4 ms·
You are missing part of the point of the article. Don't blame the tech company or the sports owner for getting these concessions. Business owners are always g
by slg 8y ago
You are missing part of the point of the article. Don't blame the tech company or the sports owner for getting these concessions. Business owners are always going to act in their own best interest. Individual people do the same thing. Lots of people who live along the Washington/Oregon border make all their big purchases in Oregon because of the lack of state sales tax. I don't see anything morally wrong with doing that. They are just responding to economic incentives. Instead blame the politicians for setting up this perverse game of incentives in the first place. This article is trying to educate politicians (and the general population) of a better way to accomplish the same goals.
- Avshalom 8y agoThose Business Owners are ALSO the ones setting up this perverse game of incentive.
- lotsofpulp 8y agoWhile I understand the gist of your post, the people residing in WA are violating their state's tax law by not paying sales tax on their purchased in OR, whereas subsidies offered to businesses are legal(ized).
- slg 8y agoThat is fair and actually goes to further support my point. I would bet almost everyone reading this has at some point failed to pay sales tax on a purchase in which the retailer didn't collect the tax. We were all committing a crime to save a few dollars here and there. That was the whole motivation behind the fight to get internet retailers to start collecting taxes. Don't blame business for responding to economic incentives the same way you personally would.
- throwawaymath 8y ago> Don't blame business for responding to economic incentives the same way you personally would. On the other hand, the modal business has much more economic power and leverage than the modal individual. There's a reasonable argument that they should be held to a higher standard of responsibility and compliance because their contribution to the problem is magnified.
- maxxxxx 8y agoThey also put out a lot of propaganda and false information out to get their way. It's not like they just take advantage of an opportunity. They create that opportunity with a lot of questionable practices. And in addition voters are stupid. Spending a million on a swimming pool for kids is waste but half a billion for a sports stadium is a must.
- slg 8y ago>They also put out a lot of propaganda and false information out to get their way. It's not like they just take advantage of an opportunity. They create that opportunity with a lot of questionable practices. If a politician believes a single report prepared by a sports team over the literally dozens of peer reviewed academic studies that say the exact opposite, I blame the politician. >And in addition voters are stupid. Spending a million on a swimming pool for kids is waste but half a billion for a sports stadium is a must. That is democracy in action. More people want the sports stadium than the swimming pool. You might disagree with them, but that doesn't make them wrong.
- killaken2000 8y ago> More people want the sports stadium than the swimming pool. You might disagree with them, but that doesn't make them wrong. Is this true? Was there a vote on this? The politicians make the decisions and if people don't like it they can vote for someone else but I would bet in some deeply partisan districts they'd vote for anyone on their side. There's a lot of things the majority of the public want but the power that be say no.
- slg 8y agoIn many jurisdictions a referendum is required to spend that type of money. That is one of the reasons that a sibling thread is discussing the Chargers move from San Diego to Los Angeles. A vote was required in San Diego and the Chargers knew it would not go in their way. You are free to lobby your own local government to make a similar requirement for a referendum.
- 8y ago
- kettlecorn 8y agoI don’t like the notion that it is morally just to always act in your own self interest and that it is the job of regulations to tell you what you should and shouldn’t do. That framework doesn’t extend to the nuance of life. I can choose to find fault with tech companies and sports owners while still holding politicians accountable as well.
- jakelazaroff 8y agoIt's crazy to automatically indemnify people for acting in their own best interest. If I could steal a million dollars today and get away with it, it's in my best interest to do so rather than spend however many years working for it. By this logic, as long as a politician makes such a deal in order to garner public support or votes, with no concern for the wellbeing of their constituents, we can't blame them either. They're not doing anything wrong, just responding to political incentives!
- losteric 8y agoWhy does the blame always lie with "politicians"? That's unhelpfully reductionist... we are a democracy. Businesses, private citizens, and representives all come together to define our public policy. Those "perverse" tax incentives were a reasonable compromise between voters and businesses within a state. The perversion only exists at the interstate level, so which politician is "at fault"? The Washington legislature, responsible for all of Washington? Individual WA representatives, who get one vote regardless of their constituent's distance from the border? Or is it on the Oregon side? If either state copied the other, there's no problem - but which one "wins", and how do those changes get implemented?
- amelius 8y agoThe politicians at fault are the ones who were without foresight and allowed the wrong incentives to exist for local politicians.
- analog31 8y agoI live in a one-party gerrymandered state, not a democracy. It makes perfect sense in my case to blame the politicians.
- tajen 8y agoFor those unfamiliarwith gerrymandering, I highly recommend the John Oliver explanation, a humorist of actual facts, showing maps and tactics of politicians that are borderline criminal. https://youtu.be/A-4dIImaodQ https://youtu.be/A-4dIImaodQ
- analog31 8y agoAmusingly, my friend is a high school math teacher, and had to find topics to keep the kids interested in between the AP test and the end of the school year. So he had an exercise where the kids used a software program to come up with different strategies for gerrymandering our state.
- slg 8y ago
- chiefalchemist 8y agoAre politicians and appointed elected officials - that is those with power and influence - required to publish their investiment holdings? The companies, by definition, act in the best interest of their shareholders. What if those also happen to be shareholders of a given company looking for a good deal?
- maxerickson 8y agoWashington has a use tax, buying large items out of state doesn't change the tax due on them.