2 ms·
Isn't it just an outworking of monism - the brain is a machine, a part of that machine must be responsible for a particular function. People who injure specifi
by pbhjpbhj 8y ago
Isn't it just an outworking of monism - the brain is a machine, a part of that machine must be responsible for a particular function.
People who injure specific regions lose specific abilities. Magnetic stimulation of particular regions leads to different feelings, etc..
It doesn't seem that misguided as a first approximation?
- YeGoblynQueenne 8y agoThe problem is with collecting evidence for what you take to be the truth in the first place. It's called confirmation bias and it has nothing to do with methodology, instruments, or techniques. What goes wrong is in the space between the experiment and the interpretation of the experiment: if you set out to prove something you already hold to be the truth, you're very likely to "prove" it regardless of what your data, or your results, actually say. It might sound strange, but the right way to conduct a study is not to start with a hypothesis and gather evidence to support it. Instead, what you're supposed to do (but nobody ever does) is to first collect some observations, then come up with an hypothesis to explain them, then collect more, new evidence and test whether this new evidence supports the hypothesis. Otherwise, you risk collecting only the evidence that supports your hypothesis- or interpreting it in a way that supports it. Not that doing things "the right way" keeps you safe, either. In practice, everyone will have preconceptions and already-formed ideas about what is true and what is not and no amount of good practice will completely protect you from drawing the conclusions you prefer from whatever data you collect. So, when you see a study that starts out with the premise that "this man is fearless" concluding that "this man's brain can feel no fear" it should ring all the alarm bells and raise all the red flags. Especially so if the study (or at least the article reporting it) stresses the subject's fearlessness continuously. In short, this study seems to have found exactly what the researchers expected to find. That's as bad as it gets.