6 ms·
You are thinking of this as a person who already has a government issued ID. If you don't drive and don't travel internationally there isn't much in life that
by slg 8y ago
You are thinking of this as a person who already has a government issued ID. If you don't drive and don't travel internationally there isn't much in life that would require you go acquire a government issued ID. If the only reason you need the ID is to vote, many people who don't already have an ID won't vote.
- mikejholly 8y agoThis argument seems like grasping me to. How would one function in society at all without an ID? Opening a bank account, cashing a check, driving a car, visiting a doctor, taking a train or plane, going to court. These are all activities which require ID. Sure, there is a tiny fraction of people who can't engage in those activities. But how likely is it that those folks are going to be voting, anyhow? I found this video pretty funny while searching around: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rrBxZGWCdgs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rrBxZGWCdgs
- erik_seaberg 8y agoEmployers are legally required to check ID. Not sure about landlords or hotels but nearly all of them seem to.
- coin 8y agoEmployers are required to verify documents which shows legal status, some of which are IDs. However there combinations of documents on form I-9 which are not IDs.
- tzs 8y agohttp://www.slate.com/articles/news_and_politics/explainer/2012/08/voter_id_laws_why_do_minorities_lack_id_to_show_at_the_polls_.html http://www.slate.com/articles/news_and_politics/explainer/20...
- slg 8y agoAn ID certainly makes those things easier, but a government issued photo ID is not actually required for any of them. Like I said in my original comment, the only things that absolutely require an ID are international travel and driving. If you do neither of those, then you might not have an ID.
- Latteland 8y agoBased on ICE hassling poor people on buses, they'd like to check everyone's id on a bus.
- pseudalopex 8y ago7% of US households don't have a bank account.[1] Many people live in walkable areas, carpool, or rely on transit. Visiting a doctor doesn't require ID. Taking a train or plane (or a bus) is easier with ID but possible without. [1] https://www.fdic.gov/householdsurvey/ https://www.fdic.gov/householdsurvey/
- mikejholly 8y agoThat's surprisingly high! Although I'd assume the total number of people have IDs is greater than the count of those who have bank accounts since there are multiple activities which require IDs (only one being opening a bank account).
- pseudalopex 8y agoYou can even open a bank account without government-issued photo ID. It's just harder.
- downandout 8y agoVisiting a doctor does take ID if you have insurance. Also, by federal law, picking up any prescriptions that a doctor writes requires ID, certainly at least for narcotic prescriptions.
- pseudalopex 8y agoDoctors' offices generally make some effort to verify the identity of anyone not paying up front. Some insist on scanning a government-issued photo ID. Others are more flexible. Regulations for dispensing controlled substances vary from state to state. As of 2013, only 24 states required pharmacists to verify identity.[1] Many of those regulations apply only in certain circumstances, don't specifically require government-issued photo ID, have fallback procedures, or allow the pharmacist to dispense the medication without ID if withholding it would harm the patient. Florida recently passed a law that says it's good enough if the pharmacist recognizes the patient.[2] [1] https://www.cdc.gov/phlp/docs/menu-pdil.pdf https://www.cdc.gov/phlp/docs/menu-pdil.pdf [2] https://www.healthlawrx.com/2018/07/florida-imposes-new-id-requirements-for-pharmacist-dispensing-of-controlled-substances/ https://www.healthlawrx.com/2018/07/florida-imposes-new-id-r...
- iamnotlarry 8y agoThat's an amusing video. Well framed. But as to your idea about life without an ID... I routinely refuse to show my ID to bank tellers, doctor offices, trains, planes, etc. I avoid most activities the require ID. There is one obvious exception--I drive every day. I carry my ID with me at all times. But I refuse to show to somebody who is not writing me a traffic ticket. That refusal has not impeded my ability to conduct a normal life. FWIW, I am not opposed to voter ID. I am opposed to universal ID. My voter ID should not be required to open a bank account, or rent an apartment. It should be for one purpose. I recently tried to open a bank account. They asked for my SSN. I gave it to them so they could report taxable income to the IRS. They asked for my drivers license. I refused. They asked for my employment history. I refused. If they asked for my shoe size, I would refuse. Over-collection of personal data is a big problem right now. Most people facilitate it. I try to resist it. So far, it hasn't prevented me from voting.
- eeeuo 8y agoSo, the premise is that all Liberals think this way, right? It seems odd that Fox News keep returning to college campuses over and over and over to get quotes that are intended to represent the views of Liberals writ large. I mean, they're in New York City, wouldn't it be simpler to go outside their office and interview some adults with jobs? Trying to wrack my brain to figure out why they would keep talking to 18 year olds over and over again, hmm...
- downandout 8y agoI’d love for you to explain how living life as an adult in the US without an ID is remotely close to possible for any reasonable length of time. Want a job? You need ID. Banks are obviosuly out, but so are prepaid reloadable cards. Live on cash only from an under-the-table job where you weren’t asked for ID? Fine, but where do you plan to live without ID? Even weekly motels require ID. The idea that a legal, eligible-to-vote US citizen is running around living life in 2018 without any form of ID is preposterous.
- tzakrajs 8y agoNo, what is preposterous is that you cant imagine people with no employment, no bank account, nor vehicle to drive living in the US. Those people have a right to vote even if you aren't impressed with their quality of living.
- downandout 8y ago...living in the US. Those people have a right to vote Living in the US and having the right to vote are not the same thing. Illegal aliens, temporary and permanent residents, and other people of varying status live in the US but cannot legally vote, at least in federal elections.
- rectang 8y agoThere are "people with no employment, no bank account, nor vehicle to drive living in the US" who are U.S. citizens. Disenfranchising them is unamerican.
- tzakrajs 8y agoRight, but I was speaking about citizens. Nice deflection. People on HN are usually great but many seem to argue in bad faith and it makes me want to quit this platform (in addition to the others).
- downandout 8y ago