9 ms·
> That’s because dossiers on billions of people hold the power to wreak almost unimaginable harm, and yet, each dossier brings in just a few dollars a year. For
by oblio 8y ago
> That’s because dossiers on billions of people hold the power to wreak almost unimaginable harm, and yet, each dossier brings in just a few dollars a year. For commercial surveillance to be cost effective, it has to socialize all the risks associated with mass surveillance and privatize all the gains.
> There’s an old-fashioned word for this: corruption. In corrupt systems, a few bad actors cost everyone else billions in order to bring in millions – the savings a factory can realize from dumping pollution in the water supply are much smaller than the costs we all bear from being poisoned by effluent. But the costs are widely diffused while the gains are tightly concentrated, so the beneficiaries of corruption can always outspend their victims to stay clear.
Spot on. Google's in exactly the same boat, it's just that they provide a few services which are legitimately useful (Search, Gmail), so they're targeted less right now.
How we will get out of this, I have no idea...
- crispyambulance 8y ago> How we will get out of this, I have no idea... I don't know. It was a faustian bargain we all made. It was fun for a while, but now it is getting increasingly ugly. How does one get out of a Faustian Bargain, anyway?
- clouddrover 8y ago> It was a faustian bargain we all made. I didn't make that bargain, but I think the real problem these days is that it doesn't matter if you made it or not. All it takes is one weak link in the chain and suddenly you're under surveillance from a company you had no intention of being involved with. I don't, for example, use GMail but if I communicate with people who do then my mail falls under Google surveillance. I don't use Google Drive but if I do business with a company that does then some of my data has been forked over to Google and I'm unlikely to ever know about it. I don't use Facebook but if I appear in a photo that someone else uploads and annotates then Facebook has a photo ID of me without my say-so. It's difficult to stay clear of surveillance companies when you're constantly being undermined by the unintentional (or, perhaps more precisely, unthinking) actions of even just a few people. My data's being bought and sold every day and there is no way I can control that, opt out of it, or even get a list of companies who have my information or what they're doing with it. If this is the information age and if information has value, then my information is my asset and I want control of it. Without the ability for a person to assert sovereignty over their own data, how can there be a balance of power between the individual and large organizations seeking to exploit everyone's data?
- crispyambulance 8y ago> ... it doesn't matter if you made it or not. Yep, like in the film "Rosemary's Baby". It was Rosemary's husband that made the deal with the devil but it was she who ended up carrying the child of Satan.
- _jal 8y agoSpot on. Opting out of the weaponized, automated surveillance machine is not really possible. I do block FB, Google and a bunch of others at the IP level. There are fallbacks, but I do end up leaking when they stand up new IP blocks, and the smaller surveillance shops are impossible to keep up with. I also pee in their datasets sometimes, but that's a more experimental/entertainment activity. And I'm playing with some other ideas not ready for prime time. > how can there be a balance of power between the individual and large organizations seeking to exploit everyone's data? Regulation. That's what you do with antisocial behavior, negative externalities and worse. The transnational nature of the net adds complications and freeholds, but the big boys absolutely could be brought to heel, if people wanted to. Politically, the winds seem to be blowing in the other direction in the US, and the GDPR has been argued to death here. But that's how the situation improves. (It will never be "fixed", absent an event that destroys the ability to run networks.)
- FredFS456 8y agoAny more info (eg. tools + source) on how to pee in their datasets?
- drcharris 8y agoI think a very effective way is to get much better control over your cookies, when you allow them to be set, under which conditions, on which sites. I use a combination of CookieBro and Umatrix on Firefox for this. Cookies are only allowed for sites I actively want to log into. For sites that require cookies to function, periodic auto-deletion via CookieBro handles those.
- _jal 8y agoI shouldn't overstate what I'm doing - this is largely an exercise in reversing what they're doing. And when I figure it out I might have a little fun by way of verifying I figured something out. Tools - I use Charles Proxy and perl with WWW::Mechanize (substitute your recreational language of choice). Sometimes JMeter is helpful, but that's kind of a rathole if you haven't had reason to subject yourself to it before.
- aldoushuxley001 8y agoYou have to Faustian Haggle.
- smt88 8y agoA Faustian bargain implies that we knew the price. Facebook actively misled (and continues to mislead) us about what we were giving up to use its service. I always get downvoted for FB criticism, perhaps by their employees, but I have evidence for what I just said: Zuck's many, many, many public apologies.
- crispyambulance 8y agoA Faustian Bargain is the pinnacle of deception. We had no idea of the "real" price in the early naughts. You are right about them misleading us.
- ryandrake 8y agoI don’t think people really can feign ignorance. What did we think was going on? FB built this huge free product out of the goodness of their hearts? Did nobody stop to think about how Zuck became a billionaire and pays all these employees?
- yifanl 8y agoWhen facebook came out, the vast majority of sites _did_ (or were assumed to) operate that way.
- TAForObvReasons 8y agoHere's the problem: many people in tech circles, including HN, passionately argued that their main monetization technique was selling ads, that they were incentivized to protect user data. But it has become clear that while they were profiting off of ads, they were also essentially giving away the data they were supposedly protecting. EFF and others sounded the alarm as it was happening but many people here and in other tech forums couldn't believe it was happening in 2009. But now that it's all in the open we're seeing a bit of history rewriting.
- crispyambulance 8y ago> Did nobody stop to think ...? Sure, we certainly "thought". There were the mildly provocative arguments about facebook users being "the product". Like cattle. Many just assumed they were not susceptible to ads or strong enough not to be manipulated. Folks were thinking about this on an individual basis, assuming that yes, some dumbasses would get sucked in by Farmville but that they themselves were impervious. Turns out it doesn't matter what any one individual thinks. Facebook is all about scale and knowledge. They're selling enormous social power to whoever forks over the money. It doesn't matter to facebook if the real customer is selling soap or authoritarian government. I think only now are we getting wise to the full implications of Facebook and the like.
- mikeash 8y agoI believe the standard process is to win a fiddle contest.
- crispyambulance 8y agoTouché !
- rhaps0dy 8y agoAll the violin virtuosi are probably on Facebook, so they can get us out of the bargain.
- erric 8y agoPaging Joshua Bell[0] [0]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joshua_Bell https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joshua_Bell
- erikpukinskis 8y agoBe ye angels? Nay we are but men!
- stuntkite 8y agoIf you win, you get a solid gold fiddle and out of the contract. If you loose you get a smaller silver fiddle and they kill one of your friends.
- mtgx 8y ago> it is getting increasingly ugly This is what's scary. The ugly part is just starting, because we haven't even gotten to the point where their AI systems have super-human intelligence and can use all of your "whole-life/everything you've ever done" data against you. How bad is this going to be in 20 years? And does anyone really think Google and Facebook will "self-regulate" sufficiently on this, without extreme outside pressure?
- CaptainZapp 8y agoA good start is to get rid of your Facebook account and try to find alternatives to Google. Sure, DDG is not quite there, but for most of my queries it's just fine. Having "deleted" my Facebook account some four years ago was a real liberator, though.
- ed312 8y agoDDG is definitely "good enough" for 90+% of my searches. I occasionally have to reword something or change a keyword. Maps and Gmail on the other hand...
- bla2 8y agoI don't get why people recommend DDG. It's mostly a different skin on bing search results. Why is relying on bing better than relying on google? If DDG had its own engine, I could see the "they're the small underdog focused solely on this" angle, but as-is, you have the choice of Microsoft or Google.
- CaptainZapp 8y agoThere's that little thing that they don't track and bubble you.
- sveme 8y agoThey do have their own engine.
- Kiro 8y agoNot for regular search results. https://duck.co/help/results/sources https://duck.co/help/results/sources
- cpeterso 8y agoWhat is a "regular search result"? Your link says: "DuckDuckGo gets its results from over four hundred sources. These include hundreds of vertical sources delivering niche Instant Answers, DuckDuckBot (our crawler) and crowd-sourced sites (like Wikipedia, stored in our answer indexes). We also of course have more traditional links in the search results, which we source from Bing, Yahoo, and Yandex." I use DDG because I like its !bang searches and I genuinely prefer its Instant Answers and page layout over Google's.
- hutzlibu 8y ago"How does one get out of a Faustian Bargain, anyway?" Well, Goethes Faust got away pretty well, beeing gods favourite .. and a grammar exploit in the bargain. (the bargain was, Mephistopheles serves him, until he says some specific words (Verweile doch, du bist so schön) ... and in the end Faust says, now I feel like I could say "Verweile doch..." Mephistopheles thinks thats it, summons his demons, to prepare for it. Faust dies, beeing old ... but since god was the all powerful judge and Faust his favourite, ... well that was enough to save his soul. And the demons had to go away accomplishing nothing) So any lessons for the real world? I don't see any... edit: maybe to give more context: Faust made the deal, because he was not content, mainly about the limitations about understanding the world, but also in general. And the words of the bargain mean something like, now I am content. So Mephistos part was to make him content, or even too full of this world. But it is somewhat complicated, beeing Goethe.. but worth a read, at least in german. Don't know, if the translations are good enough, because much of the greatness of the book, is the powerful language and verses, which at least I could never translate adequately.
- neaden 8y agoLet's hope Zukerburg isn't a fan of Marlowe then.
- pm90 8y agoLegislation. Vote for politicians who care about these things (increasingly many do, especially the younger ones). Or stand up and run on a platform of providing a safer internet for all of us, free from the kind of tracking that we take for granted. I agree it may not be easy. But we desperately need more tech-savvy politicians in these technological times.
- replies_to_all 8y agoWhat did I (people who are not attached to gmail and Google search) give in this bargain. I have all the Google things (like most) but I also have backups on Box and Mega. gmail is great, but I have several other addresses that I use that filter and forward mail to gmail, so it is always "my choice" which of my email Google gets to see.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- Torai 8y agoYeah. He is right. Anyway, thank you. I couldn't read an article so long to communicate so little, so I just went into the comments here. Thanks again.
- dopamean 8y agoLots of people come to the comments without reading the article. I wonder how many of your downvotes came from people who did just that.
- obelix_ 8y agoThe fix is not complicated. I have no issue with my search data/post viewing history providing me better results or better ads. The real damaging data to people and society at large is a different set of data. It's the publicly visible counts next to every thought and utterance reinforcing misguided beliefs and behaviour up and down the food chain constantly. Any experienced shrink, psycologist or educator, marketing/PR expert knows applying the right amount of feedback at the right time is critical to how people process info. Remove/delay/reduce the visibility of like counts/view counts/upvotes/retweet counts that are displayed and the world will be a different place overnight.
- frgtpsswrdlame 8y ago>I have no issue with my search data/post viewing history providing me better results or better ads. The real damaging data to people and society at large is a different set of data. Hmm, I disagree. It seems to me that both sources of data are dangerous. Yes, showing "You have 10 likes" is bad for users as social media companies iterate their way towards addiction but your search data is a toxic asset beyond just showing ads. Let's say google leaked everyone's search history tomorrow. How many marriages are going to be ruined? How many politicians are going to resign? How many future politicians will decide to never run? How many firings and never-hirings will there be based on that history? People should be able to live normal lives without being surveilled - by governments or corporations.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- dirkgently 8y agoSo after a long article about Facebook, the first comment is about Google. If Tesla kills a driver, it's Tesla and Waymo. If Facebook is selling your data, it's Facebook and Google. Why don't we stop pretending and just say we all hate Google, irrespective of who is actually at fault? That will save us trouble of having to find any evidence proving our claims.
- EnFinlay 8y agoThe article is about the dangers of large companies tracking users to such a high degree that it's dangerous for us, profitable for them. Facebook is an example. Google is also an example. Personally I'm more worried about Google because they have all my e-mails and everything my phone does. I don't have Facebook anymore. It's not about hating Google, it's about recognizing the power and ubiquity they have, and how for many in HN, it dwarfs Facebook in terms of potential personal impact.