27 ms·
Why I Don't Love Gödel, Escher, Bach
- jimhefferon 8y ago> The high-level, slightly handwavey description of this theorem is that, for any sufficiently expressive mathematical proof system, there are more true facts within the system than there are proofs for facts, which in turn means that not every fact can be proved No, no, no. The proof is not by cardinality. The proof is constructive. That is the point of the book, or at least a major theme of it. For example, that is the point of the record player analogy.
- gota 8y agoIf I recall, the point is that if you have a record player that can play _every record_, then it can play _a record that breaks it_. I think the piece's statement is supposed to relate to the "enumerating all deductions" bit of the Godel-numbering
- cowpig 8y agoThe author also wrongly asserts that this metaphor is supposed to illuminate the incompleteness theorem when really it's just teasing some ideas that he explains in more detail later in the book.
- j2kun 8y ago> "the proof" As if there can only be one. (And it seems OP is describing the theorem, not a proof)
- Grue3 8y agoIt's just plain wrong to say that there are more facts in a theory than proofs of facts. Both of these sets are countably infinite. Godel's theorem proves that provable facts are a strict subset of all facts.
- j2kun 8y agoWhile I agree with you, in the context of a "hand wavey" explanation, "more" is not rigorously defined and so saying "plain wrong" is silly. A strict subset relationship is a reasonable interpretation of "more" in the context of an informal discussion.
- Grue3 8y agoLeaving aside the fact that talking "informally" about infinities easily leads to wrong conclusions, the OP wasn't even talking about a strict subset relationship. The comparison was between a set of proofs and a set of facts, which are sets of different mathematical objects. So at best you can say that each proof proves a fact (a fact can have several proofs) and the set of facts that have a proof is a strict subset of all facts. Or, informally, there are more facts than facts which can be proved. Oh, wait, this just restates the theorem we're trying to prove in the first place and doesn't give any insight into why it's correct.
- Sniffnoy 8y agoYes, but the use of "which in turn" suggests that was not meant; it suggests that what follows is a real deduction and not a mere rephrasing.
- widdershins 8y ago>It's just plain wrong to say that there are more facts in a theory than proofs of facts. Both of these sets are countably infinite. Some infinities are larger than others. This was proved by Georg Cantor, who created set theory.
- aleeds 8y agoAnd if you read about Cantor you will find he defined a term called 'countably infinite'. No 'countably infinite' set has a higher cardinality than any other.
- criddell 8y ago> it hints at grand unifying patterns, but the pattern it finds is just the abstract notion of self-reference, and then it keeps bringing it up, making a few unnecessary references, showing some pictures, and asking, “Isn’t that cool? Isn’t that weird?” That is pretty much what I thought of the book the first time I tried to read it but didn't get all the way through. The book, especially in the beginning, was super fun to read but it lost its charm for me after the first third. One huge benefit to me from the book is a nice introduction to Bach's music. To this day I enjoy finding patterns in music.
- DanielBMarkham 8y ago“A fun illustration of something,” is pretty much as far as the book goes: it hints at grand unifying patterns, but the pattern it finds is just the abstract notion of self-reference, and then it keeps bringing it up, making a few unnecessary references, showing some pictures, and asking, “Isn’t that cool? Isn’t that weird?” The book is a puzzle. That's it. It's not the answer to life, the universe, and everything. It's a nice puzzle that illustrates how self-referential things relate to one another. Superficially. I'm okay with that. Because it's a fun little puzzle, it engages people's minds in new ways. This is what has caused all of the praise over the years, not because it's some post-grad-level deep-dive into epistemology or something. I think the reviewer misses the point. The criticisms they make are actually features. I could criticize the book as well. I struggled with it. But I wouldn't criticize it along these lines. They don't look very insightful.
- amptorn 8y agoWhat's the solution?
- DanielBMarkham 8y agoIt's a duck. Seriously, "puzzle" in the sense that things are assembled and related to one another to create mental constructs that are pleasing to contemplate. The solution is to read the book and work the puzzle. Or it's a duck. The duck thing might work better for some of the more literal-minded, including the author of the critique.
- muro 8y agotl;dr. Excellent first few chapters (which deserve the high praise and possibly are the cause of all the hype), gets less and less interesting. At some point, I dreaded returning to it and gave up.
- lolc 8y agoDid you sum up your experience reading the book? Or did you try to sum up the critique we're discussing here? If it's the latter you failed.
- zirkonit 8y ago"tl;dr" here actually means "Too long; didn't read", as in, GP's result of reading the book, and not the "here is the summary" we usually tend to associate with the abbreviation.
- lettucehead 8y agothanks - that was helpful to know
- muro 8y agoThe book. Apologies, you are right, should have been clearer. I think the other comments at the time were also about the book, not the article.
- honoredb 8y agoSo now we have to consider the specter of someone writing an overly verbose review of something that reduces to "tl;dr". Someone might summarize the review by writing "tl;dr: tl;dr". Or they might express the same thing, but overly verbosely, so someone might summarize their response by writing "tl;dr: tl;dr: tl;dr". In general, if N "tl;dr"s is a valid sentiment, and any valid sentiment can be expressed overly verbosely, then N+1 "tl;dr"s are a valid sentiment, so by induction any positive integer repetition of "tl;dr"s is valid. However, there exists some number L such that L repetitions of "tl;dr" is itself too long to express the necessary point, and someone who didn't read it would want a summary, the most succinct of which would presumably be "tl;dr: tl;dr nested L times". This meta "tl;dr" itself might be expressed overly verbosely, of course...
- stuntkite 8y agoI'd owned this book for many years and had a similar experience to OP. But one day someone gave me `I am a Strange Loop`, which I started reading and enjoyed way more. After getting in a little bit Hofstadter makes some apologies for GEB saying it was the sum of work of a very young person. I think he was 24? I think it's pretty incredible considering his age. The things that lead him to thinking critically about consciousness because of his disabled sister I found to be something that changed not only how I interacted with people that were differently abled, but also changed how I saw my own disabilities. Sure it's more than a bit full of itself, but I can't for the life of me think how I would edit it any differently. It's honest from the place he was standing. With a lot of thought, a desire to share, and a perspective that no one else could just stumble on. IMO, it really does kind of have to be what it is. So, I decided to put down IAASL and try to really get through GEB first.. like for real this time... and found an Open Courseware[0] on the book to follow hoping that would help me really cut through it. It did! The trick that did it for me was the prof's suggestion that you just skip the first 300 or so pages and he picked up from there. I'd thumbed through it and much like op had "looked" at every page, but once I skipped the first 300 and followed along with the course, it was like butter. There is something funny about all the intro dialogs that can fatigue by the time you get to the meat. That said, I really enjoyed his reflection on GEB in IAASL and enjoyed the read of IAASL a lot more. Regardless of what you think about what Hofstadter proposes, I think his contribution to critical exploration of the consciousness is artful and invaluable. I think it's fun, compassionate, and beautiful, and it really changed how I see myself and my environment. It sticks with me and I think about it a lot and it makes me happy to share it with people. [0] https://ocw.mit.edu/high-school/humanities-and-social-sciences/godel-escher-bach/ https://ocw.mit.edu/high-school/humanities-and-social-scienc...
- fao_ 8y agoThis. 100 times, this. GEB is an alright book, but nobody I know has actually managed to finish it. I Am A Strange Loop discusses the exact same thing, but does so with the experience of years of writing in metaphor, and more importantly, entirely in metaphor. All of the metaphors are well-crafted in that they are both a pleasure to imagine, can be recalled rather easily, and accurately map to what the author is trying to express. IAASL also distills the main thesis of GEB, so it is not only more expressive but much more to-the-point (Which I, too think is the main problem with GEB as a book). I do not hesitate to recommend -- for all those that struggled with GEB, or all those that wish to read GEB, pick up a copy of IAASL, and then if you still wish to read GEB, try it after reading IAASL.
- Upvoter33 8y agoI had much the same reaction to GEB as this author: it seems like I really should have liked it, but never have. To me, it always just seemed too clever by a half (or, perhaps, I am just too dull witted by some other fraction ...)
- alkonaut 8y agoHas anyone read it and not found the dialogue bits meandering and superfluous? I found the other chapters acceptable but the useless dialogue left me feeling the whole book was pretentious and babbling.
- Invictus0 8y agoI loved the dialogues; they were really helpful in explaining some of the more technical content and I loved the little puzzles and devices he scattered throughout them. The use of metaphoric exposition followed by technical description is brilliant for making reinforcement learning fun.
- vilhelm_s 8y agoSure. I love the dialogues, they are by far my favorite part of the book.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- Crespyl 8y agoThe dialogues were the only parts I could make sense of the first few times I read the book (at a young age). I greatly enjoyed them and found them both amusing and eye-opening; even more so when I could finally start making sense of the prose that accompanied them.
- javajosh 8y agoI actually tend to agree with this review - the record-player analogy for incompleteness is particularly bad. But what you have here is a young man high on his intellectual gifts playing in beautiful abstract worlds, imperfectly, sometimes pointlessly. It's that intellectual playfulness that makes this book special, since books are usually either intellectual or playful but rarely both. Not to change the subject, but Frank Herbert's work has a similarly undeserved reputation for depth, IMHO. The Dune series wants to be about so many interesting, connected things: consciousness, religion, ecology, psychology, politics and speculates about (non-scientific) connections between mind and matter. Herbert had the good taste to not describe every detail about the world, but all of his considerable artifice is a very thin veneer on what is ultimately a juvenile power fantasy. There is really nothing there, philosophically speaking, even though, to my young teenage self, it really felt like there was.
- nwah1 8y agoCan you give an example of fiction in which there is "something there"?
- javajosh 8y agoYes, I can. Actually Herbert himself did have a good (taboo) thought in Dune with his Golden Path idea, that to save humanity it must endure a tyrant for thousands of years. Asimov's Foundation series had a lot to say about the natural ebb and flow of civilization on a long time scale, a very Buddhist view. He also had a lot to say about the nature of general AI, and the relationship to such beings with humans, in his Robot novels (I'm most familiar with the Daniel R Olivaw novels, e.g. Caves of Steel). Of course, when it comes to society, politics, and technology, Neal Stephenson, in both Snowcrash and The Diamond Age, has a lot of great philosophical ideas. Like a good author he shows, and doesn't tell us about his ideas. The character Raven in Snowcrash, for example, expresses the now pretty common understanding that individuals, armed with technology, can challenge states (e.g. bin Laden). There are lots and lots of other authors and ideas.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- donquichotte 8y agoGEB is one of the most overrated books ever. It's a painfully long, tedious, masturbatory, self-aggrandizing collection of loosely related tales. The idea of self-similarity is somewhat interesting, but certainly not 1500-pages-of-incoherent-ramblings interesting. I have no idea how this won the Pulitzer prize, probably the judges just could not admit that it was too tedious to finish.
- code_duck 8y agoFor me this book was a companion to Metamagical Themas, a collection of Hofstadter’s Scientific American articles. Being a collection of articles, that book is much more accessible.
- yosefzeev 8y agoI think there is a modern predisposition particularly in analytic, academic circles wherein criticizing a work is tantamount to somehow being "more superior" than the work itself. This article reminds me of such ivory tower conceits. What I liked about Godel, Escher and Bach was that although it introduced some heavy concepts--it did so in a playful way. It opened many doors in relation to consideration of the world and the things in it that had been closed to me previously. I am sure I could find some way to suggest that the work is somehow "not as good as everything thinks". I can do that with any literature but such articles are more like flame bait. What I have to ask is "Did my engaging with the work leave me having a fundamentally different worldview? Did it broaden my horizons somehow?" In the case of this work, yes, it did. Everything else is a footnote to that experience.
- guelo 8y agoWhat's the point of, without any knowledge about him, attacking the reviewer as a poorly motivated elitist? That he disagrees with you does not mean that he is an inferior person to you.
- ggm 8y agoYou missed the point: sui generis, this kind of review... its a kind of thing. it belongs in a set. The observations relate to the set, the general properties of the set. Thats why we're allowed to make them. Does he know the author? no. Does the author display all the tropes which conform to members of the set? Yes.
- jatsign 8y agoDoes anyone have a better metaphor, or a link to someplace with a better explanation, of the Incompleteness Theorem?
- beaconstudios 8y agoI'm not familiar with directly, but if you're more familiar with comp-sci: based on my understanding of Curry-Howard correspondence, I would think it's the logic equivalent of the halting problem. I could be way off-base though, I'd appreciate a mathematician chiming in on whether my intuition is accurate here.
- chriswarbo 8y ago(Caveat: I'm a computer scientist, not a mathematician) The halting problem, and universal computation itself, came directly out of work on incompleteness. Incompleteness is about being unable to prove statements in a particular system; it leaves open the possibility that a more powerful system might be able to prove that statement (but that more powerful system will have its own incompleteness, and so on). Turing got involved after attending a series of lectures on Goedel's incompeteness theorem. He came up with turing machines, showed that they cannot decide their own halting problem, and proved that they're equivalent to lambda calculus. Goedel tried to make a more powerful alternative to lambda calculus, called general recursive functions, but it also turned out to be equivalent to turing machines and lambda calculus. This lead to the Church-Turing thesis, which claims that any effective/physical/realisable system of logic cannot be more powerful than turing machines/lambda calculus/general recursive functions. In this sense, we can still "solve" the halting problem by using a more powerful logical system (e.g. oracle machines), but the Church Turing thesis says that we can never carry out those calculation to get a true/false answer. I like to think of incompleteness as a mathematical property, applying to all systems but allowing the "escape hatch" of switching to a more powerful system; and I like to think of the Church Turing thesis as a law of physics, that there is a limit to the logical power of any physical system (i.e. Turing completeness). There's a nice summary at https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GnpcMCW0RUA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GnpcMCW0RUA
- youdontknowtho 8y agoIt was an enjoyable read. I thought that it had it's moments.
- tombert 8y agoI admit that I found the book a bit pretentious and irritating the first time I read it, but someone encouraged me to read it again, and I was unemployed at the time, and I really enjoyed it the second time. I don't know if I just didn't understand it very well the first time, or if I had just become a bit more interested in theoretical math and philosophy, making me pay better attention. I admit that the tortoise and Achilles analogies get kind of weird, and sometimes feel a bit contrived, but I actually found them instrumental to the overarching theme of the book: self-reference. The theme was a bit more clear in "I am a Strange Loop", but I still really enjoyed GEB, if for no other reason than it made me finally understand the concepts of "axioms" and "theorems" and whatnot.
- jhbadger 8y agoA couple of comments: 1) The author complains that the Socratic dialogs are contrived and largely consist of one character explaining something and the other saying "I see" and so on. Well, that's true, but that's kind of how the format works. You could make a similar complaint about Plato's _Republic_. 2) I think the author totally misses that the reference to not hearing the silverware during 4'33" in a cafe is a joke. Of course it wouldn't work that way.
- nabla9 8y agoThis is common problem called "illiterate literary critique". People who don't read books, or have restricted themselves into limited genres, subjects and styles are easily thrown off. It's common to see very good writing as contrived or pretentious if it's not what you are not familiar with. Claims of elitism are used to paint actual skill and quality as negative.
- yakubin 8y agoIt is is possible to know where the style comes from and still dislike it. E.g. I read Plato’s Republic [sic] and hate it for, among other things, its literary style. I find it artificial and, in the case of Plato, fundamentally dishonest - serving as an argument from authority (see Popper’s critique in “Open society and its enemies vol 1”).
- pmoriarty 8y ago"The author complains that the Socratic dialogs are contrived and largely consist of one character explaining something and the other saying "I see" and so on. Well, that's true, but that's kind of how the format works. You could make a similar complaint about Plato's _Republic_." Plato is widely criticized by philosophers for doing just that. We cut him some slack, however, as he was one of the first to do so. Hofstadter, by contrast, was reusing a well-worn technique and had 2500 years of critiques of Plato and literary innovations to draw on. Socratic dialogs do not have to be so one-sided. It's not difficult to make both sides of the dialog raise relevant, interesting, thoughtful points, and many Socratic dialogs post-Plato do this. It's sheer lazyness, incompetence, or intellectual dishonesty to make them one-sided.
- audunw 8y agoI read and finished GEB first, and then read 'I am a Strange Loop'. I think the trick to reading GEB is to not take it so seriously. You can skim sections, you can skip parts, you don't have to understand everything, not everything has to make sense. I think the author here misses that when he complains such about the quality of the metaphors. They're not meant to help understand, as much as being there to give a vague idea about what's coming in a fun way. If you still don't enjoy GEB, then it's not for you, and that's OK too. I found 'I am a Strange Loop' a more dry and less enjoyable read than GEB, but it was certainly a lot clearer, and better written in many ways. I would probably recommend it before GEB for most people.
- stuntkite 8y agoI definitely think GEB is important to getting into IAASL, which is why after I got into the book a bit I put it down and really made an effort to get into GEB. IAASL can totally be read on it's own, but I think it's fair to say you at least want to have a copy of GEB around to look at while you're reading it. I can't recommend that course enough too. I guess I couldn't find the book on my own. So anyone that can, great! But having someone who knows the book take your through it, at least for me, made it a lot more fun. It was, in my experience, kind of a rare book in how I wanted to share what I was looking at with someone but didn't have anyone to share it with really. Having the prof giving a breakdown made it a lot more digestable for me.
- tejasmanohar 8y agoWhat's IAASL?
- jason_s 8y ago<quote>…well, it would have been, but for some reason I kept struggling to get through it. I thought highly of it, but my secret shame was that my admiration for the book was based mostly on the first two hundred or so pages. It took slogging effort to get myself through the rest, effort sporadically applied over the course of years. I did eventually make my way through the whole thing, but even now, I can’t necessarily be sure I’ve read and absorbed every page, even though I’ve certainly looked at each one. By the end, my impression of the book was much more reserved: it does have some genuine high points and I can understand how it came to have its classic reputation, but I also felt it had a number of problems I’ve rarely seen discussed. For me personally, it ended up falling short of its reputation as a sparkling, effervescent text that drew together art, mathematics, and culture, and given how little I’ve seen this discussed, I wanted to write down why I feel this way. </quote> That's not the point. So what if you don't get everything? Are you supposed to get everything in Knuth's The Art of Computer Programming on the first read? The record-playing example is a wonderful metaphor for Godel's theorem, not a terrible one.
- pvg 8y agoAre you supposed to get everything in Knuth's The Art of Computer Programming on the first read? The Art of Computer Programming is a reference work so this isn't as trenchant a counterpoint as you might have thought.
- jason_s 8y agoGEB is just as technically deep as TAOCP.
- giantsloth 8y agoYou are making a simple assertion that the metaphor was good without any explanation, while the author made a deep and cutting explanation as to why he he believes it’s a terrible metaphor. You’ve made no counter argument.
- red75prime 8y agoMaybe Hofstadter hadn't chosen the best metaphor, but criticizing it from the point that it contains too many irrelevant details isn't unlike dismissing the use of apples for teaching counting numbers (what happens if I bite an apple, what if an apple is larger than another one and so on).
- waserwill 8y agoThe reviewer has interests which are superficially discussed in the book, and even those about which readers may often express interest. I believe the book would have been several times less interesting to me had I not looked into the philosophy of mind and the problems of consciousness and neurobiology. I'd enjoyed the math, the music, the art, the cultural references, and the surreal metaphors; but those weren't the full story—Hofstadter says that the book is not about those things outrightly, albeit towards the latter chapters, iirc. These references, though generally enjoyable, serve as a path towards expressing a strange proposition, however indirectly. Perhaps it was done more clearly in IAASL, but I've not read it. However, personally, the rhetorical flourish with which it was done here was enjoyable.
- swah 8y agoSome folks find it too easy: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1141374 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1141374
- xkgt 8y agoI share the same sentiment with many of the commenters. I found GEB to be unnecessarily verbose and repetitive. But that is not to say that I wasn't impressed by the book. Irrespective of your disposition, there is a lot to take from it. First time I previewed it, I was blown away by its scope and depth that I decided to buy it. But after few chapters, I found it difficult to get past the fluff writing. I will take the advise of skipping first 300 pages and re-attempt this. Like one other commenter, I too recommend the Open Courseware on GEB. I have only watched the videos on the chapters that I have already completed. It offers a fresh perspective and academic take on the material presented in the book.
- andrzejsz 8y agoI probably asked that before but anybody knows about ebook of GEB?
- 1bent 8y agoAs far as I know, there's no legal ebook of G.E.B. I've this vague memory of hearing that the author regards it as a physical work of art; plus maybe the "ambigrams" were only licensed for the print edition, and the book won't be legally distributed without them.
- brudgers 8y agoMy first GEB, I traded for a complete works of Shakespeare. The second is sitting on a shelf alongside Fluid Analogies. Thinking about the GEB phenomenon today, boggles my mind. Sure it won a Pulitzer. But it was a best seller. That's how different the world was...non-fiction could be thick and highly technical and sell in volume to the general public...it didn't need to be a new journalistic summary or popular history, it could have long passages that many readers wouldn't fully understand and puzzles that they could not solve. A non-fiction book could require the reader to work. Not vague self-improvement homework, but intellectually in the present moment of the text. It was OK for a book to be hard. GEB is a piece of genius that would never get off the ground today. Basic Books is part of a conglomerate and self-publishing isn't a replacement.
- lettucehead 8y agoNo Starch Press!
- alexgmcm 8y agoThe Road to Reality by Roger Penrose was a bestseller just recently and I found that impossible to read even with a graduate degree in Physics.
- TheOtherHobbes 8y agoThis makes me feel better. So far as I can tell, without a graduate degree in physics, that book is a giant bucket full of minced-up grad-level math, and Penrose is a pretty terrible guide to it. On the up side it made me think I should put some time and effort into understanding the math and the ideas. That was nearly fifteen years ago now, and it's turned out to be a lot of fun as an occasional side hobby. On the down side, he completely fails to make even relatively simple concepts either simple or accessible. When you spend your life surrounded by some of the smartest grad students in the world, you're going to have a very unrealistic idea of what the average human can understand. Of of how to explain things to the average human in a way that makes understanding more likely. Infuriating book - but I'm still glad he wrote it, and that I tried to read it.
- 8y ago
- giantsloth 8y agoThis is a perfect opportunity to whip out one of my favorite quotes by Simone de Beauvoir: “Proust observed with astonishment that a great doctor or a great professor often shows himself, outside of his specialty, to be lacking in sensitivity, intelligence, and humanity. The reason for this is that having abdicated his freedom, he has nothing else left but his techniques. In domains where his techniques are not applicable, he either adheres to the most ordinary of values or fulfills himself as a flight.” I think this quote applies to a lot of people on this site.
- purplezooey 8y agoIndeed, and to Peter Thiel
- j2kun 8y agoI also dislike Thiel, but this is gratuitously negative and irrelevant to the discussion.
- jkabrg 8y agoWhat does "fulfill himself as a flight" mean? Is the lesson that since professors are "less free" than everyone else, they criticize everyone else out of bitterness? Or is it that since they're so specialized and able to make a living only in their specialty, they don't need to practise good judgement outside their discipline? Is it that they live in an ivory tower and don't know the difference between theory and practise? What does that quote mean? ... Maybe they "abdicate their freedom" when they have to teach students and battle administration. I seriously don't know what that quote means.
- prr123 8y agoFrom what I got from the essay (it's been a while...), people who chose a "serious" path in life see no value in things that do not contribute to their goal. E.g.: If you focus too much on engineering, you stop being able to see value in other aspect of life, such as philosophy. De Beauvoir describes a couple of states of freedom of mind: 1. Children who believe in what they're told and don't think about their freedom 2. The serious man who chose a goal in life and do not think about their freedom (which the quote is about) 3. Nihilists who realize they're free but chose to do nothing 4. Adventurers who accept their freedom, but chose no precise goals 5. Passionate men who choose a goal according to their freedom and show no concerns for others 6. Genuine freedom (freedom + goal + concerns for others freedom)
- Procrastes 8y agoLike another commenter, I was in my 20s. I had no background in Math or CS when I read GEB. I was just a self taught C programmer writing door games for BBS systems. I read it cover to cover and it inflated my mind like a segmented bouncy castle. I had whole rooms to play in that I had never even realized were in there. Parts of it were slow, but I just put that down to my ignorance and plowed on. I can honestly say the book changed my life.
- chillingeffect 8y agoSimilar here. I accept that it's a cartoon-y version of Big Adult Concepts, but as a teenager, it taught me what meta means.
- booleandilemma 8y agoPeople read the dialogues?
- commandlinefan 8y agoI actually read just the dialogues to my son as bedtime stories when he was 5 or 6 - they actually work really well that way.
- adultSwim 8y ago"I realized that I wanted to like the book much more than I actually liked it in practice." This. Maturing has moved me past books that I "should" like. Communication is important! If it takes you 500 pages of hot air to explain something simple, where will there ever be room for a complex idea? For nuance? It's embarrassing how a ten minute CPG Grey can be better than many books I've read.
- Tomte 8y agoGEB is a book – like TAOCP – that makes me feel inadequate. I "know" I "should" work through it. I "know" I "should" enjoy it. But I never follow through. This review gives me hope that maybe I'm not just a ludicrous failure, but that there are different ways to go. Obviously, I do believe that, and I don't believe I'm a total failure, but still, I can't deny the nagging voice in the back of my head sometimes.
- carapace 8y agoHave you tried Smullyan? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Raymond_Smullyan#Selected_publications https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Raymond_Smullyan#Selected_publ...
- Tomte 8y agoOnly as a child, a German translation of one of his books with Knaves and Knights. Also Gardner. It impressed me, but was too difficult for me back then.
- pvg 8y agoSecond time in this thread I see someone mention GEB in the same breath as TAOCP. I'm curious how they ended up occupying the same kind of mental space for you and apparently others. In the immortal words of Jules Winnfield, it "ain't the same fuckin' ballpark, it ain't the same league, it ain't even the same fuckin' sport". Not that you are under any obligation to read either and plenty of very good arguments can be made you're better off not-reading at least one of them.
- Tomte 8y agoIn the same way as both chocolate ice cream and riding a rollercoaster make me happy, but are totally different. :-)
- pvg 8y agoRight but do you feel you have to read, to pick a slightly less fraught example, the white algorithms book? Or Patterson and Hennessy? Like TAOCP, those work perfectly well skimmed or read in bits and parked on your bookshelf or in your bathroom. GEB (or Moby Dick) are intended to be read in entirety.
- vanderZwan 8y ago> I’m familiar with how record-players work, but I have never played a record designed to break a record-player! If I recall correctly, at some point there were copyright protection measures on some audio CDs got so aggressive that they would actually brick your CD-ROM drive if you were foolish enough not to have autorun disabled (I'm not even talking about the Sony Rootkit scandal). That's a quarter century after GEB was written though.
- purplezooey 8y agoTortoise: Right—who wants to hear the racket of clinking dishes and jangling silverware? OP completely missed the tongue-in-cheek reference to silence here.
- Liron 8y agoI agree that GEB weaves a nice braid in many ways, just not an eternal golden one.
- jlarcombe 8y agoYes, an irritatingly-written book, very hard to enjoy despite seemingly being perfectly designed for my interests. I feel the same way about Iain Sinclair's books, which I kept on buying until I eventually admitted defeat that they're just not for me, despite the amount of fascinating stuff within
- floatboth 8y ago> decided to explain its working by coming up with a metaphor involving record-players and records that are designed to physically break the record-players they’re played on Wait... I've seen this style of explanation somewhere... M O N A D T U T O R I A L S
- thanatropism 8y agoAs I've heard it explained, monads are simply monoids on the category of endofunctors, or something. (I know what monoids are in group theory, and have a vague glimpse that functors are maps between categories. I figure that endofunctors are functors from a category to itself; how they come to be their own category or how monoids even apply, well.)
- poe876 8y agoYou don't love them because you hate them you dimwitted trash.
- inputcoffee 8y agoThis was a pre-internet book though. The internet has made explanations hyper competitive. At this point I can find dozens -- perhaps hundreds -- of explanations of Godel's theorem. But in the pre-internet days I could go to the library, or have my friend Kent explain it to me. (He had to explain first that languages were either complete or true -- he called it sound if I recall. soundness was the property -- and then it was demonstrated that these formal languages were sound, therefore incomplete.) Back then you couldn't just google Godel and say "oh, that reminds me of music returning to the tonic" or whatever and then google that. I think because a lot of the ideas have sort of spread out into culture, and been re-explained over the years, the best explanation are not in those books anymore.
- pfortuny 8y ago“The best explanation”... That is something which you should reconsider. Few problems have a single optimal solution. And knowledge is more a matter of cumulative subjective experiences than a single event. What is good for me is bad for you (as a matter of fact I find Gödel’s proof unmistakeaby clear).
- inputcoffee 8y agoI concede the point: the "best" explanation is best in a context. The best explanation for a PhD candidate about to defend their thesis the next day is not the same as it is for, say, me. But that reinforces the point I am making.
- superkuh 8y agoMaybe he read it too old. I read it in high school and it absolutely blew my mind. It was a slog at parts, predicate calculus and symbolic manipulation like that was new to me, but I can say without qualification that it changed my thinking and life.
- danharaj 8y agoThe treatment of Godel's theorems in GEB always struck me as gratuitous: It treats a technical result as having great philosophical import. The philosophical content of Godel's theorems is already found in the Liar paradox, "This statement is false." and incompleteness in a grand sweeping sense involving language in its entirety can be found in works as early as the Daoists and the Greeks. Edit: I should say that this wasn't at all obvious to me when I was in college and thinking hard about incompleteness. The limitations of mathematics disturbed me deeply. These days, I think it's part of the beauty of mathematics that its limitations are its own result.
- rwallace 8y ago> The philosophical content of Godel's theorems is already found in the Liar paradox, "This statement is false." Sort of. Common reactions to the English version of the liar paradox are along the lines of 'that's meaningless so it doesn't imply anything' or 'so natural language is inconsistent, what do you expect?' Most of the work Gödel did was to find a way to encode meta-logic into formal language in such a way that he could then state the liar paradox in a format so ironclad that it could no longer be dismissed.
- danharaj 8y agoSure, that's the technical content of Godel :) If people chose not to take the Liar paradox seriously, I think they would gnash their teeth just as vigorously at the incompleteness theorem, and there is an expansive graveyard of attempts to circumvent it.
- myWindoonn 8y agoIn my opinion the most important bit of Gödel's results is Tarski's Undefinability, an essential corollary that is often completely omitted when talking about incompleteness. GEB covers this (on p580 in my copy) and talks a bit about the consequences. The other important part, of course, is that these results are inescapable.
- avaku 8y agoExactly how I feel about this book.
- burntrelish1273 8y agoTo be frank, GEB gave an impression of magical thinking meets intellectual masturbation. I couldn't see the value in dilettantishly lionizing "beautiful ideas" while bounding from one topic to another.
- dgreensp 8y agoA metaphorical fugue on minds and machines in the spirit of Lewis Carroll The dialogues are supposed to be whimsical and bizarre dream-like riffs on the topic at hand, a la Alice in Wonderland, not sharp teaching instruments. I think Hofstadter did get the supposed point of Cage’s piece, or why would he have joked about whether people want to hear ambient noise or not? The review gets good in the middle when it starts talking about Zen, and I agree with some of the conclusions towards the end. As another commenter pointed out, Hofstadter was young. In a way, the whole book is like an amateur piece of music or film or poetry, at times clumsy or campy but generally endearing. I understood this even as a kid.
- monochromatic 8y agoThe critiques here are spot on. The dialogues at the beginning of chapters were tedious and mostly unhelpful. The treatment of anything far afield from math was pretty shallow and cursory. That said, I still loved this book in spite of its imperfections. I think it’s important to read it at the correct time in one’s life. When I first read it (at 19 or so), it showed me a lot of things I’d never thought about before. The topics it didn’t really do justice, it at least hinted at things that were new and interesting to me. It doesn’t hold up quite so well to subsequent readings by my older self, but I’ll always have a soft spot for it.
- ianamartin 8y agoThis critique sounds like it comes from someone who has engaged with a wide range of topics enough to know that there is a lot of detail and nuance, but not enough for any of it to have coalesced into a simple understanding of it. Cage's music is annoying and pretentious, and I largely think that because Cage was annoying and pretentious. He made a classic mistake in the art world of trying to tell people what his work was about and then getting pissed off when people either still didn't like it or chose to interpret it differently. That's a rookie mistake, and it's a fight artists never win. The smart ones keep their mouths shut and let the work speak for itself. The good ones make art that can be meaningful to a lot of different people in a lot of different ways. This was one of the great sticking points in the "War of the Romantics" between the New German School (Wagner and Liszt) on the side of program music against the Leipzig group (Schumann, Brahms) pushing absolute music. This battle between composers arguing about whether meaning should be explicit and imposed or if it should be intrinsic to the music and left to the listener was the context for Cage's work. And his work is most charitably interpreted as social commentary, even though that's not what he wanted. The best thing you can say about it is that it asks the question, "What is music now?" But he thought he was the first person to ever ask this question and got really irritated when people pointed out that academics had been asking this question for a couple thousand years. So, a lot of very serious musicians thought he was pretty dumb, and he got pissed and said it's not dumb, you're dumb and you don't understand it, and if you were smart you would think it's all genius. It's really hard to defend that kind of a person, but it gets easier as time passes and you can stop thinking about the artist as a person and think of the art. But as a professional violinist for over 30 years and a music theorist, I don't object to the Hof's assessment. I could say similar things about Milton Babbit too, integrated serialism, and a lot of contemporary classical music. It would probably get a response from a certain kind of person who would say that I just don't get it or that I haven't given it proper study. Well, I have, and I think it's kind of dumb, it's been done before, and I no longer have the youthful zeal it takes to debate these things point-by-point. Similarly, the criticism of the treatment of Zen also seems a little youthful. I grew up in a very Catholic family with parents who basically don't accept Vatican 2, and still practice Latin mass, and a large part of my home schooling was the intense study of Catholic history, philosophy, and theology. I took being Catholic extremely seriously for a very long time. But over the years I came to the conclusion that it was basically a bunch of cute fairy tale stories. Wonderful philosophy; terrible religion. And I'm not blind to the rich cultural heritage the Catholic church is responsible for. As a classical musician, I'm extremely aware of (and grateful for) how much the Church is responsible for Western Music as we know it today. As I was drifting away from Catholicism, I got pretty deep into Buddhism. Ultimately I came to a similar conclusion. Great philosophy; silly religion. Ultimately this article comes across almost as whiny and angsty and teenagery as John Cage does when he's defending his music: "You just don't understand me!!!" No dude. Trust me. I understand it. It's just kind of stupid. You'll grow out of it eventually. The book isn't perfect by any means. It is contrived. I don't think you could write a book like that today. But it was written in a very different time. A time when the knowledge divide between ivory tower academics and lay people was explicitly desired by the academics in a wide variety of fields, including--classical music. Babbit was famous for arguing that classical music should not be comprehensible to anyone who didn't have a PhD in Music Theory or Composition. That classical music deserved to be as respected and obtuse as advanced math and science, and that normal people didn't deserve to be able to understand great art. This book was a direct reaction to that academic pretense, and it presaged an era that has disseminated more knowledge across a wider range than any other explosion of knowledge since the printing press--and far outdone it. Outside of that context, the book almost doesn't make any sense. Why would anyone write like this in a world where the top academic minds of every field lay out their innermost thoughts about the most challenging problems in their field on their blogs and talk to riff-raff in the comments and try to make things as understandable as possible? Well, no one writes like that any more. Not even Hofstadter writes like that any more. It is an artifact of its time . . . a lingering remnant of a world where knowledge had to be protecting by intellectual elites and a wide-ranging understanding of difficult concepts was seen as a threat to the academic establishment, and a reminder of how recently things worked that way. When I was a kid violinist just getting into the completely new world of these concepts, it was illuminating and perhaps life-changing. As a grown up now with a different perspective, I can't see how it would have nearly as much of an impact on a younger person in today's context, and so in my world, its value has shifted from being the kind of book that initially illuminates a certain set of ideas and now reminds us of the world we came from way more recently than it feels like.
- jweather 8y agoI've read it cover-to-cover at least three times, gifted a copy, and read it out loud to my son. I find it very playful and mind-expanding. I will admit that it is verbose and wandering, but I think that's part of the charm. Out of curiosity I wandered through Amazon's 1-star reviews of this book to see what other people had to say. "Obtuse and impenetrable", I can certainly understand. It takes a certain bent to put the effort into reading it, and a certain level of interest to sustain that effort. The bulk of the critiques, though, including the OP, seem to be that it's too shallow in some specific area. How could it possibly dive any deeper into a fraction of the topics covered without being split into a multi-volume set? Perhaps more economical prose would allow for deeper dives, but personally I think it serves as an excellent layperson's introduction to a huge number of topics in logic, philosophy, theology, biology, music, art, language, etc.
- deepaksurti 8y ago>>takes a certain bent to put the effort into reading it Years back, I scanned through a few pages and realized it needed effort as you mention. OTOH, I think there are 2 kinds of great books: one which just suck you into their world and other which demand effort/tax to pay to immerse in that world. The former are incredible books, while the latter are still great. I found `On Lisp` by PG in the same latter category though GEB and OL tackle different subjects.
- optimuspaul 8y agoI find the latter to be too tedious usually. If they don't at least start out as the former then the latter will never be finished by me. I think that those two kinds are poles of a spectrum and I believe there is a falloff point not too far past the middle that I find acceptable. I think it is interesting you say the one end is incredible but the other end is "still great". Does that mean you enjoy them less?
- ludston 8y ago> Does that mean you enjoy them less? Enjoyment is not the point. I am a different person because of reading GEB, and my coding style changed because of reading On Lisp. With internalisation and comprehension, the first kind of book will change the way that you think forever. This kind of book is going to be a boring if you are unable understand the concepts that it is trying to communicate. If these concepts are going to change you forever it might take some reflection (i.e. if you continue perusing the entire book at "reading speed" you will hit a point where you no longer understand what the author is talking about due to not sufficiently internalising the earlier material.)
- agentofoblivion 8y agoI also found the book to be pretentious and full of nonsense. It gave the impression something profound was being said, but was mostly poetic license that might be charming to some, but I found to be irritating since it seemed to confuse rather than clarify.
- honoredb 8y agoNitpick: "…had 13 not been prime" is not meaningless whimsy--a prime number of images is harder to lay out on the page. Mentioning this in the caption without explaining it is whimsical, but like a lot of GEB I'd argue it's whimsy with a purpose: training the reader to look for applications of abstract concepts. The reader ideally goes "wait, what? There's no connection between those two things! Unless..."
- vilhelm_s 8y agoIndeed. And it's a small but interesting sentence, because it serves as a counterexample to some theories of counterfactuals. To quote the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy article on David Lewis (p □→ q means "if p were true then q"): > The basic idea behind the alternative analysis was similar to that proposed by Robert Stalnaker (1968). Let's say that an A-world is simply a possible world where A is true. Stalnaker had proposed that p □→ q was true just in case the most similar p-world to the actual world is also a q-world. Lewis offered a nice graphic way of thinking about this. He proposed that we think of similarity between worlds as a kind of metric, with the worlds arranged in some large-dimensional space, and more similar worlds being closer to each other than more dissimilar worlds. Then Stalnaker's idea is that the closest p-world has to be a q-world for p □→ q to be true. But "13 is prime" is the most central example of a necessary truth; in this example there _are_ no p-worlds. So the fact that this sentence is, in fact, meaningful shows that the way we use language is doing something different from Stalnaker's model. And of course, the connection between counterfactuals, analogy making, and general intelligence is one of Hofstader's research interests, and he comes back to it in a later chapter. This example of his again kindof makes fun of counterfactual reasoning about mathematical objects: > Related to this notion of slipping between closely related terms is the notion of seeing a given object as a variation on another object. An excellent example has been mentioned already-that of the "circle with three indentations", where in fact there is no circle at all. One has to be able to bend concepts, when it is appropriate. Nothing should be absolutely rigid.
- jrochkind1 8y agoI could have plenty of other critiques (and share some of OP's), but I had no problem with the record-player metaphor, I found it pretty apt. The very physical/analog nature of a record player makes it not hard for me to imagine a record designed to break a player, one can totally imagine one whose grooves jostle the arm so much it breaks (no idea if this is actually practical, it doesn't really matter). I wonder if it doesn't work anymore now that fewer people have experienced a record player, although the author DID say he encountered it first 20 years ago and had trouble with it then, I dunno. > can the problem of record-player-breaking-records be suitably addressed by redesigning record-players? If no, why not? What if we simply read the information from a record using a visual device with no moving parts? Dude, it's a metaphor/analogy, it's not that hard to realize taking it that literally takes you out of it. No analogy can ever be carried to it's end and still be a good analogy or metaphor. That's why it's an analogy, not the thing analogized. (which is a lesson that is (ironically? intentionally?) consistent with the messages of GEB? The map is not the territory.)
- grkvlt 8y agoAnd if I remember correctly, in the dialog, one of the record-player-destroying-record-proof record players R^whatever does scan the record visually to see if it would break the player - but is still vulnerable to a recording of 'this record cannot be played on player R^whatever' so this point is addressed...
- dmd 8y agoThere's a discussion in GEB about mystery/detective novels, and how the physical fact of seeing that you're near the end of the book leaks information about the state of the plot to you. He muses - what if you inserted some number of blank pages at the end, so you weren't sure where the end was? But no, that's too easy - you might flip through and see them. What about Lorem Ipsum text? Well, that's better, but still obvious. What you really need to do is pad out the book with text that looks as much as possible like the real book, but isn't. And then one reads the latter parts of GEB, and you start wondering...
- optimuspaul 8y agoWait what? Are you suggesting that at some point in the book the text is just padding to throw you off? I haven't read it yet, but if that is what you are suggesting then I actually want to read it now. (if not then my interest is still don't feel any pull to it at all)
- svat 8y agoYes that's perfectly plausible :-) A lot of the book similarly makes you wonder about the book itself, what tricks are being played. That's one of the enjoyable things about it. (See my comment here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17464621 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17464621)
- phyzome 8y agoYes, and in fact he makes it perhaps a bit too explicit that that's what he's doing.
- mtreis86 8y agoFrom what I can tell the book has no real beginning or end, but three threads each of which start and end in different places, none of which start or end at the beginning or ending of the book. That chapter seems to be the end of one of those threads as the rest of the chapter after that statement doesn't really make sense.
- KevanM 8y ago
- interfixus 8y agoThe Tortoise. Not Tortoise. Author doesn't seem to have delved too deeply into this unique book.
- appleflaxen 8y agoI haven't read the book. Can you elaborate on why the definite article is an important aspect of how the book is written or interpreted?
- interfixus 8y agoIt's not the definite article per se. It's just that The Tortoise is specifically The Tortoise all throught the book, just as is in Lewis Carroll. Not getting that, I don't really believe anyone could have been getting the spirit of the book at all, no matter how all my downvoters may feel about it.
- svat 8y agoA lot of people think that the goal of the book was to explain Gödel's theorem. Some even think the book shows that "mathematics, art and music are the same". In fact, as Hofstadter says in the preface (to the 20th Anniversary Edition I think), this is utter nonsense and he intended no such thing: his goal with the book was to build up a certain philosophical argument about what consciousness is (and his answer was something like self-reference, or transcending "levels"). I might be misquoting this, because, like most people, I found the way he builds up this argument more fun and memorable and interesting than the argument itself. Do not read the book to understand Gödel's theorem, or Escher, or Bach. In fact, Hofstadter is not even really interested in Gödel's theorem itself: his interest is more in the particular trick that Gödel used to prove the theorem (Gödel numbering), which allows Gödel to encode statements about the system as arithmetic statements (within the system). And although the explanation in GEB is surely not the best explanations of Gödel's theorem, it is one of the most enjoyable musings on things "like" Gödel numbering — something you won't find in other places that are more interested in Gödel's theorem itself. I think if one tries to read the book expecting to learn or understand something, one can get frustrated. But like other Pulitzer-Prize winners for nonfiction (say The Soul of a New Machine), any learning is only incidental; what one can enjoy is the way the book is constructed. It is a work of literature, not mathematics. The dialogues are my favourite parts of the book — sure they may not be realistic, but they take surprising turns, they often have a lot hidden in them (I remember reading one half way through and suddenly suspecting something, then noticing that they formed an acrostic, reading the first letters down the page). Other things I most loved about the book is the way it is self-referential, the way everything fits together, elaborate puns seem to be set up over a course of 300 pages, etc. All in all, it is a book just simply of Hofstadter having fun. (I had the same impression of Hofstadter's translation of Pushkin's Eugene Onegin — I've read at least three other translations; Hofstadter's may not be most literal but it's surely enjoyable and with the most outrageous rhymes: who else would rhyme "debts" with "Till his creditors cast their nyets"! You can read online an article he wrote [1] before starting his own translation, then a very critical review of his translation [2] but whose "bad" examples (and the whole first chapter linked there) show what's actually fun.) You can see him enjoying himself, and you can go along if you'd like to have fun as well, forgiving a few things here and there, skipping parts that you don't find as much fun. [1]: https://archive.nytimes.com/www.nytimes.com/books/97/07/20/reviews/hofstadter-translation.html https://archive.nytimes.com/www.nytimes.com/books/97/07/20/r... [2]: https://archive.nytimes.com/www.nytimes.com/books/99/09/12/reviews/990912.12louriet.html https://archive.nytimes.com/www.nytimes.com/books/99/09/12/r...
- darkerside 8y agoIt's incredibly ironic that the author mistakes the dialogue of characters for the opinions of the author in the Tortoise and Achilles' remarks on 4:33.
- kingbirdy 8y agoWhy is that ironic?
- microtherion 8y agoI still like GEB, which I first read as a teenager. But later, when I read Hofstadter's "Le Ton beau de Marot", I was struck by similar thoughts about Hofstadter's non-mathematical ideas as this review hinted at: His tastes in music, poetry, etc, are very conservative and rather conventional, he doesn't seem to make any effort to engage seriously with any modern work, and he tries to pass this off as edgy sophistication. After the 50th repetition of "they were playing this awful Rock Music and my brilliant friend X remarked on how awful it was", it gets a bit old.
- cestith 8y agoPersonally, I enjoyed the whimsy and the references in GEB. I considered the weak references past the author's knowledge to be a nod and a pointer to go make a bibliographic romp through other material as one wished. It's an inspiration along the discussion of its ideas, but is not complete. That incompleteness may be because it so deeply references itself, hence the book itself being a funny metaphor. As directly useful reading to get someone more acquainted with a broad discussion of algorithms and logic without textbook depth of individual topics, I'd recommend _The_New_Turing_Omnibus_ by Alexander Dewdney and _The_Advent_of_the_Algorithm_ by David Berlinski. Probably the latter and then the former, actually. I wouldn't call GEB a bad read. I think because of its high reputation people expect too much from it, like it should be the definitive book of truth about logic and proofs. It's one book, and if one reads it in the light of it being a fun romp through topics that are somehow loosely connected in the vein of James Burke I think it delivers rather well.
- VLM 8y agoThis is what happens decades after something that WAS status signalling at one point, no longer is status signalling.
- draw_down 8y agoPeople don’t like to admit that it is a signal though.
- patfla 8y agoI first bought GEB in the early 80's. At that point, I had only a year in college and I made little headway with the book. Went back to college and ended up double-majoring in Japanese and Computer Science and took a bunch of math courses. Have now spent something like 30 yrs as a software engineer and, in particular, I've worked with many interesting people including one mathematical logician who taught me about such as Alonzo Church and the history of functional programming languages. So picked up GEB again a couple of years ago and found it much easier going. But then put it down again because most of the ideas, in addition to being very verbosely explained, are now old and there really wasn't a whole lot new there aside from elaborate explanation. I imagine that the book served its purpose in its time although if not Hofstadter, someone else would probably have come along and put together the various ideas.
- _emacsomancer_ 8y agoThough interestingly the beginning of the discussion of 'Zen': > This might seem unfair, so I’ll give a very specific but pervasive instance of this sort of meaningless flavor. Many parts of the book invoke Zen, which is a school of Buddhism that originated in China and has spread to several other Asian countries but, in the Western mind, is usually associated with Japan. (We do, after all, know this school by its Japanese name Zen and not by its Chinese name Chán, its Korean name Sean, or its Vietnamese name Thiền.) seems to miss the fact that Buddhism originated in India and that not only the Japanese word Zen but also Chinese Chán are adaptations of the Sanskrit dhān(a) (meaning originally something like 'concentration' or 'contemplation'). (Obviously philosophy is not static, and surely there were Chinese developments in it, but by the same token there were also Japanese developments and to point out that Zen Buddhism did not originate in Japan and fail to mention the anterior roots seems rather odd to me.)
- spraak 8y ago> seems to miss the fact that Buddhism originated in India and that not only the Japanese word Zen but also Chinese Chán are adaptations of the Sanskrit dhān(a) (meaning originally something like 'concentration' or 'contemplation'). Etymologically this is true, but in the sense of tradition, India doesn't really have a Zen tradition, it really did originate in China. Dhyāna is much more broad and not only part of Buddhism, but also Hinduism and Jainism
- _emacsomancer_ 8y ago> India doesn't really have a Zen tradition, India certainly has meditative/yogic practices and it seems unlikely to me that some bits of these wouldn't have travelled from India to China along with Buddhism and Sanskritic vocabulary.
- spraak 8y agoYes, of course India has a deep history of meditation and yoga and etymology does show relationship, but it is incorrect to say that it means the same thing in that place, most especially because the Sanskrit word itself wasn't purely preserved, it was mutated into a native sounding Chinese and Japanese word that took on a new, specific connotation reflecting the practice that evolved there in China. A simple example of this is the meaning of "pudding" in British English vs American English. > Pudding originally referred exclusively to varieties of sweet natural-casing sausage. The meaning grew to encompass anything boiled or steamed in a bag, then shifted to refer primarily to desserts, especially those cooked by boiling or steaming. Most recently, in American English, it has changed to refer exclusively to the thick custardy dessertstuff [1] So this simple example illustrates that location can have a specific effect on the meaning and connotation of a word, and that a word may have a broad meaning from where it originates, but can have a very specific and different meaning elsewhere. [1] https://english.stackexchange.com/a/12564 https://english.stackexchange.com/a/12564
- ggm 8y agoIt is not obligatory to like it. Few grand works are truly flawless. The ideas underneath are entertaining, and informing, and made me think (I got to read a pre-publication proof copy in the UK on the brink of University Computer Science degree) Sure, it could have been shorter. I bet if you cut any bit, somebody out there would complain it was missing.
- ajmurmann 8y agoI'm so glad I read this. I've tried to finish the book au least three times over the last 15-20 years and never made it much beyond page 200. I loved the prose sections but had a hard time getting through the Achilles & Turtoise sections. Some of them were super long and I always felt like they were clearly trying to convey some important, deep message that I'm too stupid to understand. Despite not enjoying them I actually reread some sections because I thought it must be me not getting it, although I had no problem understanding the actual explanation. I'm so happy to learn that I can skip the silly stories and dialogs without missing the value of the book. Maybe now I'll finally finish the book?!
- acconrad 8y agoDid I just grow up in unintelligent circles? I never even heard of GEB until I was around 28 (I only heard of IAASL today thanks to this thread/article) and I'm only now just getting around to it. Did I miss the boat here now in my 30s?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- ptrkdy 8y agoThere's a pretty big clue on page 9 that the book is supposed to be read backwards and upside down, starting at the end of the last dialogue. I know I found Hofstadters easter egg...
- perfunctory 8y ago> The dialogues are a big part of why I originally struggled with the book: they are meandering and long, and they regularly outstay their welcome. I would disagree. I found the dialogues absolutely beautiful and a big part of what makes this book so enjoyable. I think it would be a mistake to treat this book as a textbook whose goal is to convey some material in the most efficient way.
- svanevik 8y agoRead GEB when I was 20. Absolutely loved it, and it had a big impact on my choice of studies and career. Since then I've had a lurking fear that I'd be grossly disappointed if I picked it up again now. Your review indicates I should probably let it be. Thanks!
- amptorn 8y agoThere's also the fact that Hofstadter persistently equates strong AI with grandmaster-level chess-playing, and the entire chapter of nothing but totally unscientific, unfounded, incredibly wrong, biology-free speculation about how the human brain works.
- dunk010 8y agoThe author's main points are: * The dialogs are overlong and obtuse * Some specific metaphors don't click * The author attacks various things which he feels Hofstadter belittles (avant-garde music, Zen) He may be right about the dialogs, though as others have said perhaps it's better to read the chapters backwards. Or, even, metaphorically like the Crab Canon: dialog, chapter, and then dialog again. He's clearly projecting his own perspective without thinking about the perspective of others when it comes to the metaphors. This won a Pulitzer, not everyone has a mathematical background and can straight up understand Godel when directly explained. But it's the third part that is most troubling. These days it's fashionable to take some earlier cultural artefact, and assassinate it on the basis that every point of view is valid, genuine, and can't be criticised. I smell that same pattern in his counter-attacks on "avant-garde social commentary masquerading as music" and Zen. Hofstadter has an opinion on these. A strong, negative opinion. Attacking Hofstadter the way he does to me more smacks of a post-hoc character assassination than intelligent engagement with the material. As an aside: I read Hofstadter (somewhere) say that he has spent a lot of his life after GEB trying to hammer home that it was about self-reference, self-reference, and nothing but self-reference. I think he even described "I am a Strange Loop" as being GEB but much more direct (I still need to read that one).
- kwoff 8y agojesus fucking christ, downvote me away from here you ignorant millenials - what the fuck is wrong with you morons? EDIT: can someone please ban me from ever visiting this site? Who the fuck upvotes 400 points this asinine bullshit?
- gerdesj 8y agoSoooo, you didn't like a book that challenged you in a way that you did not like. I personally did enjoy it first time around. It’s a venerated book among a certain stripe of computer scientist and mathematician That is a bit trite and if I may: a bit disingenuous. I'm neither a comp sci nor a mathematician but I love GEB. It is a classic. I first discovered it by accident at school. It did not change my life as such but I think that DH did have a bearing on the way I think even nowadays.
- sgustard 8y agoSince the record player analogy was mentioned, I'll just quote the relevant entry from the Index of GEB, page 772. If the potential wonderment of the curiosities and untapped frontiers teased herein don't explode the mind of your 18-year-old self reading the book for the first time, there may be no hope for you. record players: alien-rejecting, 487-88; Epsilon-Zero, 486; family of, in Crab's jukebox, 154-57; Grand Self-assembling, see record player Epsilon-Zero; as information-revealers, 158-61, 164; intrinsic vulnerability of, 75-86, 102, 424, 470, 486-86, 536, 543, 584, 721, see also Tödelization, TC-battles, etc.; likened to formal systems, 84, 85; low-fidelity, 77, 85, 101, 406-7, 470; Omega, 78, 468, 483-84; Numbers 1, 2 ... etc., 76-77; Tortoise-chomping, 483, 487-88; two-channel monaural, 634, 669; see also jukeboxes
- amyjie 8y agoI haven't read GEB yet, but I had a similar experience reading "I Am A Strange Loop." It was too prosy, too long, too many examples and too obvious for anyone that has thought about these things before. It didn't go deep enough or propose mechanisms for anything. If you've never thought about any of these things before you might find it cool, otherwise it's a verbose rehash of things that have been said in better ways. https://altreason.com/i-am-a-strange-loop/ https://altreason.com/i-am-a-strange-loop/
- JAdamMoore 8y agoIt seems clear from his own writing that he lacks the intellectual capacity to fully appreciate the book. In his own words he describes repeatedly the struggles he faced with simple and obvious conventions of both writing and thought.
- internetman55 8y agoI don't love godel escher bach cause when i took my mathemat logic class the most annoying students were the ones who read that book!!!
- jbgreer 8y agoLike several others I read GEB during my undergrad days. I recall attending a local CogSci roundtable to announce my achievement, which I then viewed as something of a right of passage. When I told a prof I had just read GEB he laughed and said, "Oh no you haven't. You've just started."
- mcnamaratw 8y agoI think there are at least two groups of people here, completely talking past each other. This happens a lot on HN. The two big groups seem to be (1) people talking about enjoying popular science writing, and (2) technical practitioners talking about what they do. The only thing we maybe forget as a community is that (1) and (2) are different genres that don't overlap very much. One group is trying to read GEB as a popular science book and saying, wow, it's an unusually good one. The dialogs are a nice rest from the technical stuff and probably convey something. Another group is trying to read GEB as an introductory technical book and saying it's a mixed bag. The dialogs are a distraction from the technical stuff and sometimes don't convey enough.
- DonHopkins 8y agoFrom the classic MIT-AI Lab humor directory: AI:HUMOR;GEB REVIEW (I'm including a copy for reference and archiving since the web server publishing this link is written in MACLISP running under ITS on a PDP-10 emulator.) http://up.update.uu.se/DSK%3AHUMOR%3BGEB%20REVIEW http://up.update.uu.se/DSK%3AHUMOR%3BGEB%20REVIEW The following review of "Godel, Escher, Bach: An Eternal Golden Braid," Douglas R. Hofstadter, New York: Basic Books, appeared in "Fusion", Magazine of the Fusion Energy Foundation, Oct. 1979, pp. 61. "Douglas Hofstadter, author of "Godel, Escher, Bach," has not had such a vaired experience with the antiscience movement as Bateson [Bateson, Gregory, "Mind and Nature--A Necessary Unity", preceding review in Fusion], but his brief career, nevertheless, is a clue to the message of his book. Hofstadter is a computer expert in the field of artificial intelligence. This dismal discipline, which emanates from the Bertrand Russell-Karl Korsch networks, has been used primarily to develop brainwashing programs. Hofstadter claims to be part of his network through his close association with Marvin Minsky who, in turn, works closely with linguistician Noam Chomsky at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology. Politically these "artificial intelligence" academics link up to the Bateson circles through the various radical groups they mutually support. Artificial intelligence is as nasty a discipline as its use in brainwashing implies. It is based on the premise that the operations of the human mind are essentially compatible with formal Aristotelian logic and thus can be replicated by a sufficiently complex computer. ...... Douglas Hofstadter's interminable driveling (777 pages) reiterates Bateson's point from the perspective on an attack on Kurt Godel's 1931 proof that any system determined by a fixed lawfulness (axiomatic login) is necessarily incomplete, hence incapable of solving problems that can be posed within its limits. The obvious conclusion to be reached from this proof is that there is a higher order of lawfulness (reason) that determines successive, reason-determined locally lawful systems. The British oligarchy never forgave Godel for this insight, which negate Bertrand Russell's attempted destruction of Georg Cantor's introduction of the concept of the transfinite into mathematics. Hofstadter simultaneously slanders Godel and the musical genius Johann Sebasian Bach--whose recognition of the same principle in musical composition made Beethoven's subsequent breakthroughs possible--by lumping them with the psychotic Dutch draftsman M.C. Escher. The paradoxes of formal logic, Hofstadter contends--for example, Epimenides's statement that all Cretans are liars--are really Zen koans. There is nothing new here that the eastern mystics and their systematized irrationality did not discover in bygone millennia. In fact, he says, the solution is to imbed simple axiomatic systems in more complex ones in regress. Once this is accomplished, presto, mind and the universe can be programmed into a computer. (Reviewed by: John Schoonover)