explaining their thinking, it seems like a reasonable conclusion to draw.
- will4274 8y ago> I don't see a huge amount of actual evidence for that in the article, but absent a statement from the State department explaining their thinking, it seems like a reasonable conclusion to draw. This attitude leads to groupthink and polarization. You read the source from your ideological group, which leaves out inconvenient facts, leading to your "reasonable conclusion." Another person reads different sources from a different ideological group, which mentions women who are incapable of breastfeeding but doesn't mention the health benefits for the general population and that person draws a totally different "reasonable conclusion." We'd all be better off if both of you would admit your news sources are incomplete and find better sources instead of drawing "reasonable conclusions."
- marcosdumay 8y agoWe are on a discussion site. If somebody has a source from another point of view that clarifies the drawbacks of this one, this site would be a great place to post a link. What I get from the story is that no explanation was given, to anybody. Thus no, there is no such other site, and the GP's position is perfectly reasonable. I would be glad to hear that this is not the case.
- will4274 8y ago> What I get from the story is that no explanation was given, to anybody The story doesn't include any comment from US government officials. It also doesn't include that they failed to comment (excluding the one ambassador, who is too low level to comment). Lacking a "declined to comment" line, the default assumption is that the newspaper didn't ask for a comment. It's lazy journalism. With good journalism, newspapers figure out who did what and why. Here we are mostly missing who and we have speculation to why but no hard facts. Story needs another week of research before it is published.
- ExploitsforFun 8y agoIt's like that in the US. My spouse got all sorts of pressure to breast feed. However she was not producing enough milk and we ended up supplementing so our children can get enough nutrients. The amount of bullying in this area is approaching ridiculous levels.
- smb06 8y agoIf someone says "exercise is good for you and helps to control your weight gain" are you going to turn around and say "well they didn't say you should only exercise if you're able to therefore this is state propaganda against those that are physically unable to exercise" Of course it's implied that you cannot exercise if you didn't have the limbs needed for exercising. In the same way of course it's implied that you should breastfed, if you can.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- foobarbazetc 8y agoYou’re kind of arguing against a point no one is making...