10 ms·
What makes US health care so expensive? Hard numbers, no easy answer.
- lionhearted 16y agoI did a lot of looking into this. Here's some points pasted in from an old comment of mine that was popular - -- Some reasons American medicine is very expensive: 1. Health insurance, but not treatment, is fully tax deductible. So if you buy your own penicillin, it's with after tax money, but if your insurance company buys it, it's pre-tax money. That's one of the reasons that health insurance is so widespred in America even for routine medicine like antibiotics and checkups. That's a major contributing factor in why the administrative costs are so high. 2. There's a shortage of doctors in America, and qualified doctors from other countries are not allowed to practice medicine in the United States. So there's good doctors from Canada, England, Japan, wherever that'd love to practice in the USA, but can't. This artificially inflates doctor's wages by restricting supply. 3. American doctors are typically required to get an undergraduate degree, medical degree, and do a below market, crazy hours residency in order to be able to practice medicine. That's 8-10 years of study and below market working to practice medicine. Now, medicine is very important and needs to be done right, but I don't believe for a second that a focused apprenceship couldn't teach a very specific kind of medicine - say arithscopic surgery - in just 2-4 years under a highly trained doctor, but this isn't an option. 4. The Food and Drug Administration requires new drugs to be proven not only for safety, but also efficacy. That's an incredibly high and expensive burden to meet - that means that drugs need to be proven to work to a certain standard, instead of just not harm. This adds years of development time and millions of dollars in cost to the new drug development cycle. Those are all legislated reasons that increase the cost of medical insurance, doctors, and drugs. They'd be fairly easy to remove - 1. All medical and health expenses can be written off taxes regardless of insurance. Employees can choose to convert som of their wages to a medical or health plan tax free to both the employer and employee. (Currently, under most circumstances, only employer-provided health insurance can is tax free) 2. Allow any doctor in a country with reasonably competent medical standards to practice in the United States. 3. Require that doctors be able to demonstrate that they can practice their area of medicine capably. Be flexible in how they demonstrate that. Note: This will incur high opposition from medical schools and current doctors who are currently enjoying the wage premium and had to go through the very long, difficult, and expensive system. 4. Change the drug standard from "safety and efficacy" to only safety. Drugs will come to market much faster and cheaper. There's plenty of people and organizations that will test proven safe drugs for efficacy for free or nominal cost once drugs hit market, and efficacy will get understood with time. Put this way - a proven safe but questionably effective treatment against heart disease being held off the market for five years and costing much more to get to market is not a good thing. If it's certainly safe, then let people make the decisions with their physicians, instead of having the FDA take such a strong gatekeeping stance. Technology has progressed such that we don't need government protection from ourselves as much any more. The current set of legislation has greatly increased the costs of doctors and medicine. Regardless of political position, and regardless of stance on other health issues, addressing these four points will make the medical system fairer, more effective, and and less expensive with relative ease. Admittedly, there's some powerful entrenched interests that are winning in the current arrangement, and will oppose these simple improvements.
- bryanlarsen 16y agoRe #2: Most new Canadian doctors get their American certification as a "warm up test" for the Canadian test, since the American test is similar, but easier than the Canadian test.
- RK 16y agoI find this a little hard to believe, because American licensing and board exams are expensive and usually are taken over the course of many years. For example, the licensing exam (USMLE) has 4 parts, one of which involves travel to the US for an in-person oral exam. Edit: It looks like Canada might be accepting USMLE as equivalent to their exam. In that case it would make since to only take the US exams, allowing you to be potentially licensed in both countries.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- bryanlarsen 16y agoI'll have to ask my wife for more details, but my impression is that they take the test but don't get fully licensed unless they actually plan to work in the States. They definitely do travel to the US for the oral exam. As for cost, the practice is much more common for specialists rather than MD's.
- gjm11 16y agoOn #4: surely in practice the choice is often going to be not "drug A or nothing?" but "drug A or drug B?" where drug B is an established standard treatment. In that situation, choosing drug A does harm if the drug isn't effective, even if the drug itself is perfectly safe.
- alextgordon 16y agoYes, and in fact it would be bad for the drug companies bottom line, so I doubt they'd go for it in the first place. It would essentially create two groups of drugs. The pre-legislation guaranteed effective drugs and the post-legislation unguaranteed drugs. As you point out, the unguaranteed drugs would kill people, through inaction. No doctor wants to risk killing their patient, so if at all possible they'll go for the safe pre-legislation alternative. This would greatly hurt sales of new drugs, which is the last thing drug companies want to do.
- SamAtt 16y agoIt's an interesting read and worth bookmarking if you can't get through right now (the page was going in and out as I read it). It's kind of depressing though in that his point boils down to neither side's solution being all that effective at solving the problem. Moreover his meta point seems to be that it's too complicated a problem for politicians to solve based on their need to boil things down to a sound bite solution.
- roc 16y agoPoliticians don't solve based on the sound bytes. They win power with sound bites. There's no shortage of evidence of sound bites being blissfully ignored, by politicians of any stripe, moments after an election victory. Politicians 'solve' based on lobbying efforts. And that's why they can't fix anything. Lobbying favors the entrenched and they like things nice and wasteful and anti-competitive.
- pyre 16y agoPoliticians love competition. If there is a bidding war between rival lobbyists, that's a good thing... for the politician.
- roc 16y agoFirstly, I was referring to the resulting citizen-facing services being anti-competitive. Secondly, I disagree. A small handful of would-be suitors is preferable. But a large field would only be possible if the firms were each smaller, which means they have less money for lobbying efforts in general. Which simultaneously means less graft up-front and a less-lucrative position as a lobbyist when your term is up.
- mootothemax 16y agoI'd heard arguments that compared the UK's NHS spending to that of the US, and after doing a couple of searches after reading this article, I found quite a nice infographic here: http://www.visualeconomics.com/healthcare-costs-around-the-world_2010-03-01/ http://www.visualeconomics.com/healthcare-costs-around-the-w... Seems that this article matches up against the data in the infographic at least.
- galactus 16y agoInteresting. I have lived both in France and in Canada and I find the french health system so much better that I find it hard to believe both countries spend almost the same per capita.
- narrator 16y agoThere are many different aspects as to why health care is so expensive in the US. I never really hear about doctor's salaries being mentioned as a cause. I was browsing glassdoor.com a few nights ago. The professions making more than 300k a year as salaried employees were almost all medical specialists. I really doubt any other country pays their doctors that well.
- sachinag 16y agosigh The articles go into this - yes, the salaries are higher than expected, but they're a relatively small part of the problem. It's that we consume more care than any other country, and by a lot. We have to find a way to reduce demand. That's the problem.
- cookiecaper 16y agoI don't think you can pinpoint that and say "That's the problem". As this thread and article demonstrate, there are plenty of things that all work together to make medicine as astronomically expensive as it currently is. They are all valid and it isn't simply going to go away if we reduce demand. The price may fall to try to drive demand back up, but the medical care received will still be relatively expensive. And it's not like we can just tell people who are sick to sit around and hope not to die. I think there are fewer hypochondriacs than is often represented; most people don't go to the doctor unless they need some medical attention.
- old-gregg 16y agosigh No it's not. The salaries are in fact the only reason we have this problem, so that's the key to the solution. And no, we don't consume "more care" than any other country (Japanese do way more).
- sachinag 16y agoFrom the series conclusion: "The first [thing we need to own up to] is that most of the “extra” spending is in areas of care. So, please, let’s stop pretending that cost containment can be painless or unnoticed."
- shrnky 16y agoThe reason we don't have a solution thus far is the fundamental disagreement between those who want a total government solution(public option/healthcare) and those that want a complete free enterprise solution. The idea of the government deciding who lives and dies creeps me out. If you are democrat remember power is cyclical and one day a republican may be deciding whether you or your loved ones live or die. I don't have the perfect answer, but I know it's not either extreme.
- jasonlotito 16y ago> the government deciding who lives and dies creeps me out How is that any different than Acme Insurance deciding who lives and dies? And as far as the government is concerned, it's your fellow Americans deciding.
- jdminhbg 16y agoIt's different because you can alternatively decide to patronize Beta Insurance. Don't take that as an argument that insurance is perfect, just as a response to your question about how it's different -- the reason people are more concerned when it's the government making decisions is that there's no recourse.
- jasonlotito 16y agoPatronizing Beta Insurance once your dead is difficult. =) Acme insurance denies my claim, getting Beta suddenly becomes difficult if not impossible. With no public option, I have no other recourse. Living in Canada, I've never had to deal with the government making decisions, it's always been the doctors. Their is a base line, and you can still get private insurance and go to privately run facilities. You make the distinction too black and white in your original post. You can have a public and private insurance. It's funny. My wife, a Canadian, talks with my sister-in-law, and has some family down in the US. Sometimes they bring up health insurance issues, and my wife is flabbergasted at the lack of... well... anything. The sheer number of services provided here is overwhelming, and this includes preventative services. Anyways, I'm starting to ramble. =)
- todayiamme 16y agoYou know this might be the perfect opportunity to make history. let me explain. The thing that struck me the most about the post was that there was no one thing to blame and there was no one way to fix this. That's the thing.We are looking at the problem from the human frame of reference. If someone can make a data analysis program that takes ALL of the data generated everyday and crunches it together for every conceivable variable and then uses machine learning to find common cost patterns vs. time and policy (the time and date of execution of policies and their direct impact can thus be judged). Then we might as well have magic in our hands. This is hard data that no one can argue against (some will still manage...). If we can make something like this might as well be the first time in history that policy has been made using AI as a crutch. I hope that it won't be the last.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoThe problem is not that we can't find the answer, but that we don't want to. We have the technology to determine the effectiveness of many policy choices, and we've had it for a while - it's called a randomized trial (basically a great big A/B test). We choose not to use it - it gave us results we didn't like the last time we did. http://www.overcomingbias.com/2010/03/knowing-too-much.html http://www.overcomingbias.com/2010/03/knowing-too-much.html http://www.overcomingbias.com/2010/04/too-much-debate.html http://www.overcomingbias.com/2010/04/too-much-debate.html
- todayiamme 16y agoThan you for teaching me something so important. If you're right, and I know that you are, it explains a lot of things that baffled me as well as why people choose what the choose. Sometimes the best solution isn't the best solution. Thank you.
- jan_g 16y agoI may be completely off the mark, but I think that the cost of research may be hidden somewhere in all those huge numbers . US is making breakthroughs all the time in drugs, medical machinery/equipment, IT in medicine, disease discovery & prevention, etc. For example, HPV vaccine came from the US (I know about this, because my daughter will be vaccinated when she reaches teenage period). Much of the rest of the world is piggybacking on US. That's my opinion. I am from Europe.
- travisp 16y agoI think there may be some truth to this. Even when the developing company is European, they often rely on the American market to fund much of the research.
- toddh 16y agoAbout 60% of new drugs come from the US. And there are only a couple of new molecules discovered every year, mostly it's just about repurposing existing drugs because this much cheaper. More money goes to marketing. So, that's not it.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoMore money goes to marketing only in the accounting sense. Drug companies give away lots of free samples which they list on their balance sheet sheet at retail price (for tax purposes). Incidentally, a "drug" isn't the same thing as a "molecule". A drug is a molecule, together with efficacy tests, manufacturing process, delivery system, safety tests, distribution protocols and educational ("marketing") material. A molecule is barely more than a drug idea. [edit: just a thought, this is probably a form of price discrimination as well. According to a few uninsured people I know, doctors tend to give the free samples to people who can't afford the medicine. ]
- jan_g 16y agoConcerning drugs. I was thinking in broader terms, not just the cost of scientists' salaries and laboratiry equipment, but also cost of clinical trials, approval process under various countries' regulators, marketing.
- known 16y agoI think Govt should pay diagnosis fees and patients will pay for medication.
- old-gregg 16y agoYou addressing the wrong side of the problem. The issue isn't WHO's paying, the issue is why so much? Have you seen some of the bills that folks without insurance are getting? Nearly every sort of surgery, no matter how trivial, wipes out most people's savings plus some.
- known 16y agoI agree. If we decouple diagnosis with medication, the patient will have the option to choose medication based on his savings. For e.g http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coronary_artery_bypass_surgery http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coronary_artery_bypass_surgery is done for $1000 in India. Check http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Medical_tourism http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Medical_tourism
- icegreentea 16y agoWhat's $1000 adjusted for cost of living in India? No doubt it's still cheaper than US after that, but I would believe the gap narrows considerably.
- matrix 16y agoGood article, but I'm concerned the premises of the article have been skewed by misleading graphs. The initial graph of GDP to medical expenditure is reasonably convincing, the graphs later in the article much less so. I could be wrong about this, but it feels a little like the data selection and curve fitting have been selected to supported the hypothesis rather than the other way around (something that could easily happen accidentally). On a tangential note - that pie chart he uses in each section is an unintentionally good example of what not to do when displaying data. I have to confess, I don't really understand it.
- nerme 16y agoWhat is his hypothesis? He doesn't seem to have any sort of agenda other than saying that it is a complex issue that can't be solved by a political one-liner like "tort reform" or "fixing big pharma".
- listic 16y agoCan anyone please advice a good resource to read on how US health care and health insurance system works? From a foreigner or extraterrestrial perspective, preferably. I dream of there being the site where I can read on different aspects of life in various countries, such as education, health care, etc. all described from a neutral point of view. But I'm afraid that such thing may not exist yet due to little demand. I mean, how many people are thinking "hmm, which of those 250+ countries should I choose for living?"
- old-gregg 16y agoIf you are really interested, I highly recommend listening to this podcast episode: http://www.thisamericanlife.org/radio-archives/episode/391/more-is-less http://www.thisamericanlife.org/radio-archives/episode/391/m... They explain in detail how our system works, explain the origins/history of it, and also explain WHY it is so expensive. It's not a mystery, really, especially for anyone who is involved. TL;TR: it's expensive because "medical professionals" are greedy: they do unnecessary procedures, hire and keep unnecessary bloated staff and, of course, they overcharge for everything. The probability of you being diagnosed with X goes up as the number of doctors specializing in X in your area increases (listen the podcast for source), that's because the assholes just can't stomach saying "there is nothing wrong with you" and letting profits fall. Besides, you can simply look around: there is no reason for doctors to be millionaires and drug sales reps to own aircraft. The system is expensive because capitalism in healthcare is nonsense: you get greedy assholes milking "customers" who are unconscious, scared or in pain. What's annoying is that doctors enjoy the unexplained immunity from public anger. It's always the "evil" insurance companies and "big pharma", or government regulators, who are to blame, while its not uncommon for American doctors to make million+ dollars a year delivering results that are no better of their French counterparts. I invite you to a typical cancer clinic in the US, you'll face devastated people who are dying, and who are getting ass-raped by handreds of thousands of dollars of medical bills on top of having an insurance. Those poor folks are sitting in lavish doctor's offices furnished with the most expensive hardwood flooring money can buy, surrounded by mind blowing numbers of "support staff" who have nothing to do with medicine, yet they too need to get paid. For anyone who's ever been to one, question of "why our heathcare so expensive" has an obvious, straight, screaming in your face answer. My personal solution is radical, simple and effective: ban drug commercials, introduce fixed salaries for doctors, and if someone's unhappy - GTFO, plus open visas for Indian/French/Canadian doctors who'll be more than happy to take their place. Yes, government is grossly inefficient, I know, but NOTHING can be worse that this mess we're in. The amount of money extorted from the public by "medical professionals" is just insane. I've worked for a semi-military contractor that was selling to the government, wasn't rosy, but not nearly as outrageous that this quasi-market monster of a healthcare we have.
- nerme 16y agoThe biggest point that he is making is that there are a LOT of areas where the US is overspending on health care. Which, if the effectiveness of this health care was in line with the increase spending, it would be alright. Unfortunately, it isn't, so there is a lot of waste. We are spending money on the wrong things and it is a systematic and cultural problem. Anecdotally, I tend to see a lot of people in the US go to the doctor "just to play it safe". X-rays for a sore knee, antibiotics used for a mild sinus infection, blood work done because they're not sleeping well at night... we spend a lot of money with the idea in our heads that the medical industry can and will cure all of our ailments.
- protomyth 16y agoHow many new drugs on the market will not generate a lawsuit? What is the average amount of time that a patent will last after the drug is approved for sale?
- russell 16y agoHere's my problem with it: 60+% (by eyeball) of the costs are not categorized, so there is no real guidance for reform. Outpatient care is quite high, but part of that is because hospital visits are shorter in the US and many in-hospital procedures are actually done in clinics. A lot of people, especially the poor, go to emergency rooms for routine stuff, because they can get free treatment. But I think the US is way overbuilt in expensive diagnostic equipment. I live in a county of 250K people and there are at least 5 imaging centers that I know of. Edit: San Luis Obispo is a rural county. The largest city is only about 50K people. This kind of over building is not limited to huge metropolitan areas.
- ahi 16y agoI think capital expenditures is the start of why costs are so high. It is difficult to find a hospital these days that isn't currently renovating or expanding. Hospitals can spend however much they want because they have no pressure on their prices. The insurers don't care how much they are paying so long as it's comparable to other insurers. They can just pass along the increases to employers/individuals who are required to buy. The only pressure healthcare providers have comes from Medicare and Medicaid and whatever they lose there they can just shift to the private insurers.
- jcl 16y agoWhen you say 60% is not categorized, are you referring to the green slice in his chart? That's the amount he thinks the U.S. should be spending given its wealth and what other countries spend. He is intentionally only categorizing the parts that he thinks exceed other countries' expenditures. (See the last paragraph of the conclusion.)
- barrkel 16y agoDoes anyone know how to disable the mobile view on this site on Android? It clips the images, in particular.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- WalterBright 16y agoThis article http://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2009/09/how-american-health-care-killed-my-father/7617/ http://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2009/09/how-amer... lays out the reasons in a convincing manner. Very illuminating is the article pointing out that Lasik eye surgery is decreasing in cost, and why, while other health care costs are soaring.
- zach 16y agoWOW. Thanks for sharing that article. I'm sorry I missed it when it came out. An article full of novel insights and heartfelt interest in the subject. And I used to work for the company the author headed ten years ago! Highly recommended, and I'd point out that it's highly relevant the the meme du jour, which is that if you're not paying, you don't have the privileges associated with being a customer. Employer-purchased health insurance and bureaucratic health care programs have robbed patients of their power to be customers, and it's something I was never clued into before.
- VladRussian 16y agoSo much debate around simple thing. A private enterprise (including medicine) is driven by profit motive, that means decreasing cost (bottom line, quality) and increasing margin (price). In a free market, quality decrease and price increase is balanced by competition. Once competition is severely limited and the minimal quality is enforced through things like FDA - the sky is the limit for the price.
- jdavid 16y agoa few points * that does not look like a best fit line, more like a curve * maybe the curve should slope up more at the end? * if the curve slopes up more at the end, maybe as you spend more you reach an asymptote. it would make sense if being the best at something requires more than a linear energy increase than being 2nd or 3rd best at something. * doesn't John Nash's work explain this?
- kcy 16y agoInteresting article (http://healthpolicyandreform.nejm.org/?p=12706 http://healthpolicyandreform.nejm.org/?p=12706) in the New England Journal of Medicine about a county in Colorado that was featured in a New Yorker article (http://www.newyorker.com/reporting/2009/06/01/090601fa_fact_gawande?currentPage=all http://www.newyorker.com/reporting/2009/06/01/090601fa_fact_...). This NEJM article describes some of the reasons poeple think this community has been able to keep costs low but maintain high quality care.