3 ms·
You've had sizeable replies and I've yet to read them, so forgive if I'm reiterating something here. But as for 1): IPs are distinctly /not/ PII (AKA: PD). The
by dijit 8y ago
You've had sizeable replies and I've yet to read them, so forgive if I'm reiterating something here.
But as for 1):
IPs are distinctly /not/ PII (AKA: PD). They're identified /by name/ in the regulation, unless you sell that info. Anyone who brings this up as a topic has not actually read the regulations.. or they have and are trying to create uncertainty for some objective.
It sounds like you've done enough of reading the regulation to actually know this, it's part of your job and you've spoken to legal experts (as I have).
- jiveturkey 8y ago> IPs are distinctly /not/ PII. They're identified /by name/ in the regulation. Anyone who brings this up as a topic has not actually read the regulations.. or they have and are trying to create uncertainty for some objective. Have you yourself read the regulation? You are wrong. The regulation makes a single reference (by name) to IP addresses. In recital 30. In that recital, it specifically declares IP address to be PD (GDPR doesn't use the term PII at all). Not to confuse the matter, but if you stopped there, and decided IP addresses were PD, you would have stopped short. It requires deeper analysis. Here are two good ones: https://gdpr-info.eu/issues/personal-data/ https://gdpr-info.eu/issues/personal-data/ https://www.whitecase.com/publications/alert/court-confirms-ip-addresses-are-personal-data-some-cases https://www.whitecase.com/publications/alert/court-confirms-... The soundbite-sized answer is: it depends.
- dijit 8y agoSorry, was going on the case of "if you're not an ISP" IP, when tied to other data becomes the scope of personal data. However, removing the other data renders it no longer personal data. This firmly puts it in the "it's not personal data" camp. Since it's the other data that is personally identifiable that gives it context. It's only relevant for ISPs really, but really good job on proving my "creating confusion for no reason" point. In the context of online accounts (in video games, where I work) it can't be used to identify real world people because we don't ever link to a real world identity. In cases where you log details about people individually (as in- a bank) you just don't log user details beside access logs and you're set. IP on it's own is not personally identifiable, and is out of scope for GDPR.
- pbecotte 8y agoI have taken the same stance. Have had lawyers tell me that I am wrong. Have had other lawyers telle the opposite. -shrug- when it specifically lists IP address as an example of PD in one section, the fact that another says things are only PD if you can identify a person doesn't NECESSARILY over rule that.
- mikekchar 8y agoI think a lot of this is a red herring. If you are gathering the IP address under the contract lawful basis, then it doesn't matter if it's personally identifying or not. Where it get's tricky is when you are not gathering the IP address under contract lawful basis. The tricky thing about GDPR is choosing the correct lawful basis. I think people reach for the legitimate interest card too quickly because they see it as a "get out of jail free" card. But then it ends up complicating things enormously -- especially since legitimate interest can be objected to. I've seen people agonising in public about what to do because the personally identifying information is necessary to provide the service they are offering. If you're in the situation where if someone objects to the use of their data, then it breaks the whole service -- well you're in contract lawful basis territory. IP addresses are potentially complicated, though. I'm not sure what's supposed to happen when you receive personally identifying information from someone that you don't have a contract with. The law does seem to be vague on what constitutes a "contract", because in some cases it seems to imply something different than what contract law says (i.e. if there is no consideration, it seems I can still use contract lawful basis). In this situation, if I have a P2P network and I need your IP address to fulfil my side of the protocol, then I should be able to use it under contract basis. However, I'm unclear about the actual legality of it -- especially when the information is sent to you by an intermediate node. To me, that's what needs to be cleared up. I expect it will be over a period of time. I don't think the law was written with that kind of stuff in mind. It's kind of interesting, though. I imagine it is a violation of the GDPR to track what individuals are downloading in bittorrent without giving them a legitimate interest notice, though (and allowing them to object! and be forgotten!). It will be interesting to see if anybody complains about that kind of thing.
- courtneycouch0 8y ago