33 ms·
The NSA’s Hidden Spy Hubs in Eight U.S. Cities
- azinman2 8y agoI’d love to see the intercept publish the equivalent for China, Russia, etc. It feels the press has very overindexed into the NSA.
- greggarious 8y agoNice whataboutism. While I agree China/Russia has the intent, but do they have the ability to conduct wiretapping on this scale? It sounds like the US is uniquely able to do this since so much of the internet's backbones/services reside here.
- subcosmos 8y agohttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/SORM https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/SORM
- greggarious 8y agoThanks for the link. Doesn't seem to address my contention that the US has unique levels of access. I assume that all countries spy on their own citizens, but NSA is uniquely positioned to get traffic at a global scale.
- subcosmos 8y agoThat article has details about their implementation Nationwide. It's very similar to the CALEA requirements in the US.
- greggarious 8y agoPlease read my posts carefully before responding. You are talking at, not to me.
- swarnie_ 8y agoAmerica can't claim to be near the peak of human culture, freedom and civil liberties while also wanting to be compared against places like China and Russia. Hold yourself to higher standards if you really are No. 1.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- whatcanthisbee 8y agowell good luck trying on those countries! with PRC operating quick-death-"police"-vans, aren't you telling the intercept reporters to risk their lives? maybe you should try...?
- mmjaa 8y agoWhy? Because this hurts your sense of national pride?
- frockington 8y agoIf you tried in China or Russia you'd probably get a nice visit to a permanent-stay "resort" with "daily exercise" where you get to work in fields without pay
- whatcanthisbee 8y agoyou're really optimistic... why would PRC provide a stable "work" and "exercise" routine when it can simply use a death-van? PRC is wiser to do a quick off-with-their-heads when it wants to shush someone
- frockington 8y agoTrue, a .22 round is much more efficient then lodging and food
- hhh 8y agoSuicide by multiple gunshots
- jonknee 8y agoThe Intercept is "overindexed" to the US in the same way that the Daily Mail is "overindexed" to the UK. That's the whole point.
- partiallypro 8y agoThe Intercept, though I like much of their work, has shown some sympathy with Russia and repeated things that were Russian propaganda from agencies like Sputnik and RT. Wikileaks itself is possibly even a Russian front operation.
- ilikehurdles 8y agoI like The Intercept, but it's mainly Glenn Greenwald who seems to have gone off the deep end and really dug in his heels, even when other authors in the group have written articles disagreeing with his unyielding conclusions.
- boomboomsubban 8y agoThey haven't shown sympathy towards Russia, they just don't view Russia as the sole bogeyman responsible for all troubles. Like the Trump-Russia scandal, they have reporters on the case but also point out there is similar or more damning evidence of collusion with Israel or Saudi Arabia. Your post illustrates why they take these positions. Even an unsourced insignificant link to Russia is used to discredit anyone.
- pjc50 8y agoIt's not a secret in the West, or even in China, that there's a "Great Firewall" which surveils and regulates all internet access. It's just America that pretends it doesn't have a secret police.
- JumpCrisscross 8y ago> a secret police The term "secret police refers to intelligence, security or police agencies that engage in covert operations against a government's political opponents" [1]. We have no evidence the NSA is "used to protect the political power of an individual" or even political party. They're an intelligence agency, purely and simply. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Secret_police https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Secret_police
- boomboomsubban 8y agoThat spies on members of Congress on the orders of the President... https://theintercept.com/2015/12/30/spying-on-congress-and-israel-nsa-cheerleaders-discover-value-of-privacy-only-when-their-own-is-violated/ https://theintercept.com/2015/12/30/spying-on-congress-and-i...
- tehwebguy 8y agoOne of the few groups that should be spied on
- boomboomsubban 8y agoNo, their activities should largely be public. The NSA having privlaged information on their actions is dangerous, they have no incentive to share them with the public unless it benefits the NSA.
- tehwebguy 8y ago> No, their activities should largely be public. I can agree on that
- syshum 8y agoChina and Russia do not hide what they do or the fact they monitor all their citizens data The US on the other attempts to play like the US Government is high and moral, respecting the freedoms of their citizens, while in the background they are just as Authoritarian as Russia and China
- boomboomsubban 8y agoStories like this often rely on some access to privileged information. If you were in a non-English/Portuguese country and had that privileged information, what reason would you have to expose it to an online paper you've never heard of? This line of criticism is often brought up but there is no merit in it. How many Russian language news sources are you aware of?
- just_steve_h 8y agoProfessor Chomsky has often had to respond to criticism that he singled out the U.S. for his criticisms. He rightly points out that, as a citizen of the U.S., he is obligated first to attempt to address the wrongs (as he sees them) of his own government first, since he (at least in theory) has some ability to influence his own government.
- scottmf 8y agoOf course it wouldn’t. Greenwald is effectively a Kremlin puppet and he’ll never admit he was conned.
- dooglius 8y agoThe scrolljacking on this article is absolutely insufferable.
- dopamean 8y agoIt happens a lot on The Intercept. It's really super annoying.
- pandasun 8y agoFor those who can't access theintercept for a variety of reasons: https://archive.fo/c0vWe https://archive.fo/c0vWe
- kodablah 8y agoOne wonders if a CDN might advertise, "we promise once your data enters our network at our edge locations outside of the US, it does not traverse any AT&T networks while reaching your server inside the US". Same with cloud companies' private networks across regions.
- dbcurtis 8y agoGiven how peering is implemented among backbone providers, I don't think that is technically possible today.
- kodablah 8y agoIf peering had more participants, companies could choose their peering agreements for server-to-server data (i.e. non-residential, not-public-internet) on private pipes only with companies who make the similar no-AT&T promise downstream. One way or another, the principled economic squeeze needs to be there instead of waiting on public policy.
- ancarda 8y agoCouldn't the NSA start working with other ISPs than AT&T? I'd really like to see CDNs like CloudFlare start requiring Cloud <--> Origin encryption; e.g. what CloudFlare calls "Full SSL" -- https://support.cloudflare.com/hc/en-us/articles/200170416-What-do-the-SSL-options-mean- https://support.cloudflare.com/hc/en-us/articles/200170416-W.... Right now, you can do TLS termination ("Flexible SSL"), which end-users aren't aware of -- they see a padlock -- and I'm sure the NSA doesn't mind.
- kodablah 8y agoSure they could, but one might hope the AT&T's eroded trust would serve as caution towards other overly cooperative companies. Or encourage companies to fight in court to be given the transparency allowances they desire to let the rest of us know they are legally compelled to do this and in no way do they agree or are doing anything beyond what's required. Granted, like FB issues and others, we in this community need to realize that most users simply don't care (even many b2b ones) and not get upset when our users don't move their dollars on principle. For us it's a big deal, for many there are real, harmful issues going on in the world and volume collection of data by companies and governments is not one of them. And we can't make it so despite the deluge of articles by a supportive mass media. EDIT: To clarify, you mentioned "other ISPs" but I want to be clear I'm talking about private pipes and not residential internet though I know they are often shared.
- rsa4096 8y agoFirst, I must immediately question the informativeness of anyone who thinks Washington DC is located in Maryland. Second, pointing out addresses of major AT&T PoPs is useless. Do carriers (still) mirror traffic to intelligence agencies? Most likely. However, this makes it sound like AT&T and the NSA have dedicated entire buildings for this purpose, which is ridiculous. Complete sensationalism.
- ggggtez 8y agoThis first thing you said isn't in the article at all, you just misread it. The second thing also indicates a lack of reading comprehension, thus downvoted.
- rsa4096 8y agoPlease, explain to me how I misread the map. It clearly labels Washington DC as a city in the state of Maryland.
- pwinnski 8y agoYou've misread the map by assuming "Maryland" was a state label, when evidence within the same map clearly indicates it is not. "Northern California" and "Southern California" are not states. Instead, they are areas, and Washington D.C. is in the area of Maryland.
- rsa4096 8y agoThis is ridiculous, but I'll play along. California absolutely is a state. Further defining the location of a city in a state does not really explain how Washington DC ends up being classified as part of Maryland. Washington DC is not part of the state Maryland. There is also no area (I assume by "area" you mean metro area or region) that is commonly defined as Maryland. Washington DC is part of the DC metropolitan area or "DMV," however it is in no way part of Maryland anymore than New York city is part of New Jersey. I was simply pointing out a minor (albeit, comical) factual error that immediately made me question the legitimacy of the rest of the article.
- bonestamp2 8y agoIt could just be part of regular routing, but I noticed for example that all my facebook traffic is routed to an address with an LA prefix in LA. That doesn't seem strange except that Facebook doesn't have an LA datacenter (at least not that I could find any public record of, and they seem to publish the location of other data centers).
- puzzle 8y agoThere's a difference between a data center and a POP. The former is very large. The latter is usually a rack or more in someone else's facilities. When you try to reach Google or Facebook, you rarely hit their data centers directly. They're out in the boonies, where land and power are cheap. Rather, you talk to their proxies at the edge (POPs, often in large cities). From there, your data is either returned immediately (e.g. cached objects such as popular videos or the company logo...) or forwarded over their fiber to the core clusters in the data centers.
- bonestamp2 8y agoMakes sense, thanks!
- oldgeezr 8y agoJust curious, is there a good site/book/etc to learn how the modern internet actually works? As a lowly programmer, I have a good understanding of network communications, and some knowledge of things like routing protocols, but I'm completely lost when it comes to understanding how the modern internet actually functions. Thanks!
- puzzle 8y agoI'd normally recommend books like Google's SRE one, but at least in this case it glosses over the detail of where GFEs tend to live: https://landing.google.com/sre/book/chapters/production-environment.html#fig_production-environment_life-of-a-request https://landing.google.com/sre/book/chapters/production-envi... It used to be the case that they were mostly in POPs, but I think that with Maglev (https://research.google.com/pubs/pub44824.html https://research.google.com/pubs/pub44824.html) they can live in core clusters, too. Other Google sources go into more detail, e.g. https://medium.com/@duhroach/profiling-gcps-load-balancers-94c552f06736 https://medium.com/@duhroach/profiling-gcps-load-balancers-9... https://www.slideshare.net/MichelleHolley1/google-cloud-networking-deep-dive https://www.slideshare.net/MichelleHolley1/google-cloud-netw... Back to your question, I'm not sure there is one good place to look up these things, but presentations/papers by companies like Google and Facebook are probably still your best bet. Stuff coming straight out of GCP teams will be a little more enthusiastic in tone, but that's easy to tune out. :-) Another good example is Facebook's Ben Maurer and his Fail at Scale talk, which discusses a lot of details that are necessary for modern internet services, such as queuing, session/application-layer congestion control, canarying, advanced monitoring, etc. https://queue.acm.org/detail.cfm?id=2839461 https://queue.acm.org/detail.cfm?id=2839461
- reaperducer 8y agoI'm struggling to find the new information here. We've known for years through the New York Times and others that AT&T helps the NSA. We've known for close to a hundred years about AT&T Long Lines networks and hubs for that network. It's only basic logic to put the two together and know that the NSA uses AT&T's hubs. What's new here?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- txcwpalpha 8y agoDid you even read the article? The new information is that these specific 8 buildings are specifically noted within NSA documents as the 8 locations within AT&T's network that the NSA utilizes. I don't know what The Intercept expects anyone to do with that information, but that is new information.
- zer00eyz 8y agoTo OP's point this isn't some shocking revelation. Do people think that this is the full picture? That were even close to having any sort of understanding of what really happens? To your point however this tidbit does give a good excuse to re raise the issue. Why are we allowed to spy on ourselves?
- reaperducer 8y agoI admit, I didn't read the full article because it's only barely readable on my device, but if my scroll bar is accurate, I did read about 70% of it. But my point stands. We've known that these specific buildings are the key hubs in the network for close to a century. And that they're hardened against nuclear attack, etc... Maybe I was too deep into the phreaking scene in the early days, but I thought this was common knowledge in technology circles.
- txcwpalpha 8y agoYou're still missing the point. > We've known that these specific buildings are the key hubs in the network for close to a century. And that they're hardened against nuclear attack, etc... Yes, it's been known that these specific buildings were key to AT&T's infrastructure. But any speculation that these specific buildings (as opposed to other specific buildings) were also key to NSA projects was just an assumption. The new information, which comes from released NSA memos and documents, shows that these specific 8 buildings are key to the NSA, meaning it's not just based on assumption anymore. There's some other new information in there from the memos/documents, too. You really should actually read the article before mounting your high horse and spouting off nonsense criticism about it.
- peterwwillis 8y agoThis is focused on AT&T, but there are other major datacenters in the US that are also major transit peers for foreign nations, with entire floors dedicated to government equipment. AT&T is a convenient one-stop shop, but they will probably need to use other service providers as well.
- nickpsecurity 8y agoPrior leaks showed they were paying multiple telecoms huge amounts of money to do exactly that. https://www.forbes.com/sites/robertlenzner/2013/09/23/attverizonsprint-are-paid-cash-by-nsa-for-your-private-communications/#19e05c4743cb https://www.forbes.com/sites/robertlenzner/2013/09/23/attver...
- darksaints 8y agoWow, just made a crazy realization. A while back I was downtown with my 5yo kid, and we were by the bus stop right next to this building (You can actually see the bus stop in the picture). The bus was late, and my kid was hyper, and he tried going through the revolving doors. They were locked, no big deal. After a while, he tried going through the doors again. At this point, three security guards with ballistic vests come busting out of the door with their hands on their holsters, and chewed me out for letting him play near the door. I know my way around the security industry. These weren't normal security guards that get paid to watch cctv and call the real cops. They don't give those guys guns or ballistic vests. To me it was completely bizarre that a telecom building would have that sort of security. Now it all makes sense. I actually wouldn't be surprised if they were actually military in disguise.
- eli 8y agoLike a lot of federal agencies, NSA has its own police force to secure their buildings. A few years ago they somewhat infamously shot someone who drove through the Fort Meade gate and then refused an order to stop. They were driving a stolen car, but apparently made a wrong turn.
- nxc18 8y agoThis also happened this year - guy drive past a checkpoint, the NSA didn't put up with it.
- walshemj 8y agoIts supposedly was the SOP for USAF gate guards at RAF Checksands in the UK. And I suspect try and run a gate with a vehicle at Sellafield would lead to a similar response from the Nuke Police.
- rconti 8y agoThe one in the picture? Is that NY? I don't recognize the skyline.
- secabeen 8y agoIt's interesting to see this, and the reference to "one million emails", considering the prevalence of opportunistic TLS on MTA connections. Gmail reports 89% of their inbound and outbound flow is protected by TLS [1]. Wouldn't that eliminate the ability of the NSA to intercept those messages? [1] https://transparencyreport.google.com/safer-email/overview https://transparencyreport.google.com/safer-email/overview
- bonyt 8y agoNot the first time: Room 641A: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Room_641A https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Room_641A
- d4l3k 8y agoThey specifically mention that room with a photo of it in the article.
- XalvinX 8y ago12 years later and nothing changed. The SCOTUS killed the lawsuit and Congress let everyone involved off the hook. Since there are rarely, if ever, any consequences for breaking the law or the Constitution, why would they stop?
- helios893 8y agohttps://www.calyxinstitute.org/projects/encrypted-internet-peering-project https://www.calyxinstitute.org/projects/encrypted-internet-p...
- stephengillie 8y agoThe Seattle location - 1122 3rd Ave - is an interesting spot. According to Google Maps[0], next door is the FBI Seattle Division office. On street view, the building itself has a street-level office with signs for both AT&T and CenturyLink. 3rd Ave itself is slightly notorious - hosting the surface entrances for the Seattle bus tunnel, and a large number of inter-city routes, the area has a reputation for crime and the occasional death by shooting. It was a bit worrying to commute through, as a bus rider, and seems like an odd location for an ISP street-level office. [0] https://goo.gl/maps/8oxjkCL8JFm https://goo.gl/maps/8oxjkCL8JFm
- weej 8y agoCompletely anecdotal evidence, but every morning I walk by this building and without failure I run into wireless interference of some sort on different frequency bands (GSM, bluetooth, etc.). Not saying correlation is causation here, but the interfernce is definitely a little unnerving.
- walrus01 8y agoIts choice of location is nothing nefarious. It was built in the mid 1950s as a Pacific Northwest Bell telco central office, for phone lines serving downtown Seattle, in the days when dialtone rotary pulse-dial phone systems were the highest technology available. The PNW Bell phone system and its interconnections with the AT&T Long Lines system had some sites which were mutually shared with military AUTOVON and other federal government long distance telecom circuits (such as those which fed the giant SAGE installations at McChord and in Moses Lake). It became a USWest site in 1984 through the breakup of the Bell monopoly system, and then Qwest and eventually Centurylink.
- aardvark291 8y ago> giant SAGE installations at McChord and in Moses Lake What's that?
- EvanAnderson 8y agoSAGE was a late 1950's-60's computerized air defense system: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Semi-Automatic_Ground_Environment https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Semi-Automatic_Ground_Enviro... There used to be some SAGE equipment at the Computer History Museum in Mountain View. I don't know if it's still there or not, but it was definitely interesting to see. The "light gun" user interface and the control consoles have a really pleasing aesthetic.
- souterrain 8y agoIs 811 10th (NYCMNY54) even interesting from an Internet perspective any longer? Yes, the building is part of AT&T’s network (AS7018), but as far as I’m aware, no peering occurs here at all. I’d look for equivalent shady racks or rooms at 60 Hudson, 111 8th and 25 Broadway. Maybe the comfortable relationship between NSA and at&t are more the driver for the location, and the fiber taps are all backhauled here. From a voice perspective, though, I’d think this was still a useful surveillance point, given AT&T likely still tandems traffic here.
- walrus01 8y agoThings are slowly moving out of 111 8th as Google bought the whole building and is not renewing leases for certain tenants. Most traffic exchange happens at places like 60 Hudson for Manhattan and then a whole bunch of newer, modern, low and wide purpose built datacenters (mostly 1998 and later dotcom 1.0 boom and onwards era) in NJ across the river.
- Mc91 8y agoI used to be in this building all the time, lots of companies colo'd their setups in the building. I know Forbes did, as well as other companies. The building had security but was not incredibly secure. https://www.business.att.com/content/productbrochures/colocation-data-center-new-york-brief.pdf https://www.business.att.com/content/productbrochures/coloca... Our servers there went through AT&T networks. Some companies I worked for co-located at Telehouse centers where you had a host of upstream options (including multiple options). Stephen Colbert's studio was next door to the building when he was doing the Colbert Report 3-4 years ago, I used to see him walking around from time to time.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- jakenberg 8y agoThere's an interesting 1960's era art installation by Anthony Heinsbergen on a side wall of the LA facility that seems oddly related to this... https://i1.wp.com/upinthevalley.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/12/IMG_2471.jpg?w=1024 https://i1.wp.com/upinthevalley.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/...
- always_good 8y agoI don't understand "oddly" here. The art piece seems rather literal rather than some odd coincidental association.
- XalvinX 8y agoMan is that bad art...almost like it was made by committee.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- bhouston 8y agoThis building in downtown Ottawa looks similarly imposing: https://goo.gl/maps/6xEgv4KwJ4v https://goo.gl/maps/6xEgv4KwJ4v
- walrus01 8y ago99% odds that is either a ILEC telco central office or a large electrical transformer substation. If electrical grid, similar to the big part with no windows at 970 Burrard in Vancouver. BC Hydro headquarters site with giant substation that later became office and residential condos. edit: I just moved down the street a bit and it says Bell Canada on the building. It's a CO. Another way you can tell for sure with a building like that, is that there will be a locked panel or set of highly protected hose ports for generator diesel fuel refill, from alley or street side tanker truck delivery.
- XalvinX 8y agoI feel so safe and protected. NSA should give out branded teddy bears to kids. (edit: added>> Oh, wait, the apparently already have them!! http://scienceblogs.de/klausis-krypto-kolumne/files/2016/06/NSA-Gift-Teddy-bar-590x404.png http://scienceblogs.de/klausis-krypto-kolumne/files/2016/06/...) Awwww....ain't that sweet??
- foobarbazetc 8y agoLol, I walk past the one on Folsom all the time. The most obvious spy building ever.
- akira2501 8y agoWell, yea. I'd be surprised[1] if it wasn't on the list. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Room_641A https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Room_641A
- foobarbazetc 8y agoHeh, see I had no idea what Room 641 was.
- walshemj 8y agoAll Big telephone exchanges look like that :-)
- Firerouge 8y agoI wonder what sort of performance impact this has on American internet speeds. At the very least, AT&T might be limited from upgrading their equipment until the NSA can revise their monitoring systems to keep up.
- IAmGraydon 8y agoThey’re using optical splitters, so the original signal passes though untouched. Because there’s no man in the middle, bandwidth shouldn’t be affected.
- Firerouge 8y agoThat makes sense, but at the same time, I wonder if ISPs are hesitant or inhibited from upgrading key pieces of infrastructure equipment out of obligation to maintain these copying capabilities.
- chiph 8y agoThe article describes a lot of the buildings a fortress-like. I actually don't have a problem with that - in the event of a catastrophe, I want my telecommunications to keep working. The rest of it - splitting data traffic and sending a copy to the NSA - I'd like to see how any international traffic is being sent through a land-locked city like Dallas, which should only have domestic traffic in it. Which the NSA shouldn't be looking at.
- ilikepi 8y ago> I'd like to see how any international traffic is being sent through a land-locked city like Dallas... Well, Texas borders Mexico, and although DFW is on the other side of the state, it is a very large metro area. If it's a hub for domestic traffic, it seems logical for it to also act as an interchange for international traffic with Central and South America. The hostnames I see in a traceroute to telmex.com (a big telco headquartered in Mexico City) from my office in New England on Verizon FiOS appears to support the idea that at least some traffic routes through Dallas before it crosses the border. EDIT: clarification
- yuhong 8y agoMy personal favorite is how the current debt based economy allow almost infinite amounts of government debt to be created. In fact, one of the reasons why we got off the gold standard decades ago is military spending.
- pm90 8y agoNo its not. And I fail to understand why this keeps coming up. The gold standard tied fiscal and monetary policy to an arbitrary commodity: gold. Whereas value exists beyond the commodity itself. The gold standard had all sorts of unintended consequences and is not fit for a modern economy. What is perhaps more worrying is common currency. The Euro has lead to a lot more trouble than it was worth, Frankly speaking.
- XalvinX 8y agoAnyone remember this from 2006? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Room_641A https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Room_641A I guess they just expanded, but the basic facts here are not new. "the capability to enable surveillance and analysis of internet content on a massive scale, including both overseas and purely domestic traffic." AND Klein claims he was told that similar black rooms are operated at other facilities around the country.
- sandra00 8y agoMy husband has been cheating on me for many months and I had no idea , he always locked his phone and never let me go through it for any reason. I desperately needed a professional hacker to help and with the help of Enrique Lewis I literally was able to access my husbands mobile phone without touching his phone and all messsges and calls were to my disposal. If you need such services contact ENRIQUEHACKDEMON11 at g m a I l . C o m for assistance or add and chat him up through adding him with his what's app number which is +16282035722. This is a legitimate source,you will get to thank me later.My name is Sandra tell him from me as i have gave him my word that i will help him let the world know's he's the best out here.