13 ms·
Intel and the Danger of Integration
- dvfjsdhgfv 8y ago> it was already clear that arguably the most important company in Silicon Valley’s history was in trouble: PCs, long Intel’s chief money-maker, were in decline, leaving the company ever more reliant on the sale of high-end chips to data centers; Where PCs were replaced, they were succeeded by laptops, and for the most part they use Intel processors.
- huebnerob 8y agoThe term “PC” refers to both desktops and laptops. Both are in decline as general purpose computing moves to the smartphone.
- userbinator 8y agoMore like "as general purpose computing dies, replaced by the smartphone."
- huebnerob 8y agoPeople are doing everything on smartphones they used to do on "personal computers", the form factor doesn't change that. As far as extensibility and/or openness of the platform goes, that may define general purpose computing for you but the industry has abundantly shown that it doesn't for most people.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 8y agoI don't know about the other poster's opinion, but mine is that it isn't a personal computer unless I can program it with itself. The ability for anyone to write and distribute software was what made PCs great. Current smartphones fight the idea that the user can own their device and can do whatever they want with it, preferring a walled garden approach that's helpful to consumers, but not personal computing.
- dvfjsdhgfv 8y agoIt's a disturbing trend but I see some dim hope. Everywhere across the world the importance of programming education is recognized. The BBC:micro is probably the epitome of this, with the the aim of the entire population knowing how to program a device at some point in a future. The people who learned to program in this way will appreciate the ability to control a device in this way and will naturally steer towards platform allowing them to do so. Moreover, even Apple is changing these days. Making Swift available is a step towards more ubiquitous app development. And with Swift Playgrounds you can learn to actually program on your device, even though it's not the same as controlling it the way we're used to. It's not unthinkable they make further concessions and at some point iOS devices could be programmable to a certain extent.
- lioeters 8y agoI'm also of the opinion that current smartphones are not "personal computers" in the original sense of the term. The power is in the hands of the OS and apps, they are the real users, making the decisions of how to use the computer - while the consumers are just that, consuming programs that other people/companies designed.
- lordfoom 8y ago> People are doing everything on smartphones they used to do on "personal computers", the form factor doesn't change that. I don't think folks are doing programming and graphic design on their phones...
- macintux 8y agoTrue, but we've gone from millions of people using PCs to billions using smartphones, and a majority of the people using PCs never used them for programming or graphic design.
- michaelmrose 8y agoThere are billions of pcs.
- macintux 8y agoThere are certainly more than a billion PCs in existence. I'm skeptical there are much more than a billion PC users. Right now it takes about 4 years to sell one billion PCs[1]. Considering that includes business sales, a significant chunk of that includes people with multiple PCs. Compare that to smartphones, which sell well over a billion per year[2]. [1]: https://www.statista.com/statistics/272595/global-shipments-forecast-for-tablets-laptops-and-desktop-pcs/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/272595/global-shipments-... [2]: https://www.investopedia.com/news/smartphone-sales-be-flat-yoy-2018canaccord/ https://www.investopedia.com/news/smartphone-sales-be-flat-y...
- perl4ever 8y agoA "billion per year" is clearly unsustainable, given the world population. I mean, shouldn't we step back and observe that clearly if they're selling at this rate, some grave defect in human behavior is being exploited to the extent that something will dramatically collapse soon? Also keeping in mind the end of Moore's law as people have mentioned.
- michaelmrose 8y ago
- pjmlp 8y agoEven if they do, it is just as form factor, everyone doing serious work with 21" screens or higher will be using docking stations and will be business as usual.
- mrec 8y agoIs that an absolute decline now, or just relative? (I'm asking about usage, not sales - I know the latter have fallen off a cliff since Moore's Law topped out.)
- huebnerob 8y agohttps://bgr.com/2016/11/02/internet-usage-desktop-vs-mobile/ https://bgr.com/2016/11/02/internet-usage-desktop-vs-mobile/ Mobile internet usage worldwide blew past desktop usage in October of 2016 and hasn't slowed down since, and even that's just looking at web page views. I'd argue that holistically, smartphones have been the dominant technology platform for many years even before that, since apps are the primary interface to most services on the platform.
- dvfjsdhgfv 8y agoThis may mean so many things... From "people who use desktops/laptops do it in a work environment and use the Internet less" to "mobile apps use bandwidth more intensively than local apps (which is pretty normal in an office environment)"
- mrec 8y agoThanks, but that doesn't answer the question. It's showing percentages, not absolute numbers.
- oblio 8y agoIsn't the web the biggest platform still? All platform users use web sites/web apps, even though on mobile the percentages are a bit smaller, for now, because of mobile apps.
- gsich 8y agoI wouldn't overestimate the impact of smartphones. It's just that PCs (both in desktop and laptops) don't need upgrades anymore from year to year. You can use your PC from 2012 (Intel i5-2xxx if you remember), possible even farther back and you'd still be fine for almost all tasks. Gamers and other high-performance tasks are a niche. The biggest performance gain for these machines is a SSD, not a new PC. The same will happen to smartphones. You can already see it. Manufacturers trying so hard to invent features nobody needs, just to have an excuse to buy a new device.
- dvfjsdhgfv 8y agoThat's the point. The so-called "post-PC era" has never arrived. Personally I don't know any adult who doesn't own a computer. We no longer upgrade so often but we use them on a daily basis. Pretty much anyone doing any kind of white-collar work will use a PC (that includes Macs...) Your needs outside of the work environment will vary, but people are still not throwing their laptops away just because they use their phones more often.
- oblio 8y agoThe question is: do new adults (think 18-24 year olds) buy desktops or laptops?
- apetresc 8y agoAt least one, yes? There's no university student without one, and there's no white-collar worker without one. Literally nobody is typing up their 10-page essay on their phone.
- oblio 8y agoTablets + keyboards.
- michaelmrose 8y agoTablets remain truly mediocre devices, in the case of Android running a mediocre os. - garbage multi tasking - slightly laggy typing - no real ability for multiple apps to work on the same data -10" is still a tiny screen and almost as unwieldy as a small laptop 7" is too tiny yet still not pocket size. Since a tablet usually does not have by definition a cellular modem it can't replace your phone plus the cameras and microphone normally blow. I find the idea that most people are using a tablet in place of a real computer laughable.
- farsight-1000 8y agoMobile sales are plateauing now as well. Moore's law has hit them just as hard. It would be foolish for Intel to dump everything to jump into a market just as it matures and peaks.
- throwaway2048 8y agoI really think this article fails to make its point about what exactly intel stands to gain from say, manufacturing processors for Apple. It trades in its major competitive advantage, advanced processes (dispite the propaganda intel is far from out of the game process advantage wise) coupled tightly with its processor designs that ensure margins that would make most companies blush, for low margin hypercompetitive contract work. Intel is under absolutely no real threat of being unseated as the company that powers virtually every server in existence, throwing that away to chase contract mfging work dosent make any sense, even if some other companies do it well. The arguement it makes would be more like intel going back into DRAM production, and abandoning x86.
- huebnerob 8y agoYou've got your eyes on the wrong ball, Intel the fab company will be competing for those contracts, but Intel the chip design company will be free to innovate without the burden of manufacturing.
- zeth___ 8y agoIntel had the capability to be the only game in town when it comes to latest gen chips. If Intel was an open shop that anyone could order anything no one would bother with second and third players because the facility costs are so astronomical. Chip manufacture is by it's nature a natural monopoly.
- deltron3030 8y ago> Intel is under absolutely no real threat of being unseated as the company that powers virtually every server in existence, throwing that away to chase contract mfging work dosent make any sense, even if some other companies do it well. The future of their networking division might be brighter than the server one, because decentralization (abstraction layers on top of interconnected devices) is counter to the demand of servers and hardware powering current cloud tech. The servers will move into peoples pockets or iot devices with increased decentralization.
- sho 8y ago> throwing that away to chase contract mfging work dosent make any sense It wouldn't be throwing anything away. Intel Fabs could still make Intel Design's Xeons same as always. It could just make everyone else's stuff as well as capacity and economics permitted. Why would you leave that on the table? The best example is perhaps Samsung. Not only do Samsung's fabs make all the chips for samsung phones, they make them for others as well, including up until recently even their deadly competitor Apple! If you've got fabs, why wouldn't you do that? Even if Ryzen totally destroys intel on the desktop it's heads I win, tails you lose.
- dkrich 8y agoI’m not so sure that not choosing to produce ARM based chips for the iPhone was such an obvious miss for Intel. Why would they want their business subject to the whims of a single company over which they exert zero control? Just as an example, a couple of months ago Apple seemingly out of the blue, announced they would no longer be using Intel chips in future laptop models and the markets barely noticed. Were they more reliant on PC sales that would not have been the case. Perhaps they are way behind AMD with respect to the latest chip designs, but even that is far from proven. I think this article is attempting to make a company with a very complex history and product lineup sound simple.
- trevyn 8y ago>a couple of months ago Apple seemingly out of the blue, announced they would no longer be using Intel chips in future laptop models Clarification: this was a (likely true) rumor, not an official Apple announcement.
- hmottestad 8y ago- 260 509 000 products with ARM (iphone + ipad) - 19 251 000 products with Intel (macs) These are the numbers for 2017 from http://investor.apple.com/secfiling.cfm?filingid=320193-17-70&cik=320193 http://investor.apple.com/secfiling.cfm?filingid=320193-17-7... Apple sells twice as many ipads as they sell macs. And more than 10x as many iphones as macs. Revenue wise it's a little bit closer. - 160 541 000 000 $ for iphones + ipads - 25 850 000 000 $ for macs
- dkrich 8y agoI think you’re missing the point. It’s not about the decision to do ARM mobile chips instead of PC chips, it’s about the decision to go for data center dominance instead of consumer electronics dominance.
- Tempest1981 8y agoThey had a mobile-dominance strategy -- it was Atom. They even partnered with Google/Android. (Maybe you're saying the execution was lacking?)
- blattimwind 8y agoI think the most common issue would be neglecting constant values.
- sumanthvepa 8y agoI understand the point that Ben Thompson is making: that a vertically integrated Intel lost out in the mobile revolution because it wouldn't unbundle it's manufacturing from its processor design. But its current crisis (not referring to the CEO's affair) has nothing to do with vertical integration. It has everything to do with Moore's law scaling coming to an end. This gives fabs like TSMC and increasingly SMIC from China the ability to catch up. Unless there is a breakthrough in technology -- molecular transistors or some such, Intel's ability to dominate will end soon.
- pdpi 8y ago> But its current crisis (not referring to the CEO's affair) has nothing to do with vertical integration. It has everything to do with Moore's law scaling coming to an end. Why not both? Their current business model is threatened by a technical challenge, but the company's exposure to that threat could've been mitigated by making small changes to the business model — by unbundling and diversifying.
- sumanthvepa 8y agoUnbundling and diversifying are both viable strategies. I just don't know if Intel can pull off both simultaneously while maintaining market share, and current levels of profitability.
- macintux 8y ago"small changes" would seem to be a significant understatement, however. The innovator's dilemma.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- rwmj 8y agoFrom the quoted tweet in the article: "I said that ICL should be taken to 14nm++, everybody looked at me like I was the craziest guy on the block, it was just in case". Imagine if Intel were two companies, Intel Design and Intel Manufacturing. This wouldn't have arisen - Intel Design would have produced the new ICL design and could have worked with Intel Manufacturing and TSMC on how to build it, ultimately using TSMC if IM couldn't make it.
- AstralStorm 8y agoIt is not like Intel has not repeatedly tried. Atom is their attempt. As are more advanced MCP51 micros. Intel's problem is that their CPUs were performance focused and as such didn't scale down as well - plus vendors didn't have to care as OSes were portable enough while software has to be rewritten anyway, so going Intel brought no compatibility advantage. This is the same reason why Microsoft has trouble penetrating mobile market.
- tsenkov 8y ago> Intel's problem is that their CPUs were performance focused and as such didn't scale down as well Don't know the first thing about electronics, but I am interested to learn more about what you meant here. Highly-optimized code (usually) isn't too readable or extendable, are you saying Intel has the same problem with their processor's design?
- cptskippy 8y agoThere are different design considerations when designing a CPU to run in a chilled data center vs your pocket. Intel was trying to make everything x86 from data center to pocket and that just wasn't going to work.
- pjc50 8y agoThere are a lot of instances in a design, both macro and micro, where you can trade off greater performance at the expense of something else - either area or power or both. Then these tradeoffs tend to multiply each other. If you have a design which is fast on branch-predicted and slow on branch-mispredicted, and you build a big branch predictor, it works well. But you're committed to powering all that. I mean, compare http://infocenter.arm.com/help/index.jsp?topic=/com.arm.doc.ddi0388f/CHDHCFBC.html http://infocenter.arm.com/help/index.jsp?topic=/com.arm.doc.... (few sentences) with http://www.agner.org/optimize/microarchitecture.pdf http://www.agner.org/optimize/microarchitecture.pdf (admittedly a lot more detail, but it's clearly a more complicated system too)
- tlb 8y agoFast processors work by “speculating” — calculating several possible next steps in advance before knowing for sure what the next step will be. Modern Intel chips do this several steps ahead, at multiple levels. It uses more power, because it does work that is ultimately wasted. Large amounts of speculation makes sense for data center CPUs, but not for battery-powered devices.
- mozumder 8y agoWell Microsoft is about to be fully integrated if they make their own CPUs for their PCs like Apple is about to do (and sorta like how they designed their own XBox processors)... Let's see how that plays out for them and if this anti-vertical-integration theory holds.
- ksec 8y agoI don't think, right now Integration is something wrong about Intel. It is how they miscalculate every thing every time for the past years, even before BK. Planning / Vision, and Execution, I am not sure if there are anything else other then these two attribute that is important to a company, and Intel lacked both. Intel used to win because they have an effectively monopoly in PC market. The high price, high margin and high volume CPU drove investment in tech and their Fab. That was possibly the only item I know other then iPhone that had those three factors together. When the Smartphone revolution started, everything changed. The scale changed, TSMC now produce possibly close to 5x volume then Intel do at Intel Fabs, and their leading node 7nm will likely reach a similar quantity to Intel's 14nm in 12 months time. TSMC now has 2X+ the Total addressable market in leading node compared to Intel. So while new leading node investment cost continue to increase, TSMC also had increasing market size to help spread itself. If you note Intel's mainstream CPU die size, the trend has been going downwards over recent years, i.e They are optimising for cost. Intel could also have expanded their Scale. They could have kept their integration and make more chip, expanding their Fab advantage in both scale and technology. Although they did but it was either late or taken far too long. Their GPU is only looking to launch in 2020, as a first gen product I doubt they will make much an impact and volume. Imagine they had a dGPU prepared 4 years ago, when the crypto wave hit, they ride the wave and gain money earned from Crypto, or they would have a dGPU for a market prices that is cheaper then what ever Nvidia or AMD's bumped up prices. Their 14nm process would actually be miles ahead of 28nm or 16nm that those GPU had. It took them 8 years, 8 years! from acquiring Infineon modem to actually produce a modem in their own Fabs. Next time some M&A talks about synergy one should ask them, how long does it take. Now they have the contract for iPhone modem and could produce it themselves instead of TSMC, they face a new problem that no one has asked so far. How is Intel going find additional capacity to produce an additional 100M modem for Apple over the next year? My guess, the original plan of Intel was the move to the much delayed 10nm will finally be fixed in 2018, leaving some room for the Modem. The modem is much smaller in size, so it is more like 40M unit to Intel's median chip size. But that is still roughly 20% additional unit Intel has to chip on their leading node. And if you had read some rumours about Intel delaying, or renaming their chipset originally going from 22nm to 14nm. That is a possible reason why. May be they shouldn't have defer Fab 42's construction in the first place. I am pretty sure BK's departure has more to do with his performance then whatever they wrote in that PR. And may likely has something to do with Apple. I wouldn't be surprised if Apple has been unhappy about Intel's lying and execution. Remember when Apple started to design their "thinner" MacBook and MacBook Pro, it was obvious they had 10nm and 7nm Intel's CPU in mind. First was suppose to happen last year and the latter schedule for next year. This two year delay, which Apple may or may not know, put Apple in an awkward position. Their custom foundry, were suppose to attract Apple to built an integrated SoC with Intel Modem inside, which is now even less likely to happen when Intel has not been as open about its problem. When Apple contracted Morris in TSMC, they managed to bring up a new Fab running for Apple in less then 6 months. It was a big bet on both side, billions of dollar invested. Could you imagine Intel doing that? These relationship takes time to built, and TSMC right now has literally zero fault. I do agree Intel now faces another turning point, last time they had Andy Grove, now I am not sure who they have hire to get this behemoth running. The task is enormous, and lots of Intel's best engineers and executive have left the company. The only one who may have a slim chance to completely transform Intel is Pat Gelsinger, if Andy Grove saved Intel last time, it will be his apprentice to save Intel again. Unfortunately given what Intel has done to Pat during his last tenure, I am not sure if he is willing to pick up the job, especially the board's Chairman is Bryant, not sure how well they go together. But we know Pat still loves Intel, and I know a lot of us miss Pat.
- Symmetry 8y agoThe thing is, though, that tying design and manufacturing together has been really good for Intel. Historically Intel's performance in terms of driver current and so forth at a given process node has been better than its competitors and it has reached those nodes more quickly. Intel manufacturing paid for that lead partially by accepting more restrictive design rules for transistor layout than a merchant silicon shop could ever get away with because they knew they only had one customer and one design they had to make work. With Intel's numerous missteps at 10nm that lead is over and the manufacturing debacle is taking down the design too but there's no reason to think Intel would be starting from such a dominant place if they had split up. If I were to go back to 2013 I'd tell them "10 nm is too early for cobalt interconnets!" rather than "Split up your design and manufacturing". And really you could also look at the problem as the design team being too wedded to x86 and unwilling to consider other ISAs just as much as the manufacturing problem. Intel could have done an ARM processor for the iPhone but they wanted to make a go at an x86 mobile chip instead. And while the x86 tax is small potatoes when you're paying for a deep OoO pipeline it's pretty noticeable in the world of in order processors or graphics processing units.
- macintux 8y agoThat's exactly what Ben concludes with. > To demand that Intel apologize for its integrated model is satisfying in 2018, but all too dismissive of the 35 years of success and profits that preceded it. Many business failure stories are like that. "It worked great until it suddenly didn't."
- airstrike 8y agoIBM comes to mind
- pm90 8y agoRight. Its really hard to predict this kind of shifts in processes, or how processes that you're relied on for a long time have been made obsolete. When that happens, big businesses have an especially hard time because they're usually not agile enough to reorient themselves/adopt new processes quickly enough. A peer commenter mentioned IBM. As an ex-IBM'er, I certainly think that is true. The team I worked on adopted agile methodologies (which I think has been largely adopted in the emerging tech teams). But you could still see remnants of old processes and incentives, like a weird emphasis on writing patents. That was kinda shocking to me as a SE to see a patent writing as a part of my job, but I realized it was a holdover from earlier times. Ultimately, while I enjoyed my time there, broken processes for recognizing contribution was among the most important reason I jumped ship.
- wyldfire 8y agoIntel embracing RISC-V would be a super-bold move. Given the support we can already see from the long list of RISC-V foundation members, it's bound to succeed. In the next couple of years it will probably wrestle a few royalties away from ARM. Beyond that, I think it will end up a legit heavy-duty apps processor for Android phones. It might start out on the mid/low-end phones, but manufacturers will absolutely love the idea of cutting out ARM from their BOM.
- rwmj 8y agoRISC-V is a much bigger problem for ARM than it is for Intel.
- PedroBatista 8y agoTherefore Intel getting into the RISC-V bandwagon and making it a freight train. But I suspect they won't do that.
- oblio 8y agoNokia/Symbian vs the Open Handset Alliance/Android, all over again?
- JohnSully 8y agoIf INTEL positioned itself as the main source for risc-v SOCs they could take away ARMs thunder.
- phkahler 8y agoIt would be very interesting to see and Intel or AMD designed RISC-V chip. I'm curious just how the ISA could do given similar resources brought to it. AMD should be in a better position to try because they were already planning to put ARM cores in their SoCs a few years ago. While that effort was dropped, I assume they still have a bunch of people around that know what the issues are and are ready to tackle them. Problem is ARM doesn't really have enough of those people to divert to alternatives.
- PaulHoule 8y agoGood article, but it misses plenty. One has been marketing that damages its own brand, particularly the "Atom" phenomenon. Intel had such an obsession with phones that it just had to make x86 processors that were too weak for phones, never mind anything else, full of bugs, etc. It might be a classic case of "boiled frog" because few have realized that ever since Intel switched to PCIe, Intel chips have been starved for PCIe lanes. There has been no point to SLI in a consumer configuration because there just is not enough I/O bandwidth to support two graphics cards. In fact, Intel hopes you will settle on "integrated graphics" (the same as on a phone) so you won't have a reason to buy a computer instead of a phone. Optane is a story like 10 nm. Just add tone-deaf marketing that makes a potentially revolutionary product seem like nothing. Probably the thing that has hurt the PC industry the most is the slow transition to SSD. Given a choice to a brand new computer that has an i7 chip and an HDD which will show you a spinning cursor most of the time, or an eight year old computer with a new SSD which can boot before you get old, the choice is obvious. If Intel had said something like "an i5 chip has to come with an SSD" or if Microsoft had required SSDs for the Windows 8 launch people would be like "Wow this is much better than what I had before." As it is, Intel has mandated a Meh experience for a long time and the tech press has let them get away with it. (It's murdered the tech press too since now all Tom's Hardware talks about is RGB lighted fans and the really cool monitors that might get released someday...)
- grigjd3 8y agoIt's pretty clear the PC market went into decline as the smart phone market ate up their sales and I find it highly doubtful a faster harddrive was going to overcome the convenience factor of the smartphone.
- jacobush 8y agoMaybe but it was still stupid marketing too. Demanding all Core i* CPUs to be bundled with SSD would have been a brilliant move. Not enough to turn the ship around, but steering in the right direction.
- PaulHoule 8y agoThe smart phone has an SSD in it and that is why the smartphone has many convenience factors. For instance, a netbook with an SSD can ride in your backpack and play music to bluetooth headphones, just like a phone. If either of those had an HDD you would have trouble with the music skipping caused by the vibrations of your footsteps. Probably you'd trash the HDD before long. The fast responsiveness you expect from a phone also comes out of the use of SSD. Computers with HDD frequently "go out to lunch" and that's a convenience negative for a computer (if it doesn't have an SSD).
- usefulcat 8y agoOn one hand, this article seems to make a lot of sense. OTOH, INTC is up 40% in the past year. It seems likely that there are quite a few parties out there who probably don't agree with this analysis.
- xenadu02 8y agoYes and Microsoft profits were rising at the same time the web, iPhone, Chrome, et al were eating out its foundation. Bell Labs invented VoIP; AT&T or Verzion could have built Skype at any time. Xerox and PARC. RCA and LCDs. This sad story repeats itself continuously. That's the whole problem with the innovator's dilemma and why so many people look up to Apple - one of the few companies able to cannibalize an existing product line in pursuit of the future. Mac & (Lisa/Apple II), iPhone & iPod. It is extremely rare to be able to see the future coming, time it correctly, then undercut your current extremely successful product line while you prepare for the change. Everything in business school 101 screams "NO!". Managers are paid to optimize returns and the current business. Ben is 100% correct about Intel's history. They clung to their identity as a DRAM company and it almost killed them. This time they're clinging to their identity as an integrated processor company when most of the world wants fully or slightly customized SOCs. Intel directly passed on the most lucrative mobile SOC business (iPhone). It is unfortunate that Intel missed this second opportunity. Maybe new management can pivot, but whoever it is will only have about 90 days to make the change.* * You typically have about 90 days where you're still an "outsider" who can proffer opinions on problems with current practices. For management this is also the best time to make sweeping changes since most people will be willing to jump on the new direction. IMHO after that you have to spend a few years building credibility to get things done without people ignoring or sabotaging you.
- ajross 8y ago> Yes and Microsoft profits were rising at the same time the web, iPhone, Chrome, et al were eating out its foundation. So... the scenario you have in mind for Intel's coming collapse is... a not-quite-as-dominant major industry player in the coming decades? Microsoft got passed by Google and Facebook and Amazon, sure. They're still making, y'know, crazy bank.
- jl2718 8y agoThe problem with Intel, as I see it, is an inability to get new designs to production, and a low tolerance for market growth versus market sustainment. They’ve been a disaster at acquisitions, being totally fine with wasting billions on failed outside investments without any program for internal ventures. The latest focus on “Intel is now a data company” is just complete denial of the reality. But the margins are awesome, and I’d reject any notion that they should erode that with fab services. They need more of the high-volume, high-margin Intel-designed chips that have been their hallmark. Everything else is a distraction. Some of that depends on identifying new forms of computing. Therefore, it makes sense to do technology experiments, but lately Intel has focused on market experiments, where they are not really developing new technology, but building internal organizations with sales, marketing, and product management that dwarf engineering. This is a problem not just because it diverts resources, but because nobody really knows what Intel is anymore. Engineers don’t feel like they are working in an engineering company anymore. Intel’s margins are great, and despite the negative prognostication, their market position is still dominant. Even the engineering talent at Intel is still some of the best, although the management is somewhat deliberately not their best representation. They Just need to focus on being an engineering company again, ignore sales, ignore acquisitions, and invest in their own people to do the experiments that will lead to the next ubiquitous high-margin chip.
- baybal2 8y agoIntel's biggest threat is the decline of WinTel, not its inability at making stuff for consumer products. Intel has legions of top tier IC designers, they can make Apple A10 or Qualcomm 845 class chips as weekend projects. What they don't have is determination to abandon the proven WinTel model business, which is still an extreme cash cow.
- AgentOrange1234 8y agoWeekend project? I thought the Apple chips were getting pretty competitive with Intel chips despite the thermal/power constraints of a phone. I thought AMD was getting really catching up with Ryzen and thread-ripper. I thought Intel was slowing from tick-tock to tick-tock-tweak. I thought Intel had a couple of large layoffs in the past years which axed a lot of their older^w underperforming workers. Are they truly still such a powerhouse?
- baybal2 8y ago>Are they truly still such a powerhouse? Even after layoffs, they still have a humongous IC designers headcount. Possibly, still, largest in the industry.
- davidf18 8y agoI have the 2015 15" basic MacBook Pro, still sold by Apple. I've been waiting for 32 GB RAM but there is still no low power interface for the Intel -H series 45 W TDP processor. Also, waiting for the 6 cores instead of 4 cores.
- jpeg_hero 8y agoDoes anybody know a good technical history of Intel? I teas “Inside Intel” and there was some good stuff but seemed too superficial.
- HillaryBriss 8y agoi love the article's general quotation about disruption: ... what makes disruption so devastating is the fact that, absent a crisis, it is almost impossible to avoid. Managers are paid to leverage their advantages, not destroy them ... as other firms innovate, those advantages become obsolete practices so leveraging them means taking on more risk, not less risk.
- reality_czech 8y agoDoes this mean we can have more than 16GB in our laptops now? Also, is "stratechery" named based on the old Celebrity Jeopardy skits on SNL?