7 ms·
Money is not always a good indicator of societal wealth. The standard of living rankings tell a truer story.
by gaius 16y ago
Money is not always a good indicator of societal wealth. The standard of living rankings tell a truer story.
- tptacek 16y agoIt may very well be better for everyone's quality of life to pay people less and mandate more leisure; in other words, it may be better if society decides (for most people) how hard they should work. But that's orthogonal to my point. You could mandate 6 weeks vacation in the US, too. But wages would go down as a result. Generally, if you're in our profession and you want more vacation, become a contractor. People have been doing contract work for decades for exactly this reason.
- pyre 16y agoI think the point was that if the US mandated 6 weeks of vacation, and wages went down as a result, so would prices, no?
- yummyfajitas 16y agoIf supply of money went down, but the amount of goods and services produced remained the same, prices would go down. If Americans worked less, it's likely that the amount of goods and services produced would also go down. In that case, prices would remain the same, and we would all just have less stuff.
- tptacek 16y agoWhat's cheaper in Germany? Housing appears to cost about as much as a major US metro area. Transportation costs more. Health care is obviously cheaper, but Germans pay much higher taxes. Food appears to be just slightly cheaper in Germany.
- sprout 16y agoTransportation costs more by what metric? I think the population density would do a lot to offset the naive euros/mile comparison. I suspect there's a similar effect with housing, that cultural norms in the US create unnecessarily large housing expenses, for example large manicured lawns. Though I'm reaching a bit here, I still think this isn't as cut and dry 'cheaper.' Question is more what's culturally expected? Daily hot showers are pretty pricey for example.
- ido 16y agoHousing appears to cost about as much as a major US metro area. Where did you get your information? Have you tried comparing the rent of a reasonably central apartment in Frankfurt & Munich (Germany's wealthiest and most expensive cities) with their New York and San Fransisco equivalents? Housing in major cities in Germany is drastically cheaper than in the US.
- tptacek 16y agoAre you seriously suggesting that Manhattan and San Francisco are representative of the housing markets of the entire US? The average cost of a newly built detached house in Germany in 2008 was $320,540USD. The average cost of same in the United States in 2008 was $292,600[1]. Yes, I did compare, but not aggressively. What's your source? [1] Bulwien Gesa via "Global Property Guide", and the US Government, respectively.
- ido 16y agoMy source is living in Austria, which has a very similar housing market to Germany & having friends in California & New York who pay $2000 a month for an apartment nobody here would pay even half (maybe not even a third or a quarter) of that for. And there are also much cheaper cities in Germany, I was comparing the most expensive in both countries since you talked about major US metro areas. Pretty sure that even if you go down the ladder and compare Seattle/Miami/San Diego to Hamburg/Berlin/Cologne or whatever their German counterparts are German housing is still cheaper. EDIT: I see you changed your comment while I was replying. You're right that if you compare suburban housing (detached houses) the US is cheaper. But if we are talking about metropolitan housing it's a different story. Also, relatively few people live in detached houses in Germany - these do not represent the average household like they do in the US. I don't think we are at a disagreement, because I don't think we are comparing the same thing. I am talking about metropolitan life (apartment, central location in a big city) while you are talking about housing in general (which in the US mostly comprises houses in suburbs).
- tptacek 16y agoDon't let actual research statistics and my actual argument (US v Germany, not Berlin v NYC) get in the way of your life experience. Honestly, it's not that hard to actually gather the statistics and muster an argument based on evidence. Every major metro area tracks these numbers. Having just replied to another comment with 4 minutes of Google research to establish the rough parity between the cost of the Berlin rental market with that of Chicago, the third largest city in the US, I'm comfortable supposing right back at you that you're wrong, and that housing in Germany simply isn't significantly cheaper than it is in the US, despite the fact that it is the single largest component of the typical cost of living and the fact that on average Germans earn less than Americans. And, sorry, no, I'm talking about major metro, not suburbs.
- maxawaytoolong 16y agoRenting an apartment in Berlin is WAY cheaper than in NYC, and the cheap apartments are actually nice. That's not really answering your question, but for a gigantor metropolis berlin is a lot cheaper than manhattan...
- tptacek 16y agoThe rental market in Manhattan simply isn't comparable to the rest of the US. The average cost of a 3bdr apartment in the center of Berlin is, from casual Google research, almost exactly the same in USD as a 3bdr apartment in the middle of Chicago. Chicago, in turn, is more expensive than Cleveland, Milwaukee, Minneapolis, Columbus, Omaha, &c &c.
- maxawaytoolong 16y agoI was comparing Manhattan to Berlin. Who gives a fuck about Omaha or Chicago?
- tptacek 16y agoWhy stop there? Compare Berlin to Tribeca. Who cares about the Upper East Side?
- bilch 16y agoDoesn't a three bedroom apartment actually have four rooms, three of them bedrooms? In Berlin "Dreizimmerwohnung" means that there are three rooms, period. So maybe your calculation is off by one.
- tbrownaw 16y agoIf a hamburger costs 12 minutes' pay now, it should still cost 12 minutes' pay when everyone is working less and getting paid less per year. Because it will still take 10 (normalized) minutes to make, and all the companies along the way probably won't change their profit margins that much.
- gaius 16y agoMaybe, but like I say, it doesn't tell the whole story. Would the average American take a 2% cut in wages for an extra week's vacation a year? The purpose of earning money is to enable you to live the lifestyle of your choice, that's axiomatic. If you can get everything you want for less money, are you more or less wealthy than someone who can't get what they want, for more? Also, productivity is not linear with time. 30 hours of actual work beats 50 if half of those 50 is meetings and goofing off. That's the German and French secret, if any.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoWould the average American take a 2% cut in wages for an extra week's vacation a year? From the article: "In 2008 it was estimated that three vacation days were left unused for most American workers." Since the average American doesn't use all the vacation he has, the answer is probably no.
- gaius 16y agoBecause, as the article mentions, the culture of presenteeism.
- tptacek 16y agoIn the few large company environments I've worked at, banking up unused vacation days was actively discouraged; it's an accounting problem (accrued days have to be paid on separation). That, plus the fact that virtually every established company has policies restricting year-to-year carryover of vacation, suggests that the "culture of presenteeism" idea, while compelling, is not actually suppressing actual vacations.
- jimbokun 16y agoIt's discourage by HR, but is your manager going to pass you over for a raise or a promotion because you didn't take enough vacation days?
- 16y ago
- yummyfajitas 16y agoI disagree. PPP-adjusted money is a measure of how much of the stuff you want that you can actually afford to have. "Standard of living" rankings tend to measure how much of the stuff that the study creators want that you can afford to have. A nation might have a low rank due simply to the fact that the people living there prefer different things than what the study creators think they should prefer. Measuring PPP-adjusted money doesn't have this problem.
- loewenskind 16y agoWouldn't that have the problem of people in one area wanting more expensive things than the other?