4 ms·
What is the history of slavery in the Islamic / Arab middle east? When did those countries abolish it? I think it was fairly recent, some in the 20th century...
by EGreg 8y ago
What is the history of slavery in the Islamic / Arab middle east? When did those countries abolish it? I think it was fairly recent, some in the 20th century... I mean not counting recent the scandal from the guardian about migrant workers who can’t get an exit visa.
PS: I am curious why asking about continuing slavery in other parts of the world importing Black slaves is so heavily downvoted. Aren’t people equal regardless of where in the world they are? Why discourage concern and knowledge about slavery of people of African descent??
This is like when the Paris attacks happened and the world was lit up in French colors while on the same day the same group (ISIS) killed just as many people at a stadium Beirut, Lebanon and no one seemed to even mention them. We need to move past our navel gazing.
https://mobile.nytimes.com/2015/11/16/world/middleeast/beirut-lebanon-attacks-paris.html https://mobile.nytimes.com/2015/11/16/world/middleeast/beiru...
- mikeash 8y agoAccording to this story, the last country to abolish slavery was Mauritania in 1981: http://www.cnn.com/interactive/2012/03/world/mauritania.slaverys.last.stronghold/index.html http://www.cnn.com/interactive/2012/03/world/mauritania.slav...
- EGreg 8y agoWhy did it take so long? EDIT: again, heavily downvoted for merely inquiring why slavery in the middle east persisted It seems it’s only acceptable to discuss the moral failings of the US, or attacks on Westerners, while peoples and nations in the middle east are “below” criticism or comment eh? “We” are too englightened and talking about “them” is diverting the conversation from what really matters?
- CodeCube 8y agoI think this one sentence from that article gives a strong clue: "Activists are arrested for fighting the practice." Everyone is always quick these days (at least, here in the US) to decry "Social Justice Warriors" as if they are a bad thing ... but for many across the world and across history, they were the saving grace; someone who dared ask, "why are we doing this?"
- maxerickson 8y agoIt's not everyone using social justice warrior as a pejorative, it's assholes.
- CodeCube 8y agoI guess I know a lot of assholes :)
- ben509 8y agoYou get judged on your actions; you don't get a pass because someone vaguely similar to you did good things.
- cema 8y agoAbsolutely! Actions should be more important than the names. However the names are not just labels, they often have meanings.
- ygaf 8y agoDon't confuse people "who dared ask, "why are we doing this?"" with people who want reparations, affirmative action, etc. And that's just a second definition I've thrown out there, alongside yours, when there's many more.
- CodeCube 8y agoYou reference those things as if they are a "bad thing" ... they are not universally "bad things". They are merely individual actions/tools/incentives to right historical wrongs. It's not wrong for people to want to right those wrongs, even if someone else feels that other actions would be more efficient at righting those wrongs ... that's a valid discussion to have, not summarily dismissing people proposing solutions.
- ygaf 8y ago>You reference those things as if they are a "bad thing" More accurately, as if they are not obviously noble, since you conflated everyone to have been called SJW with someone brave and insightful. But yeah I do think those things are intrinsically wrong.
- mikeash 8y agoYou were probably downvoted because people suspected what your edit demonstrates: that you were trying to whatabout attention away from the US. You’re absolutely allowed to criticize other countries (Mauritania is pretty far from the Middle East BTW), but when you suddenly bring them up in a conversation that’s specifically about the US and a prominent figure in the American abolitionist movement, it looks like you’re trying to deflect. I gave you the benefit of the doubt, but it looks like the downvoters got it right.
- anoncoward111 8y agoI agree with the rest of your comment, but I absolutely must clarify: Mauritania is considered to be a constituent part of the "Maghreb" region, which, while it isn't the Middle East, it is certainly a part of the "Arab World". Furthermore, Mauritania has a crescent and star on their flag, and their state religion is Islam.
- mikeash 8y agoYes, the whole point of my aside there was to correct the tendency to say “Middle East” when taking about the Arab or Islamic world.
- EGreg 8y agoWhy do you think the downvoters got it right? When Paris was attacked, and Beirut on same day, only France was being remembered. Somehow we haven't yet learned to care about people being hurt in other places in the world if we're not living there, if it's not part of "us". We need to start thinking of people as equal regardless of where they live. Anyway, when I saw that Facebook only let you put up the French flag I made https://customizeyourpic.com https://customizeyourpic.com And you can hear what I really think in the video there.
- mikeash 8y agoI think they got it right that you’re not interested in discussing the topic at hand, and would rather hijack the conversation to talk about your pet issues.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- sctb 8y agoIf you'd like to discuss slavery elsewhere, why don't you post a substantive article on the topic? That's what Hacker News posts are: a story and a discussion about that story.
- EGreg 8y agoIs this the norm on Hacker News that asking about continuing abuses in other parts of the world is not relevant to the topic about historical abuses in the USA, and one needs to get their own topic heavily upvoted to get a discussion?
- eropple 8y agoWhen your post reads like "rationalist" (read: white supremacist/American nationalist) whataboutism and seems to be there just to pivot to What About The Islams, Man, having a mod like 'sctb suggest you chill out is a pretty light response. Not saying your post is that. But I am saying that if somebody of that mind wanted to derail some things, they'd write your post. EDIT: Ah. Saw your comments elsewhere in the thread. Sorry for giving you the benefit of the doubt.
- ygaf 8y agoMusic to my ears. HN officialy doesn't like topics derailing.
- lkbm 8y ago> PS: I am curious why asking about continuing slavery in other parts of the world importing Black slaves is so heavily downvoted. Because it sounds very much like whataboutism. In an article about the US and slavery, you're talking about how other cultures may have been worse--ones completely unrelated to the current discussion.
- EGreg 8y agoI understand it sounds like whataboutism, but whatboutism is one of the most dangerous labels. It allows people to just dismiss conversation about current and pressing issues in the world in favor of navel gazing at a far less pressing issue. It provides cover for human rights abuses in countries which were conveniently “not the subject” of conversation initially. Like when women in the world are trafficked into sex slavery, married off as children, honor killings, caste rapes etc. and a charge of “whataboutism” is used to refocus on how a default avatar in social networks is unfairly male instead of female. It has been over a century since slavery was abolished in the USA yet it persisted and persists around the world now. I think it SHOULD be talked about, and analyzed and solved, whether or not it is whataboutism, just like we should talk about malaria or anything else. Just because it isn’t happening here doesn’t mean it’s not a BIGGER and more pressing problem. So just cause someone coined a stupid word doesn’t mean you get to dismiss issues affecting millions of people or excuse a double standard. Go beyond virtue signaling and care about actual utilitarian statistics and solutions. I would argue the supremacists are those who focus exclusively on their own ethnic group and navel gaze at their own coutry at the expense of people worldwide.
- sortquick 8y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Whataboutism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Whataboutism