3 ms·
"What is surprising is that more open, transparent architecture prompted such a substitution." Why is that surprising? You removed offices so of course people
by olliej 8y ago
"What is surprising is that more open, transparent architecture prompted such a substitution."
Why is that surprising? You removed offices so of course people don't talk anymore - politeness dictates that you don't want to interrupt other people.
And performance declined, which they blamed on switching to email rather than talking, while ignoring the even more obvious: now every time your coworkers have a conversation it interrupts you.
The use of cubicles and open plan has been shown in every actual study to have a negative impact on performance.
I have friends in open plans, and literally the best thing I have heard is that if you get the right place there isn't that much distraction.
My opinion is that if managers and executives are convinced open plan is "better" they should be placed in an open plan environment for at least 12 months before /any/ employees are moved into it. Of course that will never happen because the real purpose of open plan is to make sure that non-management employees know their place: they [and their health] are not individually important, and are just fungible units that can be replaced at will.
- joezydeco 8y agoI've seen executives agree to such a plan and then commandeer a conference room for months at a time because they're always on an "important call" or something else.
- olliej 8y agoRight? The arguments I have is that there a “meeting rooms” for conversations, to which I say: there are hundreds of employees and 5 such rooms. If they’re for conversation they should be limited to maybe 30 minute stints, and cannot be functionally boomed for longer. Of course again the purpose is to denigrate the employees who actually do work, rather than to be a better work environment. And as other people have pointed out: the turn the office into an experiment in the spread of contagious diseases
- jonhendry18 8y ago"I've seen executives agree to such a plan and then commandeer a conference room for months at a time because they're always on an "important call" or something else." That was apparently rampant when TBWA Chiat/Day tried a radical open plan office redesign. https://www.wired.com/1999/02/chiat-3/ https://www.wired.com/1999/02/chiat-3/
- djhworld 8y ago> politeness dictates that you don't want to interrupt other people. Maybe, but I think it's more of a clash of personalities rather than politeness. People in my area (all technical/engineers/product managers) are all quiet and communicate mostly over Slack. The people opposite us are from business development or something definitely more people oriented, and they're all yapping away at each other all day. Have no qualms about interrupting other people, because that's just the way they work. Might be a bit of an extrovert/introvert thing too
- olliej 8y agoHowever this study was comparing communication and productivity from the same group, just moving those people from offices to an open plan with same general layout of people, in the same area (they were just moved up one floor). The amount over face to face communication decreased (more than 50% I think), and the overall performance (according to the company’s own metrics) decreased as well. It’s basically the closest to a controlled study of office vs open plan in the real world that you could ask for. The one thing open plan is meant to just “obviously” result in is collaboration and face to face communication. The numbers they got directly countered that.
- wool_gather 8y ago> managers and executives [...] should be placed in an open plan environment for at least 12 months before /any/ employees are moved into it. Making them "take their own medicine" is unlikely to be effective in this case, because the nature of manager/exec work is perfectly suited to the open layout. That's probably a large part of its popularity -- the people who decide for it fundamentally don't understand its problems. Even if they intellectually grasp that writing code requires concentration, they don't likely understand how fragile concentration can be. Much of their job consists exactly of moving around, having conversations with various people. They have less use for stretches of uninterrupted concentration. Cf. the excellent "Maker's Schedule, Manager's Schedule" essay http://www.paulgraham.com/makersschedule.html http://www.paulgraham.com/makersschedule.html It's about the organization of time, but the basic insight applies to space/noise as well.