4 ms·
Here is my experience with SWIFT for International payments: 1. Emitter pays around 35-50 USD to send you the money. 2. It takes from 5 to 10 days depending o
by csomar 8y ago
Here is my experience with SWIFT for International payments:
1. Emitter pays around 35-50 USD to send you the money.
2. It takes from 5 to 10 days depending on (traffic?).
3. No clue where your payment is until it hit your account. Basically there is no visibility (unlike the blockchain where you can see in real time if the payment is made even though it is not confirmed).
4. Your bank take a cut. Usually it is another 10-20 USD.
And here is the worst part. In some countries (maybe many, most?) there is an obligatory FX circle even if you hold USD accounts.
1. You receive the amount in USD.
2. Bank convert USD to Local Currency.
3. Bank convert Local Currency to USD.
4. USD deposited in your local bank account.
And here is the funny part: The bank make sure it fucks you really well on the FX fees. Around 5-7% both ways. So ends up over 10% of the total amount + the fixed fees.
Welcome to reality.
- Nursie 8y agoThat doesn't sound like the sort of thing Ripple is going to fix - as it's aimed at being an inter-bank settlement layer, those banks would still get to play those games. As a consumer, sending money to other people where I am is free and effectively instant. Sending within the EU is heading this way too thanks to SEPA.
- csomar 8y agoNot really. If two exchanges support the Ripple platform, you can move USD without friction. If businesses started supporting Ripple, then you can transact with them too. You don't need to be a bank or an institution to start using Ripple. You can do so at Gatehub.
- Nursie 8y ago> You don't need to be a bank or an institution to start using Ripple. Sure, but I'm not going to stop transacting using my bank or my national currency any time soon, for a huge variety of reasons. Ripple is angling to be an inter-bank service (see the first sentence in this thread), which doesn't solve the problem of banks playing exchange-rate shenanigans.
- SimbaOnSteroids 8y agoIt lowers the barrier to entry for remittance competitors significantly. Had planned to build a proof of concept for a hackathon back in march but ran into issues with nobody on the team having foreign bank accounts that we could pair with crypto exchanges. We planned to use Bitstamp -> Bitso to change USD to MXN via moving XRP between the exchanges. All the API documentation is there to make it happen but unfortunately we couldn't open real accounts and one or both of the exchanges didn't have a sandbox API. However the cost to make a transfer would effectively be less than 1% and take roughly a day, which is essentially the time it takes to deposit money from a crypto exchange to a bank account.
- JumpCrisscross 8y ago> you can move USD without friction You can already move U.S. dollars frictionlessly: with instantaneous, irrevocable and pennies-to-a-dollar Fedwires. SWIFT is more useful for non-dollar settlement, or between banks without dollar clearing privileges.
- SimbaOnSteroids 8y agoIt's not really about being settlement layer as much as a way to crowd source vostro/nostro accounts. At least that's how I interpret what xRapid's page[0]. https://ripple.com/solutions/source-liquidity/ https://ripple.com/solutions/source-liquidity/
- seanmcdirmid 8y agoI’ve done many FX wire transfers in China, and they’ll transfer USD directly if you have it. If not, they convert to USD first, well, since it is from RMB you need lots of documentation to do that anyways. If you receive USD, it stays as USD until you want to change it tonight RMB. They actually just can’t auto convert it either way since the RMB is not fully convertible. Same is true for CHF, Euro, any other fully convertible currency.
- throwaway9d0291 8y agoHere's mine: 1. Bank charges ~5 USD 2. It happens same day 3. The receiving bank charges nothing I'm typically transferring between US, CH and GB accounts. Occasionally DE. This has been the case for all of them. When I want to avoid FX fees/spread I just use Revolut as an intermediary, which adds about a day and no fees. SWIFT isn't bad, bad banks are bad. Make sure to use decent banks and you'll be fine.