2 ms·
It's an interesting article but I feel like it fails to actually illuminate what's behind the distinction between logic and biology. "Biology is very different
by joe_the_user 8y ago
It's an interesting article but I feel like it fails to actually illuminate what's behind the distinction between logic and biology.
"Biology is very different from logic—or even from the physical sciences. If biologists find that a particular mutation of a gene is present in 80% of people suffering from a certain disease, and missing from 80% of a control
group, then that’s a significant result. If physicists tried to report an experiment in which 80% of the events supported their theory, they’d be required to explain what happened in the other 20%"
This may be true but accuracy by itself is not a very "deep" distinction. If you have crude engineering, you can accept a low percentage of accuracy. If you happen to have done good bioengineering, 80% might not be good enough accuracy.
A much more illuminating quality of biological systems is A. they are much more complex and B. they are tolerant of variation everywhere, that biological systems with varying properties interoperate without major problems whereas computer components require very fine tolerances to operate together. Human organs vary from person to person yet different people remain alive. If a given computer component varies substantially, chances are the machine won't stop.
The variation of each component of a biological system relates to another property of biological systems - "self-organization"; each of the components of a biological system appears through a million-year long process of self-reproduction. So each component has a bit of something (feedback, intelligence, design, etc) which allows it to keep going even when inputs and outputs are imperfect.
And finally, there's the quality of lack of any overall idea. Genetic code involves a haphazard of grouping of "lasagna code" that merely happens to work, that X component accomplishes N tasks, M of which serve no current purpose that's OK. These M purposes functionalities may have served a purpose in the past and may serve a purpose in the future but maybe neither. The methodologies operating haphazardly by itself serves the purpose of having a variety of instances of an organism that can adapt when the environment changes.