5 ms·
Having a single monetary policy for countries as different as Spain and Germany, with no real shared fiscal policy, is a direct contributor to this malaise. If
by hn_throwaway_99 8y ago
Having a single monetary policy for countries as different as Spain and Germany, with no real shared fiscal policy, is a direct contributor to this malaise.
If they had separate currencies, Spain could inflate away a lot of their debt. This would cause a bunch of pain for your average Spaniard, but it would also mean that Spain's currency devaluation could drastically help its exports (and of course one of Southern Europe's most valuable "exports" is tourism). A direct consequence of being on the Euro is exactly what you point out: labor isn't really cheap enough to be competitive.
- kebman 8y agoHm a single currency, seems to me, more and more to be a bad thing, only tailored for expansionist world corporations, since they are the only ones who benefit from it, really. A single currency has been sold as this good, because it does away with local money changers. However it also does away with local sovereignty, and in actual fact it does away with business diversity. When you put two and two together, you quickly see who the EU is actually working for, and it's not the small guy or the local store. All that stuff is a sham in order to cater to large multinational corporations to make it easier for them to collect and take over. The only things left over are then niche stores, while everything else turns Corporate Gray – in a way that is just all too reminiscent of Communist Gray.
- thefounder 8y agoWhy don't the US states use different currencies to be more competitive? Is there a communist/corporative conspiracy?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- sgt101 8y agoUS states enjoy fiscal as well as monetary union. The tax take in New York is used to balance monetary transfers from Tennessee, this is not the case between Greece Italy Spain and Germany.
- thefounder 8y agoFiscal union is no there yet but I think is the fist thing on the EU economic agenda. Before the immigration issue the fiscal union and a EU finance minister were the main subjects. Macron supported this even during his campaign.
- sgt101 8y agoIt is utterly essential. There must be substantial transfers from the German-Dutch-Belgian area to the South. I highly doubt that this will happen, but if it does then the Euro is saved as is the European project. But, I highly doubt it'll happen. Macron and France can vote for it as much as they like...
- gumby 8y agoBut inflating away the debt simply defers or masks the underlying problems. The use of a consistent currency makes it easier to export your labor or goods, and makes it easier (practically and politically) for other countries to provide aid.
- raverbashing 8y agoThe single monetary policy hasn't prevented most countries from having growth. The solution is price deflation, which is not as "good" (for variable amounts of good) as inflating your currency, but it works. Tourism seems to be pretty price inelastic to be honest (as seen by neverending lines and crowds). > labor isn't really cheap enough to be competitive Minimum wage in Spain is lower than in other https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/3/3f/European_countries_by_hourly_minimum_wage.jpg/1200px-European_countries_by_hourly_minimum_wage.jpg https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/3/3f/Eu... And this applies even for higher pay functions, it is usually lower than even Germany. I'd attribute their lack of growth more than internal culture (management culture, investor culture, etc), lack of investment and other factors.
- sgt101 8y ago>The single monetary policy hasn't prevented most countries from having growth. Many of these are the counties that are beneficiaries of the policy. Ireland is a more reasonable counter- similar problems to Spain, but a good recovery.
- tpm 8y agoBut Spanish tourism industry does not need currency devaluation, it is currently highest it has ever been, measured by number of visitors, and probably by earnings too. Labor is cheap enough, there are issues with labor law and other structural problems though.
- pif 8y ago> If they had separate currencies, Spain could inflate away a lot of their debt. Which is why Euro is good for Southern European countries: it forces them to concentrate on productivity rather than economic alchemy. Spanish labor got too expensive? You don't need a government to inflate your currency, you just start lowering your rates. My fellow Italian workers cannot find a job? Stop talking about "articolo 18", stop looking for assured indefinite term contracts, accept the reality! Enterprises know ups and downs: when thing go well, they'll be happy to pay you good money for your services, but when hell breaks loose your salary will be a burden for them. Either accept that employment contracts can be terminated before your retreat, or keep up the good work... uh, keep up the work... just keep up!
- batteryhorse 8y agoThe Euro has caused their debt to appreciate, so now they owe more money in real terms because the currency doubled in value. Meanwhile, Germany is able to export their goods without any currency risk. And now you have another layer of bureaucracy. The real issue is that when they created the Euro, they failed to consolidate the debt of all the nations. It's only a matter of time before the whole thing collapses.
- apexalpha 8y ago>The real issue is that when they created the Euro, they failed to consolidate the debt of all the nations. No one failed, we just didn't want to (for reasons very obvious now, in hindsight). Also, the countries (Spain, Greece, Portugal...) accumulated most of the debt _after_ they got the Euro precisely because the Euro enabled them to do so.
- pif 8y ago> No one failed, we just didn't want to (for reasons very obvious now, in hindsight). Would you mind explaining a bit more, please?
- krageon 8y agoThe Euro took away the single most painful thing still plaguing travel between EU countries. These days an EU citizen can up and leave to a different EU country with very little friction (aside from the language in some places), which was the idea. That goal was achieved. It is unrealistic to expect that countries will somehow not be able to solve their financial issues just because they lost one tool. That's an excuse, not a reason.
- apexalpha 8y agoWouldn't this be the same for the US with states like California, Washington, NY, Texas vs small, rural inland states?
- redcalx 8y agoOr any large country, e.g. China, Russia, India, Indonesia?