4 ms·
>> It seems this discussion comes up fairly often, and the solution is almost always some variation of "make driving too expensive and/or too inconvenient, to f
by YeGoblynQueenne 8y ago
>> It seems this discussion comes up fairly often, and the solution is almost
always some variation of "make driving too expensive and/or too inconvenient,
to force people to use public transit".
It's more like the other way around: the idea is to make public transport cheap
and efficient enough that it's a reasonable alternative to driving everywhere.
>> For example I live in a very public transit friendly city, but the buses are
un-ridable most of the time due to the rampant homeless issue(and all that
comes with a large homeless population) while the light rail is usually better
about being a semi-safe, semi-clean environment, that just happens to be so
overloaded between between 7am-9am, and 3pm-6pm, that there is almost any
price I'd pay to avoid it.
I live in a small town on the South coast of England, which just happens to
have one of the largest populations of homeless people, nationally. It also
has very good public transport, namely, buses, that are always full. I've
never seen a homeless person using a bus as crashing space, or causing trouble
of any sort. I can't say I ever particularly noticed homeless people on a bus.
If homeless people on buses are a problem where you live, that has nothing to
do with public transport in general.
Anyway, I think everyone gets the public transport they deserve. If everyone
wants to go around by car, then we won't have good public transport- because
why would we?
- calohorn 8y ago>> If homeless people on buses are a problem where you live, that has nothing to do with public transport in general. When you hear of people being aggressive, high, inconsiderate, or here in Portland two people had their throats slit on the light rail recently near my house, it makes the public not feel comfortable using the public transportation. Since it's called public transportation and these things effect the public and the transportation, it actually has a lot to do with the public transportation.
- rorykoehler 8y agoIt has nothing to do with public transportation. Wrong level of abstraction. It has to do with the fact the US is turning into a inequality dystopia.
- grasshopperpurp 8y agoThis is exactly right. It's the price people pay for living in a place that doesn't care about its people.
- sethrin 8y agoPeople can get their throats slit in public, anywhere which is public. There is nothing to suggest that the Portland light rail is any more dangerous than walking the streets, and to be honest, as someone who uses the MAX almost exclusively, the implication is somewhat offensive.
- YeGoblynQueenne 8y agoPublic transport in Portland, is not "public transport in general". It's public transport in Portland.
- maxsilver 8y ago> It's more like the other way around: the idea is to make public transport cheap and efficient enough that it's a reasonable alternative to driving everywhere. That would be nice, but that's not the general opinion of urbanists in the US. They (generalizing) really do believe as the parent describes, to "make driving too expensive and/or too inconvenient, to force people to use public transit", and they truly believe this will magically fix public transit across the nation. It's the urbanist version of "the beatings will continue until morale improves". They'll often lie about it, saying "we don't hate them, we just want them to pay their fair share", or "to remove subsidies". But mostly, they just really hate cars. Especially electric ones (since they largely solve most of the problems of cars, while still being cars). Just browse the top 20 posts of /r/urbanplanning on any given day to see this in action
- jacques_chester 8y ago> since they largely solve most of the problems of cars, while still being cars They solve air pollution and some of noise pollution. But they don't magically cause people to carpool. And even if they did, net passenger density for buses is higher, rail substantially higher again. An NYC subway R160 carriage can, in the space of about 4-5 car lengths, carry about 250 people, meaning those trains move a thousand or more people in the distance from a T-intersection to the back of a cul-de-sac. Cars are expensive. It's just that you don't pay for it at the car.
- DrScump 8y agoThey solve air pollution They displace air pollution to wherever the generation plant is, except for rare areas served by 100% nuclear/hydroelectric/solar/geothermal.
- kruczek 8y agoNote however that it is easier to limit and monitor air pollution generated by relatively few generation plants, than by hundreds of thousands of individual cars.
- 8y ago
- epage 8y ago> It's more like the other way around: the idea is to make public transport cheap and efficient enough that it's a reasonable alternative to driving everywhere. In Austin, they took the perspective "if we won't build it, they won't come". After the unwanted growth happened, it sure feels like the sentiment is "if we don't build it, they won't drive." There are fundamental problems with the driving infrastructure and instead of addressing it, they patch over it with toll roads, some planned or are only a quarter mile long, to allow "those who care (can afford)" through. They ignore major issues, like if one of the major bridges needs work or goes out, the city will be devastated. When the limited public transport options do come up, they've seemed to be forward looking projects which is fine except they don't do anything about all of the other problems. > I live in a small town on the South coast of England, which just happens to have one of the largest populations of homeless people, nationally. It also has very good public transport, namely, buses, that are always full. I've never seen a homeless person using a bus as crashing space, or causing trouble of any sort. My guess is that if this isn't due to better services for the homeless, then the main factor is probably the local climate.
- hvidgaard 8y agoI agree 100%. Where I live they "restructured" the bus routes, which was a different word for "we're trying to save money". The result was that we went from 4 buses every hour, to 2 during the day and from 2 to 1 in the evening. I used to take the bus when I had to go to the city, but the waiting times have more than doubled and I'll just take the car instead. It's more expensive, but there is always parking and it's significantly faster now. I vastly prefer to take the bus, so I don't have to worry much if I grab a beer or 2, but I'm not waiting hours to catch the bus.
- woolvalley 8y agoIt's probably because you have the NHS and socialized medicine, which would probably house the mentally ill homeless in some sort of mental hospital? I'm guessing the OP post lives in SF or maybe LA, where the mental hospitals were dismantled because of scandals in the 70s or 80s. There are 2 kinds of homeless, normal people down on their luck, and people who need psychiatric or addiction care. The normal people go use the bathroom in an alleyway or a bush somewhere, the ones off their rocker piss themselves while sleeping on the train. There are far more 'normal' homeless vs. mental homeless, and it's the mental homeless that cause the problems.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- YeGoblynQueenne 8y ago>> It's probably because you have the NHS and socialized medicine, which would probably house the mentally ill homeless in some sort of mental hospital? Unfortunately not. Mental illness is rampant among the homeless population. And, to be honest, even the most "normal" people will develop mental illness once forced to live on the streets for long enough. Generally regarding the NHS and mental health, the subject is very controversial. Resources are continuously slashed and the care available is not adequate, in many parts of the country.
- DrScump 8y agoIf homeless people on buses are a problem where you live, that has nothing to do with public transport in general It has everything to do with public transportation policy. Example: VTA (Santa Clara County). They started allowing "homeless" to just hang out on a given long route bus all day, recirculating directions, so they could claim higher ridership. Of course, the real-world effect is that those people who would have used buses for legitimate transportation were displaced, and a death spiral of constantly falling legitimate ridership continues. VTA's explanations (paraphrased): 2005-2008: "oh, so many more people are employed, they can afford to drive" (or, more realistic, they need prompt, reliable transportation). 2009-2012: "oh, so many people are out if work, they don't need buses to get to work" 2013+: GO TO 2005
- YeGoblynQueenne 8y ago>> It has everything to do with public transportation policy. Local transportation policy, maybe, but that is not "public transport in general", i.e. the concept of public transport in the abstract, as opposed to its implementation in specific situations. To put it bluntly, Santa Clara County is not the world.
- rmc 8y agoI think the USA has (a) much more homeless people and (b) much less buses than random places in the UK. (I remember reading a stat from ~5 or 10 years ago that San Francisco had more homeless people than England).
- bluGill 8y agoSan Francisco probably does have more homeless than England, but that is a likely a case of lieing with statistics. Which is to say there are external factors that make homeless likely to migrate to San Francisco meaning you will find other places "near" San Francisco with much less homeless.
- rmc 8y agoYes, I'm sure the social welfare system in San Francisco is better than England.
- bluGill 8y agoIt is better than the options elsewhere in the US. Note that temperatures above freezing all winter is already a significant improvement. There are very cold states that have a great social welfare system, but weather makes them undesirable.