3 ms·
If you're suggesting that because a system draws from a group of people consisting of both sides of politics (or no side of politics, then it is therefore "func
by andrewstuart 8y ago
If you're suggesting that because a system draws from a group of people consisting of both sides of politics (or no side of politics, then it is therefore "functional, fair and apolitical in its outcomes", then I suggest your conclusion is somewhat naive.
The idea of "I cut you choose" is an incredibly inspired one because fairness is inherently built in because no participant wants to risk getting the bad side of the slicing and therefore works very hard to make it fair.
- jellicle 8y agoPlenty of people are perfectly willing to draw fair districts. 7.4 billion people on Earth right now, and at least 7 billion of them would be perfectly honest and fair in drawing congressional districts. The fact that the US generally picks people from the tiny slice of committed partisans to draw boundaries is idiotic.
- vibrio 8y agowhile I like to be optimistic about human nature, the ability to find people that don't have political and/or financial interests involved in those decisions is not trivial. The 7.4 Billon people number is irrelevant. No one is going to someone from Sudan to draw districts in Wisconsin-they won't even go to someone from Illinois or Minnesota for that advice.
- jamie_ca 8y agoThey could. Get somebody from out of state, and give them just a raw map with population counts/density/whatever. Heck, do this 3 times, and then get local party affiliates to look them over, and each party can eliminate one of them so the most middle-ground is selected.
- jellicle 8y agoWhy not? The only reason for "why not?" is "because I want to bias the drawing process", which is not a good reason.