4 ms·
1. "not everybody needs a public IP address": sure, and there is no need for more than 6 computers on the entire world, ever. In my opinion, stalling the transi
by BerislavLopac 16y ago
1. "not everybody needs a public IP address": sure, and there is no need for more than 6 computers on the entire world, ever. In my opinion, stalling the transition hurts innovation; while it's true that as the things are at present public addresses are not an imperative, new technologies like P2P, which would greatly benefit from public addresses, open a whole new realm of possibilities.
2. Again correct, assuming that there is no cheaper alternative to the "addresses market". But it exists, and is (mostly) free. Once the providers realize that it's less expensive (longterm) to switch to IPv6 than to keep buying new addresses, they'll do it, even such a solution might prolong things even more.
In general, most of "solutions" to the IPv4 crisis represent a sizable effort, which will only increase as the addresses become more scarce; and the sum of it will be much larger than the effort of simply switching to v6. We'll see how it will turn out though.
- CrLf 16y agoStalling the transition hurts innovation, yes, and avoiding an address market would be good too. But this is ignoring the human problem, which was my original point. From a technological standpoint it would be nice to switch, but you have to convince everyone to switch, which isn't easy because: Most OSes deployed today either don't support IPv6 or the support is problematic. Remember that most of the world still uses Windows XP and are in no hurry to change. Most applications don't support IPv6. Many of those could be easily changed but the people responsible have better things to do, especially in the enterprise space (which most people here seem to ignore, always thinking that the consumer Internet is the only thing in existence). IPv4 is elegant in its simplicity, whereas IPv6 is complex and different for the sake of being different in some cases. This means extra cost to switch internal networks, and without switching internal networks there's no pressure to port most applications. Network administrators know IPv4 well, what works and what doesn't, where the faults are. Switching to IPv6 means extensive training which adds to the cost. Given that right now people that actually have a working knowledge of IPv6 are few and far between and seem to be concentrated in ISPs, this will be hard to change. Despite the benefits of everyone having public addresses, there are also security downsides, and these outweight the benefits in most people's eyes. So, the main problem is legacy. IPv6 benefits are irrelevant when it doesn't interoperate seamlessly with IPv4. Again, IPv6 adoption is a human problem, just like convincing people to abandon IE6 is.
- loup-vaillant 16y ago> Despite the benefits of everyone having public addresses, there are also security downsides, No there isn't. Not a single one. Just replace your old NAT by a clean firewall, and you're set.
- Dylan16807 16y agoLetting people see each individual device, even firewalled, is a security downside.
- loup-vaillant 16y agoI don't believe you. I'm willing to listen though. Do you have a link to a detailed, technical explanation of this?
- Dylan16807 16y agoI need a reference that exposing more information about systems that are nearly guaranteed to have security flaws is bad? I'll give you a simple scenario and then go look for something to make you happy. I have a computer running services A and B and several computers running service B. Service A exposes information about the computer's configuration that helps attack service B, but only if the attacker can figure out which one. Edit: I haven't really been able to find a comparison between firewalling and firewalling+NAT, just comparisons between nothing and NAT.
- loup-vaillant 16y agoBy the way, I wasn't completely explicit. I supposed that in both cases all incoming ports are closed, except for the ones you explicitly open. That way, the only difference between the NAT and the firewall is the address translation. My scenario is narrow, but I expect it to be a common one: IPv6 internet boxes will likely include such a firewall by default.
- 16y ago