17 ms·
A Faustian bargain implies that we knew the price. Facebook actively misled (and continues to mislead) us about what we were giving up to use its service. I al
by smt88 8y ago
A Faustian bargain implies that we knew the price. Facebook actively misled (and continues to mislead) us about what we were giving up to use its service.
I always get downvoted for FB criticism, perhaps by their employees, but I have evidence for what I just said: Zuck's many, many, many public apologies.
- crispyambulance 8y agoA Faustian Bargain is the pinnacle of deception. We had no idea of the "real" price in the early naughts. You are right about them misleading us.
- ryandrake 8y agoI don’t think people really can feign ignorance. What did we think was going on? FB built this huge free product out of the goodness of their hearts? Did nobody stop to think about how Zuck became a billionaire and pays all these employees?
- yifanl 8y agoWhen facebook came out, the vast majority of sites _did_ (or were assumed to) operate that way.
- TAForObvReasons 8y agoHere's the problem: many people in tech circles, including HN, passionately argued that their main monetization technique was selling ads, that they were incentivized to protect user data. But it has become clear that while they were profiting off of ads, they were also essentially giving away the data they were supposedly protecting. EFF and others sounded the alarm as it was happening but many people here and in other tech forums couldn't believe it was happening in 2009. But now that it's all in the open we're seeing a bit of history rewriting.
- crispyambulance 8y ago> Did nobody stop to think ...? Sure, we certainly "thought". There were the mildly provocative arguments about facebook users being "the product". Like cattle. Many just assumed they were not susceptible to ads or strong enough not to be manipulated. Folks were thinking about this on an individual basis, assuming that yes, some dumbasses would get sucked in by Farmville but that they themselves were impervious. Turns out it doesn't matter what any one individual thinks. Facebook is all about scale and knowledge. They're selling enormous social power to whoever forks over the money. It doesn't matter to facebook if the real customer is selling soap or authoritarian government. I think only now are we getting wise to the full implications of Facebook and the like.
- marcosdumay 8y agoIt was evidently to show you ads. Showing ads is lightly problematic, but not inheretly evil. The privacy concerns were pretty much hidden from the public the entire time.
- zipwitch 8y ago"Showing ads" is a phrase that covers a wide range of activity. Personally, I don't see anything wrong (and a lot of good) with a polite "hey, this thing exists" message. But once ads start trying to grab your attention, subvert your reasoning (often to your own personal detriment)... that's Evil. It's smeared out into billions of tiny bits, but that doesn't really make it any better. Polite advertising combined with targeting is also potentially very problematic. Passive targeting (people who are interested in X do Y so I will advertise X near Y) seems fine, but it in this day and age it intersects with tracking... which brings us back around the circle.
- nemild 8y agoI think the dichotomy was the language Facebook used to discuss their mission, not as profits but as a social company solely doing good. For example, in 2012, a book they gave to all their employees read: "Facebook was not originally created to be a company, it was built to accomplish a social mission—to make the world more open and connected." I wrote a tweet series critiquing this: https://twitter.com/nemild/status/1006533287378968576 https://twitter.com/nemild/status/1006533287378968576
- amorousf00p 8y agoSome of us didn't join the SN or believe in it. But then Google took the low road and most of us thought they were benevolent.
- geodel 8y agoFrom what I understand is that people want to feel good that they were not complicit in this all along.
- olivermarks 8y agoZuckerberg is the visible FB hood ornament, but people like Umanov are arguably still ultimately calling the shots https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alisher_Usmanov https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alisher_Usmanov
- TACIXAT 8y agoI was in high school when I joined. I have to say, I didn't think about it at all.
- ahartmetz 8y agoThen immediately doing the thing again for which he apologized - not to forget. It is called, plainly, being a notorious liar.
- polynomial 8y agoDid he say he wouldn't do it again? Or did he only say he was sorry?
- ahartmetz 8y agoYou're probably being sarcastic, but I remember him saying "we have to get much better at this" about privacy. It was before new dark patterns UI, to accept tracking, that clearly violates GDPR, was rolled out.
- TAForObvReasons 8y agoIt wasn't just Facebook. Most of the valley was effectively bought off in the Instagram acquisition, and even now much of the wealth is directly or indirectly linked to FB. There's a famous Upton Sinclair quote which neatly explain the seemingly strong pro-Facebook bias here : > It is difficult to get a man to understand something, when his salary depends on his not understanding it.
- BeetleB 8y ago>A Faustian bargain implies that we knew the price. As someone who for years often pointed out the bargain, I am not sympathetic to your position. Almost everyone I know who knew the price did pay it. Often, it was not merely the lack of knowledge, but actively putting their fingers to their ears to drown out inconvenient voices like mine.
- kbenson 8y agoThis is one of those cases where there were plenty of "internet wackos" sounding the alarm, all the way back to the launch of Gmail, and everyone ignored them. Even those sympathetic to the point for the most part just accepted it and moved on. The doomsayers were prescient, and to say they weren't there isn't just unfair, it's actively hostile towards societal growth and detecting this as it happens again. The first step to growth is accepting fault, otherwise there's nothing to fix.
- dageshi 8y agoPeople seem to forget how god awful email had become with spam back around gmail was launched. Gmail from my recollection was the first service that really managed to deal with spam in a way that worked, was free, was simple and which everyone could use. That's why people used gmail and it's why people still use gmail and why even the people arguing in this thread that google are evil are all still using gmail! (I'm generalising but I'm betting most do) When it comes down to it, despite what people say they care more about getting good services at no cost to themselves than they do about their privacy.
- BeetleB 8y ago>People seem to forget how god awful email had become with spam back around gmail was launched. While I used spamassassin (not simple), my friend used Thunderbird which did a good enough job. >That's why people used gmail and it's why people still use gmail and why even the people arguing in this thread that google are evil are all still using gmail! In the early Gmail days, I didn't know anyone who used Gmail for anti-spam use. It was all about: 1. Space (1GB) 2. Nice interface was a distant second. Most average people I know did not care about spam during those days. I mean, they cared and complained a lot about it, but getting anyone to change their provider (or software) to handle spam better was an exercise in futility. Keep in mind - this is during the days when IE 6.0 reigned supreme and had something like 90% of the browser share. Almost no one I knew was willing to change browsers, despite IE not having tabs, not having banner ad blocking or any other extension, and causing all kinds of Windows issues. If they're unwilling to change browsers, I can assure you they're unwilling to change email providers so easily. What tipped things in Gmail's favor was the extra space, when 50MB was advertised as large). >When it comes down to it, despite what people say they care more about getting good services at no cost to themselves than they do about their privacy. Agreed there.
- toopsss 8y agoPeople just submitted it. I don't know why. They "trust me". Dumb fucks - Mark Zuckerberg, 2004