4 ms·
Medical services for the poor (medicaid) are comparatively minor, but you wouldn't know it, given how much emphasis the Republicans place on the question of the
by yummyfajitas 16y ago
Medical services for the poor (medicaid) are comparatively minor, but you wouldn't know it, given how much emphasis the Republicans place on the question of the "welfare state".
I'm not sure I'd describe medicaid as "comparatively minor". Medicare is $390B, medicaid $247B ($290B including the state contributions). I guess the threshold for expenses that don't matter must bet somewhere between $290B and $390B.
http://usgovernmentspending.com/year2008_US.html#usgs30210 http://usgovernmentspending.com/year2008_US.html#usgs30210
(Use the dropdown to select year=2008, the last year for which full data is available.)
[edit: curious why I'm being downmodded. Is posting the actual numbers so detrimental to the conversation?
edit 2: put in the federal-only numbers, thanks jbooth for pointing that out. ]
- timr 16y ago"I'm not sure I'd describe medicaid as "comparatively minor". Medicare is $390B, medicaid $247B ($290B including the state contributions). I guess the threshold for expenses that don't matter must bet somewhere between $290B and $390B." 2009 US Federal Spending: 3,518 Billion (100%) 2009 US Defense Spending: 782 Billion (23%) 2009 US Social Security: 678 Billion (20%) Medicare and Medicaid combined: 676 Billion (19%) I'm not saying Medicaid is nothing; I'm saying it's not even close to Social Security or defense spending as a source of concern. source: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:U.S._Federal_Spending_-_FY_2007.png http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:U.S._Federal_Spending_-_FY...
- jbooth 16y agoCompared to the size of the government, or even just the deficit, it's comparatively minor. By your numbers.
- jbellis 16y ago390B + 240B is over 20% of the total 2008 budget. I guess we have different definitions of "minor."
- jbooth 16y agoHey jbellis, been doing some Cassandra this past week. The original contention was just regarding medicaid -- 290 billion compared to a 3 trillion budget, with a > 1 trillion deficit. Entitlements all together add up to about half of the budget. They're big. But the original point was that nobody wants to touch medicare/SS but everyone makes Medicaid the bad guy. Makes you think they're more concerned with demographics and likely voters than budget arithmetic. EDIT: Watches the downvotes. Chill out guys, it's just numbers. You'll win the house this fall, take it easy on HN.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoMedicaid amounts to 65% of the budget deficit and about 60% of medicare. Welfare amounts to another 70%. If we cut the welfare state (i.e., medicare and welfare), we would have a budget surplus. While I agree that medicaid is a politically easier target than medicare, it's not a small program. It's a completely legitimate target of criticism, and eliminating it would significantly improve the federal budget.
- jbooth 16y agoWait, 65% of the budget deficit? Your own quote has it at 290 billion dollars, that' s approximately 30% of the discretionary budget deficit. Letting alone the fact that it's part of an entirely separate budget.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoThe federal deficit was $377.9 in 2008. You do the math. I'll post the link again: http://usgovernmentspending.com/year2008_US.html#usgs302 http://usgovernmentspending.com/year2008_US.html#usgs302
- jbooth 16y agoOhhhhh, we're talking about balancing the 2008 budget.. Well that doesn't make any sense, but I'm looking forward to your answers to my questions above on the mechanics of how that would work. (EDIT in reply: Yeah, that's fine, and I went with it, but talking about percentages of a 380 billion dollar deficit in the context of current events is just plain silly.)
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]