10 ms·
It is extremely important not to lose focus on the problem because they're going to try again and again to pass it, one way or another. They'll never stop: it's
by squarefoot 8y ago
It is extremely important not to lose focus on the problem because they're going to try again and again to pass it, one way or another. They'll never stop: it's about profit both for the corporations bribing for those laws and the politicians being bribed to push for them, so they'll just keep pushing until they find the right weapon of mass distraction to keep the public attention away.
Also it is important to keep in mind the old tricks used to pass bad laws: they push initially for worse laws then after public protest they slowly step back to the initial goal to pretend people were listened to, so that not only they get what they wanted, but the public is also being fooled into believing their protest were successful and they have politicians who actually listen to them. How lucky!
- some_account 8y agoI doubt it's about profit. The internet is the only mass medium not being completely controlled by corporations. It's the only medium where truth can still be found about the real reasons why things occur. Link tax and other new laws will make sure that networks that spread truths goes underground.
- nerdponx 8y agoSounds like that's about profit to me.
- pabloski 8y agoProfits and censorship. The oligarchs want money and want to shut the mouths of those who denounce their crimes. And yes, it isn't only Russia who has a problem with oligarchs.
- simias 8y agoSounds like tinfoil hattery to me. Simple greed and technological illiteracy seem much more straightforward and don't involve a conspiracy about "the real reasons why things occur" [creepy music in the background]. It's especially ridiculous since of late the internet seems to have been much more efficient at shoveling garbage to gullible people than enlightening the proletariat. I've even seen some proponents of the bill lament that the lobbying by the "GAFA" (google, apple, facebook and amazon) won, so I'm sure some of them actually believe that they're fighting the good fight against the multinational behemoths who are trying to pillage European resources. It's relatively easy to justify the bill if you take it purely at face value without thinking about the consequences: the big players like Google make a ton of money by linking to other people's work without redistributing any of the profits to the creators, let's fix that. Of course, the road to hell is paved with good intentions and clueless politicians. That or it's the Illuminati, who knows.
- andai 8y agoClueless politicians are not magically immune from the illuminati's influence, rather they are prime targets.
- krapp 8y ago>It's the only medium where truth can still be found about the real reasons why things occur. So.. flat earth, anti-vax, 9/11 truther, NWO, aliens or... what? What's your poison?
- TuringTest 8y agoYou're looking at all the wrong places
- everyone 8y agoNonsense. Its mainly cat pictures and porn. If you're interested in learning how things work, read a lot of books. (non-fiction obviously) The truth about the fuckedupedness of our civilization is all readily available for you to read. Just no-one cares.
- AstralStorm 8y agoDid you mean ebooks and blogs by books? IEEE and other research papers in electronic form? I haven't found a book even close to state of the art... For a reasonable price. Springer research collections come close but they're very expensive. Journals are expensive and worse...
- turc1656 8y agoPrecisely! 66% of Millennials don't know what Auschwitz is and 40% don't know that 6 million Jews died in the Holocaust based on a recent study. This is astounding. Even more insane is that the overwhelming majority of society (not just Millennials) thinks that the Holocaust was the most deadly mass murder in the 20th century.
- mlthoughts2018 8y agoThe Holocaust is the largest genocide of the 20th century. Only the Chinese Great Leap Forward could be comparable in overall deaths, many of which resulted from famine and policy in a way that makes it very hard to compare with genocidal murder. Overall, I’d say it’s quite reasonable if most people register the Holocaust as the largest event of “mass murder.” < https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_genocides_by_death_toll https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_genocides_by_death_t... >
- turc1656 8y agoYes, but my phrasing was specifically mass murder. In terms of genocide, I agree. But that list explicitly excludes non-genocide mass murders. In terms of the Chinese Great Leap Forward, if you exclude the policy/famine based deaths that still leaves you with at least 13 million murders, and that's just the property owners that were slaughtered for their land by the impoverished peasants. That doesn't even include anyone else.
- shawn 8y agoIt seems time for a double-jeopardy type law for laws. If a law tries and fails to pass, there should be a cooldown period. Possibly a decade.
- gmueckl 8y agoThis would mean you get into endless discussion about whether a new proposal is covering the same topic or not. Politicians try to game every system if it helps their cause. And then there are the corner cases where the underlying situation changes enough to warrant action even though it fell through one or two years prior.
- cyphar 8y agoAside from the obvious loopholes (how do you define two laws as being the same -- and what stops your opponent from intentionally sabotaging a law they know you'd want to pass?) there are some other practical issues. If it applied to all laws, you could pretty easily imagine some negative consequences (attempts for marriage equality or suffrage could have been delayed by decades if the opposition tried to introduce laws in a way that would be guaranteed to not pass). And what if the circumstances change within that decade so that an old law proposal now makes much more sense. I do think that the law-making process should have quite a few more safeguards. The way that after-the-fact amendments work (in America or Australia for instance) is quite scary -- though Australia does have double dissolution which intends to prevent deadlocks and the Senate changing laws without authority from the House of Representatives.
- Avamander 8y agoWe are seeing how legislation lags behind AI (self-driving, facial recognition etc.), we seriously don't want to make that even worse.
- kpil 8y agoThe problem is more that the lawmakers need something to do... EU is producing a torrent of regulations, which is a bit absurd since it's layered on top of a substantial amount of already existing legislation in the member states. It's not so much about "harmonizing the markets" - it's just full speed ahead, high and low, idealistic, corporatistic, amateurish or razor sharp, but all the time relentless building the superstate.
- momentmaker 8y agoSounds like they learn from Influence by Caldini. Ask for a far-fetched goal then conceded to what you want originally.
- neonate 8y agoWhich chapter is that in? I don't remember that from the book.
- iiv 8y agoWell, it's a very old trick. Probably several thousand years, as long as people have traded. Don't give credit to Caldini just because he wrote a popular book!
- hueving 8y agoThat's basic negotiating 101. Probably older than the pyramids.
- cup-of-tea 8y agoYes. People need to understand that are whole teams of people whose full time jobs are to get this kind of thing passed. They don't care what's right or wrong. The Nuremberg defence is perfectly acceptable in business, unfortunately.
- toomuchtodo 8y agoWhere do we get the names of these people?
- sizzle 8y agoWe need more thinking like this.
- walterbell 8y agoPlus names of the businesses who support these destructive laws, so their products can be avoided.
- Moru 8y agoJust look up any movies showing in cinemas, music on the radio and reviews in newspapers. That is the same companies behind the lobbying.
- jeffdavis 8y agoPeacefully petitioning the government for redress of grievences -- whether you agree with them or not -- should be respected. It's not clear what you intend to do with these names, but I don't see anything good coming out of it.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- alpha_squared 8y agoWhile I recognize and admire the sentiment, I'm not sure I agree with the practice in law. Legislation should be as transparent as possible since it affects a populace and doesn't exist in a vacuum among involved parties. As to what intent there is with those names, it could be boycotting products/services from certain organizations -- which is a very valid and legal form of protest.
- eulers__number 8y agoyep crony capitalism; thats why we need to abolish the state and have anarcho-capitalism, as long as government has power, the companies can manipulate their power with money
- narrator 8y agoThere are many people who are paid to get up every morning and get this law passed in one form or another. They do it every day for the rest of their lives and they get paid handsomely for it. That's why they never give up.
- extralego 8y agoExactly right, except that we do not have to continue with this burden. Here’s how this is possible: Vote for politicians willing to refuse corporate donations. Visit justicedemocrats.com for details on how to vote this November.
- mpweiher 8y agoHmm..next elections for the European Parliament are in May 2019.
- hueving 8y ago>Visit justicedemocrats.com for details on how to vote this November. Keep this US-biased political crap out of articles in general, but even more so on articles about European policy.
- wildebaard 8y agoWhile I appreciate the sentiment, justicedemocrats has exactly nothing to do with (this) European law proposal.
- ryrobes 8y agoI recall seeing a tweet this morning stating the same for ethics committees in academic research papers. Students are being taught to put questionable things in - that are easy to excise. They get challenged, remove the red herring, and are approved since the "offended party" feels appeased. Anyways, Interesting analog. Intellectual dishonestly aside... I have no first hand knowledge, but it seems highly probable.
- acqq 8y agoSee also "the duck": https://softwareengineering.stackexchange.com/questions/122009/developing-a-feature-which-sole-purpose-to-be-taken-out/122148#122148 https://softwareengineering.stackexchange.com/questions/1220...
- ryrobes 8y agoHah, that is a great story. Reminds me of ancedotes of devs intentionally wasting ram in old school console game development; locking it up in some obscure way; just so that at the 11th hour, you can remove it and claim "amazing optimizations". ;)
- stcredzero 8y agoStudents are being taught to put questionable things in - that are easy to excise. They get challenged, remove the red herring, and are approved since the "offended party" feels appeased. I've heard similar stories with regards to censors. I've also seen it at work with release reviews. Pointy-haired management was given something obvious to correct, to keep them from thinking of something out of left field.
- drtillberg 8y agoIt's a weak strategy. If you make an obvious error in many contexts you are very likely to (at best) invite a cascade of critique that otherwise would have been skipped. At worst, you'll be written off permanently as a fool, fired and/or sued.
- smolsky 8y ago{quote} Also it is important to keep in mind the old tricks used to pass bad laws: they push initially for worse laws then after public protest they slowly step back to the initial goal to pretend people were listened to, so that not only they get what they wanted, but the public is also being fooled into believing their protest were successful and they have politicians who actually listen to them. {end quote} That's called haggling or bargaining and is old as the notion of trade.
- ryanmonroe 8y agoYes, GP even specifically referred to them as "old tricks". But even though the strategy is old, many people do not perceive the process that way so it's worth pointing out.
- Semiapies 8y agoSounds more like a paranoid description of how almost all political change, positive or negative, happens. You push for what you want, but if that gets too much opposition, you moderate your proposal the next go-round. The other approach, of course, is to pursue incremental change. In the same "ZOMG tricks" lens, that's boiling-the-frog-slowly.
- inimino 8y agoThese two are both as old as the hills and well known to people who read sales manuals as the "door in the face" and "foot in the door" techniques respectively. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Door-in-the-face_technique https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Door-in-the-face_technique
- TheSpiceIsLife 8y agoYou push for what you want No, you push for massive overreach. You never start negotiations asking for what you want. Then it goes to an "election", the "opposition" party (come on, they all drink at the same bars, do lines of coke in the same toilets) wins, and the "watered down" bill basses with bipartisan support. We don't live in democracies. Two reasons: 1. regular employees don't get a "winter break" and 2. Until we have real time visibility of political donations, filtered through an anti-corruption body, we can't know whether the people in government deserve, or are eligible, to be there.
- chx 8y agoWe need liquid democracy. This current system is broken.
- HumanDrivenDev 8y agoThe EU are masters at this. See: the Lisbon treaty.
- ttepasse 8y agoBad example. The Lisbon treaty was voted down by the Irish in the first referendum. But then the EU made changes in the controversial areas and then the Irish were asked again. And they were happy with the changes and as such with the 2.0 of the treaty. My point is: changes.
- loup-vaillant 8y agoThey had a second referendum? France wasn't so lucky. Our government in its unfathomable wisdom foresaw that the people wouldn't listen to reason if they were entrusted with this decision a second time (we voted no the first time, by a wide margin). So they did the smart thing, and asked the parliament instead. The result was as predictable as it was different. So yeah, changes. Not just what, though. Who. You gotta ask the right person to have the right answer, democracy be dammed. (Just to be clear, I will resent them for a long time for this. Representatives should not be able to override the people's direct decisions.)
- isostatic 8y ago> Representatives should not be able to override the people's direct decisions So if you want to get something passed, you brainwash 1/4 of the population to demand it. I'd rather my laws were divorced from manipulated emotion
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- vsl 8y ago> problem because they're going to try again and again to pass it, one way or another. Err, this simply means that EP didn’t rubber-stamp the proposal, as happens most of the time, but that the plenary will vote on it in September, and MEPs may propose amendments. I.e. what should be a standard democratic process, but isn’t in EU for some time how. They will not “try again” - attempt one is still ongoing and may very well succeed due to gross misunderstandings of the process and the general impression among people that the battle was won and it’s over. It really isn’t just yet.
- mehrdadn 8y agoWow, thanks for clearing this up. It reminds me very much of the AT&T thing regarding net neutrality in California. I thought it was over there too, but at they suddenly slipped in a win for themselves at the last minute.