4 ms·
Just to somewhat gently push back on this a little bit, math is probably not enough if you want someone to really get how quantum mechanics work at a fundamenta
by danShumway 8y ago
Just to somewhat gently push back on this a little bit, math is probably not enough if you want someone to really get how quantum mechanics work at a fundamental level.
So quantum superposition isn't just two things at the same time, it's a complex equation that combines the two states. Great. Except that non-math majors don't think of linear equations as a singular 'thing' that describes a state. That in itself is a huge paradigm shift for people like me. I'm not used to having an axis in an equation not refer to a continuous range that I can move through.
There's a comic[0] on this springs to mind, that being able to plug equations into something is not the same as understanding it. Most tutorials or technical articles I read about quantum mechanics skip concepts and assume that showing the math is enough. In doing so, they skip all of the hard, useful parts of education and focus only on the language and terminology we can use to talk about something.
I spent a lot of time in physics, statistics, and calculus where I understood the math and not the concepts. I graphed things in 4 dimensions before I encountered Flatland, but I didn't understand the 4th dimension before Flatland. I worked with complex numbers all the time in calculus, but I didn't start to understand complex numbers until years later when I started watching Numberphile.
So I'm at least a little bit skeptical of claims that that quantum mechanics are different. We've had to build new paradigms to understand a lot of stuff in the past; concepts like infinity don't map to tangible analogies, but we can still build tutorials and scenarios that demonstrate interesting behaviors and properties.
Right now the only people I can find trying to do that for quantum are the pop-science writers, and like you said they're mostly all crap. It's kind of frustrating.
[0]: https://web.archive.org/web/20120206011811im_/http://zs1.smbc-comics.com/comics/20100620.gif https://web.archive.org/web/20120206011811im_/http://zs1.smb...
- ben_w 8y agoAs you mentioned Numberphile, what do you think of the YouTube channel PBS Space Time? It helped me finally grok quite a few bits of physics that never made sense to me before.
- danShumway 8y agoFirst time I've heard of them, so I dunno. I'll add them to the list though. :)
- ahelwer 8y agoI think quantum mechanics really is different. Consider a fundamental aspect of the quantum world, familiar to anybody reading Scott Aaronson's blog: the 2-norm. People are familiar with how probability works in the classical world. For a given event with several different possible outcomes, like flipping a coin, the probability of those outcomes sums to 1 (here, 1/2 + 1/2 = 1). In the quantum world, probability doesn't work like that. Rather, the sum of the absolute value of the probability squared equals one. A quantum coin flip has probability (actually called amplitude) 1/sqrt(2) for heads and 1/sqrt(2) for tails. |1/sqrt(2)|^2 + |1/sqrt(2)|^2 = 1. This has huge implications. It means probabilities can be negative, since |-1/sqrt(2)|^2 + |-1/sqrt(2)|^2 = 1 (actually it goes further - the probabilities can be complex numbers!). It means negative probabilities can interfere and cancel out positive probabilities. And a whole bunch of other wild stuff. All of quantum mechanics (or so Scott claims) follows from this. I submit that a world where something as basic as the probabilities of all outcomes summing to 1 not holding is a world so alien that attempts to explain it in terms of our own experience will only end in confusion.
- danShumway 8y agoSure, but we don't need to explain everything in terms of our world to still try to explain concepts. We can use contradictions, or games[0], or experiments, or any number of mechanisms. Infinity doesn't really map to anything else that I understand. Some of the better tutorials I've gotten on infinity are literally just saying, "hey, look at this scenario. Do you think it works the same way as with really big numbers? Well it DOESN'T! Now watch me shove even more guests into your hotel! :)" I'm not pushing back against the idea that quantum mechanics is a completely new paradigm, I'm pushing back against the idea that math, by itself, is a good enough mechanism for teaching new paradigms. The math/pop-science dichotomy actually reminds me a bit of my early physics lessons on electricity. I'd either get a really awful analogy (electricity is just like water flowing through a pipe), or I'd get the formula to add up the resistors and calculate voltage and then get told, "well, this is all you're going to need to know for the test." Neither approach was concerned with understanding how electricity worked; one just said "think of it as something else", and the other said "don't think about it." [0]: http://www.4dtoys.com/ http://www.4dtoys.com/
- Koshkin 8y ago> isn't just two things at the same time In a way it is, though - when you measure, you get one or the other.
- ahelwer 8y agoNope. If you measure in a different basis, you can get something completely different. Quantum key exchange makes use of this.