4 ms·
The disaster is going to be when/as every state adopts unique privacy legislation. It's going to be necessary for the US Congress to override these state-based
by adventured 8y ago
The disaster is going to be when/as every state adopts unique privacy legislation.
It's going to be necessary for the US Congress to override these state-based rules using the Commerce Clause, FCC, and FTC, to takeover responsibility for legislating all digital privacy matters on the basis of its impact on interstate commerce and the FCC's overarching control of nearly anything involving electronic communication.
It won't be practical or reasonable to track users across every state and their movements at all times. People that happen to cross a state line and the need to somehow magically identify their location of origin, and all the blah blah shit that goes with that nightmare. California (or any given state) will probably claim their law applies to California residents at all times, and states will claim their laws apply if you're in their state at any point, enter the conflicting nightmare.
Here's also where GDPR's global enforcement proponents should get pretty excited: being consistent with that premise, now all of the EU has to comply with all privacy laws of all 50 US states, to the extent that they have users from the states. So EU companies will have to implement and maintain dozens of privacy schemes to fit all of the US states (as they each roll out unique privacy legislation). That glorious global enforcement. The world must now adopt all US policies. That's how it works according to GDPR proponents, right?
Instead of the Web of insanity that that 50 state disaster will spin, the Feds will ideally smother all state attempts at establishing their own privacy frameworks, establish Federal regulations on the matter and overrule the states aggressively.
- casefields 8y agoThat's how car emissions are and the world isn't collapsing. Auto manufacturers know if they want access to California they're going to have to deal with the toughest pollution regulations.