5 ms·
> - Permission requests are becoming optional, at least for now. Previously we required permission for all non-anonymized message contributors, now there will b
by mirimir 8y ago
> - Permission requests are becoming optional, at least for now. Previously we required permission for all non-anonymized message contributors, now there will be an option to publish stuff immediately and let people anonymize themselves later if they want. If this is excessively abused we'll re-evaluate this, but we've tried to build things to incentivize good judgment.
This is horrible! I mean, people can always be jerks, and publish private email. But you're facilitating that. This could readily be used, as an example, as a type of revenge porn. Sure, victims can anonymize themselves. But only after the information has been published, and potentially scraped. And you know that jerks will be scraping your site, for just this reason.
The default must be requiring explicit permission from all participants. Without permission, even anonymization is insufficient to protect against abuse.
- Alex3917 8y ago> The default must be requiring explicit permission from all participants. That's still the default. There are lots of legitimate use cases for publishing stuff without permission though, e.g. emails from Steve Jobs or whatever. Normally when social sites get a lot of traction and then die it's because they go into a death spiral of negativity: e.g. Secret, Whisper, Yik Yak, etc. The best practice for avoiding this is to err on the side of too much friction when launching, and then to reduce friction for people who are contributing positively to the community. That's basically the model we're following. The whole point of the site is to showcase positive interactions between people. E.g. showing conversations between VCs, between academics, lawyers, etc. I think the site is too wonky to get overly negative, but if it starts going that way then we'll be very quick to change things up again.
- mirimir 8y ago> That's still the default. That's good to know. > There are lots of legitimate use cases for publishing stuff without permission though, e.g. emails from Steve Jobs or whatever. Just because he's dead, and was a public figure, is it morally acceptable to publish private email? Or even legal, without permission from his estate? A quick search gives me the following. https://blogs.findlaw.com/law_and_life/2018/04/is-it-legal-to-publish-email-correspondence-without-permission.html https://blogs.findlaw.com/law_and_life/2018/04/is-it-legal-t... https://writersweekly.com/this-weeks-article/legal_emails https://writersweekly.com/this-weeks-article/legal_emails https://law.stackexchange.com/questions/3980/is-it-legal-to-publish-email-that-someone-sent-to-me https://law.stackexchange.com/questions/3980/is-it-legal-to-... Edit: Also: http://nulawreview.org/extralegalrecent/do-not-forward-why-passing-along-an-email-may-constitute-copyright-infringement http://nulawreview.org/extralegalrecent/do-not-forward-why-p...
- scardine 8y agoOf course if he is dead and is a public figure and the other part discloses it the exchange is now part of history. What is wrong with that? I love to read correspondence from folks like Newton[1] for example and I want my grandchildren to be able to read Jobs exchanges as well. [1] http://www.newtonproject.ox.ac.uk/texts/correspondence/all http://www.newtonproject.ox.ac.uk/texts/correspondence/all
- mirimir 8y agoBased on the cites that I listed, it's not that simple. Edit: Perhaps there's now legitimate public interest for most everything about him. But maybe some Apple-related stuff is still off limits.
- Alex3917 8y agoIn terms of legality there are two separate issues, invasion of privacy and copyright. Things like privacy / libel / slander generally don't apply to the deceased, so in this case I think we can safely ignore that. With respect to copyright, when you send someone an email you're using an agreed upon protocol (RFC 5322, RFC 5598, etc.) that implicitly grants the recipient a copyright. Now you can say this is a bad argument because no one ever reads those, which is true. But if this weren't true legally, then every time you replied to an email it would be illegal since (in most clients) the full text of the previous email gets copied below the new text. Users also can't really use the platform to violate the copyrights of third parties (e.g. by attaching music or whatever), since the platform is tied to their email account. From an ethical perspective, the reason we specifically excluded whistleblowers as a user story is that you can't build a sustainable business around it, since you can only be a whistleblower once. we've designed it to force uploaders to have skin in the game. E.g. they can't anonymize themselves, and they're forced to link their Gmail accounts. I think that's enough to prevent the vast majority of bad behavior. E.g. you could also copy and paste someone's private email into a HN post, but it's just not done. The only thing we really do is make the process easier by letting people making redactions, anonymize people, send permission requests, etc., but that's not exactly a selling point for people who would be egregiously abusing the site.
- JumpCrisscross 8y ago> The default must be requiring explicit permission from all participants If you send me an e-mail, absent an NDA, I generally have permission to disclose it to third parties. If FWD:Everyone required permission from all participants, they would simply fall prey to FWD:Everyone2 who didn't.
- occamrazor 8y agoFrom a GDPR perspective,sending an email gives the recipient the implicit permission to store and read the contents and metadata of the email, but not to transfer it to other parties (except the data processors that process the email) or publish it.
- crummy 8y agoDoes that mean I'm not allowed to forward emails you send me?
- Spivak 8y agoNobody is going to be able to give you a definitive answer because it hasn't been tested in the US in the context of copyright or in the EU under the GPDR. My guess is that forwarding would be fine but publishing wouldn't (in the US) and that you as an end user don't have to worry about the GPDR.
- occamrazor 8y agoHard to say, because the law is new. My guess is that it is legal as long as it is not in a professional/commercial context, or you remove my PII, or you have a clear and legitimate business reason, e.g. forwarding to a colleague within the company who is responsible for the subject matter. Examples of illegal behavior would be publishing it, forwarding it to a marketer, or eg. for a recruiting agency forwarding to a company fir which I haven’t given permission.
- mirimir 8y agoWhat about claims for public disclosure of private facts? https://injury.findlaw.com/torts-and-personal-injuries/invasion-of-privacy--public-disclosure-of-private-facts.html https://injury.findlaw.com/torts-and-personal-injuries/invas...