6 ms·
AI Can Detect Illnesses in Human Breath
- beebmam 8y agoI'm getting strong Theranos vibes from this.
- felipemnoa 8y agoThat was my first thought too. We'll be branded heretics, unfortunately.
- matte_black 8y agoJust know you are not alone.
- tomhoward 8y agoLike dismissing a brand new product prototype as being unlikely to be a big success, this is a very low-value comment, in that it can't be tested in the short term, and the penalty for being wrong in the long term is zero. So you can comfortably make this sneer about every new medical innovation you hear about, losing nothing for being wrong but crediting yourself with intuitive powers if you're right, which you likely will be some day, the more so the more you repeat the move. That said, for every scandal like Theranos, the likelihood of another one just like it diminishes (if regulators and investors are acting effectively and rationally), so it might be a while before your prediction comes up. Let's hope so!
- benatkin 8y agoDoes anyone know if TSA gate agents can see tumors, and if they've ever told anyone? Like, say, a golf-ball sized tumor in the neck? Would they have to be medically trained? Do they avoid or encourage hiring former radiologists? There was an interesting story of a doctor who noticed cancer while watching TV and passed the word on. https://abcnews.go.com/GMA/Wellness/woman-appeared-hgtv-finds-cancer-doctor-watching-spots/story?id=55640226 https://abcnews.go.com/GMA/Wellness/woman-appeared-hgtv-find...
- semi-extrinsic 8y agoNope, millimeter wave scanners barely penetrate the upper skin layers, and I don't think they have the contrast required to differentiate even a skin tumor from normal skin.
- tjohns 8y agoThere's no human operators for the body scanners anymore, due to privacy concerns. The images are analyzed by computer, and any anomalies are highlighted on a cartoon diagram for extra attention during the pat down. Also, if someone had a golf-ball sized growth on the outside of their body, I'm sure the person is already aware of it. (The body scanners can't see inside the body.)
- paranoidrobot 8y ago> There was an interesting story of a doctor who noticed cancer while watching TV and passed the word on. It's not hugely frequent, I don't think, but it's not unheard of for this kind of thing to happen. Most of the family are in the industry, and just watching TV or whatever you'll occasionally hear a comment about noticing a tremor or slight droop in someone's face that could be indicative of whatever.
- randop 8y agoThis is interesting to see being used in real world. Still wondering what types of cancer it can detect. Maybe throat cancer, who knows.
- jcims 8y agoI read a few anecdotes that said that nurses who were familiar with cancer patients would subconsciously identify an odor that was associated with them. Then they would smell it in the wild and be struck with a sudden an anxiety about whether or not they should tell the person to get checked, given the odd nature of the clue.
- ed312 8y agoIs this possibly related to the phenomenon of dogs knowing someone is sick?
- joe24pack 8y agoThat was my first thought too.
- googlemike 8y agoSensitivity and specificity scores or go home.
- vedtopkar 8y agoAbsolutely. Until then this is just marketing.
- colordrops 8y agoEven if the false positives were high, couldn't it be used as a first pass to indicate more accurate testing?
- darawk 8y agoSure, but publish the numbers so we can decide for ourselves.
- semi-extrinsic 8y agoThey have numbers in the paper[0] linked in TFA. They trained on 29 samples and tested on 12 samples. On those samples, all techniques (NN, SVM, CNN) all had 100% true positive rates. The CNNs did best on false positives, giving on average 2-3 per sample. Also, it is very important to note: they are comparing a CNN analysing a GC-MS[1] sample to a human expert analysing a GC-MS sample, which is basically a 1D plot of intensities of chemicals. This is not a comparison to a human smelling someone's breath. Also, as far as I can see, they never compare to a GC-MS run with selective ion monitoring (SIM), which would be a lot faster for the human to analyse. [0] (ResearchGate link, sorry): https://www.researchgate.net/publication/324921031_Convolutional_neural_networks_for_automated_targeted_analysis_of_raw_gas_chromatography-mass_spectrometry_data https://www.researchgate.net/publication/324921031_Convoluti... [1] A gas-chromatograph mass spectrometer is a device which samples a gas and detects what chemical species are present. It's what they do at airports when they swipe that piece of fabric on your luggage and put it in a machine (GC-MS) to look for explosives. It's a nice tool, used extensively in labs worldwide, but expensive (usually a couple hundred thousand USD, depending on specifications).
- jadeddrag 8y agoAre there any estimates about releasing this technology for general use? Or does the (US) FDA insist on slowing down this type of diagnostic technology a few decades, or can we expect to see these as kiosks in every clinic over the next few months?
- lquist 8y agoIt will be more than a few months, but my understanding is that the FDA is now one of the fastest agencies to give approval in the world. See: https://www.propublica.org/article/fda-repays-industry-by-rushing-risky-drugs-to-market https://www.propublica.org/article/fda-repays-industry-by-ru...
- rabbitonrails 8y agoThe new Theranos Blockchain is already manufacturing diagnostic units.
- keithnz 8y agoit's research.... in england. The orginal paper is here http://andrea.soltoggio.net/data/papers/skaryszEtAl-CNN-GC-MS-IJCNN2018.pdf http://andrea.soltoggio.net/data/papers/skaryszEtAl-CNN-GC-M... at the moment they are essentially saying it's a promising tech that helps experts and cuts down on their errors. It helps with one part of the analysis. Looks like it is a long way from anything general use, though it's on the path towards that.
- Omnus 8y agoYou don't seem to understand the actual problems with screening. Try learning about the field before implying the FDA isn't doing their job: https://www.bmj.com/content/352/bmj.h6080 https://www.bmj.com/content/352/bmj.h6080
- anjc 8y ago>“Computers equipped with this technology only take minutes to autonomously analyze a breath sample that previously took hours by a human expert” The AI is impressive, but I'm equally impressed that a human can sniff someone's breath for a few hours and diagnose cancer. Amazing.
- Covzire 8y ago"Didn't my receptionist tell you not to eat and drink only water for 24 hours?"
- nashashmi 8y agoI have suffered with severe nasal allergies as a kid. And had a hard time smelling anything because my nose was stuffed. I realized that I developed a sense of "smell" in my hand. I could actually feel the air. And tell what it smells like. For those who can't believe it, smells have a pH, humidity, heat capacity, temperature, density, and pressure to them. So if you can train your skin to be sensitive and concentrate on those things you can feel smells. It was not long till I realized that people give off a certain odor. And those odors are often related to the germs on their body. And the food they ate. Sometimes I could even tell if the person was sick. I never developed a method of detecting illnesses simply by waving my hand on the person unless I was acutely familiar with the sickness, but if we can develop machines to detect "smell" (a fact I did not know) then we can definitely detect machines to scan people as they walk through a door and tell what germs they carry. Of course my dream powers are to tell what antigerm ointment each person should use.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- doggo_ 8y agoOdd how the baseline mentioned in the article is better then human average. Why wouldn't the baseline be dogs, or existing non-breath tests?
- stevenwoo 8y agoFrom what I can tell, dogs worked well in the laboratory, but it did not work well in the field. In the lab they usually had 1/5 or so positive samples, but in the field, it was a much lower positive rate depending upon cancer and the dog handler would not be able to give positive reinforcement immediately in the field, also different dogs have different success rates. https://www.livescience.com/61234-how-dogs-smell-cancer.html https://www.livescience.com/61234-how-dogs-smell-cancer.html
- asafira 8y agovery cool! I wonder if they could sprinkle in some fake examples for the dogs so that they could give positive reinforcement more often.
- andrewortman 8y agoMarketing
- kondro 8y agoI saw some studies recently stating that humans' sense of smell is actually as good as dogs.
- semi-extrinsic 8y agoThe baseline is not humans smelling breath, it's humans looking at a graph.
- Tycho 8y agoI was thinking how things like this could revolutionize healthcare by reducing the need for doctors, who we never have enough of. But you know the saying, AI is always the thing we can't do yet? Meaning the goalposts shift, and stuff that was previously considered a goal of AI research is now just boring automation, and so AI is still a distant dream. Well it occurs to me that there is something similar with healthcare: healthcare is whatever is still expensive to provide. Regardless of how many life-saving treatments and inventions are adopted, there will still be some things that only hospital/clinic staff can help you with. And so we will always have the same bottleneck and people will always complain about access to healthcare, using this bottleneck as their barometer.
- frio 8y agoI don't think we're ever going to end up replacing doctors, but in the same way that tech accelerates other industries, AI should accelerate healthcare. Tying "expert machine" to "machine learning" could massively improve the pace at which Emergency Departments can triage patients, for instance, or provide doctors another useful input tool when diagnosing tricky conditions.
- _emacsomancer_ 8y agoPerhaps replacing some of the low-end GPs who essentially just walk through a decision tree.
- throwaway5752 8y agoWe could make an AI to do the hellish coding and insurer reimbursement interactions, to free them up to do medicine. Most "low-end GPs" are still extremely impressive intellects.
- glenstein 8y ago>and stuff that was previously considered a goal of AI research is now just boring automation, and so AI is still a distant dream. I think that's exactly right, which is what makes it particularly amusing to look back at Hubert Dreyfuses' apocalyptic declarations that computers can't do things that resemble human-like judgment. One of those things was supposedly chess, which required "insight", which computers can't have. But once computers got better at it than humans, everyone kind of forgot about it and pointed at new examples.
- thomasfedb 8y agoWorth pointing out that humans can also smell disease in human breath - broad odours point to disease of particular organs (liver, kidney) and also to some specific diseases (diabetes).
- ambicapter 8y agoIs this why old people smell old?
- thomasfedb 8y agoNo, that smell is a result of body odor change, not breath.
- GolDDranks 8y agoI don't think we know 100% how much specific diseases contribute, but there is at least ongoing research about that, and it seems there is general changes in body odour composition: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Old_person_smell https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Old_person_smell
- ubernostrum 8y agoSo can animals. Having had a family member who was epileptic, I can attest he often had a unique odor on his breath shortly before a seizure occurred. Now, there are people doing research into training dogs to detect that and alert that a seizure is imminent.
- tytytytytytytyt 8y agoThe existing dogs aren't good enough?
- ruytlm 8y agoAlso relevant: The woman who can smell Parkinson's disease: https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-scotland-42252411 https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-scotland-42252411
- Herodotus38 8y agoI read the paper, they had 11 patients with known cancer and trained the NN to detect volatile organic compounds in the breath from raw GC-MS (gas chromatography mass spectrometry) data. From what I understand, the interesting and novel application is in the NN learning to parse the data for the detection of the aldehydes they were interested in. Nothing about this paper involves testing in patients where you aren't sure if they have cancer or not from what I read. Lots of false positives as well. Furthermore, whether or not this type of breath testing is useful in diagnosis is an open research question. In my opinion, from a medicine standpoint this paper is pretty far from being applicable to patients, and may never be, although that is par for the course for a lot of medical research. I'm not smart enough to comment on the ML details.
- nl 8y agoThis should surprise no one. This 2016 study[1] build a device which could detect 17 diseases via breath, and I think that was a manually built algorithm. It's well known that dogs can smell cancer too (there's a 2006 study but I can't find it now). [1] https://pubs.acs.org/doi/full/10.1021/acsnano.6b04930 https://pubs.acs.org/doi/full/10.1021/acsnano.6b04930
- zdmc 8y ago"...with better than-human average performance". Hmm. Is this a task that humans currently do well?
- weregiraffe 8y agoSoon, AI will smell your weakness and go in for the kill...
- roryisok 8y ago“Computers equipped with this technology only take minutes to autonomously analyze a breath sample that previously took hours by a human expert,” They make it sound as if the human expert was also sniffing peoples breath, trying to smell cancer
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- vidoc 8y agoI misread the title and thought "I" instead of "AI". I was like, I'm clicking now!
- Bromskloss 8y agoThat doesn't sound dramatically different from being able to diagnose things from a blood sample.
- rabboRubble 8y agoIt does from the perspective of the blood giver. Many people are dreadfully afraid of needles to the point their unwillingness to do preventative tests. Also reduces the knowledge needed to administrate the test and possibly the eventual cost of executing the test. No phlebotomists needed to exhale.
- pndd90 8y agoIt is interesting that when humans (Oriental medicine diagnosis) detect the same it's considered anti-scientific.