3 ms·
>The "second alternative" makes a lot of sense, but building a startup ecosystem is a difficult, long-term play involving a ton of variables. The "startup ecos
by baybal2 8y ago
>The "second alternative" makes a lot of sense, but building a startup ecosystem is a difficult, long-term play involving a ton of variables.
The "startup ecosystem" in the way SV denizens know it is terrible economy-wise. ROI - microscopic, human costs - humongous, employment impact - small, success rates - 0.2%.
Compare it, say, with a factory cluster: annual average ROI - ~8.75% (averaged over last 12 years, Chinese data) capital costs - sane, capital recovery - certain 60%-70%, success rate after 3 years - 60%-70%, employment impact - undisputedly apparent, human costs - you don't have to stake 5 years of your life on the latest fad.
People who advocate for copying that, advocate for copying a clearly failing model.
- bradstewart 8y agoWhat are those factories producing? You have to continue developing and building products to drive factory demand. Silicon Valley certainly didn't do everything (or maybe even most things) right, but to claim it has created no economic value is silly.
- djrogers 8y agoYou're conflating 'startup' with 'internet/app/social startup'. There are a lot of other types of businesses that start small and grow...
- nostrademons 8y agoBy the numbers, Silicon Valley does a lot better than those. Annual average ROI for Google over the last 10 years has been 21%; for Facebook, 86%; for AirBnB, almost 170%. Initial capital costs in each of these cases were nearly zero. Employment impact: tens of thousands of new millionaires created. The human costs of factories are not nil either. Beijing is a polluted wasteland where if you wipe your nose it comes away black. Silicon Valley is still dealing with the toxic wastes from the last generation of industrial powerhouses, the semiconductor companies that dumped toxic waste straight into the ground. I would far rather waste 5 years of my life on the latest software fad than have 30 years of my life shaved off by cancer. Don't romanticize the past. The average professional in Silicon Valley enjoys a standard of living much, much higher than the average factory worker in Shenzhen, or in Cleveland for that matter.
- ddebernardy 8y agoThere were a few pets.com along the way in SV. For every successful startup, there's a graveyard full of failed ones.
- nostrademons 8y agoSure, but the same applies to factories. I'd seriously question the OP's numbers of a certain 60-70% capital recovery rate for factories. Maybe in Shenzhen where you have tax policy, exchange rates, and labor costs all in your favor. All you have to do is drive through the Midwest to see examples of factories that didn't survive either, though.
- civilitty 8y agoIt's highly dependent on what kind of factory you're talking about. In medical/aerospace or other high tech manufacturing, even equipment that sees high utilization for 3-5 years can easily keep over 70% resale value if maintained properly. However, to suggest that 60-70% capital recovery is certain is silly. Maybe if you're manufacturing high precision parts for jet engines or missiles or something but then your capex is going to be in the tens of millions before you even get started and recovering the capital could take an indefinite amount of time.
- ddebernardy 8y agoTrue, but that's kind of comparing apples to oranges. It's not every day where people do capital intensive investments like those involved in factories, and they usually only do so when they're fairly certain they'll get a return. That contrasts with funding SV startups, which is probably comparable to throwing darts semi-blindfolded and hoping something sticks. Sometimes it does; it usually doesn't. Also, the factories in the midwest were doing fine until they didn't; but nothing lasts forever. The factories in Shenzhen will similarly go under sooner or later. 3d printing, for instance, might bring some manufacturing jobs back to the US and Europe and put Chinese factories under pressure.
- baybal2 8y ago