7 ms·
It's sort of an interesting tradeoff. On one hand, it's not desirable for most people to rent longterm, and owning property is an important way to store and gro
by vorpalhex 8y ago
It's sort of an interesting tradeoff. On one hand, it's not desirable for most people to rent longterm, and owning property is an important way to store and grow wealth. On the other hand, you don't want a few well financed investors sweeping in and buying all the available housing just as a kind of depository for funds.
Texas has an interesting setup. Property taxes are relatively high, but you can choose one house that you occupy to get a "Homestead exemption" that brings the taxes down quite a bit. This doesn't prevent you from owning say, a vacation home, but does make it quite a bit more expensive (which seems to be fair).
- TimJYoung 8y agoThis may be a topic for a different conversation, but I also remember reading during the aftermath of the 2008 recession that the high property taxes in Texas were also one of the things that helped keep the state relatively unscathed from all of the same issues with rampant speculation/price increases that plagued similar areas like Florida and Nevada.
- grasshopperpurp 8y ago>It's sort of an interesting tradeoff. On one hand, it's not desirable for most people to rent longterm, and owning property is an important way to store and grow wealth. On the other hand, you don't want a few well financed investors sweeping in and buying all the available housing just as a kind of depository for funds. Wouldn't it also disincentivize people from lobbying for zoning laws that are only beneficial to homeowners?
- rory096 8y ago>On one hand, it's not desirable for most people to rent longterm, and owning property is an important way to store and grow wealth. Neither of these are particularly true in an economic sense, except in that homeownership in growing, zoning-throttled areas is a ticket to the rent-seeking wealth transfer those supply restraints create. Homeownership is driven by this effect, federal subsidies, and general social norms encouraging it, but it creates labor market frictions by tying you to a place and ties up all your wealth in a single asset. https://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2016/02/67635.html https://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2016/02/67... https://www.economist.com/free-exchange/2010/04/21/rent-or-buy https://www.economist.com/free-exchange/2010/04/21/rent-or-b...
- vonmoltke 8y ago> [Home ownership] creates labor market frictions by tying you to a place I have never understood this line of reasoning. I agree that it increases friction, but there is a whole lot of friction that has nothing to do with renting vs. buying. Particularly friction in long-distance moves.
- burlesona 8y agoI can tell you first hand that I bought a condo right at the start of the recession thinking I was getting a great deal, and subsequently lost my job in a round of layoffs. The next couple years I would have been better off if I’d moved but it took me three years to stabilize my situation enough to do it, mostly because I couldn’t sell and I couldn’t rent for enough to cover the mortgage, and I couldn’t afford two housing payments. I don’t know how common that sort of situation is, but I can easily imagine a much milder version of it in today’s housing bubble, which is people who bought ten years ago and now feel that if they moved, yes they’d get some equity out, but not enough to move to a home that would be “as nice” in the destination they’re considering. For example suppose you work in software and bought a house in Dallas, but you’re getting all these great offers to move to SF...
- opencl 8y agoI don't understand your second example at all. If you own a house during a bubble it seems like the ideal time to move. Sell your house to get the equity, move to a rental, then buy a house after the bubble pops.
- trustno1 8y agoUntil everyone who bought during the bubble tries to get out at the same time. This is what we're on the cusp of now -- house sales are finally starting to fall.
- claydavisss 8y agoOr leave a particular metro. Or leave California. If you are open to moving when you have to, most real estate problems are non-issues. Once you limit yourself to a hard requirement of living in a particular metro or state, you are subject to the market. Everyone reading this can afford a home somewhere decent in the US, but you have to be willing to move. How many people reading this in the Bay Area would even consider moving to Gilroy or Benicia? Not many I presume.
- maxxxxx 8y agoI like the way Texas does it. We should encourage ownership of a modest home as residence and subsidize that but multiple home ownership should be made expensive.
- Rapzid 8y agoAre you talking about the homestead exemption? That's pretty small isn't it?
- octorian 8y agoIt actually varies a lot by state. In Florida, where I used to live, it was $25-50k lopped off the value of the house before taxes were assessed. Proportional to house prices, this was a lot. In California, where I live now, its only $7k. Proportional to house prices here, it barely qualifies as lost pocket change that fell out of your pants and is rattling around the washing machine. Of course those laws sometimes include other provisions, such as tax cap portability when you move (sometimes only for old/disabled/etc, depending on the state). The limits on tax rate increase might sometimes also be tied to this.
- maxxxxx 8y agoI honestly don't know the details. I just think the idea is right. Homeownership by individuals is desirable but it's not desirable if big companies with deep pockets buy up all properties. We should have policies that put the home buyer with an average salary at an advantage over the big guys.
- api 8y agoI'm fond these days of pointing out that Texas is far more liberal than California because in Texas a working class family can afford a place to live. California's housing policies are the shame of the state (and the nation) and are destroying the state's culture. They will ultimately destroy its economy by driving away the next generation of creative people and entrepreneurs.